mich frustrieren gerade die vielen schlechten Reviews zu Anno 117. Klar, das Spiel ist nicht perfekt – aber wenn wir jedes RTS oder Aufbau-Strategie-Spiel direkt zerreißen, brauchen wir uns nicht wundern, wenn bald keine Entwickler mehr Lust haben, in dieses Genre zu investieren.
Ich finde, die Diskussion ist viel zu negativ und teilweise unfair. Vor allem grafisch, musikalisch, atmosphärisch und spielerisch hat Anno 117 wirklich Potenzial – ES IST NICHT SCHLECHT, nur weil es nicht sofort alles neu erfindet oder weil einige KI bilder verwendet worden sind. Wenn es so weitergeht mit den ganzen negativen Bewertungen, bekommen wir in Zukunft gar keine richtigen RTS/Strategie-Titel mehr.
Ich möchte auf ein Gespräch hinweisen, das Gronkh und Maurice Weber (GameStar) auf YouTube geführt haben. Ab Minute 28 reden sie darüber, dass das Spiel definitiv empfohlen werden sollte und mehr Unterstützung verdient.
Vielleicht sollten wir auch mal überlegen, wie wir das Genre stärken statt alles direkt zu zerlegen.
Was denkt ihr?
EDIT:
ich möchte noch hinzufügen:
Problem sehe ich dabei, dass selbst wenn die Punkte zwar stimmen mögen (ich rechtfertige ja nicht alles was falsch gelaufen ist) die Produktreviews einfach nur Blind dieses eine Take repräsentieren und sonst alles positive vernachlässigt wird. Das macht so ein Review halt vollkommen falschaussagend: so nach dem Motto je lauter und negativer ich klinge umso mehr werde ich gehört.
Das ist einfach nur noch meckern und heulen was stattfindet. Das geht aber mMn. ans Ziel vorbei und am Ende könnte Ubisoft aufgrund der Reviews und der daraus entstehenden Verluste, sich gegen eine weitere Entwicklung eines Anno spiels zu entscheiden.
German magazine PCGamesHardware published performance benchmarks for the Anno 117 release version (shoutout to u/Important_Still5639 who posted this on another thread, but since that was about frame gen I am gonna repost this to open the discussion on game performance):
For context: They built up a medium-sized city and did a small benchmark on there on various CPUs and GPUs. Now, if you just wanna see the benchmark, click the link and read up the numbers. If you don't like to hear any negativity about the game, please stop reading this post now, you've been warned.
The performance of Anno 117 in these benchmarks seems to best be described by the word "horrible".
4K60FPS on Ultra is borderline impossible - unless you give in to capitalism and pay Nvidia horrendous sums of money for their flagship model, 4k30FPS is a possibility, because this is still anno we are talking about and 30FPS are sufficient for that. I am not even going to consider the 144fps target, because a) why would you need it, and b) it's not like any card can deliver that right now anyway.
For the average joe: You'd expect modern medium price range cards could run this game at Ultra-1080p-60FPS, but they mostly don't. All the raytracing benchmarks are with upscaling enabled. Even with that you gotta have at least an RTX 4070 to run it, and it does not become any better without Raytracing but in native resolution. What most importantly was not tested: Raytracing in native resolution. You don't have to be an expert to guess that the numbers there will look even worse.
There is no card under 500-600€ that can run this game on Ultra settings at Ultra-1080p-60FPS according to these benchmarks, and the real numbers with those cards on your PC will be worse, because you'd not likely pair them with one the markets best CPUs available (Ryzen 7 9800X3D). I'd be interested in performance tests with medium and high settings to see how well you can play on affordable GPUs, but one thing is for sure, this game eats most GPUs alive and you will have to lower your settings even on Full HD.
And as a cherry on top, just look at the city they built for a moment - PCGamesHardware themselves acknowledge that real cities will be much bigger, and they just didn't have the time and permission to grow a city to that level and will deliver benchmarks with a big city later. If you recall the performance impact of big cities in 1800, this will likely be the same in 117 as there is not much you can optimize about rendering a metric ton of game objects.
TLDR: the things we see in the performance numbers are bad, and the factors that are not yet included in the numbers are going to make things much worse than that.
