r/askAGP • • Jan 17 '23

If heterosexuality was treated like AGP

195 Upvotes

In an alternate universe, the controversial sexologist Dr. Bay Rlanchard, discovers a peculiar yet fascinating sexuality: male heterosexuality. Unbeknownst to him, he opens a Pandora box of social issues...

Dr. Bay Rlanchard: "I evaluated adult natal males (N=9,367) coming to my clinic because they had a wish to marry adult natal females. From phallometric measurement, I gathered that nearly all had a propensity to be sexually aroused by adult female (N=9,276), an erotic preference, if you wish. Moreover, from the survey done over many years, most of these natal males (N=9,203) had experienced masturbation and arousal related to fantasies involving natal females, starting from puberty. I therefor hypothesize that natal males marry natal females due to their propensity to be sexually aroused by them. I dub this sexuality gynephilia, or also heterosexuality."

r\heteroIsAFetish:
iloveMagdalenBerns: "So men marry women because they get off on us?? That's disgusting! Stop objectifying and fetishizing womanhood!"
MenArePervs49: "I knew it! Porn makes men sexually aroused to women! They all masturbate to us, that's horrifying! WE ARE NOT YOUR FETISH!"
RadicalFemaleLove: "We should differentiate between those who are sexually aroused by women (disgusting gynephiles), from the men who can truly love and marry women."
RadFem4: "But how do we know the men we marry are not pervs who are sexually aroused by us??"
RationalCritical21: "I know a guy who had romantic feeling for me and said he loves me?"
ButchDworkinist: "Don't fall for it! All straight males are gynephiles who want to involve you in their fetish! He is just gaslighting you. Heterosexuality is a result of patriarchal oppression."
CompHetDestroyer: "Yeah, every time a HiM (Hetero identified Male) is in public, he WILL involve you in his narcissistic sexuality! Especially if he is attracted to you! Don't let his niceness fool you! He IS sexually attracted to you!!"
MenArePervs49: "Men being sexually aroused by us is a product of misogyny. It's about domination."

r\MarriedRightsActivists:
MarriedCat: "Heterosexuality does not exist!!! I never had a boner while thinking at a woman, nor seeing one!! We are not perverts! I married out of love!!"
Strai8: "Maybe in the beginning, but since I'm married I do not have any sexual feelings whatsoever, so my marriage is entirely valid and pure!"
IlovemyWife42: "I sometimes get euphoria boners from seeing my wife during sexy time when she wears sexy lingerie for me. That doesn't make me heterosexual, because I genuinely love her!"
ExultantRepository: "I got a mortgage on my house, have children, and my marriage is my whole life! Why would I turn my life upside down just for my sexuality?? Make it make sense!"
Family_Man: "Bay Rlanchard is an evil pervert who fetishizes straight men and RadFems are evil fascists! Don't listen to them, we are NOT gynephilic, our love is pure and devoid of sexual thoughts! We are straight because we love women! We do not marry for sexual gratification !!"
RenamedUser_86 "I think some men are genuinely heterosexual, like they get off on heterosexual porn and sexualized imagery of women... but they don't have romantic feelings for them, so we are NOTHING like those disgusting heterosexuals!!"
Questioning: "I like to masturbate to hetero porn and get off on it. Does this makes me heterosexual? Or that I need to get married? I'm not in love nor want to marry!!"
RenamedUser_86: "You're not heterosexual! It doesn't exist! You are repressing your need to get married out of love!"

Public_Nuanced_Take_haver: "Some, if not most, men marry women because they are sexually attracted to women. There should be nothing wrong with having a sexual orientation."
MarriedRightsActivists: "Shut up fascist! That doesn't happen!"
Conservatives: "That's disgusting!! Lock this mentally ill people up!"

Lanne Awrence's research:
"I think heterosexuality is much more than a simple sexual arousal pattern, as it can give rise to intense feelings of distress. I suspect that this distress is due to pair bonding with the erotic target, where the natal male forms a strong emotional and romantic attachment with said erotic target. This emotional bond can in the most sever cases of heterosexuality lead to wanting a marriage or a long term relationship. Not all heterosexual males will eventually marry, some are content with their sexual orientation and are content to be single and live their sexuality sporadically."

Bichael Mailey's research:
"From my data, future inclination towards a heterosexual orientation can already be seen pre-puberty, where some boys exhibit a fascination and interest towards girls of their age group. This cohort later experiences sexual arousal during puberty and all of them turn out gynephilic after puberty. I don't think children should get married, even if they are heterosexual, as they can't consent."

Bay Rlanchard's Tweet:
"Heterosexuality per se does not make men obnoxious, nor does heterosexual love. Gynephilia in combination with other paraphilias and personality disorders makes hetero men obnoxious."

Conservative Twitter:
"85% of rapists are heterosexual males! Why should we let hetero males in public?"
"Most serial killers are gynephilic. Which is not surprising because paraphilias tend to cluster..."
"Here is a collection of completely unhinged heterosexual males acting out in public, that are TOTALLY representative of heterosexual males as a whole!"
"I have nothing against heterosexuals, as long as they keep their fetish in the bedroom. Inviting people to your wedding is involving everyone in your weird sex thing."
"I disagree, they should seek help and stop being sexually aroused by women. Its because of porn. Seek christ."
"41% of mariages end up in divorce anyways... Cope and seeth, coomers! "

r\HeteroRecovery:
dudeBro90: "Help, I can't stop masturbating to heterosexual porn, and know I even want to go further and have sex with a woman!!"
StrongGuy: "Try noFap, bro!! I gave into my heterosexuality and fell in love with a woman! Repressing is so hard!!"
MachoMan666: "omg, I gave into my hetero feelings too! I hooked up with a woman yesterday, I don't want to fall in love and turn my life upside down for my fetish!!"
FemininitySucks69: "Try orgasmic reconditioning: Only masturbate to gay porn! Keep it up!"
ProudGynephile69: "You're all suckers! yes I had boners since seeing a pretty woman in a playboy magazine at 13! I'm not even married and I can't stop hooking up with women and jerking off to straight porn Friday evenings after works, and I love it ahahah!"
StrongGuy: "Bro, you're disgusting! Stop torturing us! Mod, please ban the troll! Don't give in, my dudes! Control your sexuality, don't let it control you! We know men who marry women do it to satisfy their sexual urges!"
AlexJonesIsRight: "Heterosexuality is a psyop by the deepstate to make men subserviant for the new world order. Resist!"

r\askGP:
Questioning: "Why are we gynephilic? I have this sexual urge sometimes when I see an attractive woman. I know a guy on the MarriedGuys subreddit who even married a woman, he says I should not repress my feelings and sexuality. Thoughts?"
EasyLife46: "Don't repress. I'm not married, never fell in love, and still like to get aroused from imagining being with a sexy women. Don't worry man."
FunnyGuy: "I think heterosexuality is an inborn sexual orientation which arises due to evolutionary biology, for the human species to survive."
StrongGuy: "Nah bro, it's autism, OCD and ADHD. Stop watching porn. Try NoFap."
ExultantRepository: "I don't relate, I genuinely love my wife, I know her since we are kids, we had a romantic wedding. I don't think I'm heterosexual, even though, sometimes I get sexual feelings for her. But I didn't marry her to get off, so I'm not sure if it is heterosexual."
RandomFreudFan: "It's because of trauma. You're secretly in love with your mother because you hated your father and want to recreate your childhood!"
AthenaWorshipper: "Embrace the goddess of femininity, be her slave and worship the divine feminine!"
SelfAwareGynephile: "I'm aware that I married because I'm sexually attracted to woman, and am a heterosexual guy. Guys, be proud!"
DivorcedFather89: "I married, but since knowing that I married because I'm gynephilic and sexually attracted to women, I needed to divorce, because I'm ashamed and disgusted by my sexual perversion and objectification of women."

Bay Rlanchard's tweet:
"I believe heterosexual behavior is extremely diverse in its presentation, without even taking socio-cultural aspect into consideration. Both the married man who marries out of love, and the man who simply masturbates to heterosexual erotica and goes on with his life, represent two sides of the same coin: heterosexuality."

(God, that was fun to write xD)


r/askAGP • • Jul 10 '21

As someone who thought they had AGP for 3 years I honestly think the people here are trans in denial but are too scared to transition due to the social aspect of being transgender.

164 Upvotes

I struggled with what I thought was auto-gen for the last 3 years. It was horrible it drove me to suicide nearly twice and I saw no purpose in life. It wasn't until a very dark night I had an ego death where I finally decided to transition instead of just necking myself.

So I did it, I took the "blue pills" w/e and I realized I wasn't an auto-gen. Hrt literally dropped my sex drive to 0 and I don't find becoming a woman arousing in the slightest bit, but I am much happier. I knew this would probably be the case as I first knew I was trans in 2013, and did not discover auto-gen porn until the following year. But auto-gen porn was just like dropping gasoline onto a small fire, that being a fire wishing I was female.

I denied I was trans for so long but once I got rid of my sex drive I knew it wasn't just a "fetish". But am I saying you all are "Trans" in denial too, No. But I'm saying many of you could be like me where saying its just a "fetish" is a whole lot more comfortable than saying "I'm transgender" and uprooting your entire life. I also realize transitioning can be difficult for the majority of the male population, hell I had a feminine face for a guy and I still find it incredibly hard the mountain that I climb. Plus I was in the perfect atmosphere to socially transition as I was in between jobs and had little friends in my new city, and away from family.

tl;dr Some of you are trans in denial, some of you are just in it for the fetish. But this is coming from someone who thought they just had auto-gen.


r/askAGP • • Nov 14 '21

Me after 3 years on HRT

Thumbnail
gallery
147 Upvotes

r/askAGP • • Dec 03 '20

What I learned on r/askAGP

144 Upvotes

You should be proud of yourself for being here.

  • This is a great community, with several regular contributors who are highly intelligent, honest, and caring. We have carved out a unique niche in Reddit's trans community as a safe place to discuss autogynephilia (AGP), which is defined as the attraction to the thought of oneself as a woman.

  • We are also unique in the way that trans women, detrans males, and AGP males are all present and all welcome to join in the conversation. Everyone here gets along very well, because we all share one thing in common: we all have AGP.

  • You were able to refuse to accept all the anti-AGP rhetoric that permeates throughout the trans community, because AGP connected with you. Most of us connect with AGP in such a strong way that we have no doubt it is a real condition. There are few medical conditions like AGP, where people deny that it exists, and information about it is actively suppressed.

  • We are not self-hating AGPs. This community is positively geared towards acceptance, and healthy lifestyles for people with AGP

Dr. Ray Blanchard is not a transphobic quack that has been discredited.

  • That exact statement is echoed on Reddit just about every damn day in the mainstream trans subreddits. The fact of the matter is that repeating a rather ill informed opinion over and over again will not make it true.

