r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Nov 09 '22
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/ReallyNicole • Oct 16 '13
Looking for papers on kinds over time
So there are doctors (like physicians, medical doctors, etc) in the year 1200 and there are doctors in the year 2013. At first glance doctors in 1200 and in 2013 both fall under the same kind: the kind doctor. However, this seems dumb and it would be really helpful for a paper I'm writing if it were dumb, so I'm looking for stuff on the possibility that doctors practicing in 1200 and doctors practicing in 2013 are really two different kinds. Or maybe the kind isn't relativized to the time period, but just the techniques, practices, and so on of the different doctors.
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/ThisRedditorIsDrunk • Feb 04 '13
Immanuel Kant's "Prolegomena to Any Future Metaphysics That Will Be Able to Present Itself as a Science" (PDF) - An analytic approach to metaphysics as a science.
earlymoderntexts.comr/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '13
A Short Note on Nothingness
Every once in a while I see a post on nothingness, generally asking if nothingness exists. Most responses betray a misunderstanding of 'nothing', treating it as a singular term with a very strange referent. In fact, 'nothing' is a quantifier. Take:
Nothing is on the table.
is not claiming that a certain thing, nothing, is on the table. Rather, 1) can be paraphrased as:
1*) There is no x such that x is on the table.
1*) is claiming that of all the objects in the domain, none of those things are on the table. No need to postulate nothingness.
So, what about 'nothingness exists' or 'it is possible that nothing existed'? Paraphrases suggest themselves:
2) There is no x such that x exists.
3) It is possible that there is no x such that x exists.
2) is obviously false; since I exist, there is an object in the domain which exists. 3), however, seems true; there is a possible world in which no x is such that x exists.
In short, I think most confusions over the metaphysics of nothingness can be cleared up by recognizing that 'nothing' is a quantifier, not a singular term.
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 03 '13
Achievements of Analytic Metaphysics
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '13
“Transworld Identity or Worldbound Individuals?” by Alvin Plantinga
people.duke.edur/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '13
"Advertisement for a Sketch of an Outline of a Proto-Theory of Causation" by Stephen Yablo
mit.edur/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 03 '13
"What is the Problem of Universals?" by Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '13
"Counterparts and Identity" by Robert Stalnaker
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 05 '13
"Essence and Modality" by Kit Fine
fas.nyu.edur/analyticmetaphysics • u/ReallyNicole • Feb 04 '13
Looking for papers on identity between possible worlds. Any suggestions?
Particularly papers in support of the notion that A in w1 is identical to B in w2 in some sense.
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '13
"What is Analytic Philosophy? What is Analytic Metaphysics?"
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/MaceWumpus • Feb 18 '13
"How not to Derive Essentialism from The Theory of Reference" by Nathan Salmon
math.ucla.edur/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Feb 05 '13
How To Be a Modal Realist" by Cian Dorr
users.ox.ac.ukr/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • May 22 '13
"The Unreality of Time" by John Ellis McTaggart
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • May 31 '13
"How in the World?" by Stephen Yablo
mit.edur/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • May 31 '13
"Does Ontology Rest on a Mistake?" by Stephen Yablo
mit.edur/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Jun 11 '13
"New Work for a Theory of Universals" by David Lewis
xa.yimg.comr/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • May 19 '13
r/analyticmetaphysics Reading List
reddit.comr/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Jun 16 '13
Philosopher's in Paradise: A David Lewis Reading Group Blog
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • May 23 '13
Issues with Mackie's Theory of Causation (INUS)
Richard Scheines says that the paresis/syphilis example is a situation where paresis will suffice as an INUS condition for syphilis because it is the only known cause and sufficient. This renders causation symmetrical in this particular instance. In other words, it seems like if syphilis is the only cause of Paresis, surely it is both sufficient and necessary? In this sense it is something like (AX) or A. If so, then how is this an INUS condition if INUS stands for insufficient but necessary part of a complex condition that is itself unnecessary but sufficient?
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • Nov 27 '14
New SEP article - Metaphysical Grounding
r/analyticmetaphysics • u/[deleted] • May 25 '14