I think that we mostly agree that the item system in Anno 117 was not very interesting so far - and that, when comparing this feature to 1800, it is one of the games weakpoints, because they are less interesting, completely skipping extra goods and replaced inputs, which were very interesting, but also very gamebreaking, and as such did not make a comeback - so far. This all changes now.
In the recent blogpost, we got an announcement that 117 is introducing a new tier of items above Legendary, that offer more powerful effects, alongside a screenshot that seemed to show us one of the new items, and the effect that shows just how little lessons were learned from 1800, where many late game items absolutely bent over production chains.
Having written and published an entire redesign for the Anno 1800 items as a mod, the item displayed was kind of a jumpscare, and I am worried about the rest, but because I do not want to speculate, I want to give my 2 cents on 3 specific item effects that are seem to be making a comeback, and that were the main focus of the New Horizons item rebalancing when we worked on it. But first, let me open this comment with some praise:
Prestige Cost - potential for a decent Villa rework?
Simple, concise, and a good way to balance out powerful items against less strong ones. Prestige costs for heroic items are very good, because we cannot just put them onto a small island into an officia. No, using them means maintaining prestige, turning an otherwise pretty useless attribute into one very important, and suddenly, there is more than just the handful of fixed thresholds in the Villa screen. But apart from that, prestige costs for all items would make for a very, very good and badly needed villa rework.
The proposal: every item socketed, and every Officia you build has prestige cost, not just the heroic items. That means the more Officia you have, the more prestige your island needs, meaning that prestige required for item buffs scales with island space automatically. A small island needs to maintain just the prestige cost of 9 items in a villa, Cinis needs to maintain the prestige of 20+ Officia and items socketed.
That means hard thresholds for more sockets and officia could be abolished, making prestige much more dynamic and focused on the items that you actually want to use - you can use 9 low-tier items without issue in a villa, but the same prestige is only enough for a single heroic item, so you have to have it on an island with marble roads and an amphitheater. It makes you split production across islands, as you cannot use all good items on one island.
But enough of the thought experiments, even though I am happy that anything about 117 could ever lead me to have one.
Item Design - Extra Goods
Now that OP items are back, I want to now go over the item design pitfalls of Anno 1800, in particular, three effects: Extra goods, replaced input and workforce reduction, and explain how they break your ingame economy and can be unhealthy for Anno by reducing the actual number of things required by cutting transitive connection. Now, what is a transitive connection? It is:
the ship to transport a good,
the workforce needed for the ship and the production,
the goods needed to supply the population for the workforce.
The workforce needed for supplying the goods for the population
The first effect we look into is Extra goods. Paldius, the new item illustrated, is producing extra cheese from sheep farms. Narratively, it is good, but design-wise? What you get here is free production at zero cost. The extra goods effect cuts the entire production chain behind what it outputs, in this case, cheese.
That means we no longer build Oxen and Cheese factories in Albion, at least for the amount that we get from sheep farms. One could argue that it is okay, and it's not too much cut from the game if we do no longer build those two production buildings, after all, there are over 100 of them.
But it also cuts off the transitive connection behind that production chain. All of it is replaced by a single extra goods effect.That single need for cheese builds a hidden network of supply chains behind it, all cut off by Paldius, the killer of the cheese factory. The item illustrated "offsets" this by 75% extra workforce requirement, but considering the workforce, that is less than a single Libertus home per sheep farm.
Now, does that mean that the extra goods effect is problematic and should not be in the game per se? No, it does not. But one has to be aware of the things we cut off. A grain farm producing extra oat does much less harm to the transitive connection as a bicycle factory producing extra pocket watches and gramophones (looking at you, Dario). So, it should be used sparingly and not give extra goods with a big supply network behind them.
Item Design - Replaced inputs
The replaced input effect at least only substitutes a transitive connection. It is pretty straight forward what one needs to look out for: That the substitute is only little more efficient than the original, either a sidegrade, or an upgrade that is not too overpowered.
This allows for reconnecting the existing buildings in creative ways. A good way of how to employ it in 117 would, for example, be items which replace the various colors in the game - tyrian purple instead of celtic green. That allows moving space-intensive production of dye plants from Albion to the coasts of Latium. Also, looking at the item presented, replaced inputs would have been the preferred method of implementation for this narrative design: Why can't the cheesemaker just process sheep instead of Oxen? At least sheep give milk, unlike Oxen.