  • Dr. Blanchard's research has helped numerous men in the 30+ years since he first developed the AGP typology. I know that the first time I read about AGP, it was like a door opened for me. For the first time in my life, I felt like I understood my sexuality, instead of being completely confused by it. I no longer felt like an outcast with a perverted fetish, and I embarked on a journey to self-acceptance and self-improvement. r/askAGP is here to help foster those feelings of self-acceptance and self-improvement, for all of our members.

  • Dr. Blanchard does not hate trans people, which is nothing short of amazing, considering the uncalled for hatred generated towards him every today. Blanchard has always been an ally for trans women, and was one of the first doctors to speak out in support of allowing AGPs to transition. Before Blanchard's typology, HSTS were known as Primary Transgender and AGPs were Secondary Transgender, and it was considered medical malpractice to help AGPs transition.

There is nothing wrong with having autogynephilia.

  • Being AGP does not make you a dirty fetishist, and being AGP does not mean you are not transgender. Being transgender is a choice that a person makes; someone becomes transgender only after they begin the process of transitioning. Many men with AGP choose to transition into women, and many other choose not to transition. In my opinion, this is the best community on Reddit for males questioning whether or not they want to transition, simply because we do not automatically tell everyone that they should transition.

  • Having AGP doesn't have to be a curse. Because there are so many different variances involved, it can be an awesome experience for one person, and a never-ending hellscape for another person. This community promotes living with AGP and finding ways to cope without transitioning, before actually transitioning. Somehow this concept is lost on every other trans subreddit; however, that also means you won't find people glorifying transition very often here either.

  • Autogynephilia is not a normal part of female sexuality. I don't understand how anyone could actually believe this, unless they were a male with no concept or understanding of female sexuality. If anyone actually believes this, we can get together and I would be happy to explain the differences between male and female sexuality. The basic idea is that men are disgusting. That's just how we are; when a woman understands for the first time how gross men are, they are a bit shocked by it - and highly disturbed. Women do not have fantasies about themselves the way AGP males do. Women are aroused emotionally, and AGP males that wish to live a typical heterosexual life would do well to learn how to arouse women, if they wish to have happy marriages.

There are different theories behind what causes autogynephilia.

  • Blanchard proposed that males with AGP have an Erotic Target Location Error (ETLE); the idea behind the ETLE is that heterosexual men that have AGP have inverted the object of their attraction inwards, towards themselves, as opposed to outwards, towards actual women. There is not very much substance in the ETLE hypothesis, and some supporters of Blanchard feel that it is the weakest part of his AGP typology. Those who support the ETLE hypothesis tend towards the belief that AGP is something that we are born with. Others speculate that AGP is something that a male may be predisposed to, and it can easily be triggered.

  • An alternative hypothesis for the cause of AGP is childhood sexual imprinting. There are two ways that this will happen. The first way is childhood emasculation trauma, where a young boy is humiliated and emasculated in a way that impacts them negatively. Emotional trauma happens when a child experiences an emotional state that is too powerful for the young mind to handle. The emasculation trauma will be processed by the brain through sexual imprinting, as opposed to being repressed. The human brain will process childhood trauma via sexual imprinting if it is able to, and can be observed in other forms of child abuse. This type of AGP will have a Male Emasculation Fetish (MEF). This means that they will be very masochistic and submissive, and enjoy being a sissy and forcibly feminized and humiliated. It can be hard to distinguish whether the MEF is driving the AGP, or the AGP is driving the MEF.

  • On the other side of the coin, AGP can also be caused by childhood emasculation that is a positive experience. For example, a young boy may be dressed like a girl by his older sister and her friends. The little boy may find this exciting, and stimulating in a way that his young brain is not quite ready to experience. This sort of "overstimulating excitement" the child experiences is sexually imprinted as well. This could very well be the way many fetishes begin, as most males have a fetish, and not all of them experienced childhood trauma. A young boy could start viewing his mothers high heels in a way that makes him feel this excitement and BAM a foot/heels fetish is sexually imprinted.

This community recommends transition as a last resort, rather than a cure for autogynephilia.

  • The community is split a few different ways when it comes to transition. The default position of r/askAGP is that other possibilities should be attempted and extinguished, before seeking out a gender transition. This is the default position because not only is it in opposition to the mainstream trans community, a stance that was/is sorely needed in the trans community. The idea of better alternatives to transitioning doesn't exist elsewhere on Reddit, but the reality is that the majority of self-diagnosed AGP males do not wish to seek transition. Many AGP males like the lives they have carved out for themselves as men, but simply do not have access to information about living with AGP without transitioning later in life. This is one of the main topics we discuss in this community.

  • Some of our members believe that most AGPs cannot transition successfully; therefore, transition should be avoided. There is a phenomenon taking place, where young males are transitioning into women without having ever heard about the concept of autogynephilia one during their transition. This is completely unacceptable, in the same way that the overall denial by the mainstream trans community of AGP being a real condition is completely unacceptable, and quite frankly, disgusting. This is a dangerous practice, and the trans community needs to understand that just because some members will accept that AGP is a load of malarkey without question, there will be other members that will feel the same overwhelming sense of connection and self discovery that I felt when I first discovered AGP. This cannot be reconciled with the fact that the trans community disingenuously coerces young men, that have obvious AGP tendencies, into transitioning. Honestly, that's fucking terrible!

  • Someone who is self-diagnosed with AGP and still wishes to transition will likely have a very successful transition and will not desist later. A trans woman that embraces the sexual aspect of her transition can really have a great experience. This is another strike against the trans community, for their inability to simply share all the available knowledge and resources with their community. Personally, I feel like a sexually-driven transition is the most valid reason to transition, and there is nothing to be ashamed of. As long as a person transitions for the right reasons, and stays true to themselves, they will be successful.

The intensity of gender dysphoria is highly variable amongst males with autogynephilia.

  • Not all heterosexual males that transition do so because of AGP. Like the majority of FtM transitions, a good percentage of MtF are driven by gender dysphoria (GD) alone. Trans women who identify as Transmedicalists typically are part of this group in which some members have deemed themselves to be "actual trans women" as opposed to the "dirty fetishists" who are ruining the trans community by undergoing sexually-motivated transitions, in order to "feed the agp". The "actual trans women" are HSTS, which is a very small percentage of trans women - something that most in the trans community do not realize. HSTS could be an entirely different condition, because it does not resemble the symptoms felt by the other trans women who comprise the majority. I hypothesize that non-AGP trans women also experience GD resulting from childhood trauma. Unlike AGP trans women, these young boys did not experience an emasculating experience. Often times they have been more severely abused than their AGP counterparts. This abuse can result in internalized misogyny. These males are experiencing body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) which is manifesting itself as GD. Often times, these males will go through different phases of configuring their identity prior to transition, such as working out extensively, or getting pierced and tattooed regularly. These males are not in denial of their AGP, they are actually having a different experience.

  • AGPs experience varying rates of GD, and several factors contribute to this. A male with transvestic AGP may suffer from less dysphoria than a male with anatomic AGP, due to the desire of the anatomic AGP to have a woman's body. I theorize that AGPs with MEF will experience less GD overall, than their counterparts with the positively stimulating childhood emasculation, because the non-masochistic AGP males with have a much more intense desire to actually become women, which in turns, increases the intensity of their GD.

  • A lot of young men suffer GD as a result of the Fear of Missing Out (FOMO). They are worried that, by putting off transition, they risk the likelihood of their ability to pass. GD will likely be more intense for males that have masculine features which will seriously impact their ability to pass, such as height and large hands/feet. Young men who suffer with depression and anxiety will cycle their GD into this self-feeding loop of mental-disorders, which Generation Z is seemingly plagued by. One of the main contributing factors to GD is repressing AGP desires.

Those who repress their autogynephilic urges are at a high risk of transitioning later in life.

  • The most important thing that a male with AGP can do to avoid transitioning later in their life, is to not repress their AGP desires. The desire to feminize must be acted upon as much as not transitioning will allow. Gender dysphoria flourishes in those that fantasize about being women, without acting upon these desires in real life. If you do not want to transition, you must crossdress. If you have anatomic AGP, they make really nice, realistic breast plates in the entire spectrum of skin tones. This may not be as desirable as actually having tits, but consider this: those with physiological AGP will never realize their ultimate fantasies of becoming pregnant or menstruating. Even by transitioning, they will never feel the satisfaction of "being a woman". Remember, the desire to be a woman is driven by horniness. Transition would force you to live with this sexual fantasy 24/7, while also decreasing your libido, essentially leaving you chemically castrated. If that last sentence turns you on, remember that it won't stimulate as much if your libido is lowered via estrogen and hrt.

  • Many AGP males are turned on by ideas such as: forced feminization, pressing button and instantly becoming a girl, and transitioning MtF. Analyze your own sexual fantasies, and determine how much the idea of transition turns you on. Many trans women find that they still need to use the same transition fantasies that they used before they transitioned, in order to get off. When the idea of becoming feminized, or transitioning from a man into a woman, is such a huge turn on, why not consider living this fantasy all the time, as opposed to a serious choice of transitioning that you only get to make once? Make time every weekend to shave your entire body, and dress like a complete slut. Put on a chastity cage, become skilled with makeup application, and buy nice wigs. If you prefer to dress more classy, as an office secretary, or just a casual woman, do that. Do what you gotta do, and do it as often as you gotta do it. You will notice a decrease in your gender dysphoria when you regularly feminize yourself. Go out in public if you want to, you whore. DO NOT PURGE YOU STUPID HO.

  • By not transitioning, you have more control over your sexuality. You decide when you want to act upon your AGP fantasies. Being a woman full time is a lot of work, and maintaining it will take the magic out of the whole feminization process. Remember, you are turned on by being a woman because you are not one - that may or may not be an important aspect of your fantasy.

  • There are unique cases where the dysphoria is so severe, or the desire to live as a woman is so strong, that acting out on your fantasies while continuing to live your life as a man may not fulfill you. Some people are better off transitioning, of course. In this present era, however, it seems quite clear that a lot more people are changing their genders than is necessary.

Creating a virtual persona for your inner woman.

  • One of the most validating things you can do to live with AGP and avoid transitioning, is to succumb to the trans narcissism that is prevalent amongst AGPs while they explore their femininity. Essentially, living the life of a trans woman online, creating profiles on social media and building up a following, and online friendships. Most AGPs need to be validated by others, and we are fortunate to have a means of receiving that validation, on our time, and our way. I have an instagram where I whore myself out and I will even place my reddit here(WARNING: NSFW I am nearing 40 35 years old and have a distorted view which makes me believe that I am an attractive women a.k.a. AGP) u/sissy-cumdumpster in hopes that I receive validation, or I get made fun of. Either way is a win. I like the way I look, without hrt and surgeries. I am fortunate in that I am a small man, and GAMP men find that attractive. A lot of AGP and GAMP men, myself included, are more turned on by the image of a man that has been sissified than a trans woman that passes so well she is indistinguishable from a cis female.

