r/aerodynamics • • 5m ago

Question Confused by stall speed calculations due to dynamic similarity of flows

1 Upvotes

So essentially I have been studying aerodynamics and calculations of the stall speed for a body with a given shape, weight and altitude have been confusing me.

With the above values constant, Vmin (I will refer to the stalling speed as such) is at Clmax (max coefficient of lift). However, as far as I understand for the result to apply, the Clmax has to be measured in a dynamically similar flow to the one Vmin occurs in for the given body. However, we cannot possibly find Re and M for Vmin due to not knowing it in the first place putting us in a loop.

Does that mean we cannot get a mathematically correct result?

As I am studying this by myself I cannot consult a professor, and wanted to get some input from someone to not just rely on an answer from AI.


r/aerodynamics • • 3h ago

[Hiring] Interested in remote, part-time CFD and aerodynamics work?

0 Upvotes

Remote aerodynamics role, around 15 hours a week with flexible scheduling.

The work centres on creating and validating computational fluid-dynamics problems: preparing simulation cases, running command-line-accessible solvers, and checking the results using Python or another programming language.

Relevant background: aerospace engineering, or mechanical engineering focused on aerodynamics, fluid dynamics or thermofluids, with practical CFD experience.

If interested, send me a message with your CFD background and programming tools.


r/aerodynamics • • 5h ago

Validating a fast Python 2D Vortex-Method FSI solver against high-fidelity OpenFOAM

Thumbnail
github.com
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’ve been building sharpFSI, an open-source Python solver for Vertical Axis Wind Turbines (VAWTs) with passive centrifugal-pendulum pitch control (CPPC).

While 2D Discrete Vortex Methods (DVM) are incredibly fast compared to RANS, they are notoriously tricky to get right when you add unsteady FSI and dynamic stall. To make sure the physics were solid, I built a 54-check analytical verification suite, and I’m also cross-checking the results against full OpenFOAM FSI runs.

About the Repo:

  • Core: 2D DVM with unsteady Kutta-Joukowski, dynamic stall correction, and multiresolution wake thinning.

  • Verification: verify_solver.py runs 54 automated checks (Wagner impulsive start, deep-stall limits, Kelvin budget conservation, structural elastic stops) to ensure the math doesn't drift.

  • CI/CD: GitHub Actions runs the full verification suite on Python 3.11 and 3.12. (Just fixed a fun bug where skipping a cross-check test was failing the CI exit code!)

  • Speed: Accelerated with Numba.

If you're into vortex methods, FSI, or just want to see how to build a bulletproof automated verification suite for physics codes, I'd love your feedback on the repo!


r/aerodynamics • • 10h ago

Question Could a scramjet-turbojet hybrid engine replace rockets?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 12h ago

Question How should a lifting surface model handle drag forces at extreme AoA?

1 Upvotes

Hi

I'm not much a physicist, but a programmer. I’m developing a flight-sim video game in which I’d ​​like to implement reasonably authentic physics, which is something I would define as a foundational element of the game.

If I'm not mistaken, the total drag force at pre-stall angles of attack is composed of induced drag and profile/parasite drag. Induced drag is defined as a force that arises in conjunction with lift, so it may be calculated at pre-stall angles of attack.

So I've got a question: do other aerodynamic drag forces arise on lifting surfaces at angles of attack beyond stall and if so, which forces (or better -- models) are they? In other words, does stall introduce new drag components that should be calculated separately?

The surfaces itself are modeled as strips by the Strip Theory and these strips' airfoils' Cl, Cd and Cm coefficients are trilinear (alpha x re x mach) interpolated from their polars (which are generated via AeroSandbox/NeuralFoil for 360deg).


r/aerodynamics • • 1d ago

Educational Wake vortices behind a generic fastback at 30 m/s: OpenFOAM, rendered in Blender

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Generic car shape from my own script, half model, moving ground and rotating wheels. OpenFOAM 14, steady k-omega SST, 1.66M cells from snappyHexMesh. Cd ≈ 0.28, Cl ≈ 0.20 (mean of the last 500 iterations).

No prism layers (wall functions on a castellated/snapped surface), so I treat Cd as indicative. Surfaces are Q-criterion iso-levels, rendered in Blender Cycles.


r/aerodynamics • • 2d ago

Tip vortex helix behind a small wind turbine at tip-speed ratio 6 (CFD)

17 Upvotes

Generic 3-blade rotor, R = 0.45 m, 10 m/s wind, 1273 rpm. The surfaces are the Q-criterion, coloured by wind speed, so you can see the three tip vortices and the root vortex along the hub.

Simulated in OpenFOAM 14 (sliding mesh, k-omega SST), Cp ≈ 0.32, Ct ≈ 0.81. Rendered in Blender.


r/aerodynamics • • 3d ago

Where could i find a free windtunnel simulator for aircraft? more specifically drones & model airplanes?

