r/antiai • • 1d ago Mindblown

Discussion 🗣️ Twitter user @make_claude claims that GTA 6 gameplay is running a behavioral analysis of you that will be used on the REAL you, so that companies can make decisions about real people

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

THIS HAS BEEN PROVEN AS MISINFORMATION NOTHING ADDS UP SORRY FOR THIS POST!!

second image was uploaded by them

Context (Note - the following is a machine translation of what was said):

"Rockstar Games fired me on Wednesday. GTA 6 launched the next day

I was a senior engine engineer at Rockstar North, working on RAGE performance optimization. Three months ago, I found a data pipeline in the telemetry module that shouldn't have been there, and I could prove where it led

Right now, every running copy of GTA 6 is collecting player behavior data. That part isn't news. Every game collects telemetry. The privacy policy says "anonymous gameplay data analysis used to improve future products." That's not what I found

The telemetry module's data feeds into an internal Take-Two system called Lens. Lens doesn't send anonymous usage statistics to Rockstar developers' dashboards. It builds a personal behavioral profile for every player. Not anonymous. Tied to your console account, your platform ID, your IP address

I reported this to my technical lead on August 14. He said it was "extended analytics for player experience research" and told me to leave it alone. I asked for the data processing protocol. He said it was handled at the Take-Two corporate level and wasn't Rockstar's responsibility

I pulled the complete documentation for the Lens data pipeline. Here's what I found:

The telemetry goes far beyond playtime and crash reports. Lens records every input with millisecond precision. Keypress timing, stick movements, reaction speed, trigger pressure patterns on the PS5 adaptive triggers. It runs behavioral analysis in real time and generates what they call a "player behavior signature" - a profile unique to each player, just as a fingerprint is unique to each person

Lens infers the following from your gameplay: impulse control score, risk tolerance index, aggressive response patterns, patience threshold, decision speed under pressure, spending impulsivity rating. These aren't debugging metrics. These are psychobehavioral categories

It wasn't until I found the outbound transmission pipeline that I understood what they were for

This data doesn't stay at Rockstar. It doesn't stay at Take-Two either. Lens sends the behavioral profiles through an internal API to a Take-Two subsidiary called Vantage Analytics. Vantage has no public website, no news page, no job listings. It was incorporated in Delaware in 2023

Vantage is a behavioral Al company. It uses player profiles to train predictive models and licenses those models to commercial clients. The pipeline documentation includes an incomplete client list. Two insurance groups, a credit risk modeling company, a hiring screening platform, and an advertising data broker

Your GTA 6 gameplay is generating a behavioral score right now. How fast you drive when no one's chasing you. Whether you stop at red lights. How you react when an NPC attacks you for no reason. How long you think before you act. How impulsively you spend in-game money. Every choice is feeding a model that companies are paying to query so they can make decisions about real people

I reported it through Rockstar's internal compliance channel on September 3. On September 4, my source code access was revoked. On November 18, I received a termination notice from Take-Two's legal department, citing "unauthorized access to a restricted business intelligence system" and "leaking proprietary data assets," with estimated losses of $350 million

I didn't leak anything. The Lens documentation was right there in the same RAGE source tree that every engine engineer reads every day. I never copied anything outside the network. All I did was follow a data pipeline to find out where it ended

Everything I had was already on my local workstation before they locked me out of the system. It was a standard RAGE source checkout that every engine engineer keeps on their own machine. I didn't sneak anything out. They just didn't wipe my device before they walked me out the door

They've handed this over to the FBI. They claim I tried to sell Vantage's model architecture to a competitor for $15 million. l've never discussed any of this with anyone outside Rockstar

I have the termination notice. I have the Lens data pipeline documentation. I have the Vantage customer list. I'm not deleting anything

32 million copies were sold in the first 24 hours. 32 million behavioral profiles were initialized within 24 hours. Not a single one of these people agreed to what was actually being collected, because the privacy policy doesn't describe it. "Anonymous gaming data analysis" is not the same thing as identifiable psychological profiles licensed to insurance companies

If GTA 6 is running on your console right now, Lens is running. Your gameplay is being scored

More to come"

thanks to u/Gavout15 on r/whenthe for sharing this


r/antiai • • Oct 15 '26

AI News 🗞️ Linux kernel goes full AI slop code, hides chatbot commits

Thumbnail
pivot-to-ai.com
1 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Oct 06 '26

AI Mistakes 🚨 Soooo... It's doing this now? I was asking about Xbox game pass and this was the result.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Jan 25 '26

AI Mistakes 🚨 Maybe learning how to draw is easier. Stupid clanker.

