AA is very clearly heavily influenced by Christianity. In no small part due to one of AAās founding members being heavily tied to an upper-class Christian ārecoveryā organization that barred low-bottom addicts from its methods, hence the creation of AA.
Honestly, it makes complete sense. America today and especially 100 years ago was so entrenched in white Christianity that any spiritual movement not directly aligned with the religious ous norm would have been marked as a cult WAY harder than AA is.
And okay, yes, we can recognize these roots well enough. But trying to separate from them seems impossible andā¦. Itās denial. AA is Christian Spirituality. Whatever claims the book makes to be all-inclusive of any spiritual path is overshadowed by the general teachings of the program itself, and the other 95% of the primary literature which describes a singular, male God - and preaches Christian ideals of morality & right and wrong. āWe agnosticsā is essentially a 45-minute diatribe of āitās okay if you donāt believe in the REAL god of our understanding yet⦠you willā. Like āoh yeah plenty of non-believers have worked the program!!!! And⦠you know they came around eventuallyā¦.ā Come on. Donāt even get me started on the 12 and 12ā¦
Nowhere are these beliefs and practices clearer than in the rooms themselves. People who do not believe in a Christian God are openly judged by the majority who DO. It is expected that oneās principles and beliefs conform to the norm, and that you use standardized vocabulary when talking about god⦠and what does that mean? He/Him, savior of all, Iām weak and He is strong, God the Father, God the great Protector, Righter of Wrongs and Destroyer of Evil. Itās in the Book
The Big Book.
Half the time when I mention the basic text of AA via our common language, people think Iām talking about the Bible. Thatās what it sounds like! Iāve heard people claim the big book is divinely inspired, and treat it like itās own religious text.
Thereās this unspoken caviat, of ācome as you are as long as youāre willing to eventually be changed into a socially accepted and more white-light version of the person GOD intends you to be.ā If you arenāt open to that, youāre not working the program; if you arenāt working the program, youāre not going to stay sober.
On top of all of this, I take issue with the idea of handing over my will and my life, admitting powerlessness, and the idea that I cannot stay sober by my own capabilities. That āself knowledge avails me nothing.ā That God does it for me. It seems like we are all very happy to āhold ourselves accountable ā when it comes to our wrongs. But god forbid we acknowledge the work put in by the addict when it comes to getting and staying sober. Thatās āgods workā.
The removal and denial of personal power in regards to addiction and obsessive compulsive behavioral patterns is honestly extremely counterintuitive, and I feel that it deeply undermines the capacity for change within people with addiction/alcoholism. It feels much like applying magical qualities to laws of the universe. Dew doesnāt appear on the grass because of temperature changes and condensation, water droplets in the air condensing and landing on surfaces⦠nah. Itās because tiny people go around every morning and place them there with special machines attached to ladybugs.
Iām not denying the existence of higher beings or an intelligent universe that functions in tandem with our energies and intentions. That would be silly! Like there is proof of the way that our environments and experiences are directly influenced by our beliefs.
What Iām saying is that my actions, thoughts, and feelings are not separate entities from Source.
Which is where I get really caught up and take issue with the teachings of AA; where is the empowerment? Personal empowerment doesnāt seem to have much of a place in AA. āI am a simple, mistake-making human. My best ideas get me drunk. I canāt manage my own life. Iām incapable of change. I NEED GOD, to make me capable of those things.ā
Thatās just⦠not how MY Higher Power works. And I canāt, after two years, reach a place of reconciling these Core practices of AA with my own principles and beliefs... Yes, having the community* of AA and working the steps HAS helped me see myself and the world in a new way. But a lot of that came about as a result of CHALLENGING what others in AA suggested. Like, Iāve gained personal power through getting resentful, writing it out, and feeling inside what was right for ME. Itās been the contrast of aa that has helped me the most. I see other people who live happily by the principles and generally accepted social norms of AA culture and pour themselves into AA, and do a 180 in their personalities, and I donāt want what they have at all. To me it looks like indoctrination. I donāt understand how so many people donāt see that? Please explain. Thank you if you got this far!
PS, I grew up in a narcissistic family cult - heavily dependent on Christian indoctrination to function. So that is my background. A lot of what is upheld to be the straight and narrow just looks very reminiscent of the same culture that taught me that being a mentally ill addict (and an individual human with feelings and desires separate from the family) was a moral failing on my part. Like a solid one-two, āyes youāre sick, BUT your main problem is actually just that youāre a selfish ass who canāt make good decisions so you need to beg God to fix you because if you donāt youāre gonna flush your life down the toilet forever because thatās who you really are⦠without god, that is. ;)ā