r/ancientrome • • Jan 20 '23

Apparently Google puts Caesar as a dictator?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Feb 27 '24

Constantine is easily a top 3 emperor of all time

0 Upvotes

No matter how much we poke and prod the flaws and holes, he changed the world profoundly forever and his decision to move the capital from Rome to Constantinople saved the life of the Empire for a thousand years literally. He's top 3. Yes?


r/ancientrome • • Apr 24 '24

Gender-nonconforming ancient Romans found refuge in community dedicated to goddess Cybele

Thumbnail
theconversation.com
33 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Nov 02 '25

Why does Ancient Rome tend to attract unsavoury politics?

2 Upvotes

Many, who have unsavoury politics particularly politics related to nation-states tend to idolise Ancient Rome. Why so? The Romans will probably be confused about our ideas of nation-states. Before Caesar, they were more loyal to their city-state. After his reforms and his successor's reforms (Augustus), Rome turned from a city-state controlling a lot of land into a multiethnic empire ruled by an emperor, and their loyalty became more focused towards their emperor or their general, which is why emperors had to always make sure that no general became too powerful. It's not to say that the Roman culture and its identity wasn't important, because it was definitely important, but politics weren't too focused on that, as much as it was focused on loyalty to either the city-state or the monarch of the empire. Why Ancient Rome in particular, when the concept of nation-state was very alien to them?


r/ancientrome • • May 05 '24

Thoughts on Mary Beard?

0 Upvotes

I’ve heard a lot about her and I’ve got to say, and after exploring myself, I’m super disappointed with her works and interviews.

I was watching her discussion with David Mitchell and her view on Roman Britain is incredibly baffling for a supposed expert.

She said that the Romano-British didn’t even notice the Roman’s were there and didn’t notice they were gone. For a comedian, David Mitchell seemed way more in tune arguing the they surely noticed themselves burying their coins in hoards and their cities and buildings falling apart.

I guess I was expecting more. Garrett Ryan on Toldinstone seems way more level headed about the Roman’s and really humanizes them. Whereas I found Mary Beard talks about them like someone on the internet talks about a political party they don’t like.


r/ancientrome • • Jul 04 '24

No, Caesar did not commit genocide during the Gallic Wars.

126 Upvotes

He absolutely did commit (or allow) war crimes (AVARICUM). But not what we would define as 'genocide' (as per the UN or Lempkin definitions) - the intention to destroy a group of people in part or in whole.

For a start, there's the issue of numbers. It was the later historian Plutarch, not Caesar, who gave the 'killed 1 million, enslaved 1 million out of a population of 3 million' number. This number, as with all ancient writers, should be taken with a heavy grain of salt due to the immense size and is most likely an exaggeration. Modern archaeological evidence instead seems to suggest that the pre-conquest population was in the 8-10 million range instead.

Most of the Gallic population, it seems, survived the war considering the fact that later Roman villas have been mostly found on the site of old Gallic farms. This indicates a continuity of elites in Gaul which followed a Roman model. As we now understand it, Roman 'colonisation' was not colonisation in the same sense that we think of today with the European colonial empires of the early modern period. It was a conquest, not a colonisation. The native population was not inhibited from social mobility within the new social order and the land wasn't made poor for the benefit of the metropole. Gaul was integrated into the Roman state, not destroyed, and Celtic culture continued to exist as late as the 4th century AD.

So, on a national level, Caesar didn't commit genocide. His motives for conquest were based on gaining personal prestige and glory, not a desire to ethnically cleanse or destroy a block of peoples to then completely repopulate the land with his own. The fact that he was willing to work with other tribes during the conquest and had no problems ruling over the Gauls in the already Roman provinces of Cisalpine Gaul in northern Italy doesn't point to him having any issues with the Gauls on a racial basis.