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/antiai • • 5d ago

Discussion 🗣️ Linus Torvalds is defending AI in Linux now. Seriously, what the fuck?

0 Upvotes

So apparently Linus Torvalds, the guy who created Linux, is now openly defending the use of AI in kernel development.

He literally said "Linux is not one of those anti-AI projects" and told people who disagree to fork it or just walk away.

Seriously, what the fuck?

We're already drowning in AI-generated slop, half-assed code, bogus bug reports, and tech companies shoving this AI bullshit into literally everything. Now we're supposed to celebrate it creeping into one of the most important open-source projects ever?

And sure, AI-assisted code review isn't exactly the same as blindly accepting chatbot-generated garbage. But that doesn't mean people should just shut up about the problems.

What's especially frustrating is how dismissive Linus seems toward people who genuinely oppose this stuff. Like, since when did questioning AI become the equivalent of being afraid of technology?

I'm genuinely curious what people here think. Has Linus completely missed the point of the anti-AI criticism, or do you think he's actually got a point?

Would love to hear some opinions, especially from Linux users and developers.


r/antiai • • Jun 06 '26

Slop Post 💩 “Oh my god Antis are soooo violent!!” The type of shit those same people generate: NSFW

0 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Mar 16 '26

AI Writing ✍️ Ao3 turned out to be pro-AI :/ the maintainers of the site basically admitted they're in favor of it, and the users just treat the problem as a "personal moral whim". RIP one of my favorite sites.

Post image
80 Upvotes

I get that AI is impossible to regulate or ban in a platform like this, but Ao3 stance on this and the way they worded it just makes it worse.

"Our goals as an organization include maximum inclusivity of fanworks...", "If fans are using Al to generate fanworks, then our current position is that this is also a type of work that is within our mandate to preserve."

I'm sorry, but that sentence screams they're pro-AI.

And it's also so infuriating how the users just treat the problem as a "personal moral whim". Are you kidding me? AI is ruining the environment, the job market, a lot of things, how is any of that a "personal moral whim"???

This all just reveals both the maintainers of the site and the users weren't against AI in the first place. RIP.

The worst part is that I mentioned all of this in the comments of the post and I just got downvoted. Great.


r/antiai • • Aug 27 '26

Discussion 🗣️ Why do most programmers like using ai and defend it?

0 Upvotes

Every time i see a cool new project its almost Always AI assisted. Then you tell them that AI Is bad and they Always get defensive.

Why? Has It fried their brain already?

A lot of people even on this sub Say that LLMs are actually useful for the "boring" parts of programming, that we're just using them wrong and that if you check the code Its actually fine. I am not a programmer, I have coding experience (Like lego robotics and stuff like that) but nothing with a real programming language but i am very techy,know how to use powershell/terminal. But i do not like when a program has AI in any part of it's code. If a program or a service, even if its free, has any AI code in It I avoid using It unless there's no alternative.

Is It too Extreme? I dont think im asking for Much, people have programmed without ai in even harder languages (if you can call assembly/something even lower level a programming language) ever since the computer has existed.

And also, somewhat unrelated, im sick of seeing local businesses use ai in advertising more than big companies!! My mom has a business and i design all her advertising/stuff She Needs for her and its not the best but Better than using AI slop.

Always talking about genAI of course

Edit:holy shit every time i refresh there Is a new comment. Anyways i encourage both sides to respond to eachother, if you agree with me them respond to someone Who doesn't and viceversa. This ensures a more balanced Discussion, even if we are in an anti-ai sub. And of course, helps me out because i cant respond to every single comment forever


r/antiai • • Jul 30 '26

AI News 🗞️ AI Trollies

Post image
0 Upvotes

The World is literally on fire, the UK is in a drought but wonders roll out AI Trollies! I'm baffled and my hope for the future is basically gone


r/antiai • • Dec 20 '25

Job Loss 🏚️ As a stop motion animator seeing this really sucked

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Sep 08 '26

AI News 🗞️ Navier Stokes

0 Upvotes

An internal openAI Model just solved a version of the navier stokes math problem. how did a stochastic parrot do this? I don’t feel so good bros 🤫


r/antiai • • 28d ago

Discussion 🗣️ Would You Actually Support Video Games Made Entirely by Humans?