  • You can go so far as having an only fans account, or webcam on chaturbate. You can pull a Contra Points and start a youtube channel where you pretend to be a transwoman. I love having a lot of pictures of myself to look at. I know how selfish that sounds, but fuck it.

  • You don't need to actually transition to go to the glory hole at the truck stop dressed like a filthy whore and choke on flacid dicks and pubic hair all night.

Finding a female partner whom you can be sexually submissive too, and open about your AGP.

  • This is the last point I will go over for this post, but the importance of this cannot be understated. I've noticed that some guys seems like they adhere to gender roles, and if they are not going to transition, they repress their femininity. They feel like they need to adhere to male gender roles, especially in the bedroom, by being the more dominant partner that leads sexual intercourse. If you want to live as a man with AGP, you need to make sure you will be sexually fulfilled. This is equally important to feminizing yourself. You must find a girlfriend that is compatible with your AGP and submissiveness. A good sign will be if she doesn't like giving you blowjobs or receiving anal sex. She is a keeper. If she is submissive in bed, no matter how cool she is, you need to end the relationship asap, or else you are just wasting your time and setting yourself up for failure.

  • You are a heterosexual male. Even though you are capable of being the woman in a heterosexual relationship with a real man, after you transition, you run the risk of not being able to experience a romantic bond the way you do with a female partner. Some trans women have this problem, some do not and are able to be romantic with a man. Either way, if you do not transition and start a relationship with a woman, you are able to validate your manhood in every aspect of the relationship except in the bedroom.

  • The key to making the ideal sex life a reality is through mastery of the female orgasm. You must educate yourself to be a great lover in bed, as it needs to be give and take. "She Comes First" by Ian Kerner is a great place to start, and if you have any questions about how to make love to a woman, feel free to ask me here or in PM. Being good in bed is a skill that every AGP male should possess, as submissive men are gaining a reputation as being the best in bed. If you are a giving, generous person and lover, this will be true.

  • Take your time to develop the perfect relationship for your lady.... and your, lady. This is a very magical relationship that is exceedingly hard to manifest once you transition into a woman.

Well, that's all I got for now. Goodnight, you AGPrinces(ses)

tl;dr if you don't pass at all before hrt, chances are you won't pass at all after you start hrt either. If you can manage to look sexy without any surgery or hrt, you don't need to commit to permanent changes to your body. You slut.


r/askAGP • • Nov 28 '22

Perspectives from a cis bi girl

114 Upvotes

I apologize if I appear intrusive, I’ve just genuinely always been interested in sexology and I started reading Freud and Kinsey and similar until I stumbled upon Blanchard and the 4chan LGBT board. Feel free to tell me to shut up and get out.

Meta attraction

This is a concept I’m thoroughly interested in because I think this is a lot more common in cis women (and maybe also just sub leaning people in general? I discussed this with my bi cis male switch partner and he agreed from his own experience) than the cis male researchers anticipated. When I masturbate, I often barely picture the men’s physique at all, as it isn’t important to the fantasy. It’s just faceless shadow dicks. The fantasy is about ME, what is being done to me and how I’m desired, not really the man himself. I think this is very common in cis women from what I’ve seen. It also follows with the cis female pattern of erotica reading vs porn watching. The idea that this type of attraction is “fake” and “not actual attraction” reeks of bias from a visual male sexuality.

”AGPs tend to be nerdy and masculine and into anime and wear weird shit”

Okay, so just like cis queer women lmao? Like literally so many of the trans girl stereotypes like anime inspired clothing was just shit I wore when I was 15. The straight trans and cis women are feminine in a normie way, where the most feminine you get is something akin to “a cute top and jeans”. The bi and lesbian cis and trans women are feminine in a nerdy theatrical way with shit like pleated skirts and thigh highs and chokers.

Lastly

Like okay, don’t get me wrong, cis women typically don’t almost cum from stealing their moms panties when they’re 13. I’ve seen sissy type porn and yeah it’s not a 1-to-1 mirror of cis female targeted fantasies. But fantasies where you yourself is the primary target? Thigh highs and awkwardness? Idk. It’s more common in cis women than people may think.

I don’t care why someone transitions or don’t, I don’t believe in souls so that concept is useless to me (as ContraPoints said - “heartwarming gibberish”). I don’t think we should need trans womens experiences and sexuality to mirror cis women’s to be valid, and I don’t think that if you experience this AGP thingy this means you absolutely must transition. There’s just a lot of things said in communities like these about cis women where I’m like… that’s not true, some of us do that lol.


r/askAGP • • Apr 23 '21 Heart of Silver

Banned from r/asktransgender because I said AGP exists...in a thread explicitly asking for opinions on whether or not it exists...

Post image
111 Upvotes

r/askAGP • • Aug 26 '24 Hooray

Generalized Framework for Living with AGP

105 Upvotes

Hey all. I’ve been posting here for a while, and I wanted to get my thoughts down on wtf to do after someone has determined that they have AGP, because well, I’m trying to figure out wtf to do after determining I have AGP. I’d like to move forward and make progress and stop thinking about it all the time.

I tried to write down very general advice for myself that is hopefully applicable to you. A lot of it is stuff I read repackaged in a form I believe in, and I don’t think I’m reinventing the wheel. If you feel what I say here is ignorant or missing key facts, feel free to comment. I feel this is easily digestible and actionable, in terms of allowing someone with AGP to figure out how to move forward.

This framework assumes you:

  • Were assigned male at birth

  • Have diagnosed yourself as having autogynephilia (AGP)

Suggested Reading

From the sidebar:

“If you're new to learning about AGP, start with Anne Lawrence's Men Trapped in Men's Bodies or Phil Illy's Autoheterosexual to build a stable foundation. “

Legitimately great advice, read both, it will help you more than countless internet conversations.

You realized you have AGP now what?

You read about the condition and found yourself in it, that the label defines you. Behaviors and thoughts that confused you throughout your life finally make sense to you.

If you are anything like me, this has led to trying to find new labels that you can apply to yourself that make things make more sense. There’s four key AGP subtypes, maybe you’re anatomic AGP, or transvestic AGP or a combination of that one and this other one. Maybe you can finally figure out what your gender label is, are you actually a woman in a man’s body and AGP is just a symptom, a third gender, a transsexual in a man’s body, a male emasculation fetishist, a gay homophobe desperate for copium, what is that label that you can apply and make it all make sense again? Then look into the science, what is your finger digit ratio? How about brain scans, what does that mean, etc? The hope being once you know you are X, then you know you have to do Y and Z as a result.

Ultimately, my efforts on this front have largely failed. Reading more and more has gone beyond the point of diminishing returns to outright negative returns. I am no longer achieving enlightenment, but am instead ingesting noise and developing neuroses. This is largely because the conversation on this topic is so emotional, political, and academic, but also because a lot of the discourse seems to be serving the purpose of establishing lines of cultural (dis)association instead of enlightenment (e.g. I’m not like those weirdos, they have label X!).

At some point you just need to stop trying to find labels and associated treatments and take a step back and ask yourself a different question in my opinion.

How do you want to live?

“Autogynephilic gender dysphoric men must confront and answer the existential question: How do I want to live, given that I have an unchangeable paraphilic sexual orientation? Experienced clinicians can help clients reach their decisions, but ultimately the clients themselves must decide. Often the decision is a very difficult one, in part because none of the available options are genuinely satisfactory. ” (Anne Lawrence - Men Trapped in Men’s Bodies)

Separate yourself from society and any relationships you have in your life and just ask yourself, based on your feelings, how do you want to live? Do you want to live as a woman, a man, or something in between? What feels right to you? At the end of the day this is what’s going to matter predominantly, and you will have to come up with an answer. Your strategy for life is in my opinion choosing where to live on the continuum of choices below:

[Repress (-1) -------- Integrate/Compartmentalize (0) ------- Transition (+1)]

Where Repress (-1) means living as a man, and actively repressing all thoughts/desires to be a woman, and transition (+1) means living as a woman, getting bottom surgery and repressing all thoughts/desires to be a man.

Ultimately a lot of the cultural conversation presumes that repression and transition are the only options but in fact if you think about it many if not most AGP people likely neither fully repress or transition and their choice would be somewhere between -1 and +1. Ultimately we all decide where we want to live on this scale based on our thoughts and desires and strive to do so. Again try to determine this independent of your social goals and obligations.

How to determine this?

There’s a lot of things that go into this, but again let’s ignore cultural considerations and any personal relationships you have and instead break things down in two dimensions: How badly do you find being a male painful? How badly do you find being a female attractive? The first is roughly your gender dysphoria, the pain you experience day to day living as a man. This is what’s pushing you to become a woman. The second is roughly your cross-gender euphoria, or gender envy. This is what’s pulling you to become a woman. There’s surveys you can take for dysphoria. I don’t know of one for envy but I personally find it helpful to consider these as two separate things, and reading testimonies it does seem to be reasonable to consider them as distinct. The closest analogue to gender envy I came across was having a cross-gender identity but I think gender envy is a bit more accurate for what I’m describing, and allows you to consider the relative level of it you may have. Your cross-gender identity either exists or doesn’t, and has to be cultivated.

You should read other people’s testimonies and answer surveys and try to get a sense of your relative level of both.

Gender Dysphoria

[0 —-------- 1]

Gender Envy

[0 —-------- 1]

My intuition is that dysphoria is far more likely to push someone to transition, and for that transition to be successful but I have nothing to back that up, just intuition that pain is harder to overcome than envy. Whatever the case, remember the ultimate point is to come to a determination of how you want to live.

The way to get at your level of both is to be honest and ask yourself hard questions and test yourself. How much do you really hate your male body and penis? Try resisting AGP thoughts for a week and keep going another week, how do you feel afterward? Try living as a woman for an afternoon in a totally unsexualized situation. Did you feel silly? Comfortable? Aroused? What’s your relative intensity of push and pull towards womanhood in multiple dimensions? Talking with a therapist can help here, even if they don’t believe AGP exists.

How to make this fit within Society and your Relationships

Because we live in a society, you can’t just do whatever the hell you want at any given time. Because you have goals that require social acceptance (e.g. a promotion or a wife or not being disowned by your parents) you possibly can’t do what you want to do based on your self-examination above. You have to figure out how to make these two things fit. It may well be that important relationships will end because you cannot compromise to the level required to keep that relationship, but that’s something you need to determine for yourself.

Regarding a romantic relationship, it does seem that we have distinct sexual drives, allosexual (in this context sexual desire for other women) and autosexual (desire for ourselves as a woman).

Allosexual Desire

[0 —-------- 1]

Autosexual Desire

[0 —-------- 1]

The relative level of both you feel probably determines how willing you are to compromise your desired way of life. If you have substantial allosexual desire and are not currently in a committed relationship, you should seek out women that would be comfortable with AGP and be willing to share relatively early once that trust is established between the two of you.

