r/antinatalism • • 1h ago

Serious Discussion Take Responsibility and create a better future

5 Upvotes

The Responsibility of the Present Self to the Future Self

Our needs, desires, and values change over time. The person we are today is not the same person we will be ten or twenty years from now. Yet, the decisions we make today shape the life our future selves will experience.

From an antinatalist perspective, creating a new human being means imposing existence, with all its needs and potential suffering, upon someone who never consented to it.

From a promortalist perspective, one could extend this concern to our future selves: they never consented to the existential conditions we created for them.

But unlike the conditions of our birth, many of the circumstances of our future lives remain within our control.

If we believe it is wrong to impose suffering on another being without their consent, shouldn't we also take responsibility for minimizing the suffering of our future selves?

Building financial security, maintaining our health, developing meaningful relationships, and creating opportunities are ways of caring for the person we will become.

We cannot guarantee that our future selves will be happy with our decisions. But we can give them greater freedom, fewer unnecessary burdens, and better living conditions.

A true antinatalist need not reject the pursuit of a better life. They can recognize that, although they did not choose to exist, they have a responsibility to make their continued existence as good as reasonably possible.

We cannot ask our future selves for consent. But we can act with their interests in mind.


r/antinatalism • • 1h ago

Question Anyone else have parents that don't see you as a true adult coz you have cats instead of kids?

4 Upvotes

And now I feel like the older they get, I have to parent them.


r/antinatalism • • 1h ago

Personal Story dating as an antinatalist on apps filtering by "don't want kids"my stats and why it rarely works out

1 Upvotes

being upfront about antinatalism on dating apps is basically playing life on hard mode. almost nobody even knows what the word means, so i mostly just filter for people who explicitly mark "don't want kids" and swipe right on them. out of everyone i've ever come across on these apps, only one person actually knew what antinatalism was.

here are my actual dating app numbers so far
"You saw 2.543 profiles and liked 22.1% of them, skipping 1.981."

"You sent 552 likes and 47 of them turned into a conversation (8.5%, about 1 in 12).

You also had 10 conversations with people who liked you first.

In total, you sent messages in 57 conversations."

a few times i matched with people who seemed promising. we talked, clicked on some level and for a minute it felt like it could actually go somewhere. sometimes the distance got in the way, sometimes they probably just found someone they clicked with better, and honestly, plenty of times i just got ghosted. it's happened more times than i can count.

still, i don't really mind being selective. as a guy looking for something genuine, i'd rather be alone than force a connection that doesn't fit. i prefer keeping things honest and skipping the games. if you re also childfree or antinatalist, feel free to slide into my dms. worst case we just complain about dating apps together😄


r/antinatalism • • 2h ago

Screenshot / Video How is zeke antinatalist

Post image
4 Upvotes

People who make dumb comments like this don't understand antinatalism very well,I seen anime and this Zeke guy is more like a eugenics supporter rather than antinatalist since he wants to force sterilize a race in this case people with demon gene or whatever, also antinatalism philosophy is all about suffering reduction why would proffessor Benatar like someone who harmed people and caused suffering, if I remember correctly Zeke was quite sadistic in early episodes or when throwing rocks towards civilians and being used as weapon of war


r/antinatalism • • 2h ago

Analysis Non existence is like a dreamless sleep. One that you dont have to wake from

8 Upvotes

I think if people stopped seeing non existence as some terrifying thing they'd think more about whether creating new life is a good thing or not. And we already know what non existence would feel like (or what the absence of all feeling would feel like), which is nothing, because we experience it every night when we go to bed. Sleep is probably the closest thing we can compare to the state we were in before we were born and no one complains about missing out on anything or feeling anything bad while sleeping.

I think a problem with the asymmetry arguement is that people can't understand what non existence would be like so they convince themselves that not being born is some great tragedy. But they can understand it because they experience it themsleves everyday. When someone's asleep they are biologcally alive yes but they as a person are functionally "dead" for a brief amount of time. Same thing with anaesthesia. And I find it really ironic how we fear death yet see sleep as something so comforting.


r/antinatalism • • 5h ago

Meme I don't even understand why people choose to have kids

Post image
639 Upvotes

r/antinatalism • • 11h ago

Analysis Why to produce kids so they can die?

86 Upvotes

Death, the most painful thing. Think how will you die?

If in old age then there will be countless health problems. Your bodily functions will deteriorate. Every step you walk your knees will hurt, sitting or laying down your spine will hurt. Even good food will taste like medicine. You would have many operations by now. You will be alone and powerless.

If at a young age then maybe due to an accident or other health conditions. Both of them are very painful.

