I wanted to get my thoughts down after seeing Terry Fator last night at the Parker PACE (Parker Performing Arts Center).
I had only seen itty-bitty clips here and there, and kept missing him in Vegas at the Mirage whenever I was there. I was delighted to discover he'd be within driving distance in Parker, so I bought tickets for me, my wife, and my 13-year-old daughter.
Let me start with what he does best: It's an almost supernatural talent to be able to perform the actual "meat" of what he does onstage. He takes lifeless puppets, gives them a voice, and ... holy cow, you're transported into believing they're "alive-ish," talking and singing. And the singing ... in character, doing people like Willie Nelson, Roy Orbison, and a dozen other "sound-alikes." It's really obvious this guy has put in his 10,000 or 100,000 hours honing his craft. He's a natural talent, plus he's worked hard as hell on his personal journey. He deserves to have won AGT, and he has a lot of material. So, talent plus lots of material would have been my voting criteria for AGT.
That being said, you have to "dial in" for a lot of Christian stuff. There's a song called "Horses in Heaven" that he sings by himself (no puppets). He tells the story of someone giving him the source material for the song, then basically says God made Terry the vessel to write it and make it a permanent part of his show. With special callouts to "Our Father in Heaven and my Lord and Savior, J.C.," it felt a little alienating for some people in the audience during those moments. But okay, it was one big song and a few references.
But let me get to the elephant in the room: The show is filthy. Absolutely filthy, which made my 13-year-old squirm in her seat and lean over to ask me, "Hey, Dad, are you enjoying the show?" I said, "Sure, sure ..." She responded, "Sorry this is so raunchy and uncomfortable." Literally, that's all I need to say on this topic. Look, the show is called "Pure Imagination," which is a song from Willy Wonka, a kids' movie (where the song is played as you enter and exit the show). And moreover, walking in, there were LOTS of kids. I'd say "shame on me" if I were the only idiot who brought a 13-year-old to see the winner of a (clean) TV show "America's Got Talent" who does a puppet act. But no. There were lots of us "idiots." In summary: I would not take anyone under 17 to this show. You could argue, "Well, there are only a handful of actual swear words, and the rest is double entendre / language." But it was "squirm-worthy" for my whole family. In short: I get it, it must play well in Vegas, but I wish it were clear that it was better suited for 17+ audiences.
He also did one number out in the audience, literally bringing a Kermit the Frog puppet and in perfect Kermit voice ... sang the whole song while walking around the audience. I have no idea how that was legal (profiting on another property's character), but I'm sure Terry's lawyers got that cleared somehow as "fair use" or something.
He did one showstopper, "Bring Him Home" from Les Misérables (again, no puppet), with a twist interpretation about U.S. troops, and it was really touching. I'm sure the service members in the audience appreciated it.
By the time his finale came around ... wherein he takes 19 little hand puppets and attempts to sing in 19 different styles ... on the way out I heard more than a few people note, "A lot of those in the end sounded exactly the same." As a singer myself, I think what's happened is that by the end of a 90-minute show, singing his face off (mostly mouth closed), he must get tired and the magic effect wears off a little. I'd agree MANY of the 19 sounded alike, specifically the "high-voice ones" like "Michael Jackson" and "Steve Perry."
For me, if he closed on "Bring Him Home" and put the original "19-puppet finale" earlier in the show, when he had more gas in the tank, it would have been a better show.
But also shame on Parker PACE for expressly listing this as an "All Ages" show. I can assure you, it isn't.