A few months ago our local hospital system broke up with their anesthesiology group. It was a mess, many elective surgeries postponed. I had mine a few days ago and was slightly put off when I learned the new model they are using is an “anesthesia team”. This is an MD and a CRNA. It was explained to me that this is what a lot of hospitals are moving towards. I can’t help but think this must be about $ somehow. Just wondering what you all as a profession have to say about this new model.
Hello everyone, I know these are stressful and uncertain times. I'm thankful for all the anesthesiologists working out there in the ORs or ICUs and for all the really useful posts in our subreddit about managing COVID-19 patients. I myself just finished a week in one of our several COVID ICUs.
There have been two recent posts regarding CRNAs I had to remove. The first was a vent by an anesthesiologist about the recent political moves that of course just turned into thinly veiled insults. Rule #1 here is professional courtesy, and I will ban people who violate it. I get the anger among anesthesiologists and I get that r/anesthesiology seems like an ideal place to release that anger, but please understand that vents on the internet (especially in forums that already consists of mostly your peers) get us nowhere. Support the ASA and your state chapter. Write to your senators, representatives, and governors. Tell your friends, family, and medical colleagues in other specialties about what's going on. Help your local communities that are suffering from the economic situation. That is how we will change things.
The second was the posting of a tiktok image of a completely identifiable CRNA calling herself a nurse anesthesiologist. That devolved into comments about reporting her to the Board of Nursing and US Air Force AND ENCOURAGING OTHERS TO DO THE SAME. Again I get the reasons, but this is clear cut violation of reddit rules and I cannot allow that to jeopardize this subreddit. If you want to try to find ongoing discussions about it on other subreddits, I can't stop you, but I will not allow it to be reposted here, even if the image is anonymized.
In the end, the top comments in both threads ended up being CRNAs who support the care team model saying ego is a dangerous thing. Remember there are CRNAs out there who are working diligently in the ICUs right now as bedside nurses. I've even seen them paired up with OR circulator nurses in these desperate times. And even when I'm working as a resident, they've called me with questions and given me the respect they would to an attending. The majority of CRNAs do not reflect their lobbying group or their colleagues on social media.
Thank you for listening to what I had to say. I hope all of you stay safe and healthy.
(Edit: sorry to everyone here for calling it gas, did not realize it’s annoying and cringe.)
Hi all,
Question up here so you don’t have to read below: What types of ICUs do Anesthesia / CC doctors usually staff?
Background: I’m an M-3 who wants to be an intensivist, specifically in the SICU and CVICU. I made a post in r/medicalschool but low engagement.
After rotating in the MICU and following some patients in SICU and CTICU, I discovered I really really do not want to work in a MICU. The patients are older, sicker, and it doesn’t feel as rewarding because it doesn’t feel like you’re helping them as much as some of the patients in the other ICUs. A lot of it was just figuring out what the families wanted to do with their parents or grandparents. I understand this is the nature of any ICU, but it def skews that way more in MICU from what I can tell.
I had a younger patient who had a bad accident in the SICU last week, she was in terrible condition and needed a lot of operations. 4 days later I was talking to her and she was on the mend. I really would enjoy a career where I get to have those types of patients, really feeling like I helped in getting them from a bad situation to recovery.
I wanted to make a post to brainstorm ways that CA residents can advocate for AAs to practice legally in CA. Does anyone have experience with successfully advocating for AA legalization in your state and can give advice? Any suggestions, tips, and tricks are welcome!
Also, if anyone can explain what happened to AB 985, that would be cool too.
Recently my hospital management has come out with infographics proclaiming how bad desflurane is for the environment, compared to sevoflurane. Encouraging the usage of sevoflurane over desflurane.
In my personal opinion, non-clinical personnel should not interfere with clinical decisions by clinical personnel. In my personal practice, I consider multiple factors when choosing my volatile and drugs. Truthfully, environmental consideration is not a high priority for me, compared to other factors like patient safety and shorter turnover.
Or that you are going to give them “happy juice” or a margarita etc.?
I realize that generally these people mean well and are just trying to put the patient at ease by putting what is happening to them in a fun happy social context.
