r/analyticphilosophy • • Apr 30 '17

Chomsky vs. Zizek (with a personal note that Chomsky is hugely superior in both logic and substance!)

Thumbnail
partiallyexaminedlife.com
1 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Aug 26 '26

Analytic Philosophy Is the Ideology of the Status Quo -[Psychology Today]

Thumbnail
psychologytoday.com
0 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Mar 20 '20

challenging epistocracy with epistemic democracy

1 Upvotes

i have to study whether epistemic democracy poses a challenge for epistocracy. thats it, thats the question.

I have done plenty of reading on both why not epistocracy (and actually the similar titled paper by Estlund) as well as on Epistemic Democracy, but i cant find a proper thesis and argument on how to answer such a question (my view is that indeed epistemic democracy does overcome epistocracy because, said simply, it does all epistocracy does, but better (both includes better results and the intrinsic value of democratic participation).

The quarantine is not helping with inspiration. Any clues on how to approach this etc? a view i heard was questioning the legitimacy of epistocracy etc, but it was not really convincing as it was badly explained.

Can we challenge epistocracy with epistemic democracy?

cheers.


r/analyticphilosophy • • Jun 15 '21

New online reading group starting 6/22 - Parfit's Reasons and Persons

1 Upvotes

There is a new online reading group starting up for Derek Parfit's Reasons and Persons. RSVP here to attend: https://www.meetup.com/Seattle-Analytic-Philosophy-CLUB/events/278429652/


r/analyticphilosophy • • Oct 08 '26

The hostile takover of philosophy, with Christoph Schuringa

Thumbnail
iai.tv
2 Upvotes

"Christoph Schuringa uncovers less of an intellectual victory than a hostile takeover: social and political forces, including the emergence of McCarthyism in America and Bertrand Russell's influential family connections, sidelined rival philosophical traditions and entrenched analytic philosophy as the dominant school in academia. Drawing on his latest book, 'A Social History of Analytic Philosophy,' Schuringa challenges the discipline's self-image as a neutral, rational enterprise, arguing instead that it is deeply rooted in capitalist liberalism and shaped by its struggle against Leftist engagement."


r/analyticphilosophy • • May 07 '17

i need urgent help into studying/getting carnap

2 Upvotes

hi everybody, i'll be quick: i'm studying at university and the next week i'll have my philosophy of language exam.. i'm studying Carnap at the moment but it's really hard to understand and i forgot everything i learned during class lessons. i'm having a huge headache getting what intension/extension are for carnap, exactly, and his ''state-descriptions'' of possible worlds.. can you help me simplifying? i'm sure you're experts about it


r/analyticphilosophy • • Apr 26 '21

Media Futurist Jonathan Beller Believes the Matrix Is Social Realism and Scrolling Social Media is Exploitation

Thumbnail
paradoxpolitics.com
2 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Mar 30 '10

Two Dogmas of Empiricism

Thumbnail ditext.com
2 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Apr 18 '21

An online Wittgenstein reading group (Currently studying Philosophical Investigations)

6 Upvotes

An online reading group studying Ludwig Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigatons is meeting every Monday!

You can sign up here: https://www.meetup.com/The-Toronto-Philosophy-Meetup/events/zvvrfsyccgbzb/

We take turns reading the text and discussing it - so no advanced preparation is required.

About the text:

"Immediately upon its posthumous publication in 1953, Ludwig Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations was hailed as a masterpiece, and the ensuing years have confirmed this initial assessment. The work undertakes a radical critique of analytical philosophy's approach to both the philosophy of language and the philosophy of mind. Today it is widely acknowledged to be the single most important philosophical work of the twentieth century."


r/analyticphilosophy • • Apr 24 '21

Reading group on Naming and Necessity

10 Upvotes

Hello everyone, we are a group of avid philosophy readers and in mid-May we will start a reading group on Kripke's classic work. The meetings will be weekly and last 90 minutes each.

It will be an in depth reading without prior knowledge required. To achieve the reading will proceed slowly, a few pages per week. The group moderator (who btw is not me) has a Master in philosophy, works as a researcher at university and has a long standing interest in the philosophy of language.

If this sounds appealing to you, let me know either by commenting below or by sending me a PM. We will try to establish a day and time that works for as many people as possible(bearing in mind we live in very different time zones).


r/analyticphilosophy • • 13d ago

Version 0.1β of my article on the macrophilosophical index — change log

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • 20d ago

Why do we still treat Mathematics as "Ultimate Truth"? A critique of mathematical platonism and axiological bias.

2 Upvotes

I’ve always found it puzzling why many philosophers and mathematicians—specifically logical neopostivists and mathematical platonists—search for "ultimate, absolute Truth" within mathematics.

From a purely structural perspective, contemporary mathematics seems to be a useful formal system built upon human-defined axioms, primitive terms, and pragmatic conventions rather than a window into a transcendent reality.

Furthermore, it seems that terms like TRUTH and FALSEHOOD are frequently overloaded with axiological weight. People often interpret them not just as formal truth-values within a model, but as markers of "ideality" versus "imperfection." This introduces unnecessary value judgments into what should be neutral formal inquiry.

