r/adnd • • Apr 06 '25

Learn THAC0 in 633 easy steps

0 Upvotes

Alright, buckle up buttercups, because we're about to dive headfirst into the wonderfully weird world of AD&D combat! Forget your fancy modern games with their sleek, unified "roll high and be happy" nonsense. Back in the day, we had THAC0, which sounds less like a game mechanic and more like the noise your cat makes when it coughs up a hairball. "Thaaac-0... yep, that's about right." Now, the name itself, "To Hit Armor Class Zero," is where the confusion often starts. It's like naming your pet goldfish "Land Shark." Technically accurate if you have a really weird aquarium setup, but mostly just baffling. You see, Armor Class (AC) in AD&D was backwards! Lower was better. So, THAC0 was all about figuring out what you needed to roll on your trusty d20 to smack someone wearing full plate armor. From there, things only got… well, more AD&D. And speaking of "more AD&D," let's not forget that this beautiful beast of a game couldn't even decide if success was about rolling high or rolling low! THAC0 wanted you to roll over a certain number to hit, but then you'd be trying to roll under your saving throw to avoid turning into a toad. It was like the game had a multiple personality disorder when it came to dice rolls! At its most boiled-down, brain-tickling core, the THAC0 magic worked like this: you took your THAC0, subtracted the poor monster's Armor Class, and that was the number you had to roll on your d20 or higher to introduce your weapon to their squishy bits. Simple, right? Riiiight.

Now, hold onto your +1 cloaks of elvenkind, because here's where the mental gymnastics really begin. The Dungeon Master, in their infinite wisdom (and occasional sadism), would be the arbiter of all things affecting your target's AC – maybe they're behind cover, maybe they're slippery from slime, maybe they've got some fancy magical protection (thank the sweet merciful deities for that!). But YOU, my friend, YOU were responsible for figuring out your own attack modifiers. And get this – are you sitting down for this bombshell? Your shiny, much-coveted +2 magic sword? That beauty didn't add to your attack roll like some sane system would… oh no. It subtracted two from your THAC0! Yes, you read that correctly. A better weapon made your THAC0 lower, which meant you needed to roll a lower number to hit that AC 0 gnome. It's like the game was actively trying to give you a headache. (Actually, if you can't quite wrap your brain around the THAC0 subtraction, no worries! Think of that +2 sword as adding a glorious +2 to the number you roll on the d20. Sometimes a little mental re-framing is all it takes to survive the beautiful absurdity of AD&D.)

And now, if you happen to be prancing around in some fancy +2 armor... well... uh... it makes your AC... uh... lower? Which is good? So... the number you need to hit you is... higher? Or lower? I... I think I need a nap. And possibly a flowchart. Maybe just more dice. Yeah, definitely more dice.


r/adnd • • Jan 17 '24

I tried to use Diablo to explain the different editions of D&D. Whatcha think?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/adnd • • May 30 '24

AD&D Hold Person spell. Holds the person relative to what?

0 Upvotes

I thought of this because someone asked a Hold Person spell question earlier today. This is a strange question, but let me try to clarify with an example.

I was recently DMing a homebrew adventure based on 2e rules, spells, etc. Some NPCs were in a small canoe style boat that got caught in a current and was going to be swept over a huge waterfall. No amount of paddling could get them out. Magic User on shore asked if he could use Hold Person to keep them from moving. I loved the idea of the spell holding someone, not just still, but relative to their position on the planet. It just really amused me, so I allowed it to not only stop their movement, but also lock them in effect to a GPS coordinate.

So because the boat was small/light, the NPC's immobility was able to temporarily hold the boat in a fixed position despite the current until they could be rescued (by someone shapeshifting into a harpy and plucking each of them out of the boat and carrying them to shore, the "held" person coming last as the spell effect was ended).

Later, the PC used the spell on an enemy below deck in a large sailing vessel, and the spell effectively crushed the person against a wall since the moving ship was too large to be stopped by one immobile person - haha! Anyway, I'm sure it's not how the spell was intended, but I went with it and we enjoyed the results.