But what about on a localised level, where individual tribes apparently were destroyed? This is something which, again, doesn't seem to fit the term genocide. Most of the major recorded casualties of the conquest occured after the various battles, when the retreating men were pursued and cut down by the Romans. This was fairly standard practice for armies in the day (and can be seen in other examples like the Second Punic War with Hannibal) and was about stopping the enemy from regrouping, not destroying their ethnic character.

And in numerous other examples, the families of the combatants in battles were pursued by the Romans not to exterminate, but to enslave (ancient Romans saw war prisoners and their relatives automatically as slaves). Horrible? Yes. Genocide? No, the intent was financial, not racial/ethnic. The Gallic war was filled with mass killings (as would be the better word to use in these circumstances) but not mass genocide.

It baffles me how, when addressing this topic, someone can go on something like r/askhistorians and find about three posts responding to Gallic genocide question where the response is a resounding, informative 'no'. But whenever discussion of the topic crops up in the Romaboo subreddits or other online spaces it's taken and discussed as an undisputed fact that 'yes, genocide was committed during the Gallic Wars'.

Edit: Seeing as there's been a bit of pushback here and there, I think it's worth linking posts from r/askhistorians responding to this topic:

Edit 2: Actually, the top comment mentioning the Eburones as an example of genocidal action during the Gallic wars is completely right. Even if it's believed that Caesar didn't completely wipe them out, there was still an intent to do so regardless of how much he embellished what happened. I will remove my comment responding to it and apologise for misunderstanding and looking over that example, especially when looking over the fourth link I posted the genocidal intent there isn't properly pushed back against. Sorry about that.


r/ancientrome • • Sep 07 '25

I was thinking about this, and it seems that the biblical story of Cain and Abel is very similar to the story of Romulus and Remus, which took place almost eight centuries before the Bible was written. What do you think about this?

7 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Mar 03 '26

Possibly Innaccurate Unpopular Opinion: Julius Caesar had it coming, and by it I mean assassination

0 Upvotes

What did Cincinnatus do after his term as dictator? Step aside. What did Cincinnatus do after his second term as dictator? Step aside. What did Sulla do after reviving the office of dictator and also serving as dictator? Serve as consul and then step aside. Now, what did Caesar do after his term as dictator? He became dictator for life and started planning a campaign against the Parthians. The entire republic is centered on the idea that no one man should have all that power. If Caesar meant to restore the republic, then he should have stepped down immediately after. If he meant to be a king, then he was treated like a king. And if he's still upset about being assassinated, then he's a hypocrite.


r/ancientrome • • Sep 27 '23

Approximate size comparison of the Byzantine Empire in 1025 to Continental Europe

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Mar 12 '26

Would the Roman Forum be as appealing if it were still intact?

Post image
0 Upvotes

There's something about ruins that does emotional work that intact buildings can't. The Pantheon is extraordinary, but it's also... a building you walk into. The Forum, by contrast, feels like a wound in the landscape — you're reading absence as much as presence.

If the medieval and Renaissance builders hadn't stripped it for marble and lime, and the monuments of the Forum Romanum still stood largely intact the way the Pantheon does, would we feel the same pull toward it? Or does the drama of Roman civilization depend, at least partly, on the fact that it's gone?


r/ancientrome • • Mar 01 '26

Why Hannibal deserve the "most" credit for the death of the Roman Republic, Not Caeser, Pompey or even Cato.

0 Upvotes

2 VERY big reason why Hannibal "started" this and is NOT just a cause and effects like Marious and Sulla or Caeser Vs Cato/Pompey

  1. Hannibal's wrath created such an impact on the Roman psych, when Scipio defeated him a Zama, THAT was the first time that the Roman people EVER began to entertain a the idea of a "Ruler". The political cache from the defeat of Hannibal caused a form of mass Hysteria and the Roman people and Senate nominated Scipio counsel FOR LIFE. (If I had to come up with a modern day equivalent, it would be something like... The next American President solving the 30$+ trillion debt crisis in 2 terms and the American people just decide to collectively put this guy in President for life, ON PAPER, till he drops dead. It's safe to say that Scipio felt "deeply honored" to be thought of as THAT trust worthy of a man

His popularity from solving the Hannibal crisis created something Scipio himself couldn't control, it created "the first" in what I like to call the Roman "cult of personality". It starts with Scipio and ends with Caeser, where you will get, not just, some of the most consequential Romans in Romans history, but these are some of the greatest statesmen, diplomats, politicians and generals in world history, in this VERY TINY WINDOW.