Ultimately some compromise will be necessary most likely, as almost all relationships involve compromise. You need to figure out if you are comfortable with the level of sacrifice you think you’d need to achieve whatever social goals you have. This goes beyond romance and into other social goals regarding family, friendship or your career. What are you willing to compromise and for what? Figure that out and come up with a way to live.

What Works Today May Change in the Future

What works today based on the framework above, might not work in a few months, year or many years down the line. Your “egg may crack.” You may decide to detransition. You will figure this out based on only one thing predominantly, your lived experience. In this event the framework hasn’t necessarily broken, but instead you can recalibrate based on your new lived experience and move forward.

Making it Personal - How I Use this Approach

For myself, ultimately I believe I have extensive gender envy, but not nearly as much gender dysphoria as others. I also have a strong allosexual desire. This would lead me to an ideal state of living as a male publicly but indulging in cross gender sexual experiences with a female or MtF partner. I'd also enjoy going out en femme with my partner on social occasions, but not formally transitioning.

The reality of my social circumstance is I’m married with kids. My wife does not even want to see me feminized, and finds the idea to be a turnoff. I’d also not like my kids to see me feminized and would compromise my desires to ensure that doesn’t happen.

As such I must compromise this part of my sexuality and instead only indulge in cross gender play alone, placing me closer to -1 on the scale above than I’d prefer to be, but I am comfortable with that at the moment. I will see how I feel in a year, decade, beyond, when I get there.

If you read this far please let me know your thoughts. Thank you for reading!


Because Reddit is becoming a closed platform I also posted this on a substack for posterity


r/askAGP • • Oct 23 '21

I think I’m going to transition

103 Upvotes

I made a post here a few months ago around when I first started crossdressing. My desire to be a woman hasn’t faltered, but what has gone away is the AGP desires. The more I dress up and get closer to a full “girlmode,” the happier I am and the need to indulge in AGP masturbation goes away. There was a brief period where I felt shame and threw away my clothes/makeup, and tried some repression techniques, which definitely didn’t work out. When I did this, my desire to satisfy gross AGP urges just grew. When I bought more stuff and felt like I looked okay, these urges were much less frequent again. The main thing left is just pure dysphoria as I go about my life.

At this point, it’s kind of obvious to me what makes me happier, and isn’t that the point of all this? To do what makes us happy? I won’t be losing much by transitioning, and I actually think I’ll be able to keep my job after college. I don’t care anymore if I’m AGP, or if all of this is caused by some erotic target location error. I only have one life and I’m not spending it living in misery like how repression has been.

Maybe things would be different if I managed to stay in complete denial and never considered that being trans was a possibility. But with everything I know and feel now, I think that transition is the best option. I don’t really know why I’m posting this here, but thank you all for your posts and discussions! I was mostly a lurker, but I read a lot of peoples stories and theories. Even though there are a lot of anti transition people here, being exposed to both sides has allowed me to make a decision I’m more confident in.

I really hope everyone here finds clarity eventually, whatever that may mean for them. This stuff is just so painful and I wish nobody else had to go through it. I think I’ll be leaving this subreddit for good now. If I end up regretting it and destroying my life (or being happier than ever!), I’ll make sure to check back in and tell my story.


r/askAGP • • May 26 '25

This sub is pathetic and needs to die off

98 Upvotes

I used to be a loser on this sub a few years ago when i hated myself and was ashamed of being sexually aroused at the idea of transitioning into a woman. Looking at the posts here it looks like not much has changed and the doomer-ism is rampant.

Literally all of you would be better off transitioning and moving on with your lives then rotting here and tying yourselves in knots trying to justify why your arousal means you can't transition and live a happier life.

For the record i transitioned 5 years ago and haven't looked back, it was the best decision i could have made for myself. Your arousal is a coping mechanism. Once you accept yourself and start living out your "desires" the sexual side of this fades away, but the feelings of wanting to stay feminine do not. It's about normalizing this and realizing all of this gendered non-sense is not a big deal. Dress how you want, take HRT, grow your hair long, get your nails done... like dude its the most affirming and validating shit ever... i promise you!!

During the course of my transition i literally tripled my income, found the love of my life, bought a house, made a ton of new friends and am currently moving down the path of starting a family. My life is normal as fuck and people accept me and treat me with respect and kindness.

Your life doesn't have to suck and you dont have to repress, you can literally live the exact life you have been "fantasizing" about if you get off your fat lazy asses and take ownership of your own life. Make yourself into the person you truly adore. I promise you will not regret it. Peace bitches <3


r/askAGP • • Jul 08 '26 Heartwarming

I showed a 26 year old female my feminine side on our first date and it completely changed the night

86 Upvotes

I met a woman on Hinge, and we went out for drinks on Saturday.

During the date, she casually mentioned that she was bisexual. I got visibly excited and said, “Oh my God, you’re bi? I love that.”

She laughed and asked why. I told her she would never guess, and after she kept asking, I pulled out my phone and showed her a picture of myself wearing heels.

She absolutely loved it. She started gushing over the photo and then mentioned a gender nonconforming guy she finds really attractive. I said, “If you think he’s hot, you have to see this,” and showed her a full picture of myself cross dressed.

Her reaction was incredible. She wasn’t merely being polite or accepting. She was genuinely attracted to me that way.

I jokingly said, “After this drink, we’re definitely going back to my place.”

And we did.

We had sex, and she was genuinely aroused by seeing me dressed as a woman. Staring at me, treating my feminine appearance as sexually arousing. It was one of the most affirming and exciting sexual experiences I’ve ever had.

What stays with me is that none of it would have happened if I hadn’t taken the risk of showing her that part of myself on the first date. I sensed that she might respond positively, but there was still a real possibility of embarrassment or rejection.

Instead, being vulnerable created the chemistry.

Sometimes the part of yourself you’re most nervous to reveal is exactly the part that makes someone desire you.


r/askAGP • • Dec 27 '20

Are you a young man with AGP, who can't decide if they actually want to transition? Read this!

83 Upvotes

One of the Seven Hermetic Principles discussed in The Kybalion is the Principle of Polarity, which pertains to the dualistic nature of our existence here on Earth. Every concept is accompanied by an opposing concept. Up and down, right and wrong, dead and alive - are all examples of pairs of opposites that make up reality as we know it. The Principle of Polarity claims that understanding a pair of opposites as two separate entities is actually an illusion, and that each pair of opposites is, in actuality, the extreme ends of one spectrum. This provides further proof that nothing in life is black and white; everything is always a gray area. After all, black and white are really just two extreme expressions of gray.

There is also the Hermetic Principle of Gender, which claims that gender permeates everything, on all three planes of existence: the physical, the mental, and the spiritual. The negative and positive charges of the atoms and electrons that beget material reality, are an example of masculine and feminine energy, working together. The masculine and feminine need each other to maintain a proper balance. A human beings biological sex is a manifestation of the gender that the individual is more aligned with - in theory, at least. Beyond the physical plane, however, each individual possesses both feminine and masculine energy, and one should strive to find and maintain a balance of the feminine and masculine within themselves, if they are to reach their full potential.

When the fifth edition of The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) was released in 2013, Gender Identity Disorder was replaced with Gender Dysphoria, due to stigma the word "disorder" carries. I feel like it would have been a better idea to have kept both conditions. There are trans people who do not connect with Gender Dysphoria. Is it possible that some of these same trans people would connect more with Gender Identity Disorder? A recent post on this subreddit asked if "having Autogynephilia was like having a dual sexuality" and the conclusion I came to, after pondering this question, was that, in my personal experience, AGP is more of a "dual identity" than it is a "dual sexuality".

The "dual identity" aspect of AGP goes well with my belief that my AGP is a result of childhood trauma. Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) is also caused by childhood trauma, but with DID, the trauma endured by the child is so severe that it causes the personality to split, often immediately following a traumatizing experience; this initial splitting of the child's personality forms their first "alternate persona". As the trauma persists, this initial split will fracture itself further, into several, less developed identities. Like an adult who is unaware that they have been repressing unprocessed childhood trauma caused by abuse, the identities in a person with DID are typically unaware of each other. In DID, alternate identities are triggered involuntarily, and in the most severe cases even the best therapists will never speak with the true, core personality, which the alternate personas were created in order to protect.

Like the alternate personas of DID are a reaction to trauma, AGP is a reaction to trauma. Even though it is not nearly as severe trauma, or unaware of itself and involuntarily triggered, AGP is like DID in the way that both were created in order to protect the individual from experiencing the trauma. It seems as though the brain is able to process emasculation trauma via sexuality, a rewiring which ensures that the negative emotions caused by the emasculating experience will never be experienced; this rewiring of the brain is meant to protect the child from harm, and in doing so inadvertently gives birth to the dual, feminine identity. Until very recently, there was little-to-no encouragement to be open about feelings related to one's gender, and for AGP this meant that most AGP males were going through a similar progression alone, and in silence; this progression eventually leads nearly every AGP male into the realization of a female persona within themselves.

With all the trans awareness being promoted in recent years, AGP males are more aware of themselves than ever before. I have no idea whether or not this is a change for the better overall, as far as the trans community as a whole is concerned, but it is undoubtedly interfering with the way in which the current generation of AGP males are becoming aware of, and in tune with their inner feminine persona. Young AGP males are likely more stressed about being AGP in today's world than at any previous point, because of a silent but looming pressure to transition. This leads to a fixation on the idea of transitioning, causing a cycle of regret for each passing day where they do not take action; this is worsened by the perceived societal pressure and the fear of missing out (FOMO) - with each passing day furthering their natural, male maturity. Under the threat of their own testosterone, young AGP males are deciding that transition is the best choice; the reasoning behind the decision to transition is the mind convincing itself that transition is an inevitability, and the sooner the process is started, the more successful the transition i.e. the ability to "pass" as female.

Even though the young AGP male may be hesitant about transitioning, and the idea may not even be very desirable for them to think about - and even though they may not feel any disdain, mild discomfort, or even a mild dislike towards their lived experience as a male, they consider themselves doomed. As time passes, they will become more discontent with themselves as males, and will end up transitioning anyways; therefore, they decide that the sooner they transition, the more suffering will be averted. I believe that there is a third path that is often neglected and likely not even taken into consideration, and that is a life which is supportive of a dual-identity that is experienced in both a masculine and feminine gender expression.