But it does trivialize our role and what is about to happen, and deemphasizes our role as guardians of the patient’s safety and well being. I do not like this but generally don’t push back against it because it seems not worth the trouble. How about you?
Is this what it’s supposed to be like? I got settled into a community hospital and now 1 year into practice. We do some bigger procedures but nothing compared to what i did during residency.
I feel bored most days running out things to do. The cases dont really excite me and i get through the day with no real pleasure or achievement.
Is this normal? I mean the money and life is good otherwise - but the adrenaline rush isnt there anymore. Do i need to relocate to a bigger hospital? what are your experiences like when transitioning to staff?
1st Clinical Year SRNA here...I have been becoming more proficient and consistent with my DLs (about 200 so far) but one consistent weakness lately is always asking someone to pull the upper lip "up and out" (fish hook from the side and pull towards me) when I need to intubate.
I often use my right hand to pull the lip during the DL (if not applying cricoid pressure or manipulating the head) and can obtain good views but as soon as I let go to grab the tube, I lose my view or it is severely lacking. I can still intubate, just not nearly as smoothly or confidently as I'd like.
I am above average height and already raise the bed to my xiphoid process and even lean back when necessary during the DL. Any other suggestions?
For the anesthesiologists here, I am curious what your honest, day to day perspective is on working with CRNAs.
Do you see CRNAs as colleagues, extenders, or competitors in any sense? From your experience, are they generally safe and reliable providers when appropriately trained and supervised, or have you seen issues that concern you?
Do you think physician anesthesiologists should be working to limit further CRNA scope and independent practice, or is there a realistic path for collaborative models that still protect physician roles, income, and liability concerns?
Finally, what long term impact do you think CRNA expansion and independent practice will have on the specialty over the next 5 to 10 years, both in terms of clinical standards and the job market for anesthesiologists?
Genuinely interested in thoughtful, experience based responses rather than canned talking points.
Hey, my first post here. For context I am a second year CRNA. For carotids and TCARs when I trained I mostly used Neo and Nicardipine or cleveprex.
The more cases I do I actually prefer to use Norepi over Neo as pressor of choice. I’ve just had too many instances where I’m switching to NE in the middle of the case because they aren’t responding to Neo. I think I’m one of the only in my group to do it this way. I actually worked with a brilliant anesthesiologist who taught me to do it this way in my training.
I haven’t been able to find any good research on it.I looked it up on the open evidence app ( highly recommend), Gemini, and ChatGPT.
Just wondering the communities practice and experiences. Thank you for your time.
I'm a 4th Carribean IMG, and I have been trying to get an Anesthesiology rotation in the US for the past YEAR. I've done many other rotations in the US, but none in anesthesia. Anesthesiology has been my dream since day one, since my very first day of med school. But it has become extremely competitive for IMGs and I know I'll need USCE in anesthesia to even have a chance. But not a single program will give me an opportunity to rotate. I've gone through all 162 ACGME approved residencies in the US, and managed to filter 66 programs that MIGHT potentially hear me out, but even those are starting to be dead ends. My school does not participate in VSLO (because of course it doesn't) which shuts many doors for me. I have contacted or applied to over 50 places at this point, but I'm at my wits' end. Does anybody have any advice? I've no idea what to do anymore
Edit: Thank you to everyone who reached out. While some of you are right about it being much harder for Caribbean IMGs, it's definitely still possible. If anyone knows of any programs taking IMGs for rotations please reach out. I only have 2 electives left, and would like for them to be in anesthesia
Hi everyone. I'm an aa student who has unfortunately become all too familiar with the political toxicity of the AANA and some of the biggest online proponents of it like Mike Mackinnon. I've had to research the topic, have written state reps, been involved with capital events, and have had hundreds of conversations with saa's, caa's, attendings, residents, friends, and family. I've seen far too many CRNAs call themselves doctor to people who don't know the difference between a CRNA using the title and an actual physician.
The point of this post is 3 fold, will be messy, and come off like a rant-my apologies-but it's reddit, right?
To highlight that Mike Mackinnon (one of the biggest online proponents of CRNA propaganda against aa's and anesthesiologists) is a hypocrite and possibly a liar based on his very own words (attached below)
In light of point 1 and all the attached evidence, that srna's and crna's should, as a whole, disregard Mike and the title thievery he spreads. This also applies to the AANA.