Hannibal Barca Philip V Scipio Africanas Antiochus III The Great Scipio Emilianas Marius Sulla Lucullus

Tigraine the Great of Armenia Jagurtha

Mithridates 6th of Pontus

Crassus Pompey The Great Surtorius Spartacus... That dude

Vicinggetorex: only man to ever be proclaimed to be King of the Gaulic people, in their history, that I'm aware of. Area of Gaul, is making up all the territory West of the Rhine River All of modern day france plus Belgium Netherlands Switzerland...

Julius Caesar Mark Anthony Cleopatra Octavian Agrippa Herod The Great

Now THAT'S an impressive list if I've ever seen one... far as I'm concerned, my point is, look at the top of that list. Look who is there, Hannibal... The LITERAL progenitor of the Roman cult of personality that would (help) birth the empire.

Hannibal's terror birthed the Roman cult of personality, were you will get people who are so charismatic, they will ROUTINELY convince people in the 100,000 area to die on there behalf.... Yeah we can talk about "incentives", the Marion Reforms and how they were initiated by the invading Cimbri and Tuton, not Hannabal, but...

It's Philip the V of Macidonia, allying himself with Hannabal, which was the crucial mistake, giving Rome (and I'm oversimplifying it) a "pretence" to slowly divide and conquer the ENTIRE Eastern Mediterranean Sea...

Illyrian Pirates from across the Adriatic, was always too flimsy if a "Causes Belle" to invade the Balkin regions and a subsequent subjugation of Greece...

That was until Hannibal came on to the scene in the second Punic War, and the Greek King of Alexander's homeland of Macidon, King Philip V, declared war on Rome, RIGHT AFTER the complete disaster at Cannie...

Now THAT Royal decree by Philip V to make war against Rome.... IS what started Romes expansion East.

Scipio seized Greece from Philip V and, then conquered all of Asia Minor (modern day Turkey) from Antiochus III.

Then Lucullus spent 5 years chasing Mithradates 6th of the kingdom of Pontus from the shores of Turkey, all the way to Syria and as far east as Armenia. Royal oak college ran into another highly accomplished general basically the best King that Armenia had ever had his name was tigrainians the Great and at expanded his borders farther than any other Armenian ruler.

So that's Scipio the Greek peninsula that's also Skippy out that guy Asia Minor (along with his brother). Then Lucullus conquered past Asia Minor all the way to the mountains of Armenia.

The Illyrian pirates on the Eastern Adriatic Coast were becoming a serious hindrance on traded goods, where now getting routinely stolen. We

To settle this Pirate issue.

Do you guys agree with what Im getting at here or do you guys think I'm WAY off the mark. Would love some feedback, always willing to learn more and something new.


r/ancientrome • • Dec 27 '24

The Western Roman Empire doesn't really exist... give me your best evidence in support of its independence from Constantinople

1 Upvotes

So... The majority of evidence for the creation and existence of the Western Roman Empire are usually loosely connected concepts that fall apart quickly. I'm going to outline a few simple points to prove the WRE doesn't exist, but I'm sure there is work out there that can actually support its existence as a seperate polity. I don't think they are good and its often just the actions of an Usurper. Either way make your case. I have my own short ones listed below.

Theodosius' death and the "split in administration".