I suspect that many AGP are being kept in captivity by their own black and white thinking - something that is very common in society presently, and holding back many different facets of society from viewing a situation from every angle. An AGP male that considers either transitioning, or being miserable continuing to live as a male, as their only possible outcomes, is practicing black and white thinking. Encouraging black and white thinking is a tactic used by the ruling class as one of many ways they maintain their position of power over society. This is one of many strategies used to divide and conquer, along with red and blue politics, systemic racism, and many other limiting ideologies that are imposed upon our societal subconscious... because if you can only think in black and white, you won't ever see the gray, which is usually the best solution or answer. Everytime throughout your life that you come to a fork in the road, you will either go left or go right, neglecting to consider the middle path. Black and white thinking causes some AGP males to believe that transitioning is the only way they will be able to express their femininity, in both their appearance and their behaviors. If I were to break it down into one single thought, it would be this: black and white thinking is the belief that men and women should adhere to their corresponding gender roles, and a man must transition to a woman, if they wish to adhere to female gender roles instead.

The middle path is forgoing the societally-imposed gender binary, which serves as a means of enforcing the illusion of duality outlined in the principle of polarity, and incorporating a lifestyle where a dual-identity is incorporated to satisfy both genders, in the way that best aligns with the goals and desires of the individual. AGP can be satiated, but it must be fed; the longer AGP desires go unfulfilled, the stronger they become. Everyone has a breaking point, where their long neglected autogynephilic needs will become unbearable, overpowering the mind of the individual until the needs are fulfilled. Often times, the AGP drives the desire to transition and live as a woman full time; it is important to be aware of the ways in which AGP can be deceptive. The desire to live as a woman might be superficial in a way similar to the desire to continue to live as a man - in both cases, your mind is playing tricks on you. Analyze the desire to live as woman full-time, and pull back the layers of your ego like you would peel an onion, to expose the AGP within, and determine the source that is driving your desires to be a woman. Are they desires driven by testosterone? To find out, analyze the strength of the desire in moments after masturbation. AGP desires will likely still be present, but much less intense and... well, desirable.

Masturbation is like putting a band-aid over a gunshot wound when it comes to AGP, and the AGP male must realize his desired feminization eventually. This does not necessarily mean a mandatory, medical transition. The feminization can be realized with an idea in mind, and the accessories to bring it to life. The AGP male must see themselves as a woman, or at least as feminized, to fulfill their desires, and if one desires to continue living as a male, transition can be avoided. Recall that cisgender people do not consider things like "the desire to continue to live as one's assigned gender"; cisgender people simply live as themselves, typically without the conscious awareness of maintaining their assigned gender roles. For the AGP male, the desire to live as a woman will persist until the desire is realized; likewise, the desire to live as a male will persist until the desire is realized. To understand these desires, pinpoint the motivations driving the desires; this will help you outline the goals you are hoping to achieve from each presentation of yourself. You may need to see yourself as a sexy woman to fulfill the female desire, and you may want to maintain the bromance with your good, longtime friends to fulfill the male desire.

You may find that many aspects of your desire to be male are external sources, which you have established as a male, while the aspects of your desire to be female are all internal desires, that are of the utmost importance to your inner well-being. The female desires will inevitably overpower the male desires because of their personal nature, but this does not mean the male desires should be abandoned. You need to be honest and analyze what is driving the desire to live as a male. If the male desires are based entirely on the feelings of other people, while neglecting your own feelings, then begin to consider the possibility of abandoning these desires, as they are not authentic. There are also many AGP males that authentically enjoy certain aspects of their lives as males, however, and if you truly value the people close to you and the way you interact with them as a male, or even if you find certain aspects of being male in society enjoyable, than you should definitely understand that you do not have to pick one or the other, and the easiest way to live is as either a male or female, with the option to choose depending on the situation. Note: AGPs that desire to be seen as a woman by other people, all the time, probably won't do well with this strategy, or this post as a whole.

The reason I have labeled the desires to live as both male and female as superficial desires is because these desires persist only until they are fulfilled, at which point they become satiated. Most of these desires are recurring, such as the desire to continue your career as a male; this desire is experienced on a regular basis, but only within the 8-10 hour block dedicated to your work day. The desire is not experienced outside of that, which is the ideal time to fulfill a female desire. Many of these involve sexuality, and can be fulfilled without medical intervention. One of the most important things for an AGP who chooses to live the majority of their life as a male is to own their submissive sexuality. If you are comfortable being in submissive role regardless of your gender presentation, then you have a high potential for successfully living a dual-gender lifestyle. Remember that believing the male should be the dominant partner, and the female should be the submissive partner is an example of black and white thinking, and should be avoided at all costs. If you can be honest with yourself, and you don't give a shit about pronouns, you can be successful juggling both genders. Most importantly, if you can't shake the feeling that no amount of medical intervention can change the fact that you are, always have been, and will continue to remain biologically male, and you don't feel like you are a woman trapped inside a man's body - then you can successfully live a dual-gender lifestyle.

As a final thought before this post ends, something that always reminds me why I do not personally want to transition, is the idea of maintaining the sanctity of femininity. For myself, feminization is a mental escape, to my happy place. My favorite vacation. Femininity is exciting, mysterious and euphoric. These are the feelings I attach to my own feminization, and I don't really want to change that. By maintaining some aspect of scarcity to the fulfillment of my female gender, I maintain the euphoria and stress relieving qualities, which I have come to associate with indulging in AGP. Basically, I do not wish to taint my time spent as a female, with anything other than mindless, self indulgence (great band, btw). The reality of being a human of a lower-upper class, is that life sucks sometimes. Everyone's life sucks sometimes, and everyone feels disappointed in themselves every once in a while. Everyone feels uncomfortable in their own skin for many reasons, the bulk of which are not gender-related. Do I really want to bring all that to my feminine identity, which I put on a pedestal that I've conceptualized as being pristine and clean? Do I want to lose the under-appreciated ability and right as a male human, to roll out of bed and into society, something that only men have the privilege of partaking in, without judgement and scorn? Don't get the wrong idea - I love putting on makeup. It is exciting, and fun - but I also know that if I was expected to put it on everytime I went outside, that I would hate it! Maybe that's just me, but I like to keep in mind that even if I were to transition into a female, I'm still going to have to deal with the fact that I'm me, and all my shortcomings will always be mine, and present within me. Just like you won't succeed in moving to a different country in an attempt to escape your problems, you likewise will not succeed in becoming a different person in an attempt to escape your biology... because after it's all said and done you're still you.

tl;dr If you have AGP but do not experience gender dysphoria, and can't decide if transition is the correct choice for you, consider other options, such as feminizing yourself enough to maintain your own sanity, and keep your AGP desires at bay. Do not get stuck in the false paradigm of gender roles. If you truly desire to keep living as a male, try feminizing yourself, as a male, on occasion. Bottom Line: You must take on a female role on occasion to live as a male with AGP

Hopefully somebody finds this post helpful, because it took a long time to write.


r/askAGP • • Oct 10 '21

Happy 76th Birthday to dr Ray Blanchard

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/askAGP • • Apr 10 '22

Interesting encounter on r/MtF

76 Upvotes

I posted in r/MtF that I was someone with AGP and to AMA because I thought some people there might be interested or curious? In retrospect a bit naive of me. But it was interesting. In the short space of time before my post got removed, several people commented saying AGP wasn't real, someone said I was a woman and always had been, and someone else basically told me to fuck off.

All this without anyone asking questions or trying to find out what kind of person I was or where I was coming from or why I thought that way. Even if they were right and I was trans, that means they were hating on a confused transperson. The instant hate and dismissal was very strange and unexpected. I would have thought that community was more open minded given that there was a time no one believed transgenderism was a thing, either. Oh well, I tried.


r/askAGP • • Dec 03 '23

My top practices for embracing AGP - without transitioning

75 Upvotes

(edit October 2026: It seems like some people are looking at my post history, so I wanted to clarify things. As of right now I am 8 months on HRT and have transitioned. My opinions have changed a lot since. The truth is, you don't decide whether you are trans. You don't decide whether you have gender dysphoria or not. I did not experience dysphoria when I first wrote this post, and eventually I experienced it when I realized I was much happier living as a woman full time.

I don't want you to read this post and think you can simply bypass being trans or bypass gender dysphoria if you have it. Those are real things that will always stay with you so keep that in mind. You may have to transition in that case.)

In some way, you could say that I was wrong about myself. And that's OK. You should aim to find the truth, not run away from it. And I am much happier now.

Sup people,

I thought I should share some more practical tips here because this sub needs a bit more than rants and debates. Those are practices I've been using for myself (some inspired by AGPrick) to integrate my AGP and live with it without having to transition.

This has worked for me as someone who

  1. Has no gender dysphoria

  2. Is happy living as a man most of the time

If you have severe dysphoria and don't want to live as a man, then those practices might not be enough for you. There will be no advice on transition here as I don't plan to so I can't speak on that matter.

First of all, I believe that full unconditional acceptance to be key to healing, being happy and able to function with AGP. You need to work on your feelings of shame. Repression doesn't work from what I've seen and only makes you miserable in the long run. Sex is a basic need on Maslow's pyramid of needs, and this includes your sexual needs as an AGP.

In psychology, it's well known that the more you repress something, the more likely it is to cause emotional distress and anxiety (sorry, I don't remember the exact literature). Or what will happen is that your repressed emotions will come out in maladaptive ways. Since your AGP will always be there, why not find adaptive ways to integrate it instead?

Second, a basic level of self-esteem and self-acceptance is needed. If you feel shame about your AGP, hate yourself, hate the world and hate AGP, then honestly not much is really going to work. Also, living with AGP requires pushing against society's judgments and criticisms constantly. You need to feel solid on both feet and be confident to do that.

Lastly, I'll add that you need to be able to moderate your urges and apply self-control when needed. If you enjoy the sissy stuff, thread carefully.

Here are my practices to embrace AGP without transitioning:

Dress up about 4 days a week from morning until noon (no makeup, just clothes)

Not too time consuming to do (about 10 mins to dress up), so I can still be productive while wearing girl clothes in the morning. I work from home half the time so that works well for me. After my girlfriend wakes up around noon (she's a long sleeper) I resume life in man-mode. Good for transvestic AGP.

Proper make-up and breastplate + shave once a week

I need to dress up fully at least once in a while and really have fun with it. This takes up a bit more time, maybe a bit over an hour for the whole preparation. If I'm up for it I'll stream on Kick.

Taking photos

Being able to see photos of myself as a woman fills me with self-love. I feel beautiful, I feel amazing. Also after a good photoshoot, I don't need to dress up for a while because I can just look at the photos and feel the fuzzy feelings without the hassle. Then I can go back to my regular life.

Creating a female online persona

Taken directly from AGPrick. Having your feminine self validated is so important, so having this side of me has helped tremendously with behavioral/interpersonal AGP. I have also started a stream on Kick where I am fully dressed and use a female voice changer. I went as far as sharing somewhat riské photos, but this may be going too far for you. It's up to you. Just beware of approval addiction on this one.

Going out in public

Personally, I have not felt the need to go out in public as a woman as much since having created my online persona, but you may need to. But going out on Halloween as a slutty ninja was some of the best times of my life lol. I'll spare the details. Good for behavioral/interpersonal AGP.

