r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • Jan 24 '22
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/benjaminikuta • Aug 17 '18
Is this what it means to be transhumanist?
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/didsocrateshavesocks • Feb 11 '22
Horrified by primitivist (often combined with ecofascism and misanthropy) lines of thought within online environmentalist communities
Hello everyone,
Long-time follower of the subreddit and a first-time poster. I thought I would never actually write something here, as I tend to lurk in online political spaces rather than commenting in them. To give you a bit of background on myself, I am graduating undergrad this year and have recently accepted a job in some very high-tech academic research (computational neuroscience/biology). Hopefully, I can get a Ph.D. eventually. Anyway, my entire life I have held two values in the highest: knowledge-building/discovery and freedom. In other words, anarcho-transhumanism is pretty much the right place for me politically.
Recently, I have been trying to keep up with papers in various other scientific fields--including climate science. Lucky me, I have institutional access and can read most of whatever I want. I knew climate change was terrifying, but reading the studies in black-and-white, on the PDF page, full-data, really scared the pants off of me. In response, I thought it was high time that I do my duty as an aspiring scientist and attempt to further serve the future of both humanity and other life on this planet by acting on what I read. I have not joined any IRL groups yet, as I am in my final semester and am insanely busy with wrapping up my schooling and research projects. To get an idea of the landscape of activism, I decided to take to various online communities on Reddit and other forms of social media. It was nice for a while--then I was met with some degree of regret.
When I dug further and further into some of the rhetoric of many environmentalists I found lots of anti-technology and anti-human sentiment. I shall paraphrase, some closer to the original quotes than others due to certain phrases sticking in my mind:
"The world is overpopulated. We can't feed the people we have. It is sad to say, but famine might be the only solution."
"We need to hasten the collapse of industrial civilization and go back to a way of living that is in harmony with nature."
"You cannot use technology to solve the problems of technology."
"Technology has only hurt humanity."
"Industrial civilization is forbidden knowledge; it should never have come about in the first place, and sadly we can't put the genie back into the bottle without mass suffering."
"We need to mine rare metals for technology, which hurts the environment and the people in that industry. No one is entitled to our modern, technological way of living. No one even deserves it."
"Humanity doesn't deserve to survive climate change. The best we can do for the planet is to kill ourselves off."
"The idea of technological innovation needs to end. We need to give up our childish fantasies of control and domination over the natural world. Modern science and technology, in essence, are extensions of the colonialist mindset."
"Why would we waste any money going to space when we have a habitable planet right here? Science fiction was never meant to be reality."
All of this terrified me because I thought this shit was more fringe than it seems to be. Even some scientists say things like this, especially some in environmental science and field biology. I know they aren't just online because I did meet a person like this at college--but I was sure that she was a fluke. Great. Now I have to worry about two things: oil lobbyists and people like this (Dark Green Environmentalists). Not to mention r/collapse.
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/Verstandeskraft • Mar 25 '22
capitalism + transhumanism = nightmarish dystopia
3 main reasons:
#1 It would create a caste system of enhancement (Gattaca scenario)
Every sort of enhancement - genetic, cybernetic, drugs etc. - would be available for the rich people much before it would be available to the masses (if ever). So you think you or your child is smart or athletic and this could help you to climb the social ladder? Well, Musk's child over there got a phD in Physics at age of 5 and runs faster than a cheetah; Bezo's child here has 2 Nobel Prizes and 10 Olympic medals. Maybe you could give yourself/your child a little chance of success in life by buying some cheaper/off-brand/outdated enhancements.
Economic stratification would ensure there is a genetic and cybernetic stratification, and this would enhance even more the economic stratification.
#2 Parts of your body are intellectual property of some company
Imagine all the knavish shit tech companies do happening not to your phone or your desktop computer, but to your body:
incompatibility between enhancements of different brands
no right to repair; you have to go to a licensed shop every time your cybernetic arm breaks
planned obsolescence; I hope you are saving money to get a new model for each of your cybernetic prosthesis every two years
tech companies datamining your thoughts through a backdoor in your brain-enhancement chips.
maybe using the same backdoor to run some adds in your dreams
#3 Enhanced mercenary armies
Coming to your country to steal your natural resources.