This planet has 100% mortality rate and it will be extremely painful. Statistically speaking odds are against you to pass away without any pain.

So why have kids if it is guaranteed to suffer a horrible death?


r/antinatalism • • 12h ago

Pronatalism Critique Why does it always have to biological children?

22 Upvotes

Why create more life just because it's your "own" in a way? Many children are the direct result of unwanted pregnancies or unstable home lives. Why not give those already existing a chance at life? Why does it have to be your own blood? Why do people always feel the need to create their own children while ignoring the many children who are a direct result of unwanted pregnancies or unstable homelives living in shelters? Why not give those children a chance at familial love? Many do not get it for circumstances that they did not ask to be put in. There is no guarantee that their biological children may end up in the same situation, no matter what picturesque image they have in their head of a perfect, tight knight family with their future partner. Is it truly because they want a child to love, or are they motivated purely by personal reasons? Perhaps they wish to preserve a "legacy". Perhaps they were socially conditioned into believing that biological children are the way. Perhaps they simply won't love an adopted child as much as one of their own. Whatever the reasons, you cannot guarantee that you'll be a capable, good, loving parent who equips their children with the proper skills to navigate the journey of life. The future is uncertain, and you may be directly feeding into the adoption crisis. There should be so much emphasis on creating new children when there are many in need of safe, stable, loving homes.


r/antinatalism • • 15h ago

Serious Discussion Just reposting my rant from r/antinatalism 2

18 Upvotes

I despise how my religion (that I have now secretly left) is so hellbent on the followers having children.

The religion of Islam has obviously many problems, but one problem I personally deal with is its forcefulness of making you have children, especially if you are a woman (I am so thankful I wasn't born a woman, I couldn't imagine how much worse it would be for me).

Its considered makruh (heavily disliked but technically not forbidden) to not have children. Whenever you think logically, especially during these horrid times to have children, everyone just says "But you dont know the beauty of having a child! You'll change your mind when you are older!"

When's the beauty? Is it when they scream and cry every night and ruin hours of your sleep? Is it when they poop constantly? Is it when you understand that they could grow up to despise you, or ignore you? Is it when they could grow up to die quick, or just not grow up and straight up die before they get to grow up? Is it when they cost almost $100,000 to raise for only the first five years?

Not to mention how it doesn't make sense why its so hated. Why would a follower of God have children, when they could just not have children and dedicate more time to God?

Children are expensive, annoying, and hard to take care of as well. Why is it so mandatory to have them?


r/antinatalism • • 16h ago

Question What about the hippy perspective?

2 Upvotes

I don't want children and usually arrive at the perspective that life itself is unnecessary and full of discomfort and burden.

I also go to a lot of jamband shows which is full of the hippy type. Tye dye and spinning and smoking weed and such. It's the type of crowd that considers themselves forward thinking and open to any perspective. As well as both empathetic and kind.Yet, that culture is very in support of birthing children.

I am curious what the antinatalism crowd thinks of these types.


r/antinatalism • • 16h ago

Advice Request How do you politely shut down people who feel entitled to ask when you're having children?

22 Upvotes

I've been getting bombarded lately with questions about when my husband and I are going to have kids, and honestly, I'm getting increasingly frustrated by it.

I'm starting to feel like I'm wearing a Scarlet Letter simply because I'm married, own a home with my husband, and don't have children.

What's particularly frustrating is the double standard. Nobody seems to bat an eye when unmarried couples live together, get pregnant, and have babies out of wedlock. But the moment a woman gets married, suddenly everyone feels entitled to ask when she's going to start having children. It's as if marriage automatically makes your reproductive plans public information.

The reality is that I simply don't want children. It's not something I'm undecided about, and I don't feel the need to explain, defend, or justify that decision to anyone. I shouldn't have to provide a financial explanation, a lifestyle explanation, or some elaborate reasoning for not wanting to become a parent. Not wanting children should be enough.

I want to get to the point where I can respond with something along the lines of, "That's a pretty personal question. Why are you asking?" or "Why is that something you're concerned about?" without feeling like I'm being unnecessarily rude.

I'd love to hear some clever, polite, or even slightly sarcastic responses that turn the question back on the person asking and make them realize how inappropriate it is without me having to explain my reproductive choices.


r/antinatalism • • 18h ago

Question Have you asked your parents why they had you?

53 Upvotes

I haven't asked yet, I'll definitely get to it. Though my parents say "having kids is life's purpose, there's nothing to do if you don't have kids", so maybe it was to not feel as bored and to fulfil their "purpose" 😑

Curious about what your parents said or if you have any ideas on why!


r/antinatalism • • 18h ago

Debate Are there religious antinatalists?