Sex toys in moderation (emphasis on moderation)

Having a dildo has helped for indulging my meta attraction without needing an actual man in front of me. Toys may be a trigger for addiction for people with poorer self-control, but personally it has helped me tons. I can indulge my feminine side and act out fully the way a woman would in bed. It's also much safer than going around hooking up with randoms.

Moderation means different things for different people. So long as it doesn't interfere with your life I see really zero problem. This is the AGP subreddit and we are sexually attracted to ourselves after all. Sex is fun and healthy in moderation, whether solo or with someone else. Beware of addiction.

Other habits that help me

Those may seem very basic but I think most people don't even have that.

Working out

Loving my body in general makes me feel good both as a man and woman. Not just obsess over my ass, but look at my whole body and feel proud of my biceps, shoulders, and everything. Feeling attractive as an individual has helped me manage the occasional fantasy of thinking "maybe I'd look better if I were 100% a woman…". No, you can be attractive as a man too.

Working on your shame

There seems to be immense shame around AGP, and even sexuality in general in our society. I'm not a psychologist but there are many ways to work through your feelings of shame from clinical techniques to new age or self-help techniques. Find whatever fits your boat and work on it.

Feeling shame after jerking off is not post-nut clarity. It's a feeling of being inadequate for having sexual needs, and if anything it's making things worse. Post-nut clarity to me is to be able to jerk off and come back to your senses without hating yourself.

Good mental health

Loneliness, stress and depression have been triggers for me to overindulge in the past. When I feel like shit, no amount of dressing up will make up for it. Taking care of yourself in general can do wonders for you, whether it helps with AGP or not. Make sure you're happy in your life, career, relationships, etc. That's all.

Good relationships that support your AGP (Getting out of the closet at least partially)

Opening up to all of my close friends and my girlfriend is the #1 thing that has helped me the most in terms of dealing with all the shame I had about AGP. If you are all alone and the only people who know about your AGP are people on this sub, then that's not good at all.

Developing a IDGAF attitude

Let's face it. You are different from others, and society will push back just because of that. Heck, even the LGBTQ+ community doesn't accept us. Whether it be your parents, your friends, your coworkers, doesn't matter. See your own AGP needs as important and cherish them. You deserve to exist with or without AGP. Stop caring about what will others think because it's a free world. Do whatever the hell you want.

So those are the habits that have helped me integrate my AGP. I kept it simple but there's infinitely more to say on each point.

On a final note, I wish for this sub to move towards more inclusion rather than criticism, self-acceptance rather than repression. We will go nowhere if we project our own feelings of shame and inadequacy onto other AGPs as soon as they step into our forum. Shame is the monster that drives many people to misery and suicide even, so there is no point in feeding it. Instead, let's give them tips that have worked for us, things that have helped us. This is not the ultimate truth, but my truth that has worked for me.

How will society accept AGPs if we can't even accept ourselves?

TL;DR: Repression doesn't work. If you don't have gender dysphoria or only mildly, these practices may help. Read text in bold and you'll get the gist.

edit: formatting and some potential trigger words.


r/askAGP • • Jan 31 '24

Dating a self-identified AGP

74 Upvotes

I (19F) have been dating my partner (19, AGP) for three months now and I couldn’t be happier. I would truly call them the person of my dreams. They’ve been going back and forth about whether or not to transition (to non binary femme or just a trans woman) for a while, so I refer to them as they. Honestly, a lot of the time I can’t see them as anything but a trans girl. Of course I don’t want to pressure them to transition- I’m very bisexual and I’ll stay with them no matter what they end up being. Still, I can’t help but see them as femme-leaning androgynous even outside the bedroom. Even in the bedroom, I actively enjoy treating them as a woman, as I find gender play of any sort extremely attractive.

All of this is to say- AGPs, you are not disgusting. You are not unlovable. There are more open-minded people out there than you may think. My partner thought they could only be loved despite their dysphoria and despite their fantasies, but I love those things in addition to who they truly are.

Please don’t give up hope. Self-hatred and self-disgust are horrid things. There are more people who will love you than you might think.


r/askAGP • • Dec 08 '20

How many of you are "former gifted kids"?

74 Upvotes

That description could include
- having scored a high IQ test result as a kid and having based your identity on that
- always having been lauded for being "smart" more than any other attribute
- having had an easy time in school without doing much and thus never having applied yourself

... but ultimately falling short of what you consider(ed) to be your potential, be it through lack of work ethic, mental health or social problems or other factors. And if that description does apply to you, do you think your autogynephilic fantasies are connected to that in some way?


r/askAGP • • Mar 12 '21

My Method for Living Life as a Straight Male with AGP

71 Upvotes
  • If you wish to remain living your life as a heterosexual male, you should not worry about transitioning to become a woman; instead, you should be in a relationship with your female persona, as if the female version of you were your significant other.

  1. The euphoria experienced from feminizing yourself can be preserved if you only indulge when you have the time to do so.

  2. Fully feminizing yourself is an arduous process, that can always be an amazing, fun time if done in moderation. Living as a woman, and having to go through the process of getting ready as a female on a daily basis, would become devoid of joy over time.

  3. In order to maintain a state of "gender euphoria", I would recommend a maximum of once per week - generally speaking. Perhaps you'd like to be feminized for a week straight, and that is fine. If you wish to be kept in chastity with your girlfriend holding the key, a prolonged state of feminization could be doable.

  4. You will constantly be thinking about being a girl if you are not maintaining the urges by feminizing yourself occasionally. The longer you go without any self-feminizing, the stronger and more unbearable the urges will become. Likewise, over-indulgence in feminizing yourself will become less "magical" over time.

  • You absolutely need to find a real girl that will be aware of your AGP, and participate in the experience with you. This is crucial, and you should not settle for anything less.

  1. You need to learn about women, and understand female psychology if you wish to become "good" with women. Women are the opposite of men - logic and thinking rationally are not the way to interact with women. The best way to communicate with women is physically, and emotionally.

  2. Read this PDF: She Comes First by Ian Kerner. This is the holy-grail for teaching submissive-type men how to make love to a woman. The type of woman that is receptive to the styles of love making discussed in this book are good candidates for types of women that will be open and receptive to your AGP - with the ultimate goal of participating in your AGP being a requirement.

  3. Once you have a girlfriend, you can discern how compatible you are sexually. Most AGPs are submissive, so being with a woman that is submissive likely won't work out long term (although it might - you never know).

  4. Most men suck in bed - it is unbelievable. Most women have an idea of what good sex is that is way off the mark. If you are lucky to be her first partner that gives her multiple, sustained orgasms, every single time - she will do almost anything to keep you. You can fuck up so many times, and it won't matter with how many orgasms you can give her. Submissive men are much less likely to cheat, and sexually fulfilled women are much less likely to cheat.

  5. She will wish to please you sexually, after you open her up to this new world of sexual pleasure. Start slow with a chastity cage and panties, then move on to shaving, and over time, she will become aware of your AGP. The goal is to make your girlfriend your Mistress, and the owner of your pathetic clitty. This process begins and ends with you being the king of her orgasmic pleasure. Once she realizes that keeping you in chastity = increased pleasure for her, she will take off running.

  • Having a partner to share with, and be open to your AGP sexuality is amazing, and it should be the sought after goal for AGPs who desire to live the lives of straight men. You can be a man for her in every other way, and vulnerable in the bedroom. When you have this, you will most likely not worry about transitioning much anymore. Of course, the more blue-pilled types in the main trans subs still seem to transition anyway... and subsequently watch their relationships fall apart.

  1. Being in a female-led relationship full of chastity and pegging is great, but what I often enjoy is just feminizing myself and hanging out with my girlfriend. I enjoy being in my narcissistic bubble of "gender-euphoria" just as often as I enjoy engaging with her while feminized. Her presence alone is wonderful.

  2. I like to take lots of selfies when I am feminized, and it occupies much of my time as a replacement for going through the arduous process of hairy, working man-to- soft, shaven girly boy. I don't have any social media other than reddit for myself as a man, but my female persona has an Instagram and reddit account where I can post lots of pictures.

  3. This is something my girlfriend isn't much a fan of, but it is something else I require to maintain my sanity: I need to be validated. I need validation from men that I am hot, and I need to read the things that strange men online would like to do to me. I need to be a slut for men, but only so far as the online world of anonymity extends. I have no desire to meet with men as a sissy in real life, and this would be considered cheating in my relationship. My mistress fulfills those needs for me anyway, and she is better at fucking me than any of the guys that have had a go.

  4. This narcissistic, validation-seeking side of my AGP is very important to me, and helps me maintain my sanity. When I have a night where I can be all dressed up, and just take lots and lots of selfies / pictures, I can use these pictures on social media and online to satiate my AGP desires for many days, weeks at this point.

  5. Typically these days, it is my girlfriend motivating me to get dressed up more than myself. She just loves making me happy, and I love making her happy. I have watched her become a much more confident, proud woman over the course of our relationship. I love her more than anyone, even myself. She is a beautiful woman for putting up with me. Being in a relationship with an AGP means there will always be another woman competing for my attention, and she knows this. She is amazing for all I've put her through.

  • Other users like Grindenhausen have their own methods for living as heterosexual men with AGP, and these methods are just as valid. I don't knock anyone for sharing what they know works for them, and I know that this method won't work for AGPs that start to indulge in self-feminization and end up going overboard, or taking things to unnecessary extremes. This is what works for me, and I know it may sound unattainable to many of you, just keep in mind none of this connected for me until after I turned 30. I was about to explode from not acting out on my urges to feminize myself until after I turned 30. Don't freak out so much about this AGP stuff, it can be bad for your health! Feel free to ask me any questions you may have about anything in this post. You can live as a straight man with AGP, and have a normal fulfilling life with zero urges to transition. I promise that you can have everything that you want out of this life, despite AGP. You might even wake up one day and have one of these in your life:

Yours truly,

A Giant Prick


r/askAGP • • Apr 04 '21

Chaser on Autogynephilia

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/askAGP • • May 19 '26

[MTF] After years of forced feminization fantasies, I finally transitioned — and became my own fetish