This one is more of a lie than the few sentences make it out to be. Often its said Honorius and Arcadius split the empire, pretty stunning stuff from a 17 and 10 year old. What is more likely is that different factions of the eastern court took control of the young emperors. It seems likely Theodosius made Stilicho guardian of his children before his death. In response to this news, his court rival back in Constantinople desputed this and tried to take as much control of Arcadius, including trying to marry his daughter to him. Another faction stopped him but the work was done, it seems that history assumes Theodosius left each of his young children with seperate court rivals, not very compelling and imo Stilicho should have got both of them. This stand-off from this development seems to be the "split in administration" that births the Western Roman Empire, and in some circles this starts Byzantium too. Its bonkers history that does work for lost ideologies. It's a lie.

The WRE was a seperate empire...

Just simply not true in any way, the Emperors were often family and the courts east and west were always in communication as one. The West was always the junior partner with the great example being the Theodosian Code. It was written up in Constantinople and "imposed" on the west. Everyone had a sort of ceremonial script to loudly declare their support for this code. There is no indication that this was ignored or not implemented in the West.

Anthemius, the last non-puppet western Emperor.

The WRE that is supposed to be this independent polity needs to explain how Anthemius can just be imposed on them from Constantinople. The other explanation of course is that it was always the same polity with a new Augustus issued to the western provinces by the capital in Constantinople.


r/ancientrome • • Jul 27 '24

Marc Antony was such a terrible person, and a terrible Roman

0 Upvotes

Maybe I'm pulling too much from his HBO description, but he just comes off as such a transparently self serving power hungry degenerate. Yeah you can argue Caesar and Octavian were in it for themselves too, but they at least had other concrete goals like expanding and stabilizing Rome long term, Antony couldn't do much forward thinking besides deciding who to cheat on his wife with on any particular day.

He's the worst product of his time, a man with a modicum of military talent that let him stomp all over the Roman people.


r/ancientrome • • Sep 06 '26

Dodecahedroi theory

Post image
0 Upvotes

Apologies if this has already been hashed out, I looked around thr internet and mostly found two camps, ritualistic or utilitarian and neither fully explained the mystery.

But I had a thought and I might have come up with some explanations for some of pieces that don’t quite fit.

Utilitarian theory

As some people have pointed out it is fairly useful at holding thread or yarn and not letting a ball roll or a spindle unravel and would be particularly useful if you’re working alone or without spare hands (children or servants).

This is probably the strongest evidence that makes it a utilitarian object, but people are baffled by the lack of wear, the burial status of a mundane object, and why it has mostly been found at the edges of the empire and not all through out.

If it was so useful, why didn’t it spread across the entire empire?

Yeah, why was it mostly found in the northern frontier and in the fringes of the empire? On the frontier there is more work and less hands. So having an object that helps facilitates the mending and manufacturing of cloth and clothing would be a treasured item especially if it was made out of a rare metal. In areas that people had spare hands (children, servants, laborers) reliance on an object like that would probably be seen as a symbol of poverty not ingenuity “oh I have people for that”. But on the frontier you need all of the help you can get and ingenuity makes or breaks a settlement or fortification.

If it was so useful why don’t we find wear on them?

This is probably the most damning piece of evidence that keeps it out of the utilitarian column and puts it in the ritualistic or purely cosmetic category. If it was so important that someone would want to be buried with it, where is the wear?

If we look at other Roman burial traditions (that the dodecahedron are often found alongside) the use of uncirculated round metal objects that were used to buy things (can’t say the C word, thanks clankers) was a way of paying respect. You don’t send people off with used and worn items. You give them new, so the same could have been for the dodecahedron. You don’t bury them with their old worn version, you give them a new ornate version, which was probably a new reproduction of their original.

Why the holes?

Clearly they served some kind of purpose, right? A military grade range finder, or some kind of sorting device? But the holes where robably to make it weigh just right so it worked with specific materials. If it was too heavy you would snap the thread if you tugged to flip it. Or it optimized metal resources, or perhaps they acted as a metal reserve/bank in an area tight on resources. Like Lois and Clark used the lead from their food stores as munitions for hunting and defense, a dodecahedron might have served a dual purpose. If you needed metal either to trade or for something specific you wouldn’t cut off a lobe, that destroys the function, but removing some of the face metal would preserve the function.

