r/arcteryx • u/TumblingBroccoli • 9h ago
Jacket advice for hiking
This is one of those Atom vs. Proton vs. whatever posts, sorry :)
I am a happy owner of a Beta AR and a down jacket (the Rab Microlight). I do multi-day hikes in England, Scotland and Scandinavia, also in Spring/Fall, in rainy conditions (0-10 C, 30-50 F). I take the down jacket for warmth, but it works on my nerves that I can't let that become too wet.
I am looking to expand my collection with an insulated jacket that provides warmth while being less sensitive to water than the down jacket. Doesn't have to be waterproof as I have the Beta for that, but I don't want to worry if I have to pull it on over a wet baselayer, for example, or during prolonged periods of rain where the Beta eventually lets some water through.
It does not have to be a midlayer while hiking (and therefore not super breathable): I find that while moving, I am fine in a baselayer+fleece+Beta if windy. It would be a jacket to stay warm during breaks, while waiting for the bus back, at camp.
I would also prefer to wear it casually (to work) as a standalone jacket. No pouring rain (have the Beta for that), but a small rain shower would be nice so I don't have to take the beta out every day.
I have tried the Atom on, which felt great but not too sure about the stretchy side panels in terms of watmth. Is the Proton better for the above situations? Are one of the variations of these jackets (SL, heavyweight) something to consider? Am I correct that the Gamma is a fairly non-insulated softshell (and therefore probably too cold for this?)
Thanks in advance!