I’ve been having particular trouble with tower rush defenses. Specifically in arena but I imagine tips can be transferred. I’m learning to recognize them better but it’s obnoxious. I don’t tend to win them at best I force so many towers by avoiding them entirely that their eco is imploded. My pocket shows up and I’m free but my pocket is behind. At worst their pocket comes and I’m left out to dry by mine. Which unironically… sometimes works better if my pocket is autopiloting to an army and I don’t end up defeated. But I shouldn’t be putting my pocket behind and I should be able to defend myself.
I usually play team on the side. Figured it gives me the most “real” experience to pressure. How do you win the 1v1? If pocket shows. It opens Pandora’s box so let’s focus on the initial pressure.
I play Byzantines usually and I can’t string a defense in there. Plus I like the civ. I know I’m in that phase. Haha.
Here’s what I’ve tried…
1)MAA - heavy delayment of castle. Usually I get one tower down and that’s it. They just villager hop between towers. Maybe I pick a vil or 2 off but feels horrible. After my gold runs dry I either continue MAA production (hopefully I have gold in a better spot) or cut it and I’m still behind.
2) Archers - delays me a little less? If I have like 4 on gold thinking I’m going into archers or playing an archer civ. It’s not too far out. Position them on the outside of the range on stand ground. But idk in my experience by the time I get the archers up they already have a tower blocking key resources I need. Slows a little but still doesn’t feel like a win. And if they get pulled in well… that’s that strat. I know stand ground exists. I forget sometimes lol.
3) Rush with the vils. This feels awful to do if I’m being real. There’s nothing that feels more barbaric and coin flipsy. I hate having to do it in any game. And depending on if I get a Fortnite kid who’s mastered quick building I could either win trading vils or they quick wall and I lose villager seconds on resources and then they still get the towers up. Or I lose vils trying to tear it down.
4) Build your own towers. This really never tends to work for me either. People rushing know what they need. Fletching, upgraded towers via teutons or Koreans or something and then packed with a half dozen vils repairing if a fight happens. Matching their aggression pulls those same vils off resources delaying castle and eventually I run out of stone because nobody’s really mining stone unless you’re rushing towers. Maybe I start mining stone? That’s a further delay. Delays castle, delays dropping a castle. Very rare I tend to win those.
5) Go castle. I mean I’d love to but it doesn’t workout whenever I try it unless the rush comes late. If the rush comes at like 9 minutes…. Fastest I can really manage is 14-15 minutes castle up time. I don’t preemptively play any of the fast civs plus that wouldn’t really make me feel like I beat the towers. Perhaps my up times are too slow? Idk I feel like I’m doing the optimal stuff? (15F/6W/2G usually what a shoot for clicking up at with no loom) while going for a FC. Then I either need to have the stone for a castle (oftentimes blocked by towers) or I need to both build siege and train mangonels while microing repairers. By the time I get the mango up I’ve got like 6-7 towers in my base and I’m like ripping nails out one by one. If their pocket comes with literally anything I’m cooked.
It feels like the only way I can “win” is to have them bring the rush late. At which point I can hit castle first. But that’s not really a counter strategy and relies on them not doing it correctly.
I’m not high elo. I play around 1000-1200 in team games. So half the time I get smurfs and other times I get noobs. It’s annoying when you do get smurfs because I’m still learning but it’s inevitable. If they go for a rush of some kind and I execute correctly I may lose the micro. That’s on me and I’m ok with that. Or perhaps I just didn’t build enough of the right units or time upgrades. Still on me. Just takes a bit of practice but I was in the right ballpark. If I hit someone in my skill level with the same strat. I execute. Bam. I win.
Right now it feels like I’m just not able to execute a proper defense.
TLDR: Help towers suck lol.