The best example of a problematic implementation would be Susannah Brightwoman - She takes in all the supply chain of Steam motors and replaces it by filament factory and a coal mine. Replaced Inputs should synergize well with the detailed and high amount of goods in 117, which sometimes are very interchangeable - why not make flour from barley, or beer from grain?
Item Design - Workforce Reduction
In 1800, one of the major transitive connection killers is workforce reduction. By reducing workforce down, sometimes even to 0, less or even no population is required to run it, and thus the workforce requirement of a production chain does not mandate the supply of population levels that consume all sorts of goods. In this regard, workforce reduction is unhealthy for the supply chains.
The way to use this effect properly is with sparingly, with little to no reduction, even in combination: Anno 1800 had like 3 different items that would all reduce ALL production workforce by 50%, and as such, you could run all islands on zero workforce.
Used in reverse, as workforce increase, this effect can actually create more connection in the game - any higher workforce requirement means more mouths to feed, thus necessitating the need for more houses, and thus, more production. And I believe this is exactly what this effect should be used as, as a sidegrade effect that increases workforce, giving the player more things to do for more efficiency - like in the item shown.
Outlook
We are only getting 30 heroic items, and their design is probably already finished. Knowing how many items Ubisoft added to 1800, always adding them when there was no other selling point, it should come as no suprise that there will be more. I believe that from now on, more heroic items will be added. Egypt will have them, and any DLC, should there be any, will also add more, and because they are a selling point, they will be as OP as it can get.
It would be very unhealthy to bend over Anno 117 through OP item effects, but with the right approach, they can be powerful without being gamebreaking.
I know Anno 117 is a buggy mess and yeah they used AI and lied about it (just take a deeper look at some specialists man..). The game is still well designed. So the Game Design Department really created a new twist to anno that gives the game a new dimension.
The warfare is so well made for an Anno game.
Me and two friends are playing againt the veteran AI and we all started in albion. After 6 hours this dudes had amassed 400 ships. We guess he doesnt go beyond tier 2 but still the quantity of units is purely insane.
We made a battle plan and tried to attack one of his secondary islands. Our fleet was around 200 ships. We landed but our 20 units died trying to conquer his villa. Our fleets clashed on the ocean and a huge movie like battle begann that lasted 10 mins as more and more ships arrived within the continouse battle. We dodged shots, focus fired created pinzer movements. The sun was setting and the orang light over the ocean was kissef with flaming arrows catapults and balistas!
The battle was amazing and i hadnt had so much fun in a game for years. What baffles me is that the warfare is now so deep. The units actually missing is a level that creates so many moments and play potential. We failed to defeat him and the next try we will build ships just like in modern navy combat (screens, battleships, cruisers etc). Because it would actually work in the game now.
Apart from all the shit things you could say about the game atm and possibly in the future two anno 117 creates and gameplay experience that no other game achieves and no other anno game ever achieved yet.
Thank you devs, i know ubisofts boot on the back of the neck can be crippling but please patch the game, work on the bugs, accept community ideas and the game will be your best achievement as a dev!
I mean at least AI wasn't used in the translation according to Thorlof himself. Does this mean AI generated artwork then? Judging by the description, it means the assets have stayed ingame and it's not only placeholders - although in game dev, sometimes you just leave in the placeholders because you run out of time.
Bold move disclosing this like 2 days from release only and it would be interesting to see the extent.
A few days ago, the roadmap for the rest of 2026 was published. While it promises Stamps, Item Overview and improved storage statistics Update 3.0, all very, let's say "requested" features for 117, the roadmap also gave me a sudden realization.
Namely how much the released fixes have shifted from "drops in the bucket" to actual meaningful improvement. It seems that the Cinis fiasco has led to more change than just an apology letter, and it's damn time that it does: there seems to be a window of opportunity to get 117 back on track. Anno 1800 demonstrated just how much success is built on lasting rather than a good release, and sold many copies over years, while 117 has run out of steam very fast after a few botched releases.