To rally support for common sense policies and legislation throughout our country in regard to anesthesia practice.
As you can see from Mike's very own words, "you don't know what you don't know..." in reference to those who are not physicians. This is an argument that everyone online uses against Mike and his current day propaganda. He is not a physician. He did not go to med school. He is not a doctor. Yet he seems to have forgotten his very own words or taken a worldview change for the worst. If you read through the attached evidence, you can see that Mike had his heart set on med school. He later claims that he did get in but chose crna school instead. Anyone who has posted on SDN knows that the people that gush over wanting to get into med school will almost certainly post when they get accepted. Mike gushed over it and even considered going over seas since he knew his scores and gpa weren't competitive at all for the US. Yet there is never a post that he got in an him celebrating. One poster even asks him about it as you can see below in the photos. The evidence seems to indicate that Mike never got accepted to medical school and simply had to find another route. There's nothing wrong with this but there is something wrong with lying about it. This coupled with the fact that he spouts so many falsehoods and half-truths about crnas vs. anesthesiologists (and aa's) shows a dark pattern that he left bits and pieces of online. You really need to read some of his posts. He talks about how being a midlevel will not challenge him but that's the path he ended up taking! Then, in one post he talks about aa's being the equivalent of an anesthesia tech yet in another post he says that aa's and crna's do a similar job and that any edge a nurse would have as a crna would be lost after the first few years of experience just as it is with np/pa. So which is it Mike? You can't have it both ways. Mikey has a really bad habit of talking out of two sides of this mouth. The evidence is below and it's unfortunate that he has such a huge following online and so much pull in the crna world. Anyone with commonsense will read his posts and see the doublespeak. This person who jumps from one contradiction to the other has unfortunately built up a "great" reputation in the crna world and is considered a leader. So, fresh srna's joining school are obviously going to listen to and be guided by their leadership. The evidence here needs to be a pushback against that and a return to common sense.
Mike admits in the posts below that he had a 3.0 gpa from his nursing degree (if he stretches the truth on so many things was the gpa possibly lower and he's rounding up?). The average bsn degree gpa is 3.5+:
So, Mike is already behind the curve here on what might be an exaggerated gpa. It makes one wonder how he was accepted into crna school with such a low gpa:
I've talked with many people about this since finding these past admissions from Mikey Mouse and inquired into why he would have such drastic changes and contradictions. He really wanted that doctor title, which you can easily see when reading his posts below. And guess what... he got it. The system needed to get gnarled and twisted-but he did it. He's a doctor. And we let him do it. Shame on us? Well, we should stand up for what's right and especially patient safety. Basic truths matter. I'm training to be a midlevel. He's a midlevel. And patients need to know that. We've all met people in our life that drive a huge truck and some have suggested that might be the root of Mikey Mouses' issue with stretching the truth-you be the judge:
A few other points...
I mentioned I've talked to many anesthesia residents. Many aren't too familiar with the political fight. This makes sense since they're so busy in residency! But, I'd like to see some more awareness on the topic so we can work toward better legislation and policies for anesthesia. I obviously want to be able to practice in every state as an aa but that's going to take years. The ASA and the AAAA should work together more than they do. AA's know their place as a midlevel provider. We are quick to call our attending's if something comes up. We are there to provide the best care we can but we know our limits and will certainly call in the big guns when and if needed. We are not like crnas's who want to practice independently and think we can handle everything on our own. I've heard so many horror stories of the crna thinking they have something handled and then the attending walks in randomly and is like wtf why didn't you call me? We are not like delusional srna's that now call themselves NARs (nurse anesthesia residents!) We want to learn from our attendings and participate in the ACT.
I need to add the caveat that most crnas are normal people that don't participate in this garbage. I've gone to their reddit page and seen the majority denounce using the term doctor for themselves in the hospital setting, BUT, they aren't keeping people like Mikey Mouse in check. There's no accountability. I'm hoping that can start happening. If an aa or aa student started talking out of his scope, he'd get piled on.
ps. Mikey's self proclaimed "research" is very sophomoric. It doesn't compare to any research that residents and attendings put out. It's embarrassing he claims it as scientific research but what else should I expect from a dude that title steals? You can see below that his most recent "research" is to try and get more crna's to be independent from anesthesiologists (sounds great for patients).
