r/arcteryx • u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. • Dec 20 '20
Meta Shell Selection Flow Chart - Development Project
24
u/IyamNaN Dec 20 '20
First, I love it. Something like this has been floating around my head for a bit.
I might consider some outlinks to content such as “are you sure you want pit zips?” As most people think they know that they do when often it is not needed.
Other dimensions I would add, “do you often stack multiple jackets with hoods” which precludes drop hoods.
6
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
Hmmm... something that crossed my mind and is considerably more work is more of an infographic style which integrates that sort of information. Not sure I have the time these days but I can mull that over.
Otherwise yes, that simple decision point for DropHood is very useful. I will see about remapping some things for V2. Tying features to activities and behaviours is the goal here.
4
u/IyamNaN Dec 21 '20
Yeah. This additional work was why I never started it. But seeing this, it is clear perfect is the enemy of good.
12
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
Truly.
One of the things I’ve found is that people are super bad at making an initial thing. But super good at criticizing a thing they see. I find this a very useful behaviour because it means that all I have to do is make something quick and dirty, and then listen and everybody helps make it great.
3
1
3
u/Cicada17 Dec 21 '20
Nice job. I like that you kept it simple and not clog with overdescription.
2
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
Simplicity is, I think, absolutely key for this to work. People are recommending a lot of additional information and much of it is very useful.
We'll see how much I can add before it feels bad.
3
u/Spark217 Dec 21 '20
Love it if you could also have a trim/fit aspect to this. Not sure how you’d work it in. Maybe as a side data criteria
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
Yes, fit seems to be one people are interested in. There’s basically just two levels of fit here, so maybe it can be made to work?
1
u/Spark217 Dec 22 '20
Yeah, the issue is that fit for tech wear is dependant on the layering system they intend you to use. I tried on a Sabre yesterday and the large was too large, the medium was too restrictive.
4
u/ChiefJoJo74 Dec 21 '20
This is terrific. It hits most of the key criteria. I’ve thought of a similar thing which added hoods, pockets, abrasion and packability dimensions.
You could argue pocket placement is a function of using a harness or not making that moot in your graphic. I do think we’ve seen enough questions about hoods, abrasion and packability that it makes sense to weave those in... “want pit zips, abrasion resistance but strongly prefer separate hood and collar -> Beta AR.”
3
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
I’ve thought of a similar thing which added hoods, pockets, abrasion and packability dimensions.
I will have to analyze that post for more information, thanks for the link!
You could argue pocket placement is a function of using a harness or not
You definitely could argue that, and I don't think it's wrong. I personally don't care for hand pockets on shells even though I don't usually use a harness. But I think the point stands.
I do think we’ve seen enough questions about hoods, abrasion and packability that it makes sense to weave those in
Hoods yes, packability maybe, durability I really just don't think anybody actually needs to care about. The 40D nylon GTX Pro is enough for basically everything most people do. 80D is just so extra, and the Alpha SV's 100D, what is that even for? That said, you're not wrong that people definitely do want to know about it!
8
u/PocketG Dec 21 '20 edited Dec 21 '20
Nice job, this is a pretty complete flowchart of all the jackets I don't like the feel of and have zero interest in buying. 😅
I'm more of a softshell/fuzzy/ski/windbreaker/urban/runner type of fanboi. Fairweather climber, if you will.
I really only wear obnoxious loud, scratchy crunchy hard shell goretex when it's raining/snowing.
6
u/johnflstf Dec 21 '20
PocketG, while I LOVE his chart idea, I completely fall into your camp. I hate the sound and feel of wearing a potato chip bag, er, I mean hard-shell. Would you mind sharing which jackets you prefer and what you like (and if applicable don’t like) about them?
11
u/PocketG Dec 21 '20 edited Dec 21 '20
In no particular order :
Fuzzy Fleeces: Polartech High Loft is my jam. This is the ultimate touchable fuzzy fleece.