0 Upvotes

I keep seeing people criticize AI and talk about how bad it is, but when it comes to video games, suddenly it's okay as long as the game is good. Or they'd suddenly be okay to reverse-engineer a video game and make AI mods with it. Or even, I've seen people hating on replacing artists with AI, but with code it's fine.

People will bash AI slop games all day long, but do they actually go out of their way to support games made entirely by real people? Or do they just complain about AI slop while continuing to buy whatever game looks good, regardless of how it was made?

This all sounds like hypocrisy to me, I'm curious because there's a difference between saying you're against AI-generated content and actually supporting the people who put their time, effort, and creativity into making something themselves.

I already don't have faith in humanity and we're already living in the AI dystopian world. It's simply not going anywhere. I still plan to publish my first video game on Steam without AI, but I doubt if it's gonna gain any success at all. It's already bad for people getting into the industry because not only I'm competing against experienced developers, I'm also competing against AI games that could technically just copy my whole game with Claude or whatever.

I'm already working on a first-person horror game, it obviously won't look that amazing since I'm just doing everything on my own with no AI involved. I stopped expecting support from people a long time ago, so I guess I'll just publish it and then change my career. At least I'd probably be proud of it.


r/antiai • • Aug 19 '26

Discussion 🗣️ The $2.5 Trillion AI Doom-Loop: The math makes absolutely zero sense.

10 Upvotes

I’ve been down a massive rabbit hole looking into the macroeconomics of the AI boom, and honestly, the math is completely broken. People keep comparing this to the Dotcom bubble, but what’s happening right now is a whole different level of financial insanity.

Here is why the AI sector is a ticking time bomb, broken down simply:

  1. The scale of this spending is genuinely terrifying

Projections show that global AI spending is going to hit around $2.5 trillion in 2026. Just to put that into perspective:

  • If the AI industry were a country, it would have a bigger annual budget than Italy's entire GDP (the 8th largest economy on the planet).

  • This single-year spend is basically the entire valuation of Amazon.

But here’s the kicker: global AI revenue for 2026 is projected at just $375.93 billion. That means AI is only bringing back a measly 15% of what's being pumped into it. It’s operating at a staggering 85% net loss. Think about how absurd the unit economics are right now: AI companies are literally spending $6.67 just to make $1.00 in revenue. No normal business on Earth could survive that.

2. Stop saying this is "normal hyperscaling"

Whenever you point out the losses, tech bros jump in with: "Oh, Uber and Amazon burned cash for years, it's just normal hyperscaling!" No, it’s not.

  • Normal Software: You build the code once, you take on some debt, and then you scale. Your cost to serve a new user is basically $0. Once it's built, every new customer is pure, godly profit margin.

  • AI: Every single prompt costs real money in electricity and compute power. If ChatGPT gets twice as many users tomorrow, their costs don’t go down—they double. You have a permanent, expensive bottleneck of training models plus the endless cost of running them.

  1. The 30-Year Debt vs. 2-Year Chip Nightmare

This is the ultimate structural flaw. To buy the insane amount of GPUs needed, tech giants are taking out 10-to-30-year corporate bonds and long-term loans.

But these cutting-edge chips are only useful for 2 to 3 years before they become completely obsolete and need to be replaced by the next generation.

To actually pay off those bonds, these companies would need to make all that money back plus interest in a tiny 3-year window. That is mathematically impossible right now. So what's their play? They are forced to issue new bonds and borrow more money just to buy the next round of chips. They are literally taking on massive debt just to finance their next round of getting into debt. It's a permanent hamster wheel.

4. Everyone is losing money (Creators AND Users)

To get out of this loop, AI companies have to jack up prices like crazy. But who is actually going to pay for it?

Right now, AI is massively underperforming for real businesses. A recent PwC study found that only 12% of companies using AI have actually managed to both increase revenue and lower their costs. The other 88% are either burning money on useless pilots or seeing their budgets eaten up by expensive consultant fees and messy data fixes.

The AI creators are bleeding cash, and the B2B clients buying the AI are also bleeding cash.

Conclusion: Betting on a Digital God

That 85% investment loss isn't a normal business deficit. It is a blind gamble. Investors are essentially betting that AI will rapidly turn into a literal "digital god" that can completely replace human labor end-to-end. Because honestly, that is the only scale of economic return that can ever justify a $2.5 trillion price tag.

If we don't see a massive, revolutionary jump in actual performance very soon, this bubble is going to pop catastrophically. And that's completely leaving out looming geopolitical nightmares (like Taiwan/chip supply chains), copyright lawsuits, electricity shortages, and the general public backlash against AI.