I’d be glad to hear critiques, counterarguments, or clarifications if anyone sees this differently.


r/analyticphilosophy • • Sep 13 '26

Justification vs explanation in scientific theories

2 Upvotes

I refer to empirical theories eg. in physics, no formal like mathematics. I analyse them as a product of knowledge not process. I am aware that one reflects another but conflating the "levels" leads to category mistake. I also refer to the Justified True Belief conception of knowledge. By "necessary" and "possible" I mean the modal epistemology. I mentioned 2 aspects that come with empirical theory - I aware that there is also semantic, I omitted it because I thought that it's not relevant to my problem and the emphasis should be on the 2 level that my problem is actually about.

I have some troubles understanding how it works with the justification and explanation. This is how I understand it now, there might me some misconception so any corrections are appreciated:

The theory itself answers the question "how" not "why" it works. It is based on explanation. This appears to be widely shared statement that makes me confused.

Justification is what connects the epistemic agent to the truth of its belief. It is what gives the epistemic agent the right to have knowledge, not just belief that might be accidentally true.

Justification is the "human element" in knowledge. It also "shows" how knowledge operates on possibility, not necessity. A lot of old theories in science had seemingly adequate justification, but later some new finding, information etc. that was unavailable/undiscovered then and the old theory turned out to be false. If we want make knowledge necessary, we have to exclude every possible true claim that actually constitutes what we understand as knowledge, because there is always a possibility of mistake in factual claim. Justification criteria should only minimise the possibility of error and sharpen what we consider knowledge.

I see explanation in science like Aristotle's concept of Episteme, this is however the result of him relying on the form of things, definitions, I doubt that it is how theories now are perceived. Also I understand explanation intuitively as ruling out the epistemic subject, for example "Mary is sad because John left her" is explanation vs "Mary is sad because I saw her crying" is justification. The difference seem tobe about categories?

Justification is about epistemic level, where the epistemic agent is involved, but explanation seem to be metaphysical - how the things are in the world. I am not sure if I get it right.

How it looks like in scientific theories? Is the theory itself an explanation about some part of reality, but it also has justification on another (epistemic) level? There must alway be justification in empirical statement, you cannot just make up something, that's not how science works. So is it about categories? Does an empirical theiry have the 2 aspects simultaneously because they are on different levels? So is it a difference between "scientific theory" and "scientific knowledge" only in the fact that they pronounce different leyers of the theory?

Can statements based on explanation be falsified? It seem to me that falsification applies to statements based on justification. But then it means that explanation based claims are necessary true. And do they belong to knowledge? Empirical theories obviously can be falsified, so is it because they are connected to the epistemic aspect with justification? Aristotle secured his Episteme as necessary by applying the metaphysical theory of matter and form, if the forms are fixed and the system is deductive, the modal necessity is unavoidable. But now we don't connect the theories exclusively with a priori metaphysical terms, rather knowledge with justification, is it why can unlike Aristotle falsify empirical theories?

Btw. I know about Doxa in Aristotle's epistemology, but he draws a clear line between them. Doxa is something like JTB, but I am interested in his explanation -based theory of knowledge which is Episteme.

I "sense" that the truth makers and truth conditions might have something to do with the whole problem. I can't explain it, but I my philosophical intuition is quite sharp and following it often leads to the missing element that I need in order to fully grasp the problem.

I am not sure if I get all this correct and I need clarification. Btw. I apologize for my English, I hope that my post is understandable despite it.


r/analyticphilosophy • • Jun 25 '21

Two questions about naming and neccesity

4 Upvotes

Hello, these questions had originally been posted on r/askphilosophy without getting any answers, so I'm posting them here as well in hope of getting a response.

  1. I am somewhat confused about what the necessary aposteriori that Kripke discusses actually shows. From what I understand, in the case of phosphorus and hesperus, both names rigidly designate the same object, which means they designate the same thing in all possible worlds. And since venus is necessarily self identical, "hesperus is phosphorus" is true in all possible worlds, so it is necessary and aposteriori. But this does not mean that venus must necessarily exist right? Or even if it existed , it's not necessary that venus is what we see in the night sky. There is a metaphysically possible world where instead of venus, there are two other heavenly bodies that cover the same portion of sky that venus does. Is that correct? Similarly with water. "Water is h2O" is a necesary aposteriori identity statement, but that doesnt mean that water must necessarily exist, or even if it exists that it must exist on earth. So again it is metaphysically possible that some other water-like substance filled the oceans that wasnt H2O and therefore not water. So , if I understand correctly the necesary aposteriori doesn't have to do with what things must exist or where they must exist, but with what properties are necessary for an object if that object exists in the first place. Is that a correct understanding?