5 Upvotes

Also if there are any decent airfoil apps anyone could recomend it would be greatly appreciated, thanks!


r/aerodynamics • • 3d ago

hi guys, need some help in starccm

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 3d ago

The theoretical interactions of a mathematically perfect Cone used as a projectile at hypersonic speeds (over Mach 5)

0 Upvotes

I recently had the question of how a mathematically perfect cone would interact with being fired at supersonic speeds. If it is assumed that with a near zero-radius tip (infinitly approaching the ideal) the cone causes infinite pressure to penetrate any obstacle and that the cone is made from an indestructible material so that it doesn't deform from the infinite stress and that with a perfectly smooth lateral surface a minimum of friction is formed, will shockwaves and superheated plasma still be formed, and is there anything I overlooked?

I am not an expert, and most of this is pure speculation. I just was inspired by the attack "True Sphere" from the anime Jujutsu Kaisen and wanted some expert opinion.


r/aerodynamics • • 4d ago

Im getting Lower lift as compared to paper how to fix this ?

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 5d ago

Towards accurate aerodynamics models for wing icing

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 7d ago

Alguna idea de tema para ensayo sobre aviación y física a la vez?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 7d ago

which phy project is best for my school's science fair

0 Upvotes

Design and Development of an Intelligent Aircraft Wing Anti-Icing System: Automated Temperature Regulation and Statistical Analysis of Energy Efficiency
Your system will:

  1. Measure the wing's temperature.

  2. Detect when the temperature falls below a set value.

  3. Automatically switch on a small heating element.

  4. Switch the heating off when the target temperature is reached.

  5. Record temperature and energy consumption.

automatic wind-tunnel testing machine for aircraft wing
aircraft testing machine that:

  1. Generates airflow using a fan to simulate wind around an aircraft wing.

  2. Automatically changes the wing's angle using an Arduino-controlled servo motor.

  3. Visualises airflow using tiny threads attached to the wing.

  4. Measures airflow speed before and behind the wing.

  5. Collects experimental data to investigate how changing the wing's angle affects airflow and the onset of aerodynamic stall.

  6. Uses statistics to analyse results through averages, graphs and standard deviation.

which one of these is good for my schools science fair and wud give me a chance of winning


r/aerodynamics • • 8d ago

A real-time 3D wind tunnel for cars on a phone (lattice Boltzmann, for fun, not engineering CFD)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 9d ago

Frisbee-like lift for drones?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/aerodynamics • • 9d ago

Question Anyone with knowhow on how wind behaves against an apartment building, that can give some insight?

2 Upvotes

I'm about to install an air condition unit for heating during winter and am clueless about the aerodynamics of wind against apartment blocks. Any help would be appreciated. I have an apartment on 4th floor and I don't have a dedicated drain I can use for the condensation from the compressor unit, so I need to stick a pipe out of the railing in my balcony, the balcony is also glassed in so wind doesn't go through it.

My apartment is pointing straight East. In my region, during winter the wind mainly blows from west and North/north east. I should already be shielded from west wind.

I need some help considering the optimal placing to minimize the condensation water hitting against the wall or neighbours below.

I've added an image of the general shape of my apartment, I'm considering placing the condensation pipe at point B. Anyone has any idea how wind from North, or North East behaves against this building? I assume wind from North/North-North-East will not be a problem. It might slightly shear, but then roll along the wall.

For North-East wind I'm not sure how it will behave. The wind will hit the building at a 45 degree angle, and shear on the corner. Will the shearing wind roll along the wall mainly with a force parallel to the wall? And will this wind shear protect against north east wind so the water dropping from point B only moves sideways? Or will point B and point C still get hit by North-East wind with an oblique force vector?

Right now I'm considering point B or C. I'm considering point B assuming the wind that rolls against the wall will "shoot out" the droplets a little.


r/aerodynamics • • 10d ago

Question Where to start with John D. Anderson / CFD books

11 Upvotes

Hi, I'm interested in learning more aerodynamics from an interest in motorsport and car design perspective (mostly as a hobby, I don't think I have the right credentials to get a job in motorsport). I have a little bit of experiance with fluid dynamics from my physics degree but not much.

I was interested in his Computational Fluid Dynamics book but wondered if I would be better off reading Intro to Flight or Fundamentals of Aerodynamics first?

Are there any better or follow up CFD book out there you would reccomend after this as well?

Thanks!


r/aerodynamics • • 10d ago

Research Anyone have experience with Ansys FENSAP-ICE? Looking for the best ways to learn it

1 Upvotes

I'm now looking to learn FENSAP-ICE for in-flight icing simulation, including droplet impingement, ice accretion and ideally ice crystal icing.
Has anyone here used it, either in academia or industry? I'd love advice on:

Learning resources: tutorials, courses, books or papers that helped you get up to speed

Validation: good benchmark cases or experimental data

Anything you wish you'd known when starting out
Thanks in advance!