69 Upvotes

Hi everyone. This is my first time sharing my full story here, and it's a bit unconventional compared to what you usually read.
The Beginning
Ever since I was a child, I had an intense fetish for feminization. I would wear my mom's clothes, her heels, anything feminine I could find. As I got older, I would book motel rooms just to dress up completely as a woman in private. But here's the thing — I was just a regular guy. I had a girlfriend. I wasn't attracted to men. I didn't feel "trapped in the wrong body" in the traditional sense. I just had this burning fantasy that I couldn't shake. I knew I couldn't die without knowing what it actually felt like to be a woman.
The Decision
Three years ago, I made the biggest decision of my life. I started HRT, grew out my hair, and committed to two major surgeries: facial feminization and body contouring. I went all-in from day one because I was terrified I'd regret it halfway through, and I figured if I was going to do this, I needed to go hard.
For the first year, I kept living as a man while the hormones did their work. I watched my body change while maintaining my normal life. It was surreal. After my surgeries, I'll be honest — there was some regret. I thought, "What have I done?" But I knew there was no going back, so I forced myself to push forward.
The Mental Shift
I had spent years watching forced feminization content, and I found a therapist who understood my goals. We worked together on mental exercises to literally break down my old self. I wanted to rebuild myself as the woman I had fantasized about for decades.
And it worked. Today, I have become my own fetish. I see myself as sexy, feminine, and desirable every single day. I wear very high heels (it took time to learn, but now they're part of my daily life), dress provocatively, and keep long nails. Sometimes I think I might overdo it, but this is for me and my own fantasy fulfillment.
The Hard Part: Sexuality
The most difficult transformation was my sexuality. I used to be into women exclusively. But through intensive mental reconditioning and training, I completely shifted my attraction. Now I'm exclusively into men. I have no interest in bottom surgery (SRS) — keeping my penis reminds me where I came from, and honestly, it forces me into anal sex, which I now view as the ultimate form of submission.
Where I Am Now
Are there dark days? Absolutely. Are things complicated? Yes. But overall, I'm doing well. When I look in the mirror now, I see what I always fantasized about. I pass as a biological woman most of the time, though I definitely attract attention because of how I dress — think very sexy outfits, sky-high heels, dramatic nails. Some might say it's too much, but this is my journey and my fantasy made real.
I'm open to answering any questions you might have. I know my path isn't the typical narrative, but it's mine, and I'm living it unapologetically.


r/askAGP • • Jun 16 '21

Seeking cross-dressers, transfeminine people, and others broadly interested in the idea of being a woman to participate in an online survey!

69 Upvotes

TITLE: Gender, Sexuality, Identity, Personality, and Mental Health of Cross-Dressers and Transfeminine People

PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR: Kevin J. Hsu, Ph.D.

ADDRESS: 1600 Woodland Road, Abington, PA 19001

TELEPHONE NUMBER: (215) 881-7955

DESCRIPTION: We are researchers at Pennsylvania State University recruiting cross-dressers, transfeminine people, and others broadly interested in the idea of presenting as or being women for a study that will examine gender, sexuality, identity, personality, and mental health within these communities. This study will require you to complete an online survey with questions about your demographics, political orientation, religiosity, gender identity, sexual and romantic history, sexual interests, personality, mental health, relationships, attitudes, and other aspects of your experiences and behavior. This study will occur online entirely on a computer of your choice, and it should take about 1 hour. You will not need to complete the entire survey or answer all of the questions in one sitting. If you choose to leave and return to the survey at a later time, then you must use the same device.

Please follow this link for more information and to take the survey: https://pennstate.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_4I5iJOdfDAfvvbn

Thank you very much for your time and interest! Please contact the head of the research study (principal investigator), Kevin J. Hsu at (215) 881-7955, [email protected] for further information.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: You must be at least 18 years or older to participate in this study.


r/askAGP • • Sep 03 '22

The ideological roots of "gender dysphoria"

66 Upvotes

What is gender dysphoria?

Gender dysphoria is a severe mental disorder that is diagnosed as systematically reported discomfort with the sex of the patient. That is, a man who suffers from GD is a man who suffers from a severe mental illness in which feels that his body is the "wrong sex" which leads to feelings of discomfort and disgust regarding all that he perceives to be the sexed features of his body. These feelings should be strong and recurrent for a long period of time.

For example, a friend of mine said that his life would be easier if he was a hot woman which means he wouldn't have to work hard, but that is not gender dysphoria since it is only one way to manifest the opinion that hot women have an easier life than other people. For gender dysphoria to be diagnosed it needs to be recurrent and strong enough to impair functioning.

We will see that this mental disorder is a very recent social construct that is derived from the tacit acceptance of a specific spiritual framework. Let me elaborate.

Gender dysphoria and gender ideology

Wookie Haircuts said in a comment to another post:

...Many people on this subreddit are taking feminizing hormones and do not believe they can ever be women. However, I did find a correlation with gender dysphoria in AGPs and belief that you have a female soul, but the direction of causation isn't known. So it might help some AGPs to understand that they are not or cannot be literal women, but many will still be unhappy with their bodies and will continue feel unhappy unless they take feminizing hormones or find some other method to get rid of gender dysphoria.

Funny fact: Roughly 40 years ago nobody reported such feeling as "feeling unhappy with their bodies" in the sense of having a body of the "wrong gender." Now hundreds of thousands of people report these feelings. Why?

Back in the 1980s when Blanchard and co-authors were creating the concept of AGP, they saw patients which were typically middle-aged men with a crossdressing fetish that were obsessed with the idea of changing their sex. People 40-50 years ago believed there was a thing called a "sex-change" operation and they believed that sex change was a real deal, unlike crossdressing which was regarded as only pretending to be the opposite sex. Back then, their symptoms were not about hating their bodies but about "wanting to become women", an idea that they associated with sexual gratification.

So how can gender dysphoria come about? Its origins lay with the mainstream conception of transsexualism instead of Blanchard's approach focused on paraphilias. Harry Benjamin reported a rather sophisticated case a couple of decades earlier, the case of a man called William J. O'Connell:

....

The leopard cannot change his spots, and I cannot alter, if I would, the basic femininity of my psyche. If there is indeed an eternal soul, then I suppose mine to be in gender feminine. At all events, what is certain is that from babyhood I have known - call it intuition, call it recognition - known beyond all doubt that I belonged among the women, and have longed to take my place there. Englishmen born and raised in India go home to England. So with me, always: to become a woman would be to come home. A dull home, perhaps, that of a thirty-four-year-old spinster, but still and always home. This would be my happiness: to wake tomorrow and find myself just such a woman. It is, you may think (especially if you are yourself such a woman), a curious sort of happiness to pursue. True, but plain water is more than champagne to one in desert lands.

The pain in my life is not merely that caused by prejudice and misunderstanding. Far more, it is the pain of conflict, the profound dichotomy of mind and body. I have perforce "lived a lie" as man and boy, always painful, always false. Yet to dress as a woman, not being one, is equally false, as well as dangerous. What, then, to do? A problem implies a solution: the solution to mine is to alter one of the elements, mind or body, to conform to the other. Putting aside the possibility of an unchangeable feminine soul, I still must say that my mind and heart - my 35 psyche - have been shaped by a thousand million longings and choices and feminine values; I could not acquire a masculine psyche without ceasing to be myself. Any psychiatrist would admit, that a "cure" is hopeless.

But, if mind-conforming is not the solution, there remains the alternative: changing the body to fit the mind. This, within limits, is possible; and to people that accept false teeth and spectacles, plastic surgery and artificial limbs, it ought not to appear unreasonable. A man may be made endocrinally female by the female hormones, which control the secondary sexual characteristics of hair and breasts; and anatomically female by the removal of male organs and the surgical creation of a vagina. She cannot bear children; but, surely, if she is female in anatomy and hormones and psyche, she is a woman. This limited womanhood became my goal, this was the happiness I pursued.

My decision was made in the clear perception that my life was quite intolerable in its falseness. After some hard, realistic thinking, I went to a sexologist, a man wise in the ways of glands and their secretions. He received me with kindness and understanding, and sent me to a psychiatrist who confirmed his judgment that I was of sound mind and quite competent to decide where my happiness lay. Then he carefully began the process of feminization by the administration of estrogen and other female hormones. Months went by while my breasts began to develop and other changes took place and while my doctor studied me and tested and observed. Then at last - a glorious day - he approved me for surgery.

....

(The transsexual phenomenon, pages 34-35)

This narrative was written around 1960 and published in the highly influential book The Transsexual Phenomenon. This kind of narrative became the blueprint for the gender identity ideology: that people have a sexed soul separate from the body and that the body can be changed to match the sex of the soul. Also, note that this guy really believes that a sex-change operation changes the person's sex (like Blanchard's patients).

But like Blanchard's patients, the patient Harry Benjamin quotes never reported the symptoms we associate with gender dysphoria today, that is, the feeling of discomfort with his body. His symptoms were instead, platonic symptoms: he believed that he had a soul that was matched to the wrong body and that to achieve happiness, his soul should be placed in the correct body, that his soul could migrate from body to body in the same way that an Englishman born in India could return to England. Today people who identify as gender dysphoric report different symptoms from this platonic conception, instead they claim to feel "uncomfortable" or to "hate their body" because that is the symptom they were socially conditioned to develop and perhaps to associate with gender.

Humans do not develop gender dysphoria if they are not socially induced to develop it. That is because humans are bodies: a man is a man, and a woman is a woman. Saying that you are a "man trapped in a woman's" body is just nonsense from an objective perspective. It can only make sense if you assume that humans are not animals living in the real world but magical spirits that inhabit a body.

That is, suppose that people are souls that wear bodies like they were meat suits. Then, if you think your body is a meat suit you wear, then you think your body might be uncomfortable, and this belief combined with the idea that maybe if you had a "female meat suit" you would feel better, leads to the belief that if changing your sex will make you feel better. This belief is what leads to the feeling that your sexed characteristics are disgusting.

Therefore, to first believe your soul can be mismatched in some way (which leads to either discomfort or this platonic desire to be a woman), it is only if you have the delusional belief of being something else than your body, then you can develop the belief that you are in the wrong body. For example, among hundreds of people who identify as gender dysphoric, I never heard one say "I am disgusting", they say "I hate my body", they can only say that because they actually fail to understand that they are their bodies.

That case Benjamin reported had some of these characteristics. It is a bit different but the main ideological elements that allow people today to develop gender dysphoria are there: people have sexed souls that can be mismatched to the body and this mismatch can be corrected with the magic of sex change. However, other elements were more platonic: instead of formulating the concept of treatment of gender dysphoria as distress from being born in the wrong body, he thought that the path to happiness lay in changing his sex because his soul was female. Also, today people who report gender dysphoria tend to believe that hormones are the really important component of their magical cure rather than sex-change surgery (most transgender people do not even have it today).

These are cultural differences because we live in a different time: if the label "gender dysphoria" will still be in clinical use in 50 years then the reported symptoms of gender dysphoria in the future will be different from the symptoms that are reported today. The fact is that "gender dysphoria" lacks a very precise psychiatric definition and the poorly defined nature of it motivated me to write a satirical piece that pokes a big hole at the DSM-5 diagnosis of gender dysphoria since their definition can be shown to logically imply that men who regularly shave their beards have gender dysphoria: Do you shave regularly? That might be a symptom of gender dysphoria (substack.com). This only shows that the concept of gender dysphoria is poorly formulated by the psychiatric profession at the moment.