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • Dec 22 '15
Nobody probably needs this, but I'm sick of these defenses of primtivism within anarchist circles. Given that I depend on technology, I have to take primitivist ideology very personally so here's a rant.
So people who don't care if 6.5 billion people die are totally fine with you. I'm honestly appaled that other anarchists can even see such ideas as anything other than authoritarian. Primitvist "anarchists" don't even give a shit that their politics are extremely ableist. I depend on technology to survive, I can't not take primitvism in a very personal way. Because for me, along with most of the planet, such an issue would be deeply personal.
Rather than liberate civilization prims would rather everyone die to fuffil some sort of ideological mythology. One that is highly Darwinian and not at all anarchist. Such a change would be asthetic rather than radical, it's still an ideology promoting domination. Primtivism doesn't eliminate domination and control but rather changes it's asthetic. As David Graeber has pointed out, there were societies in the past that were highly anarchistic, but these often existed next to pre-civilized societies that were not at all anarchistic. The Hazda are highly anarchistic, but the Inuit were not just as an example. Primitivism also lies upon a reactionary appeal to nature.
Not only is the primitivist view of a natural state deeply mythological, but there is no such thing as a "natural state". Everything is natural! Yes trees are natural, but so is nuclear waste... This happens to be because the divisions of nature and artifice are constructed. Humans and indeed civilization are not seperate from nature. Civilization is a highly modified enviroment but it still is a natural enviroment. Primitivists however will use the word nature to appeal to a reactionary tendencies.
Rather than speak about our ecology, and the enviroments that sustain us. Primitivists talk in huge strokes and meaningless abstractions. Rather than dig into the root causes of our problems, the primitivist simply focused upon empty, psuedo-intellectual posturing. Often, this is the result of taking the absolute worst elements of post-modern thought. Chomsky was right about Laccan and Zizek, and I think similar critique should apply to the primitvist crowd. Interestingly, most of primtivisms critiques come straight out of marxism. The whole ideology of primtivism can be boiled down to dialectical materialism. Read anything from Jensen, Zerzan, or Jerach and their analysis is remarkably similar (obviously there are differences but their underlying concepts are very similar). By doing this after reading anarchist pieces, one should conclude that rather than expand on anarchism primitivism breaks with anarchism. Indeed it's first and foremost, a pessimistic form of marxism.
Primitivism also fails to aknowledge the very real cause of our ecological problems, it's not civilization that caused this mess, it's domination and control, it's capitalism, it's colonialism and the state. Our environmental destruction has everything to do with hierarchy and power, not civilization. "But wait!" Cries the primitivist, "Civilization created hierarchy and power!". This is blatantly false, as mentioned above many primitive societies had hierarchies and power. Many pre-civilized societies were abusive to animals, many were patriarchal.
The dismissal of language also deserves mentioning. It's not that language doesn't have limitations (it absolutely does), but rather than try and expand our abilities to communicate and feel empathy, primitivists prefer to reduce them. Not only should we not develop new ways to communicate, we should not speak. We should exist in mute awe. Of course technology that might expand our abilities and help us overcome fundamental limitations is attacked by primitivists. Rather than make sure every person is able to fully realize themselves and be free from others restraint, primitivists in many ways want a prison. A prison of human limitation and isolation. Because of this, people who want to change themselves are completely disregarded. Not to mention trans-people and disabled folks are completely fucked over by primitivism's authoritarian and Darwinian vision.
Primitivism is wrong, so fucking wrong. I know that probably sounds vague, but it's without any empathy or love. It does not concern itself with people and their needs for freedom. It doesn't care about people suffering, it simply wants to replace our current suffering with a different kind of suffering. Primitivism is a sociopathic ideology. Case fucking closed.
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/gamingfanpr • May 29 '20
Capitalism will not fund research that will save lives
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/justanachoperson • Oct 23 '23
lets see how high we can realy jump
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/ccnnvaweueurf • Jul 10 '20
The working class can soon take control of a huge portion of the manufacturing process. We are soon going to be able to manufacture Vertical Machining Centers in garages using smaller CNC machines, made from smaller 3d printers.