Attached are screenshots and webpages to substantiate everything in this post at the end. Dates aren't in order but it paints the picture...
I still work bedside as an ICU nurse, so although I am an incoming SRNA, this question is centered around what others practices are and what you expect from the bedside nurse when doing bedside procedures that require anesthesia.
My unit does quite a bit of TEEs w/ cardioversion. Usually the anesthesiologist comes with their own drugs and any other equipment they choose to use. A few like POMs so they bring those as our unit doesn’t have as many readily available. I have consents ready to go, an ambu bag, suction, NC, NRB, simple face mask and ETCO2 set up with the bite block handy for probe insertion. Crash cart is in the room and the patient is placed on pads, and connected to the zoll for the cardioversion. Echo tech brings other miscellaneous supplies that the cardiologist prefers.
This one anesthesiologist came to me and says “where are my drugs?”. I explain to him we don’t have a specific drug box but he can access anything he wants from the Pyxis, or tell me what he wants and I can pull it. (We do have a med kit for RSI, but that’s all it’s used for). He says he can go get the meds. I ask him does he need anything else? He says a few 20cc syringes. I said okay. Grab him those, and we all head back to the room and I tell him where the IV site is and that it’s working properly. He says great. I step out and I call cardiology and say we are ready for him and he arrives about 5 mins later.
We conduct a time out and cardiology asks anesthesia is he good to place the probe. Anesthesia says, “where are my fluids, I can’t give meds without running fluids”. I’m looking like, you have to be kidding me. So now the cardiologist who I work with all the time is getting annoyed saying “so we aren’t ready”, and now it looks like I’m not prepared even though I called him to say we were.
I say, I’m sorry Dr. Heart, I thought we were ready, because the other anesthesiologists usually bring and have everything they need, but let me pull these fluids for Dr. Airway.
TLDR; what do you want from me at bedside for procedures, anything I can do to be more “prepared” and this is for any bedside procedure not just TEEs. Thank you 😄
What was your peak income in your career? How much were you working? What was the circumstances of your practice and what area of the country? Just curious more than anything. For me it was 2013 about $1 million in private practice with 12 weeks of vacation. After that we sold to private equity, I got a substantial multiple and it set me for the rest of my life. I am now back in private practice working 24 weeks a year and loving it.
I'm an SRNA that just started clinicals not too long ago and would like a critique of my study plan for overall knowledge.
For class I just study Anki (a flashcard program) flashcards on the topics and my lecture. That's great so far, I'm not messing with success.
For my actual knowledge I have been passively reading Morgan and Mikhail and studying the associated Anki flashcards from a pre-made Ankisthesia deck for active learning. In this first year I'm going to try and get through all that. I also listen to the ACCRAC podcast every day.
From my understanding, M&M is the basics book lol, so what are my next steps in your opinion over the next few years. I have Miller heavy so I reference that occasionally, and I love Open Anesthesia and Apex ( a CRNA board prep site) and look at those to explore topics quickly.
For clinical prep I use Vargo and Jaffe.
Any suggestions. Just looking for a long term plan so I can actually be smart and not just get good grades.
I also posted in r/CRNA as I know they will have more knowledge of our boards and such, but I'd appreciate your insight as well.
As a resident interested in greening our ORs (a sentiment shared by absolutely no one else at my institution…), I am trying to gather some resources to present to the higher ups to start a conversation. Obviously, other institutions have done so and successfully reduced emissions upwards of 80-90%.
I was wondering if there was any information on the economics of such a transition? Such as those associated with removal of the pipelines, acquiring tanks, any other logistical problems that need to be addressed, etc.
Are there associated cost savings, aside from environment savings? I would assume so, but don’t have any supporting data.
Thank you!
Edit: ITT people getting mad over false assumptions they’ve made without gathering any info and thinking I’m talking about doing away with nitrous instead of transitioning to cylinders
The comments trying to deter for whatever silly reasons only adds fuel to the fire 🔥