Preface: This is very much a work in progress, and it's open to suggestion and critique. Due to a lack of coherency in the definition of an abstract god, I'm going to develop particular themes that are common to many gods to determine whether Natural Selection can be said share them. Lacking any one or several attributes does not necessarily disqualify Natural Selection from divinity; any cutoff point would be arbitrary and likely exclude other individuals commonly described as 'gods'. We must rely on the preponderance of the evidence to make a final determination.
Omnipotence/Omniscience/Infinitude/Omni-whatever:
Natural Selection definitely has none of the plenary powers in this suite, which are usually limited to the capital-G monotheistic God. I'm developing the idea of Natural Selection as more like a pre-exile Hebrew Yahweh: essentially a stand-alone god that doesn't quite belong to a polytheistic pantheon or deny the possibility of other gods, but which is our god. If you're unwilling to posit a god that is not God, you can stop here. Then again, you probably weren't ready to LARP a Materialist for the purpose of the arguement, either.
Mind/Personhood:
This is likely to be the most contentious point of the argument. It's very common, when discussing evolution, to hear the reminder that Natural Selection is a non-intentional process, that there's no ultimate goal of creating 'better' organisms - mutation is the result of natural processes, and different mutations are more or less likely to survive in conditions as they change. The mutations that are inheritible accrue complexity over time, and tend to (but don't always) provide an ever wider range for survivability/fitness, which we describe as progress or improvement purely subjectively, using our experience as a yardstick.
That reminder has to be made because of how common it is to describe Natural Selection with intentionality, even to personify it, and the dutiful Materialst will want to point out that this is metaphorical language and mitigate the chance of 'woo' settling in.
But why can't Natural Selection have intentionality? For a Dualist, the answer might be easier, but a Materialist is forced to admit that the human mind is also just a series of exceptionally complex processes. There is no room for free will in strict Materialism - either the universe is deterministic or stochastic, but it is not open to something other than other molecules/energy states moving the molecules/energy states that define our thoughts. What is diagnostic of a mind in materialism? Coherent Intentionality. This opens the door to many things being 'minds' that we may not be ready to to consider like us. Some materialists seriously talk about the universe as a mind. Dismissing the intentionality of Natural Selection appears to be more performative than rigorous; if we're not so desperate to defend against the creep of woo, it's much easier to see Natural Selection as having will or intention - not to produce better organisms, but to see that life survives.
Natural Selection is not selecting for mind. It's not selecting for moral character. It's selecting for survivability.
I'm iffy on the argument for personhood; I haven't been suitably convinced that there's a satisfying argument for identitying ANYTHING as a person while excluding something else, other than it's a convenient category we use for separating out actors and non-actors in our lives. Thus we tend to depersonalize people that don't matter to us and we don't interact with, while personalizing our pets, cars, home, etc. (I'm very open to assistance or critique on this point.)
But I think Natural Selection can be 'personified' - if we need a personality as a step in granting personhood - as cold and heartless. Natural Selection doesn't care about you. If cockroaches offered more survivability than humanity and the two were pitted against each other, Natural Selection would not care which one was smarter or painted the Sistine Chapel. Natural Selection is competition-focused, pitting her [why not her? we can roll her up with Mother Nature] children against each other in a scramble for limited resources, and regularly ensures the carrying capacity of those resources will be exceeded, in order to test survivability. Natural Selection is not interested in creating heaven on earth or giving anyone a life of ease - Natural Selection is only interested in the proliferation of life.
Differentiating that goal from the presumed goal of 'progress' makes it much easier to map the intentionality to what we observe, and mitigates the need to defend against an appearance of progress.
Practical Efficacy:
Consider Thor. As a subject of Germanic mythology, Thor is certainly a god, whether or not he's a god that exists. As a subject of Marvel mythology, we don't generally consider him a god. What's the difference? In the Marvel mythology, he's frequently called a god, just as in mythology. He has supernatural powers, and exhibits many of the same qualities of the Germanic god. Is it because the comic Thor does not demand worship? Neither do most pagan gods; worship is given as a bribe for favor/miracles much more often than it's depicted as desirable to the gods. It is because nobody beleives the comic Thor to have real efficacy in the world, whereas the Germanic Thor, for wrong or right, was believed to be able to intervene in the affairs of reality, and not just the mythological stories in which he featured.
Natural Selection is efficacious. She does not listen to prayers, and she does not take bribes, but we can witness her in the way viruses form new strains, bacteria evolve to feed on newly available resources, and finches speciate into groups most fit to survive on different food sources.
Supernatural Essence:
An obvious and important response is that Natural Selection is not supernatural. Most people take supernatural to mean 'extra-natural', or outside of nature, but it has historically meant 'above' nature as well, as in 'that which orders nature', which it certainly is. As a small-g god, Natural Selection is in good company with many other nature gods which are merely personified aspects of nature said to have control over their realm.
Origin of Morality:
While this is non-obvious without accepting some aspects of social evolution theory, as the morality we would want to see encouraged is not shared by Natural Selection, Natural Selection is the origin of our morality from the perspective of a materialist: our ever-evolving morality is an economy of memes (in the original Dawkins sense) that compete to drive the most fit society/human super-organism. An important point that arises, though, is that we can understand our morality to be experimental and fit to the moment just like all of Natural Selection's other creations; we can't derive a sense of objective rectitude from it. If we want pare our morals back to their core element, it is 'life must survive.'
Creation:
Natural Selection is not a creatrix in the demiurgic sense, like the Classical Deity. Rather, she follows a more typical pagan tradition of creating life from already-existing elements (as Adam and Even were fashioned out of clay, in the story). She is a creator, but a limited creator - more of a Lego enthusiast than the ex-nihilo variety.
So what?
This, too, is a good question that I don't have an answer for. I wouldn't expect this idea to sway anyone. And even if they were a Materialist who then accepted Natural Selection as a deity, she doesn't demand worship and it's probably a waste of their time (though we can throw it into the meme economy grinder and see what happens). They'd be better looking to current culture than Natural Selection for the most appropriate ethical stance, although they might be useful to have a semi-formal supernatural origin to appeal to as a way to blunt the arguments of those who can't posit the subjectivity of morality.
I really just thought the idea of a materialistic theism was an interesting topic to investigate.