It seems the roughest of times are over, as Update 2.0 delivered. Not in terms of player numbers, but in terms of what it did to the game. No, it's not going to save Anno 117 by itself, but it is small incremental improvement. 2-3 more patches like this, and it might go somewhere. And by the looks of it, we are actually getting this! There is going to be this Update 3.0, and early 2027 is said to bring a Mod Browser and Mod Management to the game.
Now, I don't want to celebrate early by any means: The success of this turnaround depends on just how brave the fixing work gets, and how well Egypt will be designed when it releases. The bread change of Update 2.0 was quite unprecendented. I had to look it up, and never before has a need consumption rate directly been adjusted, except for a Lifestyle Need in Anno 1800 right after it was added. The thing that comes closest is a patch that increases consumption rates for unhappy population, which was released in 2016.
Is it radical to redo the balancing of need consumption and production (and Attributes)? Yes, it is. And it is probably what is needed. After all, something just is wrong if production runs at 500% easily, half of your population comes from Area Effects and the bread for half of Cinis is produced in a grand total of 6 bakeries. This was a necessary and good change, and let's hope there are no faster-producing bakeries in Egypt that nullify it.
The published roadmap, alongside the quality of Patch 2.0 is a good indicator that Ubisoft Mainz is bringing out the big cannon and aiming it quite well into the right direction. I hope they don't miss their shot, because this cannon only has one or maybe two left.
Civilization VII is a good example for that it is never too late to start fixing the obvious conceptual problems, and it makes me hopeful that Anno 117 can do the same.
I get that there needs to be some mechanic preventing too fast expansion for noobs. In older Annos, this was the fact that you needed access to advanced construction material.
Now they just charge you like crazy to settle islands, but you need to settle them to get fertilities, but in return you can just build Trading Posts whereever you want? Do they not need material to be built?
Sorry, but I will not accumulate 260k to get a small island such that I can produce a low tier product for +2 income and a single resident on it.
The Construction cost of trading posts should be a fixed amount. Not cheap, but 10k, some wood and, most importantly, tiles. That prevents rush tactics and keeps noobs from settling the second island too early, but it allows players to settle the islands they need to progress when they need them.
I tried the demo of Anno 117 and several issues stood out to me. The game feels very unfinished. There are numerous bugs and glitches that affect the overall experience. On top of that, the interface is quite confusing: it’s often unclear which mission is currently active or whether a research project has already been completed.
The building system is also frustrating. Due to the diagonal construction, many gaps appear because there are no corner buildings to fill the space. The balancing feels off as citizens keep revolting even though all their needs are met.
The missions themselves are very simplistic, yet still buggy and unpolished. What’s especially annoying is that quests can only be completed by clicking on the small “bubble icons” instead of being finished automatically when entering the quest giver’s harbor. This makes it easy to miss objectives.
It would also help a lot if there were proper map modes to show building radiuses or coverage when clicking on structures, just like in Anno 1800. Right now, you can’t clearly see how far a building’s effect reaches unless you manually check everything. On top of that, the game throws you into complexity very quickly. By the second tier of the Romans, I already had to settle three new islands just to establish basic production chains. Trees also don’t seem to regrow, which makes no sense, and the economy feels very unbalanced with strange income fluctuations.
I also tried playing with higher graphics settings, but the game just lagged heavily. In its current state, both the UI and graphics look very similar to Anno 2070, which feels outdated.
Overall, the demo leaves the impression that Anno 117 still needs a lot of polishing before it can deliver a smooth and enjoyable gameplay experience.
I wanted to share my review for Anno 117 that was published on the most poorly named website in the world. Typically the site reviews and discusses miniatures/board games with a focus on allowing people who want to start playing a game get ready for a casual event. That's how I approached reviewing this game, not for sickos on the Anno reddit but for people who liked the time period and were interested in the game. The only other video game that is covered is the horse-girl racing game.
Due to living a life and wanting to play the game I didn't finish until last week and decided to wait until the 1.3 patch was released. I enjoyed Anno 117 but I wasn't going to recommend it to a non-anno sicko with the religion bug.
Compared to many city builders, and especially those with long early access times, I think Anno is actually pretty simple to get into and play if you're on lower difficulty levels. Depending on the response from the readership I might provide an update if something changes in the game.