  2. At the end of the book Kripke gives an argument for dualism. The argument presupposes that we can rigidly designate sensations and that we can conceive that sensations exist without the body. Firstly, I don't see how we could rigidly designate a sensation like pain. Pain at least seems to be different than any other physical object , so how could we designate it. Secondly kripke says we can imagine that a pain exists without the body, again I don't find that as intuitive as kripke. Maybe I could imagine some kind of ghost but other han that I dont think I can imagine myself feeling pain or even existing without my body.

Thanks in advance for any answers.


r/analyticphilosophy • • Mar 08 '21

What is the difference between Sui genris and non reductionism ?

3 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Jan 13 '21

Noam Chomsky - Matter and Mind

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Nov 30 '20

Does Godel's ontological argument require Platonism to be true? Could it still work from a foundation of immanent realism or some type of nominalism?

3 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Nov 22 '20

Where to start with Philosophy

10 Upvotes

I don't know where to start with philosophy, I want to learn, but I am not sure where to start, what is a good starting point, etc. The problem is that I am not sure what I am interested in yet (if I want to learn analytic philosophy or continental, for as an example). So my question is, there is a good start point that is shared by both of those (like logic, etc.) that I can invest while I decide where I want to go.

My obsession is with "truth", but I think that is not information at all (it doesn't say too much), maybe with "the closest way to be sure to speak about facts" I can be more specific, but I personally don't believe in absolute facts at all (I feel that analytic philosophy it is going to be a bit of a disappointment for me in that aspect), so idk where to go actually. Maybe ethics and language?. That is probably the only paths I feel I want to follow, but I would appreciate a lot a good starting point advice for a new student.


r/analyticphilosophy • • Nov 06 '20

I need help with some key concepts in metaphysics/philosophy of mind

6 Upvotes

Hey guys, I've started to work on Chalmers' argument against physicalism (specifically type-B physicalism) and I found his arguments to be sound. To be honest when I first heard about zombies and the conceivability argument I found it quite weak. However, I kinda like it now.

Anyways I've been struggling with the whole strong/brute necessities dialectic. I understand that they pose a problem for chalmers account but I dont get why (I guess that it has to do with my basic understanding of two dimensional semantics and intensions). Also, all the examples that I found so far are about psychophysical identities which appeal to the uniqueness of the phenomenological realm (although I know that there are authors who have posed alternative counterexamples in terms of the metaphysical brute necessity of the laws of nature). I found that argument pretty weak, I mean appealing to the queerness of phenomenological states doesnt sound like an argument to me. Additional reasons should be provided right?

Finally I kinda grasp Chalmers' response that strong necessities are quite ad hoc and break the modal realm into two separate spaces puting unnecessary constrains to logical possibilities. But I would appreciate if someone could explain this better to me.

Thanks to everyone!


r/analyticphilosophy • • Aug 13 '26

Literature 20th Century Analytic Philosophy - Bibliography - [PhilPapers]

Thumbnail
philpapers.org
2 Upvotes

r/analyticphilosophy • • Oct 25 '22

How would Frege analyze the sentence 'The present king of France is bald'?

8 Upvotes

Is it true/false? meaningless? meaningful but with no truth value? What does it say, really?
I remember that when writing an exam on Rusell (maybe a year ago) this question came up and I don't remember what I answered, I just remember that it was wrong. So, what is the correct answer? I'm sure Frege would say that the description has sense, but no reference and the sentence as a whole has its truth value as its reference. But beyond that I'm kinda confused


r/analyticphilosophy • • Aug 13 '26

This sub is open again.

14 Upvotes

Greetings folks, there are about 1400 of you right now. But the sub had been locked down as restricted for about 3 years. So no posts have been accepted for all that time. Please do tell a friend, and invite your neighbors. Please take a look at the rules, and the related communities.

If there is something that people interested in analytic philosophy should be talking about or thinking about. Please do post it here.


r/analyticphilosophy • • May 11 '21

Question on Panpsychism

3 Upvotes

Is panpsychism true?

The definition of consciousness that I use is subjective experience. If you ask what constitutes experience, and what enables it to occur? Then I will answer mental properties and mental states. The faculties that drive mental states to occur is the brain.

I posit the question because I’m interested in views that are not my own. I accept the hard problem, I believe progress is going to be made eventually, so there is a point in asking if it’s true.

To say that an entity is consciousness, is to reduce that entity to just consciousness. Which makes no physical sense. I have consciousness until I no longer do, I am not just consciousness because after it goes away I will still have other parts of myself that exist.

I also hold that self-knowledge is controversial. I don’t know if it’s possible to introspect and become more aware of anything.


r/analyticphilosophy • • May 08 '21

Desiderata and Adequacy Conditions (Question)

2 Upvotes

Dear All,

here is a question about the meaning of some technical terms used in philosophy.

The terms desiderata and adequacy condition are used to set standards against that explanations, models, or theories are evaluated to assess their acceptability or goodness.

But, what exactly are desiderata and adequacy conditions? And how do I know what a relevant desideratum or adequacy condition is? What is the difference between them?

Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts.


r/analyticphilosophy • • Mar 01 '13

Interview with A.J. Ayer on Logical Positivism "I suppose the most important [defect]...was that nearly all of it was false"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes