After all the hype, I sprung for two new Apple TV 4Ks and four HomePod mini 2s, intending to use them either in a four-speaker surround setup or as separate stereo pairs in the bedroom and living room.
With all the talk about Siri AI coming to the new HomePod minis, and the new Apple TV shipping with Siri AI, I assumed I'd be able to use the minis as both TV speakers and smart assistants.
Apparently, once you set the HomePods as your TV's default audio output, the Apple TV takes over Siri requests whenever it's on. That would be perfectly acceptable if the TV actually provided spoken Siri responses. Instead, you're left with text or graphical responses on the TV screen, with no audible feedback from the HomePods.
From the explanations I've seen, this is intentional behavior based on Apple's assumption that you're looking at the screen when the TV is on.
But did nobody at Apple consider that people might want to interact with Siri without staring at their TV? Like, say, asking a question or setting a timer while cooking in the kitchen with the TV on? Right now, if I ask Siri to set a timer while I'm cooking, the Apple TV interprets that as a request for a sleep timer and literally shuts the TV off when the timer expires, without any audible confirmation to let me know that a timer was even set in the first place).
The whole appeal of HomePods is that they're hands-free smart assistants that can also function as speakers. Why should using them as TV speakers compromise their usefulness as assistants?
Part of me wonders whether this is intentional. Sell people on HomePods as both speakers and smart assistants, then limit their assistant functionality when they're paired with an Apple TV, effectively pushing customers toward buying additional HomePods or a HomeView just to regain functionality they thought they already paid for.
What's especially frustrating is that I've found other Reddit posts from people who've used both older and newer Apple TV/HomePod setups, reporting that they could previously get spoken Siri responses from their HomePods while the TV was on. If that's accurate, Apple hasn't just overlooked an obvious use case it's taken away functionality that previously worked.
FWIW, I bought this setup because I wanted to get away from Fire TV's bloated UI. Ironically, I'm now starting to think my Alexa-enabled Echo devices worked far better within that ecosystem than these HomePods do in Apple's.
Am I missing something here, or has Apple actually taken a step backward with its new ecosystem?