Change my mind.

Small disclaimer: I ironically used AI to help structure this text and make some of the arguments easier to follow and understand. The ideas and conclusions are still my own.


r/antiai • • Jun 19 '26

Discussion 🗣️ This Subreddit is Bad for Your Health

5 Upvotes

I'm very Anti-AI but I think I've realized that being in this subreddit is extremely antithetical to what most people here actually want.

The truth is, most people in the Real World are mostly neutral on AI. Arguments aside most people don't feel that strongly about it and may use it occasionally but don't pay it much mind. Sure this varies with younger people and creatives disliking it more and conservatives and techbros liking it more but overall, like with most controversial topics, the average person just doesn't care.

However, this subreddit makes AI, ironically, feel so much more prevalent and inevitable than it really is and I think it negatively impacts the people who join this subreddit for its intended purpose due to Rule 2 and Rule 3 not being enforced in the slightest. On this sub, the only users are people complaining about AI and brigaders looking to defend it which makes AI feel so much more infectious than it is.

Human, real, authentic art is still being made daily by millions of people in numerous forms and most people just aren't interested in AI "art" outside of the occasional post on their social media feed. There will be people who use their own anecdotal evidence to claim otherwise but the facts are that AI TV, Movies, and Music aren't making any significant impact on culture outside of making the people browsing subreddits like this miserable.

For what it's worth, I think the best thing anyone here can do is just leave this subreddit and go enjoy something human-made or make something yourself. AI has been facing copyright and legal issues since it first blew up and restrictions will likely come as long as the people continue to want it especially with the large AI companies burning more and more money each year.

No matter what some dumbass will always think differently to you, even the most hard to argue with statement would be disagreed with by someone just because. So just ignore the Pro-AI brainrotted clowns and go live your life, vigilant but free, while they sit behind a computer screen and preach about how AI is the future to the few who bother to listen.

And to those who are truly convinced AI will take over everything, Pro or Anti, just remember that there are millions of users on Reddit Alone who refuse to engage with anything made by AI which is a number that only increases as you explore other corners of the internet. There will always be a market for human-made content regardless of how far AI comes as it lacks the quintessential human experience that makes us care about art in the first place.

Thank you for listening to this little ramble, and have a lovely day.


r/antiai • • Sep 13 '26

Preventing the Singularity Hot take/ pure Copium ❤️‍🔥

0 Upvotes

Let me preface by saying this: The only data centers I support are Public Libraries.

Ai is pure hype- and hype is like karma, it only works if you believe it. Placebo.

The car was inherently more useful and practical when compared to the horse, thus the less reliance on the horse. Just like the camera and painting. Quantifiably and culturally we paint more now than ever. 🎨

Ai is completely Artificially Inflated, hence why they’re running at astounding losses and their shit is literally cannibalising itself.

Any system built on instability will fail. A house built on sand, if you will.

What we are seeing is just the ass end of a predatory system collapsing. If you suggested the idea of a public library in this economical ecosystem it wouldn’t work, because it’s built on empowering profits, not people.

The patriarchy and all its shadows will fall into the light of the matriarchy. 🌍

We’ll all be okay in the end.

Love finds a way ❤️‍🔥


r/antiai • • 28d ago

Discussion 🗣️ yall, ik yall hate ai but..........weeeeeee may need to do smth here

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Sep 11 '26

Preventing the Singularity The AI bubble isn't the dot com bubble

0 Upvotes

The current conversation around the AI bubble seems to be equating it to the dot com bubble where, yes the bubble will burst but the technology will continue to exist just like the internet today and railroads.

I don't agree with this case for a few reasons. When we look at the dot com bubble, it were effectively the businesses built on top of the very stable TCP-IP stack (that is still very stable today) that were financially unsustainable. Pets.com did't have a technology problem just a business IPO problem. Neither was the base technology very expensive. Not the Capex and neither the Opex.

I'm not exactly sure whether the LLM transformer architecture can be considered stable. For one, hallucination isn't solved and won't be and second the technology requires constant very expensive retraining.

With AI we know that the cost of technology is astronomical but the cost of operation is equally high with energy costs, training costs, cost of staff. Not to mention the interest rate at which today's AI companies are being funded is much higher than the 2000 case.

