r/animecirclejerk • u/AttitudeOk94 • Aug 08 '23
r/animecirclejerk • u/[deleted] • Dec 15 '20
Yet this sub likes him for some God-forsaken reason.
r/animecirclejerk • u/Ao3y • Apr 17 '24
Unjerk I'm not impressed by Maomao in the Apothecary Diaries. Please change my mind?

[Original curation and hours of fine tuning the AI arttheft bots initiated by https://creator.nightcafe.studio/u/Philosophaster. Enjoy, and please consider sharing your link for funsies if reused š]
I got flamed in the Apothecary Diaries subreddit for daring to speak my thoughts, so I'll word them a little gentler here.
[SHOW SPOILERS]
One of anime's deadly sins is always breaking the film rule: "Show, don't tell."
I just want to know if anybody else feels like Maomao wasn't directed, animated and spoken with feeling. Some people argued that she has complex feelings like humility and low self esteem and thinks little of herself, but to skip my argument for why that's not a great argument, I propose that if you want to see someone with low self esteem and a lot of inner turmoil, look at Kyo from Fruits Basket.
That's a conflicted character. But Maomao is a monolithic, mostly unchanging character, and it was really hard for me to overlook her frustration with.... everyone and everything... because it came off like she was disdainful 24/7.
I used the example of the hardened cowboy trope. We see the flashbacks where his whole family was gunned down, how he suffered as a child and that turned him into the badass he is today... but at no point do we really see his emotional journey toward hardness or feel bad for this archetype because he's a monolithic character. Clint Eastwood is pissed, disdainful of wrongdoers, and is here to kick ass. Maomao is very similar, I'd argue, and after watching the whole anime so far, I was sad that the director didn't give us a more dynamic, emotive character, and I was tired of her looking down at every single person in her daily life.
Does anyone else feel this way?
To all the rest: be nice.
r/animecirclejerk • u/Cantthinkagoodnam2 • Nov 03 '24
Jerking it hard Literlay just regular girls but with drawn lines on their chestsš
r/animecirclejerk • u/Ok_Mushroom2563 • Apr 02 '25
Jerking it hard Frieren being #1 on MAL is offensive to me
I see Frieren at the top on MAL and I just think to myself--Have these people even watched anime for the last 20 years? Like. This has to just be mostly zoomers and paid for reviews right?
My working theory is this:
40% paid for reviews
40% zoomers that haven't seen other classics and or have really underdeveloped taste because they're under 25 years old and seen a grand total of 30 anime
20% Recency bias for an actually good show amidst corporatized garbage that so much of media has become
Here's why:
The show is good. The pacing is fine. The story is fine. The characters are fine. The dialogue is... okay.
The problem is the show is _____really_____ tropey. I think if you took out all of the instances of Fern being mad or Mister Shtark being a little b!tchboy or Frieren wanting to sleep in or clown around the show has almost no dialogue left. It's VERY sparse on interesting, nuanced dialogue. The characters too. Fern's the tropey precocious purple-haired teen. Starke's naruto anime blast acts cringeworthy and seems weak but is actually strong omg who woulda seen that coming! Ubel is assassin-babe trope. Denkin is sage old man meme. They're practically all tropes. Their lines barely deviate from what would lend evidence toward the trope.
The action and animation and music are like the best parts of the show. But is that what makes a show a 10? I don't think so. I get it. That part is subjective.
But let's compare it to Steins;gate which is just below it on MAL. Every single episode of Steins;gate is a literal masterpiece of dialogue and character writing. It very obviously had multiple writers all working together, checking their work, and iterating on plot=lines and conversations. There's almost never a dull-moment in conversation. Yeah there's several instances of Okabe droning on about the organization only to be interrupted by Mayuri's Doot-do-doo! But for (1) there's actually important character development happening as the show goes on such that even the trope evolves and becomes more interesting. And then if you just aren't going to accept that and remove that stuff then yeah the show is still super dense with good dialogue.
You could argue the action is non-existent and the animation is just okay for its time period, but the music is still good and the story and plot development and pacing are all phenomenal. I could see people not really getting it for the first few episodes but on re-watching it's even more savory than before. On rewatching Frieren the first episode was still so boring I nearly fell asleep (and I actually fell asleep watching it the first time through).
TL;DR - Frieren dialogue is meh. Show is too tropey. Steins;gate drastically knocks it out of the park in that regard and it is offensive to me to put them on the same playing field really. Frieren is just a good show amidst all the crap we have nowadays but Steins;gate is literally timeless. I could do similar comparisons with other shows but yeah.
r/animecirclejerk • u/MooreThird • Oct 26 '24
wokalized Why corn more faithful to sauce material than office version š? NSFW
Found this on Facebook.
r/animecirclejerk • u/[deleted] • Jan 31 '23
Unjerk Genuine question: Why donāt anime characters look Japanese despite being Japanese?
r/animecirclejerk • u/EfficiencySerious200 • Dec 17 '25
Erm it's pronounced "manga" Frieren is a great example of how you can turn a MID concept and story, and anime fans would legitimately suck and glaze it to no end, calling it complex and peak, because bandwagon
r/animecirclejerk • u/A12qwas • May 23 '25
my fujo hating, lesbian loving ass be like when I see a lesbian fujo
r/animecirclejerk • u/Hagfishsaurus • Mar 01 '23
Donāt look in the comments of pikameeās departure announcement
Worst mistake of my life
r/animecirclejerk • u/LilianaLucifer • Jan 14 '26
I am media illiterate Bravo Fujimoto,I kneel!
r/animecirclejerk • u/OnyxEyes6194 • Nov 03 '24
Meta Is there a term for this design scheme of āshort brown hair and tight with the main lead but not usually a core love interestā?
r/animecirclejerk • u/avoteforatishon2016 • Jul 07 '24
Jerking it hard Me after finding out that this sub hates male yuri fans
r/animecirclejerk • u/Zenry0ku • Jan 16 '24
The series no one in this sub has actually read
r/animecirclejerk • u/[deleted] • Jun 02 '23
[Serious]Disliking yaoi and yuri doesn't make me homophobic, right?
It's more of, "It's not for me."
r/animecirclejerk • u/Yakplayz • May 26 '22
This sub has become more of an actual circlejerk than real anime communities
r/animecirclejerk • u/x_nasheed_x • Jul 16 '22