Those holes could have told a story of resourcefulness, resilience, and strength during hard times. Being forced to take some metal to solve a problem but not removing a knob, easily reflects the unbreakable spirit that it takes to survive in a frontier territory, so they would want to memorializing that deeply personal history.

Conclusion

In that way, a helpful mundane object might have become a symbol and record of a persons life on the frontier. It might have also symbolized wealth and status to people not familiar with day to day Roman life deep in the heart of the empire, but it also served a practical purpose?

I think that might solve some of the issues, but I’m sure there are more, so if you poke holes in it or have better explanations let’s talk about them.


r/ancientrome • • May 29 '25

We know Emperor Justinian didn't deserve general Belisarius. Because how the hell you blinded your greatest general?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Apr 30 '24

Is Sol Invictus the right God for Rome?

0 Upvotes

I just thought about it, but Rome basically worshipped the Greek God's with different names. So if the Romans did decide to have a native God to themselves, is Sol Invictus the right choice?

(I'm wondering if that's what Aurelian was after)


r/ancientrome • • Oct 14 '26

"Gladiators were too expensive to kill off", but were they really?

0 Upvotes

I often hear it said that gladiator fights were rarely to the death, for the reason that gladiators were expensive to train.

This reasoning strikes me as flawed. The games were meant to be ostentatious displays of wealth. The elites who put on the games were not known for pinching pennies. In fact, spending money was kind of the point. During the inaugural games of the Flavian amphitheater, 9000 animals were slaughtered!

In fact if gladiators were known to be expensive, this would make killing them off another display of tremendous wealth, just the sort of thing the games were intended to showcase.

I think although its true that not every fight was to the death, a lot of them were. These were slaves, human chattel. Training them would not be a major expense for a wealthy aristocrat. Gladiators were expendable and they were expended for the entertainment of the crowds.


r/ancientrome • • Jul 22 '24

Is Trajan overrated?

0 Upvotes

Trajan was certainly a great ruler and an extremelly good general but I think that he's somewhat underrated. Now, before you set the Praetorian Guard on me remember that ''overrated'' isn't the same as ''bad'', it simply means that he wasn't THAT great whilst still being pretty great. Trajan was most definitely a top 5 emperor but to call him Optimus Principes (greatest ruler) is going a bit too far in my opinion.

This is primarily for two reasons:

  • His military campaigns, though astonishing, were not sustainable in the slighest and his territoria gains in the East were almost immediately reversed by his successor Hadrian in a move that can only be considered successful. Trajan does get a lot of credit for solving the Dacian matter which Domitian had been incapable of dealing with but Dacia too would eventually be abandoned

  • His successor Hadrian was probably an even better ruler but it is doubtful that Trajan had any merit in appointing him. His wife probably deserves that plaudit

With that being said you can't discount his popularity with the troops, the people and the senate and his building projects of which a new and improved Forum was the most important


r/ancientrome • • Apr 16 '26

Remember Masada. Around 960 Jewish Sicarii defenders, led by Eleazar ben Yair, chose mass suicide over surrender to Roman forces under Flavius Silva during siege of Masada in 73 AD, marking the end of the First Jewish-Roman War.

11 Upvotes

To date Israeli soldiers take an oath near the hill fortress " Masada shall never fail again". It's become part of their ethos. The fall of Masada also ended the first Jewish revolt against Rome, that resulted in destruction of Jerusalem.

Incidentally the term Sicario is connected to Masada in a way. The Sicarri were a band of Jewish extremists, in fact regarded as the first assasins, noted for their violent attacks on Roman Legions. The Sicarri were the one who took refuge in Masada and held out.