Once the bubble bursts and the sharp re-corrections happen I'm not sure AI will return . My main fear is that the bubble will kill a lot of created value which in turn will impact private equity, which in turn will screw the job market all over again


r/antiai • • Sep 06 '26 Bravo

Job Loss 🏚️ Came across an announcement for GPT-6 and I'm sh1tt1ng bricks

33 Upvotes

RANT INCOMING

So apparently this massive, remorseless water-sucker, ChatGPT has upgraded even more, and I'm so fucking scared. I'm planning on being a game developer soon and this thing can possibly outperform us; I have seen it has generated full browser games, such as a ripoff for Mario Kart.

Can't you companies not suckle the entire fucking ocean? Can you not be so fucking ignorant and cause us to lose our jobs, especially if it is like FIFTY years before we retire? I have LITERALLY went into adulthood and this shit has started to become too much of an issue.

I've had this dream job for quite some time now and I don't plan on it getting fucking crushed to smithereens before long. Our brains are being reduced to nothing but molecules.


r/antiai • • May 22 '26

Discussion 🗣️ Don't ban AI. Ban capitalism instead.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Sep 03 '26

Job Loss 🏚️ My blood is literally boiling at this reply

Post image
1 Upvotes

« It is just a tool » my a**

It is probably a bot but still boiling my blood because I know a lot of humans think the same.

https://www.reddit.com/r/programmer/s/9ocXv27Kpt

EDIT: Many nonstop wondering why this "calm and thoughtful post" is making my blood boil.
The reason is: BECAUSE IT IS NOT JUST A TOOL.
- TWO years ago, all SWEs were saying AI is dumb and its code is useless and just a better autocomplete, and they were right.

- 6 months ago a lot of SWEs stopped coding manually altogether and justs review AI code

- Now, a lot of SWEs claim they don't even review code anymore, anything that passes the unit tests (which also written by AI) get shipped.

Can't you see the trend?? Are some of my fella SWEs that blind of where is this heading?
It's not just a tool, it's not just "a new level of abstraction", it's a replacement!


r/antiai • • Jul 30 '26 Bravo

Discussion 🗣️ I dont like the direction this sub is going in.

2 Upvotes

Ok so this is probably going to get downvoted but I have to be honest about this sub.

It’s literally an echo chamber where people just make baseless and inaccurate arguments just to pump out one more sentence that remotely is against AI. It’s just a cesspool where people whine about made up scenarios and point fingers at pro AI rage-baiters and act like they are the problem.

I say the word "people" like most of the people here aren't bots reposting the same anti-AI memes every couple months.

Worst part is, whenever someone makes a GENUINE correction they are downvoted to oblivion and wiped off the face of the post.

Can we please talk about the actual downsides of AI instead of putting our attention to outdated facts or rage baiters?


r/antiai • • Oct 06 '26

Preventing the Singularity Skynet will actually happen apparently, scariest AI video yet

0 Upvotes

Kurzgesagt dropped a video explaining the Open Ai incident this year, please watch it, im at a loss of words.... Is this shit REALLY true? Did this actually happen?

https://youtu.be/ujkD4SxPKOI

Dude.... Skynet is inevitable if this video is true, I'm a very tech oriented person, I have a good grasp on pretty much everything modern tech but im flabbergasted here, I dont even know what to say


r/antiai • • 27d ago

Discussion 🗣️ A global revolution against AI its goal is to ban AI entirely from the internet.

0 Upvotes

r/antiai • • Jun 04 '25

Discussion 🗣️ What do you think about photo collage?

Post image
19 Upvotes

Photographers use already created images (sometimes taken from open sources, sometimes from magazines, for example) to create works of art. This is a recognized, "approved" method. Collages can be either analog or digital.

It seems to me that if you believe a person is stealing other people's work by using AI, then we should also "cancel" collage as an art form. Or, for example, can a collage made by hand from various AI-generated images be considered art? What do you think?

I ask you dont use arguments like "the person made an effort" or "there's a soul in it." Creating a collage from AI-generated images, you will also be making an effort. And, personally, I don't believe in the concept of soul. And idea and message can exist whatever artist uses.

This isn't a bait—I'm genuinely interested in this issue as a photographer.

Photo example: "Mellow Apocalypse" by Alnis Stakle.


r/antiai • • Aug 21 '26

AI "Art" 🖼️ AI in Avengers: Doomsday Trailer (to no one's surprise) Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I haven't seen anyone online yet talking about this "painting" in the trailer that looks very AI generated to me. Why are 3 of the figures melting into the fabric on his chest? And zoomed out... it all just looks super suspect to me. Am I reaching or does this look off to anyone else?