PrintNC Steel Ball Screw & Linear Rail CNC cutting aluminum: https://youtu.be/Q61Oshiozuw
printNC project https://threedesign.store/
Mostly printed CNC's/3d printers: https://www.v1engineering.com/
Huge industrial Vertical Machining Center (VMC) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqePrbeAQoM
3d Printed CNC cutting aluminum: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_atw3e0nIrg
Linux Welding Arm: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSQO3IkQ0Lo
Open Pick and place machine for electronics assembly: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y14pdfjYsyo
Robotic Forging/blacksmithing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0wE4tSVfUc
Huge mostly printed 3d Printer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ru5N2d2n_4c
Modular Cobot designs for work places: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8e76BjH9ez4
Crushing/reorganizing machines for recycling: https://mbmmllc.com/products/
DIY Wire EDM cutting Titanium: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvzneuHc0Sk
Youtube channel where they crush lots of stuff: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJJb04Ff2H2o6CPMUbvEJrA
Small scale plastics recycling: https://preciousplastic.com/
Open builds repository/forums: https://openbuilds.com/
Free software Free Society by Richard Stallman: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf
History of machine tools in human society: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZ8l9MPAoyk
r/hobbycnc mega list of CNC free file sits https://www.reddit.com/r/hobbycnc/comments/h9lrsd/ultimate_list_of_all_cnc_file_sharing_sites/
With the capability to mill aluminum the capability to build larger CNC's becomes possible. These larger CNC's being able to handle large industrial loads and make more machines. I think the making more machines part is the most important part. 1 operator in capitalist operations run 2-15 large machines. What if we were able to do that for one operator: milling steel, recycling plastics, milling pressed plastic sheets, and then the human operator can operate a hand lathe or sweep, assemble etc.
In 2 years time or less I hope to have a PrintNC CNC working to mill parts for a larger Vertical Machining Center with tool changing capabilities and able to do production steel runs. I have a CNC capable of doing wood, and plastics . I have a 3d printer as well. I got the 3d printer complete for $350 and then ordered the parts to build 5 copies of the MP3DP printer plus a few dozen print hours per new machine. That cost was about the same as I spent on the complete first printer. I am moving but will pursue more printers in future. 3d printed print farm
I wish to figure out a free waste product to end product process using recycling machines and automated machine tools. I am a hack and don't know what I'm doing. but it is doable and the technologies work, We the working class are about to gain access to tools of manufacturing normally controlled by very rich individuals/corporations.
My goal with this post is to spread awareness of the potential of automated machine tools and discuss how they can be utilized towards the end goal of total liberation.
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/rechelon • Nov 08 '16
As Society Grows More Complex Only Non-Hierarchical Social Systems Can Survive
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • Dec 13 '20
Anarchist direct action against fascists and drug dealers (Athens, Greece)
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/null_radix • Feb 12 '16
Sci-Hub: a website that bypasses journal paywalls, illegally providing access to nearly every scientific paper ever published
sci-hub.ior/anarchotranshumanist • u/soylentbomb • Sep 14 '20
‘Like an Experimental Concentration Camp’: Whistleblower Complaint Alleges Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Detention Center
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/Reaperfucker • Oct 18 '20
Godhood Must Be Equally Distributed To All Working Class
The only way for the path of godhood is through Science and cybernetic. Transhumanist Egoism is based.
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • Jun 20 '15
Will Artificial Intelligence be a Buddha? Is Fear of AI just a symptom of Human Self-Loathing?
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/RelationBackground55 • Feb 14 '25
Spread the word
I made the first ever anarcho-transhumanist anthology but the blog was taken down here is the new link i appreciate any support https://blog221595527.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/utopia-and-dystopia-1.pdf
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/Michael2Terrific • Dec 16 '19
Does anyone still use this board????
So i kinda just discovered anarchotranshumanism and thus this board, i just wanted to know if anyone here is still alive, that's all...
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/rechelon • Dec 07 '16
Article about anarcho-transhumanist Rob Boyle and his award-winning Eclipse Phase RPG
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • Apr 22 '16
First Gene Therapy Combating Human Aging
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • Nov 18 '15
A rant on the 'role' of anarcho-transhumanism as a bulwark against primitivism, and traditional anarchist tribal demarcations.