Modern Gnosticism

Gender ideology is in fact a modern version of the Gnostic Cults that emerged during the days of the Roman Empire:

Gnosticism - World History Encyclopedia

People thought that salvation meant recognizing that material reality is evil (in the case of gender dysphoria, the belief that your real body is evil) and trying to transcend by learning the secrets of God which they called "gnosis" (in the case of gender dysphoria, transitioning to the right sex). These similarities have been perceived by some conservative political commentators (White House Embraces Transgender Ideology | National Review).

That is why I think it is correct to state that gender ideology is a religious cult: gender dysphoria only exists if one accepts these fundamentally religious concepts. Also, we should keep in mind that religious feelings have been shown to be as strong as any others and that means that people can be willing to do anything for religious beliefs (including suicide), and also religious beliefs can cause extremely severe mental disorders. Just because a concept has a religious origin instead of a physical origin does not mean it is less genuine.

Puberty and gender dysphoria

Many teenagers report feeling weird about their puberty. That's because they grow fast and these changes can be sometimes perceived as bad. Then, these teenagers might come into contact with gender ideology, which states that these feelings are caused by the body-soul mismatch.

Teenagers are gullible and it is easy to make them interpret natural feelings from growing up as some sort of body-soul mismatch. It is by interpreting their feelings through the ideological framework that claims that "bodies are meat suits" which can lead to the development of gender dysphoria. This is why gender dysphoria is so endemic in this demographic and why it can be common among teenager people without unusual sexual proclivities such as homosexuality or AGP.

Homosexuality, AGP, and gender dysphoria

Homosexuality can lead to the conclusion that the person has a female soul: what differentiates men and women more than anything else in mainstream society is that men marry women and women marry men. Homosexuals do not want to do that because they are sexually attracted to the same sex. In fact, among poorly educated people in developing countries, it is often understood that homosexuals are not real members of their sex because they partly define the sex of a person with the social role of procreation. In addition, homosexuals have brains closer to the opposite sex, and also gay men do tend to look slightly more feminine on average than straight men, and butch lesbians do tend to look slightly more masculine on average than straight women. So, if they come in contact with gender ideology they can rather easily develop the belief that they have a male/female soul trapped in a female/male body.

AGP requires a bit more mental work to lead to gender dysphoria. Typically, it is a middle-aged man who has crossdressed for decades that slowly developed a female character that he portrays in his crossdressing sessions. After many years of doing it and then coming into contact with gender ideology, he starts to believe that maybe he is not a real man but a female spirit inhabiting a male body. Back in Blanchard's days, these men never developed the symptoms of gender dysphoria while having lived as men for decades and in most cases marrying and having kids, because gender ideology did not exist in its present form and there was no internet to spread this ideology around.

Summary

An important evolution in gender ideology over the past few decades is that back in the 1980s people believed there was a "sex-change surgery", while today people believe that gender is separate from sex, also believe gender is inborn, and finally, believe that gender confirmation surgery (instead of sex-change surgery) is a necessary measure to achieve happiness. This means that today we think people are born transgender which implies that many people are brainwashed to believe that if they do not undergo the magical ritual of "gender confirmation" they will be forever impaired since they are "repressed transgender." Which naturally leads to gender dysphoria.

In the past, men (women) just thought they were men (women) and that they could become women (men) by having a sex change. Hence why it was called "sex change surgery" and not "gender confirmation surgery". Then, some people thought: it was OK to be their sex, but it would be EVEN BETTER to be the other sex and identified as transsexual. These people did not feel disgusted about their sex, they just felt it would be better to "switch" to the other sex, which means they did not develop any beliefs of disgust towards their bodies. Now things changed: teenagers are brainwashed into believing that they need to transition to the opposite sex and that they need to do it quickly before they become unable to "pass", otherwise they will be unhappy. This is what causes gender dysphoria.


r/askAGP • • Sep 01 '23

There is a hard pill of the week to swallow , prepare yourselves

64 Upvotes

Cis Females ARE NOT AGP and they cannot truly be AGP....

Moser study its a complete failure , it doesnt proof that AGP is female sexuality at all

AGP in denial that want prove they have some sort of female sexuality are only illusional

In the specific, AGP in females is simply ( erotic self focus ) .

Cis females dont develop compulsory gender transformation fetish as agp males do

Cis females dont develop body dissociation and embodiment fantasies for someone else body

Cis females dont develop emasculation fantasy or forced feminization fetish as agp males do

Cis females dont develop transvestic fetish for females clothes and dont get aroused by them

Cis females are not aroused by their own lactating breasts

Cis females are not aroused by their own period or dirty tampons

Cis females are not aroused by taking part in feminine activities socially like sewing with other womens

Cis females are not captured by other feminine women because their anima is triggered and they want to merge with them .....

I know ... the pill is hard to swallow ... but we must swallow it there is not other choice


r/askAGP • • Mar 16 '26

15 years of crossdressing and I'm done. Here's why

63 Upvotes

I wanted to share something I’ve been sitting with lately.

I’m 27. I’ve been crossdressing since I was 12, started building my own wardrobe at 19, and over the past two years went deeper into it than ever before. I checked off pretty much every box: going out fully dressed, getting good enough at makeup to pass, exploring things sexually, building a decent following online.

But recently I started asking myself harder questions about where this is actually going.

A few things I keep coming back to: I don’t think this lifestyle is sustainable long-term. Finding a partner who genuinely accepts it, not just tolerates it as a kink, seems rare to the point of being unrealistic.

The window where it’s even physically viable is also finite. And the path to having a conventional family life gets narrower the further you go down this road.

There’s also something that bothers me about the culture around this that I don’t hear talked about enough. A lot of it, when you look closely, is rooted in a pretty demeaning view of women. The whole fantasy often frames femininity as something lesser, submissive, something to be worn as a costume rather than lived as an equal. That’s never sat right with me, and the more I stepped back, the harder it was to ignore.

When I’m honest about why I got into this, two things stand out. I’ve always struggled socially, likely due to being mildly on the spectrum, and women in particular were hard for me to relate to. On top of that, I have a serious porn addiction that warped how I think about sex and probably fed a lot of this.

The frustrating part is that on paper my life is fine. I’m reasonably attractive, I’ve had real relationships, good friends, a solid job, things I care about.

Looking back, I think this was a kink that took root in low self-esteem and quietly grew from there.

I’ve decided to do a full purge on May 1st: clothes, makeup, toys, online accounts, all of it. I’m exhausted by how much mental space this takes up, and I want to actually build something with my life instead.

Curious if anyone else has reached a similar point, and what that looked like for you


r/askAGP • • Mar 29 '24

Repressing is the only logical choice for most people

63 Upvotes

Please note how I’ve said for MOST people. There are a few who are either rich enough or have the genes to pass well enough to get past all the negatives of transition. But for the other 99%, it’s simply not worth it.

I haven’t been very active on this sub for a while, but this is something I’ve been starting to think about as I continue to repress. And considering the pinkpill posts recently, I think this needs to be said.

Transition is objectively a foolish idea. Repressing healthily is the best way to have a stable, safe, and successful life. You can say whatever you want about being your “true” self, but here’s the reality:

  1. Living as a non passing or clocky trans woman is insanely tough. You get looks from people at best, and I don’t even want to talk about at worst. Even just doing simple things like going to the grocery store would become anxiety inducing events. Going to work and looking presentable becomes a huge challenge if you aren’t lucky enough to work remotely. Maintaining a feminine appearance requires more work (makeup, hair removal, voice training, etc) than it would for a cis woman, and WAY more work than living as a man. This will take a LOT of time out of your day and become exhausting over time, causing you to stay at home more often.

  2. Chances are you will look much better objectively as a man than a woman. It will be way easier to maintain a clean look and keep relationships in your life. People will like and respect you more, and you’ll have much better chances at dating. Boymoding is not a solution, because it’ll eventually give you an uncanny look and boobs.

  3. Dysphoria can be managed through a healthy relationship with AGP. You can keep indulging, keep fantasizing, and keep crossdressing as much as you want without actually transitioning. Shave as much as you want, and grow your hair as long as you want. Pretend to be a woman online if you need to. Embrace a genderfluid life, and you can still keep the perks of being a man. This will save you a lot of time so that instead of transitioning you can focus on more important things in life, like your relationships, hobbies, passions, and career.

  4. Money. Unless you’re lucky, you’ll need to spend large sums of money on surgeries to pass as well as possible, which will also take up time and energy from your life.

  5. The chances of losing family/friends or at least harming those relationships is very high, and even a little unethical if you have a wife/kids. People are still transphobic, even if they don’t realize it. This will literally define who you are, instead of just being a normal guy. You will likely be seen as a weirdo, even by your own family.

I could go on, but you get the idea. It’s not about whether you’re truly trans or would like the changes from HRT or not. It’s just the actual reality of transition in this world. You probably already know about most or all of these, but reminding yourself of the risks will keep you on the right path.

If you don’t care about all of this, do what you want. But I’ll keep being a coward and repress, because it’s the smart thing to do. I wish you all the best, no matter which path you take!


r/askAGP • • Jun 09 '24

I think I'm done with the concept of AGP (my final post)

61 Upvotes

This sub and community sucks, I'm sorry but I had to say it.

The amount of worthless and frankly toxic discussions here are doing nothing but fueling self hate and shame. It's just the same individuals posting the same schizo brained posts, looking for any reason to deny themselves happiness in order to live up to this man made concept of "being normal". You guys are doing nothing but spinning your tires in the sand, you're accomplishing nothing, you're waiting for someone to save you and that's just... not going to happen. I used to post here all of the time trying to figure myself out and i can say after 5 years, it was a MASSIVE waste of time. I accomplished nothing but hate myself more by obsessing over the incoherence of transgenderism and therefore AGP must be the truth and suppressed knowledge that must come out into the limelight. I frankly dont care anymore, i've been living in the moment after my transition and im just existing as a happier care-free version of me.

There is a thriving community of trans and lgbtq+ people who will love you and accept you for who you are and together we can make the world a more tolerant place for people like ourselves (AGPs included). You DONT have to agree with every little detail of the movement, i certainly disagree with aspects of it but I know ultimately the community is a force for good... even if they can be cringe sometimes. Consider it growing pains.

Instead of sitting on your asses at home and crying about your "affliction" (that isnt even an affliction but just a normal human experience) why don't you devote sometime to liking who you are by allowing yourself to actually be kind to yourself? You can be in love with yourself as a woman and become the actual person of your dreams, thats dope as fuck... and once you realize its not that big of a deal you can start loving others and being a thriving/contributing member to society. Your AGP is cope and you use it as a tool to deny yourself happiness because you are to cowardice to own who you are in a public setting.

There's nothing wrong with being trans, there's nothing wrong being AGP, if you deeply desire to be a girl just fucking do it... man. Enough of the self hate, enough of the repression, enough of the pandering to people who don't actually care about you. There is one person who is responsible for your happiness and thats YOU.

Go outside. Ride a bike. Grow some boobs. Wear a dress. But for love of the flying spaghetti monster, just do fucking something!!!