-Mountain Hardware Monkey Man Fleece and Pants. You literally become a furry monkey if you wear this. https://www.mountainhardwear.com/p/mens-polartec-high-loft-jacket-1858721.html?dwvar_1858721_color=233&pos=0
-North Face Campshire Pull Over. I own two of these. Prepare for people to want to touch you. https://www.thenorthface.com/shop/mens-campshire-pullover-hoodie-nf0a4r5d?variationId=R70
Strechy Zipups: Polartech Power Stretch is the shit. Kyanite Hoody/Jacket, and Rho Ar are made from this stuff and I love it. Just lite fuzzy stretchy awesomeness.
Outerwear: A lot of windbreakers are swishy plastic, These are not. Best soft technical hand feel: Gamma (Fortius), Solano and Trino (Goretex Infinium). Good technical hand feel: Nuclei, Argus, Squamish.
Stuff that goes without saying: Proton, Atom, Cerium, Thorium.
Pants: I live in athleisure, 2 way/4 way stretch. Mostly running/yoga/travel pants. Lululemon, Cotopaxi, Prana. The best damn comfortable/durable pants right now for everything from climbing, work, casual, chilling, are the Prana Stretch Zion Straight Pant, imo. These are seriously good pants. I don't know which arcteryx ones are like these, but if they make some, I'd get them.
Baselayers: SmartWool. Merino wool. Thin 100/150 type and thick 200/250 type. It's expensive as hell, but it doesn't stink. I also enjoy synthetic stuff like Odlo. The Army issued me some synthetic long underwear called the GEN III ECWCS system. I've had it for over a decade and it's still amazing stuff.
Fun stuff to have:
If you live where it's really cold: Fleece lined pants or straight up Fleece pants. Also fun as hell....Down puffer pants. Are you man enough to rock these in public as outerwear? https://www.mountainhardwear.com/p/mens-ghost-whisperer-pant-1871181.htmlI live in southern Japan and commute on foot or by bike. My goretex rain setup is Refuge jacket/pants from Showers Pass. My skiing kit is a Saber suit. Being military over the last 15 years I've been issued so much crunchy goretex that doesn't breath and just turns into a billowing sack of sweat. I've had to wear that shit during hot and humid monsoon seasons in South Korea and typhoons in Japan. So I really hate gear that conjures up bad memories of ill fitting hoods, fogged up ballistic eyewear inserts, and sweating buckets just from walking.
My current branch just allowed us to start carrying umbrellas. Real talk. If Arcteryx made a $150 umbrella that was sturdy enough to withstand 20-30 mph winds blowing off the sea of japan, I'd buy it.
3
u/johnflstf Dec 21 '20
PocketG, wow! Now THAT is a reply. Many thanks for your insight. I completely agree with your assessment of Polartec Power Stretch. I have the Kyanite, but didn’t know the RHO AR was made from it too! It’s now on my list to get. Let me recommend my absolute favorite... the Lorum Hoody. Same Polartech Power Stretch, but just a tad nicer imo than my Kyanite.
Just read up on the Trino and the SL Hoody version is on my short list too.
Another insight for you, my soft-shell-loving brother from another mother... I have and like my Gamma MX Hoody, but one of my first Arc purchases was the Hyllus Hoody, with its Polartec Power Shield O2 High Loft. These two jackets perform the same function, but I find the Hyllus twice as snuggly AND it has a longer rear hem (my only “Gamma gripe” is it’s shorter hem). As they are next to each other in my closet... I arrange my 35 Arc pieces by use (please forgive the shameful “flex”), I almost always reach for the Hyllus instead of grabbing my Gamma. Just a thought if you can find a Hyllus, buy it. Don’t think, just purchase. You can thank me later.