7 Upvotes

I'm curious if you are or if you know antinatalists who are religious?? I mean, I guess it could happen but it'd be extremely rare since the Bible says be fruitful and multiply, which makes me cringe every time I see it.


r/antinatalism • • 18h ago

Screenshot / Video The Bible agrees with us.

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/antinatalism • • 20h ago

Personal Story my cousin had two children to take care of her and hubby when they’re old, both children were born with high support needs autism

134 Upvotes

they had the first child in the hopes that they would have a guaranteed caretaker when they’re elderly.

then they had the second child to help take care of the first child.

both have high support needs autism, and they have been struggling immensely to provide for them.

thankfully, they’re not planning to have a third child.


r/antinatalism • • 20h ago

Debate Some now semi intentional pronatalist one-liner sayings now favorable to arguments that dismiss antinatalism didn't always have that meaning.

3 Upvotes

This is relevant because many times an unintentionally pronatalist saying is "life is short". The implication: it doesn't matter if pronatalist policies cause suffering, because the suffering is temporary. It's not actually that extensive, the human lifespan is not that long for suffering to matter for anyone if you think about it.

But that's not what the quote originally meant.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ars_longa,_vita_brevis

"skillfulness takes time and life is short"

The meaning was not that life is not actually that long, the meaning was that an individual mastering an art or skill takes longer than that individual's one human life span.

https://crossidiomas.com/life-is-too-short/

The phrase “life is too short” is a common idiom used to express the idea that time passes quickly and we should make the most of it. This saying has been around for centuries, with variations appearing in literature, poetry, and religious texts throughout history.

One of the earliest recorded uses of this sentiment comes from the Roman poet Horace, who wrote in his Odes: “Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero,” which translates to “Seize the day, put very little trust in tomorrow.” This idea was later echoed by other writers such as Shakespeare and Robert Herrick.

The "time passes quickly" interpretation of Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero is debatable:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carpe_diem

Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero,” which translates to “Seize the day, put very little trust in tomorrow.”

The ode says that the future is unforeseen and that one should not leave to chance future happenings, but rather one should do all one can today to make one's own future better.

Later on, maybe through pop culture whimsy, the phrase took on the meaning that life is too short to worry about anything, which is a favorable interpretation for someone that would want to dismiss antinatalist arguments that life is suffering. Suffering is not simply about magnitude, it's about the time period over which the suffering is experienced.

Words and connotations (and thereby what becomes the prevailing socially acceptable definition) change over time, perhaps deliberately to some conscious extent to make things more favorable to pronatalism. There doesn't have to be a conspiracy, the trend overall in humanity is for people that continue to reproduce and encourage it to become more, not less, pronatalist over time.

"Life is too short to worry" is a phrase originating in the 19th Century:

https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/lifes-too-short.html

What’s the origin of the phrase ‘Life’s too short’?

We feel as though we are busy these days, but that’s not new. This response goes back in print form to at least the late 19th century, and in people’s minds probably much further. In May 1877, The Morning Oregonian included a story with this opinion:

“Oh I say, drawled Gerard; ‘life’s too short to be wasted talking about a woman. Let’s go and get some beer.”

In 1975, the English writer Shirley Conran published the book Superwoman, aimed at busy women, and coined the phrase ‘Life is too short to stuff a mushroom’.

People seem to have got even busier since and ‘life is too short to …’ has become just ‘life’s too short’. Note the apostrophe. Perhaps now ‘life’s to short to type is’?

So unintentionally (or perhaps intentionally) pronatalist phrases dismissing or downplaying suffering (whether the suffering was arguably mundane or not) because of the "shortness" of life in which the suffering could take place were not always around nor recognized as the valid prevailing interpretation.


r/antinatalism • • 20h ago

Argument You can only be a woman after you procreate

34 Upvotes

The guy I was seeing told me this because he knew that I was antinatalist.

The problem is that I am very bad at argumenting in the heat of the moment.

He had a daughter, so he fully believe that procreation was necessary to became a man or a woman.

If they said it to you, how you would respond?

(Ps.: I dumped him, of course)


r/antinatalism • • 21h ago

Question Does anyone know a couple who meet all these criteria?

22 Upvotes

A man and a woman couple.

Met before either turned 30.

Still together and both are 45 or older.

No kids (both as a couple or beforehand).

Didn't not have kids due to infertility. So both were fertile as far as they knew.

Basically, I'm struggling to think of anyone who had every opportunity to have a child but still chose not to. I think this will become more common, but for Gen X and older I can't think of anyone personally.


r/antinatalism • • 22h ago

Adoption / Fostering Who’s here donating financially to those kids in need?