I'd be willing to bet I'm not the only one who has noticed a pattern where our role on reddit is basically to counter primitivist ideology on /r/@. Since we want to use technology to liberate minds from the confines of their current biological substrates, and they see tech as a dangerous force for our enslavement, this isn't a surprising dynamic to have within anarchist forums.
What I am concerned about is that this is a non-ideal way for us to transmit or promote our transhumanist ideals or our more basic philosophical commitments. I've noticed a pattern (anecdotally) where transhumanists tend to value analytic thought and communities like LessWrong are disproportionately transhumanist. On the flip side, I have noticed that primitivists tend to involve themselves in spiritual communities and have commitments to continental philosophy (e.g. Heidegger and the Frankfurt school). I think debates about the goodness or badness of technology is basically a proxy war between styles of thought that are different on a basic level.
If we shift our focus to the broader anarchist movement, I think we'd see that it is really a mixed bag. Underneath general agreements on individual issues (e.g. prison abolition, open borders, trans rights, etc), we see deep disagreements on basic philosophical issues such as the merits of the analytic vs. continental traditions (this is actually too complex to make sweeping judgments as if this were a binary model IMO), what kind of ethical theory to adhere to if any, the legitimacy of faith in religion/spirituality, the value of science, or, more broadly, empiricism.
This leads me to question the typical tribal demarcations in the broader anarchist movement. In somewhat simplistic terms, anarchists are traditionally thought of as people who oppose social hierarchies (i.e. the state, capitalism, and social norms that are oppressive like racism, sexism, etc). So AnCaps are typically thrown out for their support of employer-employee dynamics or absentee ownership of capital/land. But, I mean, isn't this a little arbitrary given that the broader movement can't even build consensus on definitions of freedom or the legitimacy of ethics?
Maybe there's utility in working with primmies and nihilists on common causes like opposing arctic drilling or whatever. But we want very different things in the end. There's also utility in working on letter writing campaigns to prisoners with the broader anarchist movement, even if we disagree about the ethics of human enhancement. But what do we say about maintaining open channels with liberals or right-libertarians - gasp - in communities like LessWrong? I'd argue there's utility in cooperating with them to promote rationality, and that given potential basic philosophical commitments we might have in common, debate/discussion with them may actually be more productive than debate with nihilists or new age types in the anarchist movement. On another risky note, maybe there's utility in working with AnCaps on things like opposing corporate-state 'cronyism' and that we shouldn't make a cross with our fingers to ward them off all the time.
By criticizing these popular tribal demarcations I hope to make it apparent that we can expand our role beyond infighting with primmies which, frankly, seems too limited to me. Within anarchist forums defending tech is well and good, but some attention should be paid, IMO, to promoting analytic thought in general, outside the narrow context of debates over tech and civ. Likewise, there would probably be value in introducing anarchist critiques of power relations (and the ethical views behind it) to the skeptic/rationalist and the non-anarchist transhumanist communities. Then there's that whole, hugely important space outside debate forums where there's the question about how to focus RL efforts or activism, insofar as we decide that anarcho-transhumanism is itself a useful affiliation to maintain.
In writing this, I fear that I may have come off as being someone trying to seize the position of a 'leader' trying to tell others what they should be doing. This is more of an attempt to critique our apparent 'role' on reddit as the pro-technology anarchist team, and to start a discussion about more ideal ways for us to mesh with the broader anarchist movement, and otherwise organize as anarchist transhumanists.
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/Adam_133 • Oct 29 '15
The Incoherence and Unsurvivability of Non-Anarchist Transhumanism | IEET
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/rechelon • Jul 04 '12
"As a transhumanist, I reject limitations to social imagination based on human nature."
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/robotmalatesta • Jan 17 '12
If you are a transgender person in Sweden today looking to legally change your gender, in the 21st century you are still forced to undergo surgery that will render you permanently infertile and forever unable to have children. This barbaric practice of forced sterilizations has to stop!
r/anarchotranshumanist • u/[deleted] • May 12 '20
Some questions about anarcho-transhumanist political orientation
I noticed that some of my friend consider Anarcho-Transhumanist to be another version of Anarcho-Capitalism. How true is that ?
I'll let this poll for a week.
Hope you're all leftists
And don't forget to explain and detail more in the comments if you want.