Also, please be kind as this is my first time reviewing a video game.
The demo is too short. You can start a new session, but you are never really getting a true long term evaluation of the game. Lets face it - this is Anno, there is needs to be a good evaluation on how things feel after 3+ hours. Like the UI.
I've only played for about 5 hours, so take this with a grain of salt. It's not a bad game as far as I can tell but IMO it lacks a lot of the polish that I would've expected from a modern Anno game.
Graphics:
It is not well optimized and could just run better on my RTX 3080 and DLSS Performance
Zoomed-out stuff really doesn't look too good IMO. Seems like the reduction in detail is just not well done and also the lights make it look odd from time to time. I also often cannot really tell what each building is by the looks.
Zoomed-in some models are more detailled than others. Some have clearer textures, some are weirdly blurry and low-poly, e.g. small round objects like bread tend to be angular. People and animals just don't look good to me with that slight bluriness. Something else just is off.
There is a noticable loading of details when changing zooming levels. I cannot remember this from any previous anno game.
All in all the graphics is in parts really good and there is much detail. But they didn't get the performance and LOD stuff right and it's not a consistent level of quality between different objects.
UI:
It could be a bit less generic but overall it's fine. Would've liked some more love in general.
You don't see your current island balance, only total income which is not enough on its own. You can go to the statistics menu to view it.
Clicking on stats like the currency doesn't take you to the right view in the statistics menu. That's really annoying and would be so easy. Tbh, I would prefer just having good "tooltip"-style information to easily view information at a glance.
General:
I feel like the early game is a bit generic and there is no noticable short-term goal or NPC interaction. E.g. in 1404 you had this grand vizier guy where you needed to get some reputation/fame/whatever and it just added a nice touch of making the world less empty. Apart from NPC enemies that you typically just ignore early game.
The tech tree feels a bit cheap to me. It could be a bit better visually and how it's integrated into the game itself. Doesn't feel really anno-like to me this way. It could've even started with a small quest (like in 1800 where new content was often reached with a quick quest or small quest line). Just maxing out knowledge (if that's the english term) to speed up research and then clicking what you will need in the next X hours is a bit lackluster. But overall I like the idea.
Same with the religion stuff. Just a cumulating stat with basic visualization with - how I understand at least - some basic bonuses. Why not at least have an altar building where you choose your god/goddess with a quick "quest" to unlock it. The whole feature could be more engaging and less generic. But maybe it gets more depth later on (or with DLCs).
The AI stuff with loading screens to me is just the tip of the iceberg. I just feel like they really didn't put in the time and effort to polish it.
Aside from all the negative points, I actually think so far it's a decent game and I like that they didn't just do more of Anno 1404 and Anno 1800. I really like that you can now integrate production buildings into the city. The °45 angle doesn't interest me but I'm not aiming for beautiful city layouts.
I'm curious about the upcoming DLC and whether they'll patch some of the stuff at the same time.
Edit: Not sure about the comments around the word "polish". Maybe it's not generally used like I use it? At least in Germany it is (yes, we use the english word).
Alright, before I make any false allegations, as that would be unfair in this critical time for Anno, and I in fact don't want to kill the dawn of the delta hype under false pretext, so I am gonna simply ask this: u/Ubi-Thorlof, does this image include AI generated content or not?
Because here, we have a water canal stemming from the nile, which leads to a grain field, then a gate, and then the canal continues on right up to the temple and leads right to the stairs. Based on prior incidents, I've become sceptical about any new Anno artwork, and my eye tells me a human would not connect it like that. Logically, the general shape still connects from main river through a gate to a temple, but somehow there is water where there should be a pathway.
I don’t get it, I mean I really don’t. There’s no way to unlock the Anno 1800 Twitch Drops even after the game completion. A one and done.
Similarly they did a stealth Twitch Drops for the Demo of 117 that most of us missed and again, no chance to earn it.
What is this this horrible practice? The pointing that they unlocked 1800 at the end, the point is that they never gave you a real chance to actual unlock the drops.
Anno is one of my fav game to an extent that i am playing only Anno 1800 from last 2 years. I tried others but nothing beats 1800. It would be great if they add more regions like Asia and India. Also, more tier of population in all regions.