Neighbors hired a company to install a walkway. They dug about 16” deep into the root system of a large oak near the edge of our property, roughly 4’-5’ from trunk. Tree is 60-70 feet tall and very old. Should I be concerned about the health of the tree or increased risk of tree fall?
Contractors haven’t cleaned up yet so I can see a lot of the roots that they dug up laying around. Most appear to be 1” to 3” in diameter.
I have a good relationship with these neighbors, but I was pretty blindsided by this. I do love the tree, but not enough to get confrontational about it. I figure they may not have known the contractors would do this. But is it crazy to think the company who did this without talking to me are out of line? Or is this no big deal?
Edit for clarity:
Thanks for the helpful responses. I don’t dispute that the neighbors have the right to do what they want on their property. I wish the contractors had taken care to not jeopardize this tree, but what’s done is done. I’m simply trying to understand if there is an alternative to me being on the hook for a very expensive tree removal to mitigate risk of collapse onto a structure.
Additional edit:
I can’t believe I have to explain this, but I did not plant this tree here. This tree was here before me, my neighbor, and probably either of our houses.
Update: I have called several professional arborists of varying qualifications, and there does seem to be a general consensus that the tree is more than likely unstable, with about 40% of the structural root base compromised. While nobody can guarantee whether or not it will collapse, it's too close to too many houses and structures to roll the dice. The tree will be coming down, it will be pricey, and I am very sad. But I will work with my neighbors and their contractors to seek as fair of a resolution as possible. In the meantime... "The grass withers, the flowers fade, and sometimes the oak tree in your yard gets massacred by a grossly irresponsible contractor with heavy machinery... but the Word of our God will stand forever." -Isaiah 40:8. Sure, I'm upset, but life is too short to hold onto bitterness. So onward and upward; there is much else to be grateful for. Thanks to all who offered helpful advice and encouragement, and I apologize to anyone I got snippy with in the comments. Be blessed, everyone.
Update #2: Finally had a chance to speak with these neighbors last night, and turns out they are roughly as upset as we are with their contractor. The excavation was done when they weren't home, and they were badly misled about the way the work was going to be done, the depth of the excavation, the route of the path, the installed product, etc. Moreover, the contractors did something similar to a tree of their own in the front yard, and they paid for this work, so they are likely more upset than we are. We will be working together to make sure the company takes full responsibility, and insurance claim(s) will be filed as required. Never assume the worst in people, folks - there's often a lot we don't see! Good neighbors are out there, and a lot of times it starts with trying to be a good neighbor yourself. "Do unto others..." you know the rest. Be well!