Let’s see, what else... ok, some jackets I own and have gripes:
Beta AR: I DON’T PREFER THE DROP HOOD BECAUSE I OFTEN HAVE HOODED MID LAYERS AND THEY DON’T NEATLY FIT INSIDE THEM. Oh, why was I SHOUTING? Because the Beta AR is so damn LOUD if you even move an inch, whomever your talking to won’t be able to hear you. (For the rest of you... PocketG is right there with me... yes, that was a GRIPE.)
Theta SV: Loudish, but not as rock concert awful as the Beta.
Ok, how about a GoreTex jacket you might, PocketG, be able to live with in a downpour. My go to shell is my Sabre Pullover. Partly because the colorway Nebula is awesome, but mostly because it’s a “softshell” GoreTex, it’s not nearly as loud as the “hard shells”. Nearly. (Shouldn’t matter if it’s a pullover or not, that’s just the model I have.)
...And no, I don’t think I AM man enough to rock those down puffer pants!! Lol!
Thanks again for the effort you exerted in replying to my question, PocketG.
2
u/PocketG Dec 21 '20
No prob, John. Got sober this year and lost 40lbs so its been a year of donating fat clothes and then trying to make the wardrobe one that sparks joy.
Many an afternoon I've spent walking around Tokyo and Yokohama fondling nice outdoor gear trying to find the stuff the feels best.
I'll check out your recommendations. Be well
1
2
u/Alternative_Bench_38 Dec 21 '20
Absolutely love this. But IMO the Beta SL hybrid is awful next to skin. Though that’s likely just personal preference about PacLite.
5
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
The upper parts of the Beta SL Hybrid are C-Knit (yoke and arms and underarms I believe?). That’s why I put it there. Also I don’t know where else to put it.
3
u/BaronsDad Dec 21 '20
I use mine as a rain jacket and it's my default shell when I go long hikes spring/summer/early fall. Low exertion. Long hours. Might rain/get windy. Gamma MX for similar low exertion hikes that's colder but snow is more likely than rain.
1
1
Dec 21 '20
This is great. Only thing is I think the alpha and beta fl are much better rt an zeta for emergencies as they are much higher quality and still packable. Otherwise perfect
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
While I agree that the Alpha FL is a phenomenal emergency shell, I do have to list the Paclite shells somehow. I wish Arc'teryx would just stop selling them.
1
u/Psycho1024 Dec 21 '20
Great chart for hardshells. However, for shells, should just default at Gamma LT and go on from there. So many people think they need gore tex this and that while a good simple softshell would serve them better for 95% of their use.
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
I think discussing the "to hard shell or not to hard shell" question is a bit beyond the scope of this concept. The idea is that if you're researching hard shells you walk the flow chart to figure out which to pick.
Does somebody need to make a decision tree for deciding to hard shell or not? Yes, somebody probably does need to do that.
Now I generally agree that people need hard shells way less than they think they do. Although I would advocate that the Squamish or Houdini Air are where most people want to be, not the Gamma series. But that just depends on what you're doing I suppose.
1
Dec 21 '20
When does one need to consider the Beta FL over the Gamma LT? Asking because I’m about to buy a shell. This had me considering the Beta FL.
5
u/IyamNaN Dec 21 '20
Sustained Rain or heavy/wet snow, hard shell. Intermittent rain or light powder my snow, softshells.
My hardshell gets far more use in PNW than my soft shell.
1
Dec 21 '20
Im PNW, ill go with the Beta then! Thanks!
1
u/IyamNaN Dec 21 '20
Awesome. Planning any activities with it or general everyday wear?
1
Dec 21 '20
Cycling, carpentry and everyday use.
1
u/IyamNaN Dec 21 '20
It will work great, although cycling I find I want something cycling specific so it’s shorter in front and longer in back.
1
Dec 21 '20
I don’t love riding in the rain, but maybe that’s part of the reason...