Sicarri were so named after the small daggers they hid in their cloaks and which they used to assassinate Roman officials, soldiers. Sicario was derived from this to indicate the hitmen of the Latin American drug cartels.


r/ancientrome • • Aug 01 '23

Is it real restavrated Roman building, or just new, pretending to look like Roman?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Nov 22 '24

I find Aurelian massively overrated on this sub

0 Upvotes

I'm going to be downvoted, but for a long time, I was an Aurelian fanboy. Today, much less so.

I don't think Aurelian was a bad emperor. He did his best, with the means at his disposal, in a context of great instability. His record is better than the majority of those of the emperors of the crisis of the third century. But when I see some people here placing him above Caesar or Augustus, it seems so surreal to me.

His accomplishments for which he is so often praised are the annexations of the Palmyrene Empire, then the Gallic Empire. In the case of the Palmyrene Empire, Aurelian simply advanced in a straight line destroying all the cities that resisted him, without documented strategy or tactics. The legend that he spared cities after a divine vision is today considered a pagan parody of Constantine's Christian vision. When he encountered the Palmyrene army, he charged at it and annihilated it thanks to his much larger and better trained army. Zenobia's escape also made his conquest easier...

As for the Gallic Empire, it is even less impressive. I think it is misleading to imagine this “empire” as a nationalist secession. Tetricus behaved like a legitimate emperor, in the customs of the Roman aristocracy. It was much more of a glimpse of the Tetrarchy than a secession. Subsequently, Tetricus surrenders without fighting for a single moment, when he learns that the attacks of the Goths have been mastered and that his “empire” no longer has any reason to exist. Aurelian still massacres his soldiers for no apparent reason.

Its domestic policy is not glorious either. Its currency, the aurelianus, was not effective in resolving the economic crisis, and was quickly replaced. In addition, for an unknown reason it puts an end to food aid granted to the poorest since Trajanus. Finally, the invasion of the Sasanian Empire that he planned before his death was carried out by his successors, without any obvious geopolitical change for the Roman Empire.

If we absolutely had to compare Aurelian's journey to that of another Roman figure, I would say that it simply resembles the first part of Constantine's life, when he got rid of the Tetrarchy. Perhaps the hype is due to Aurelian's appearances in Total War, where his reign is largely rewritten and glorified. Tell me if I have omitted or distorted certain elements of the reign of Aurelian.


r/ancientrome • • May 21 '24

Was Rome really evil as portrayed in tv shows and movies?

0 Upvotes

So I was busy watching some history movies and tv shows and any show that takes place during the Roman Empire, the Romans are always portrayed as evil and money hungry and just plain a holes

Some examples that I watched are passion of the Christ, the tv show Barbarians, Ben-Hur and so on

So where the Roman rly that evil as Hollywood portrays most of the time?


r/ancientrome • • Jul 21 '24

It isn't a watch, so what is it?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • Feb 10 '22

META: Posts about coin collections

1 Upvotes

I've seen a few of these recently, and they really bug me. People showing off Roman coins they have bought. The trade in looted antiquities is a real problem. There are temple sites around my way that have suffered from serious destruction and looting, in one case with a JCB. I have been disuaded from making some of my geophysics work on Roman sites public due to fear of looters raiding the sites. My latest large work on a Roman road is circumspect for that reason. All because people loot sites and sell the coins on ebay for a profit from coin collectors.

Of course, if anyone asks these coin collectors why they are supporting the trade in looted antiquites, they say, "I got it from a reputable source". Well I don't believe that for a second. Even it were true, it's still promoting an activity where many do just buy looted coins from ebay. It's distasteful and promotes criminality.

Can we please ban showing off coins on this sub.

EDIT: A word


r/ancientrome • • Nov 14 '23

Would you say Jesus is on the same level as Julius Caesar, Augustus, Cicero, etc., influence-wise in ancient Roman history?

0 Upvotes

Yes, Jesus wasn't a military leader or of political influence, but he did find a religion that would come to dominate the Western world for the next 2,000 years. His life story is the most famous story of all time and is told through text, music, art. Islam was certainty influenced by Christianity and wars have been waged to preserve Christianity.