r/androidtablets • u/getmoneygetpaid • Nov 23 '24
The sorry state of Android tablets - even the best ones
WARNING: if you get big feelings when someone criticises your favourite manufacturer for half-baked features, stop reading now.
I am a simple man - I want a tablet to do precisely two things:
Plug into hotel TVs when I'm travelling for work.
Be a smart-home dashboard when I'm not travelling.
To accomplish this, I have the following requirements (which even a mid-range phone from half a decade ago can meet):
Upper-mid range / high range processor. Nothing below Snapdragon 870. I've been bitten before with a low end processor that couldn't keep up as apps became more intensive and was so slow that it was basically a paperweight after a year.
Multiple users. It's going to be docked, powered on and logged in most of the time, running Tasker automations for the smarthome stuff that I wouldn't want running when using my personal account. I also have things under an NDA for work, so I can't have my kids or guests having access to my main account.
HDMI output. I want to connect the tab to TVs when I'm staying overnight with work or on vacation for music and movie watching.
Fingerprint reader. Entering passcode is annoying.
90hz screen minimum.
These are VERY basic requirements, which almost every mid-range phone from half a decade ago meets. Should be easy, right? Well, here's what I found:
Almost no Mediatek tablets have HDMI out. This elimintates almost every Android Tablet out of the gate, including all Honor pads, all Blackview and most others.
Xiaomi Pad 6 has HDMI out, but only at 4:3 resolution, so you get big black bars on the TV. There is no multi-user, only 'second space', which limits functionality. Xiaomi also has major issues with it's widevine certification, meaning the Pad 6 has to be re-certified (including Netflix uninstall) every couple of days. No thanks.
Oneplus Pad 2 has the same issue with 4:3 resolution. It also has no fingerprint reader. Additionally, the multi-user isn't properly implemented - you can't choose a user from the lock-screen; it has to be from the last logged-in user's profile. So for example, if I use my tab in the morning before work, my kids can't use it in the afternoon until I return, unlock it, and switch profile.
Oppo Pad Pro has no HDMI out.
Honor has no HDMI out.
Some Huawei tablets do have HDMI out, but same issue with 4:3 ratio since Huawei killed their desktop mode. Also, it's a pain in the ass to get apps working which require Google Play.
Pixel Tablet has a low-refresh screen. Also, no HDMI out. I tried it with the speaker dock, and found the dock was absolute trash - actually worse than some of the speakers built in to other tablets on this list.
Xiaoxin Pad Pro doesn't allow multi-user. Despite passing Widevine tests, Netflix wouldn't play in HD for me. Some apps were stuck in Chinese and Gboard wouldn't allow UK English. Some Google services like QucikShare don't work.
Lenovo pad (P11 pro and P12 pro) have two major dealbreakers:
Their UI is a jittery mess. The SystemUI (launcher and quicksettings) do not run at 90fps - more like 30fps. They look bad and it is jarring. The notification shade/quickpanel also look glitchy and have bad animations. I like Nova Launcher, but it also causes visual glitches as with most Android devices since Google fucked up with Android 12.
Both devices are out of support from Lenovo, so there's no hope of them being fixed. The fact that Lenovo's flagship devcies are not currently supported is pathetic. I'm not paying £400 for something which could become incompatible with apps tomorrow, and never be fixed.
So I guess that leaves me with Samsung. I don't like Samsung's UI. I'm a digital designer and OneUI is not for me. Luckily I'm also pretty resourceful and thought I could get around most of it. I picked up a Tab S8 and Tab S9 to try. Installed Theme Park, and off I went.
I hate the horizontal app drawer. HomeUp no longer has a vertical drawer option, and I can't install Nova, or it breaks DEX. However, I believe a vertical drawer is coming in OneUI 7, so I can live with it for now.
I can replace the ugly squircle icons using Theme Park, but not in DEX. I guess I can live with that...
HDMI out works like shit on mirror mode (UI slows down like crazy), and only works well on extended mode. Dex constantly switches out of extend mode, back to mirror. OK, this is getting silly.
The official keyboard/trackpad case is awful. The trackpad is incredibly unresponsive - almost impossible to highlight a specific letter in a word.
I bought some Galaxy SmartTags to track my stuff. Well, the tablet doesn't register my smart-tag location unless the screen is on and the app is open. I've set every permission and disabled every battery optimisation and still no-bueno. My tags are only found when my dad comes to visit with his samsung phone, or the postman comes by.
On my second profile (designed for being a smart-home wall panel), I can't install any of my smarthome apps. SmartThings simply won't install, giving a Samsung error which has apparently been this way for 4 years. Google Home causes the tablet to get stuck in a loop and freeze up. If you can get into safe mode, you can uninstall Google Home and it fixes it.
Also on second profile, Tasker can't acccess the 'keep awake' function due to missing permissions. I've granted all permissions. I think this stems from Developer Options not being available on second profiles.
'OK Google' actions often don't launch in the foreground, which is confusing. Playing music, for example, opens Youtube Music in the background. I can overcome this with Tasker, but again, it's just more tangled mess.
Google Quick Share won't work on second profile.
So all in all, a complete bust. Even the top tier Android tablets are pretty poor. I think I'm going to give up and just get a super cheap tablet for my smarthome controls, with only one profile, and a separate Windows laptop or Chromebook to use when travelling.