2
u/IyamNaN Dec 21 '20
Like all things being done in the rain, it’s a mindset. You are going to get wet, either from the outside due to rain or from the inside as you over layered. Accept it and the knowledge you are hardcore. 😀
Gore makes some sweet cycling jackets. Also, castelli/sportful make some nice wind stopper jerseys I prefer.
1
1
u/iammortalcombat Dec 21 '20
Pockets...hip? Chest? 1,2, or more? May make it too cluttered but it would be helpful
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
The struggle between too much information and too little is rough. Hand vs chest pockets is definitely a strong decision point. Absolutely on the list of things to consider.
1
u/dylbeano Dec 21 '20
Wish I’d had this like 10 months ago
2
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
Perhaps tomorrow night, while I’m attempting to take over the world by altering the timeline, I can drop this post off in ten months ago for you!
1
u/Apocarion Dec 21 '20 edited Dec 21 '20
Awesome stuff, but which one do I buy to walk my dog in the park?
On a more serious note: Would it make sense to overlay the "core intended use" with this chart?
For instance blue, yellow and green for all-round, climbing/mountaineering and hiking. You could draw rectangles in those colors (can be faint) around all jackets, indicating what they are best used for.
Edit: Something like this: https://images.app.goo.gl/RNrLPtNog8HGdQDW6 without different shapes and added color legend.
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
but which one do I buy to walk my dog in the park?
You stop at the top, Beta FL! =D
For instance blue, yellow and green for all-round, climbing/mountaineering and hiking. You could draw rectangles in those colors (can be faint) around all jackets, indicating what they are best used for.
I think colour is out since I’m targeting colourblind users as an accessibility point. But symbols or patterns perhaps might make sense.
I’d like to cover blind users too which would mean being screen reader accessible as a PDF or HTML. Not sure how that works yet.
1
u/Apocarion Dec 21 '20
Makes sense. In science we usually try to use color blind friendly palettes for data visualization.
1
u/jrbake Dec 21 '20
Cool chart, I’m just not sure what to do with “start here with Beta FL” - go with that jacket if you have no interest in other features listed?
2
1
u/onetermpeanutfarmer Jan 09 '21
I see the Beta SL selling out at some places. Is this primary for it providing the general Arc aesthetic at a lower price point, or is there a true gear superiority to it somewhere?
I see it indexed as next-to-skin, but know that PacLite is not particularly breathable. Does it present something that either an all Gore-Tex Pro or all Infinium piece could not do better?
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Jan 09 '21
Do you mean Beta SL Hybrid, or Beta SL?
1
u/onetermpeanutfarmer Jan 09 '21
Sorry, the Beta SL Hybrid. Did they make an SL this season?
2
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Jan 31 '21
Ooops, sorry, missed responding to this.
Sorry, the Beta SL Hybrid. Did they make an SL this season?
No, they didn't. It was effectively replaced by the Zeta SL a couple seasons back.
Is this primary for it providing the general Arc aesthetic at a lower price point
Yes I think this. It was strictly worse than something like a Zeta AR or a Beta AR. I am perplexed by the Arc'teryx need to fill in the lower shell price point. That's not what the brand is about? The new S21 Beta LT is filling that same niche. It's not really increasing the versatility of the product, it's not a Patagonia Pluma. It's a cut-rate product. At least it's better than the Beta SL Hybrid.
or is there a true gear superiority to it somewhere?
I don't think so, no. It was adequate for several things, but not the best choice for anything.
I see it indexed as next-to-skin, but know that PacLite is not particularly breathable. Does it present something that either an all Gore-Tex Pro or all Infinium piece could not do better?
The Beta SL Hybrid, if memory serves, was Paclite in the torso, and C-Knit in the yoke, arms, and hood. Basically anywhere skin would touch if you're wearing any kind of shirt. I think the mid-trunk is generally not that problematic for delamination, so it wasn't that bad.
I never really understood what the Beta SL Hybrid was for, and that hasn't changed. But I am glad it is gone because the new Beta LT is mostly a better product.