15 Upvotes

I am not adopting or fostering but have been giving out money to kids in need for over a decade. It is only $20-30/mth but I think it is much better than making my own child.


r/antinatalism • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Discussing the ethics of procreation when facing the reality of chronic illness and disability

10 Upvotes

Hello,
I recently discovered antinatalism after realizing I do not feel thankful for the life I was given. Growing up with chronic, severe physical health problems and unhelpful medical systems has made me view existence through a lens of profound suffering. It has made me wonder: how do people justify bringing new sentient beings into a world where bodily suffering is a guaranteed risk? 
I often stumble upon stories or videos of parents who find out beforehand that a child will be born with severe disabilities, yet choose to proceed anyway because of their own desires. This has led me to a philosophical question for discussion: To what extent is the decision to have a child, especially when there is a known risk or reality of severe physical suffering, driven by parental fulfillment rather than the best interest of the child? 
I’d love to hear the community's perspective on how antinatalism addresses the societal expectation that parents have an inherent "right" to reproduce, regardless of the physical burdens placed onto the resulting person.


r/antinatalism • • 1d ago Regret

Serious Discussion Why are we taught to make peace with the world being a horrible place and just continue to reproduce despite it?

149 Upvotes

Recently I have been thinking of how horrible things happen daily in this world and honestly it seems there aren’t any limits to the abuse and pain other humans are capable of inflicting on one another. And has further influenced why I support antinatalism. And I’ve questioned how my parents especially my father who always said “the world is such an evil place” brought me here and how ironic it is that he said that while he emotionally abused me himself..

It’s honestly terrifying to think that one person could be having the best day of their lives while another could be having something horrible done to them from assault to being murdered. And the prominence of the human trafficking industry is extremely disturbing people will literally commodify others to reap their own benefit. And that’s not even scratching the surface of what heinous things have been done towards individuals or entire ethnicites of people through history. And that these things continue to happen but it’s just seen as a normal part of life like “get over it” but that to me is truly unsettling and I don’t understand how it’s treated as a fact to just make peace with. Even as a child we’re just told often to be the change we want to see and while I agree that it’s beneficial it doesn’t negate all the harm that’s done to others. Or the fact that this is something that will continue to happen because it’s in human nature.

I


r/antinatalism • • 1d ago

Question Have you forgiven your parents? Should you?

3 Upvotes

Even if you happen to have good parents, do you feel like they have wronged you personally? How do you forgive them for having given birth to you? Do you think they deserve your forgiveness inherently or should they earn it? Do you think the act of giving birth to you is forgivable, should forgiveness for such act be given at all?

I’m puzzled at whether for forgive my parents myself.


r/antinatalism • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Gender and Antinatalism

11 Upvotes

I consider gender to be the most recognized cultural restriction.

It is no different from age and nationality, for instance.

Biologically, males and females are not vastly different. Majority of the characteristics distinguishing the sexes are related to reproductive matters (chromosomes, gonads/gametes...). The only meaningful categorization would be based on said anatomical specificities, this goes without mentioning intersex individuals whom culture doesn't even seem to acknowledge. Therefore, sex is merely relevant if the goal is procreation.

Gender roles are established around those distinctions.
Females are associated with "womanhood" that idealizes childbirth and fragility (in order to facilitate submission). As for males, they're provided with a manufactured sense of pride and responsibility from carrying the role of caregiver/ provider, and this is framed as both their duty and a condition for qualifying as a 'real man'.
As for stereotypes, they are additional tools that rigidify gender boxes in order to provide false evidence of their differences.

Both sexes are oppressed and coerced into the illusion of identity.

In reality, we are all genderless.


r/antinatalism • • 1d ago

Quote He was dead for millions of years with no inconvenience...

Post image
399 Upvotes

r/antinatalism • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion I hate the fact that I'm unable to share my antinatalistic views with my friends/people I meet irl

93 Upvotes

By sharing my views with them, I don't mean that I'm going to try to force them to adopt the same beliefs as me. Rather, I mean engaging in a peaceful discussion or debate in which both sides can hear each other's arguments.

The problem is that antinatalists are still a small minority compared to the general population. That's why, if you ever dare to publicly express the belief that giving birth to children is immoral, people will immediately frown upon you, perceive you as someone who is crazy or depressed, and ultimately treat you as an outcast.

That's why I've never really had the opportunity to discuss any of this with people I know, apart from my family, who are Muslims, btw. Yet, they still understood my arguments and respected my choice, even though they're religious.

I'd be very curious to hear other people's perspectives. Maybe there are some people here who feel comfortable discussing antinatalism openly.