I've been building Signal Edge for over a year now. It's an options alert system that's been running live since early this year. Scans hundreds of tickers, finds setups, picks the contracts and sends out alerts with entries, stops, targets, etc.
I've been trading the alerts myself with real money and also have a bot running full time executing trades on a live account.
Honestly it's been a pretty wild year lol.
Back in April we had 221 call alerts averaging +49% on a 5 day hold. May averaged +34%. Had some ridiculous individual alerts too, HOOD went +685% and ORCL +373% on the same day. Both actually went quite a bit higher at their peaks.
Then the market shifted and calls started getting absolutely wrecked.
The weird part is the alerts never really stopped finding moves. Even during the bad months, roughly half of our call alerts still hit +50% at some point within 5 days and about a third doubled. Holding them is what stopped paying.
October was almost the opposite. Puts were doing really well, averaging +68% on a 5 day hold. From mid October into early November we had 92 put alerts with a 70% win rate and 2.8 profit factor.
What's crazy is roughly 80% of those puts hit +50% at some point within 5 days and almost two thirds doubled. But actually capturing those gains consistently is a completely different story.
November 4 we went 14/14 on puts.
A few days later? 0/13 lol.
Same system.
That's probably been one of the more frustrating parts of all this. You can spend months building something, have it perform incredibly well, and then suddenly the exact same setups just stop working.
Something else I've noticed from the bot is that most of the losing trades never even went 30% above entry. They just never really got going. Meanwhile some of the biggest winners looked almost identical when the alerts initially fired.
So now I'm spending more time trying to figure out what actually separates those trades and when the system should just sit out entirely.
We even paused call alerts in November because I wasn't happy with how they were performing. I'd rather have fewer alerts than keep forcing trades just because the system found a technically valid setup.
Another thing I've learned is how misleading averages can be with options. A couple massive winners can make an entire month look amazing, but take those out and sometimes the numbers tell a completely different story.
And then there's the execution side of things. Picking the right direction is one thing, but contract selection, position sizing, entries, exits, volatility, slippage, all of that can completely change the outcome. Especially when you're actually putting money behind every alert.
Some of the put data was pretty eye opening too. The typical alert was up around 100% at its peak within 5 days, but we were only capturing a fraction of that with our exits.
I'm starting to think knowing when NOT to trade is just as important as finding a good entry, maybe even more.
One thing I'm really curious about is how other people handle shutting strategies off.
Let's say your algo has been profitable for months and then suddenly goes through two terrible weeks. At what point do you intervene? And how do you know you're not just turning it off right before it starts working again?
Do you use market regime filters, rolling performance metrics, volatility conditions, or just let the system run through the bad stretches assuming the edge is still there?
That's something I've been going back and forth on quite a bit. Would genuinely like to hear what others running live systems have experienced because some of this stuff looks a whole lot easier on paper lol.
All alert numbers are tracked across every alert we post, using either a hypothetical 5-day hold or the alert's own exit rules. They're not my personal fills or realized trading returns.