1
u/onetermpeanutfarmer Jan 31 '21
Thank you so much for this input! Your insights are always the best!
I think we approach when Arc makes new or revises products from the same two optics: (1) does the tech have some, albeit very niche at times, unique value or superiority, and (2) trying to get some semblance as to what the hell Arc has going on behind the wizard's curtain. FW20 was a weird season, but we can chalk that up to COVID for now.
To your point, the new Beta LT starts to put us back on the right path. This is not to say that there is anything revolutionary about the Beta LT outside of the fact that a jacket like this was not in their recent lineup despite it being the best solution for the huge push of new outdoor or tech casual folks. Again, not knocking the jacket as everyone needs a jacket like this (I have a ~2012 Zeta LT that is literally this: 3L Gore-Tex with pit-zips that may have more days against it than anything else in my closet). Just trying to keep my eyes open so we don't become like Apple super fans that are so dedicated to the brand that they go nuts over a feature that has existed in the market for several years.
3
3
u/Rmccabe69 Feb 05 '23
I know this post is older, but as someone who is about to buy his first arc this guide was more useful then their website
2
1
u/paleo_anon Feb 04 '25
What's the main difference between the Zeta AR and Beta AR? I'm looking for a summer backpacking jacket
1
1
1
1
u/quiverfull7 Dec 21 '20
Sublime - something you’d think Arcteryx themselves should’ve come up with a lot sooner.
Without begrudging sincere inquiries, here’s to hoping your charts defaff (unfaff?) the sub
1
1
1
1
u/eolewind Dec 22 '20
Hello,
This is a great idea and start! Thanks. I think you will help a lot of people. Here is a few thing you could highlight:
A legend chart specifying different of GoreTex Families by their quality. Most of the time it's the key difference between All Round (AR) and SeVere (SV) of the same family as an example/
For you arrows guideliens, options you could also add
"hike in moutains vs plains"
To define the shape:
example : The Zeta family (which is part of Traverse collection) is longer, great for shity coutrisides hike, such as scotland or forests. The Alpha is for alpine env. means harness, as you mentionned.
Also note that in mountain you want to wear a helmet under your hood.
You can't with a zeta.
"I wear a big bagpack or not" :
The SL and FL are not recommended for long haul trips with backbacks because of shoulders abrasion. But they are lighter, more breathable and ultra packable (heck the emergency stuff).
For a multidays trek shity weather, consider a AR or LT. from the next section.
"(Winter or high altitude ) vs (summer or high output)"
The AR is more for winter or high altitude (>3000m). But it is not breathable enough for high output or summer.
I think consider a SV as AR you will scratch against walls, unfriendly rocks, climbing equipment, skis edges, etc.
"How about mixed weather AKA it's raining, but not really"
This is where the GAMMA (softshell) series comes in ;-)
Or if you do some wither high output in dry conditions in the mountains, such as ski. it a plus.
You could highlight these family names color codes.
take care!
1
1
u/kcdtx Dec 26 '20
Just wanted to give you props for this great piece. Can't wait for the next. ((Tapping fingers))
1
0
Dec 21 '20
[deleted]
1
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 21 '20
It might be!
I will definitely have to trim information of various kinds to retain its readability. We'll see what makes the cut!
1
87
u/Astramael Urvogel Jr. Dec 20 '20 edited Dec 21 '20
Been thinking about doing easy decision flow charts for a few different product lines for awhile. Decided to take a stab at the shells first.
This is just a first pass, quick and dirty. What do you all think? What should I change? I'm sure we can create something that's easy to use and useful with this format.
Initial thoughts:
Has to be information-light, and easy to figure out for somebody that is new to Arc'teryx.
How do I mark the DropHood on the Beta AR?
I should probably do it 3-wide with the Alpha SV in the climbing column right? I just don't know of anybody who uses the Alpha SV for serious climbing.
Where does the Beta SL Hybrid belong?