Thoughts on my liberal interpretation of the spell's effect?


r/adnd • • Jun 30 '25

Atheist cleric situation

0 Upvotes

I have a 10th level cleric in my campaign who doesn't worship any gods. He draws his powers from "the universe". As DM, I liked this spin on the class.

In my next game the players will need to travel through the ethereal plane. According to the Manual of the Planes, clerics are limited to only 1st & 2nd level spells if their deity doesn't make its home in the ethereal plane or an adjoining plane....but this cleric *has* no deity.

Should I let him slide & have access to all spells appropriate to his level or slap em with the limitation?


r/adnd • • Oct 21 '24

What is this Old School Renaissance OSR Thing? Learn Everything About it Here and Join in the Fun!

0 Upvotes

This is my love letter to the OSR community. My Magnum Opus. Everything anyone needs to understand what the OSR is, where it came from, and how to get into it. Enjoy, and Like, Subscribe, and Share it Around! Thanks!

https://youtu.be/qGnja9GL5go


r/adnd • • Jul 26 '20

hating on other dnd players/editions is not cool.

0 Upvotes

don’t get me wrong, i love a good old adnd campaign as much as the next guy, but guys.. you do not look cool at all by bashing people for liking 5th edition.

some people like playing a warforged tortle celestial warlock dragonborn sorcerer fighter mage rogue who dual wields rapiers and has 20 charisma. i personally don’t, but some people do. other people like playing a regular old human fighter with 11 in every score and nothing special to speak of. i personally fall in the middle, but i don’t mock people for liking either.

5th edition players font mock you for liking adnd. so why do you mock them for liking 5th edition? you guys look immature.

EDIT: i now realise that my viewpoint was pretty one-sided, and that i sounded spiteful. i did not mean to sound that way. i also realise that more 5e players mock adnd players than i realised. i am sorry. however, it still doesnt excuse mocking them, its still a bad thing to do.


r/adnd • • May 23 '25

Is this technically a more Believable/realistic depiction of what a Magic user/wizard Adventurer would look like?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Image is the Magic User from the Second DnD Capcom game.

Mostly say that because it wouldn't make sense for an old ass man wizard to go put adventuring with his weakened body because Low Dex and Con due to aging. Plus old Wizard tend to be experienced and powerful in media they appear in .

Also the Most famous wizard Merlin age kinda varries in his myth + he was a Cambion so there's that.

Also most wizards probably suck at socialising so they'd probably end up coming off as an edge Lord due to being a introvert/nerd.

Also side note: Pulp Fantast is probably closer to Light novel/Manga/anime fantasy then it too a more serious fantast like Song of Ice and Fire or middle earth. Also a lot that stuff would trace its dna to Record of Lodos which was just a couple magazine writers personal DnD campaign they wrought about in there publication that got so popular it became a manga, then anime and finally it's ttrpg.

Also fun fact the artist for this game originally had a witch like character designed for the Magic User but TSR rejected it so she made him an edge lord.


r/adnd • • Apr 09 '21

On being Trans/Non-Binary in Gaming.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/adnd • • Aug 06 '21

Bioessentialism in Dungeons and Dragons, and in depth look.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/adnd • • Mar 10 '22

A Better THAC0

1 Upvotes

I have recently discovered a very elegant way to handle THAC0 and descending AC.

I was not the first to come up with it; u/Fingon_Spengler published it in their Engines & Empires RPG back in 2008. As far as I know, that was the earliest publication of the method.

How it Works

  1. Compute THAC0 by subtracting normal THAC0 from 21. So 20 THAC0 becomes 1 THAC0. This should be pre-computed for each monster and PC; it would be cumbersome to write down the normal THAC0 and perform this operation every time you attack. [Feedback from u/anonlymouse about mathematical complexity]

  2. Attack roll procedure:

    1. Calculate target number:

      1. Start with your THAC0 (pre-compute things like strength bonus, magic bonus, etc. per weapon)

      2. Add the enemy's AC

      3. Add any other modifiers

    2. Roll equal to or under the target number in order to hit.

This is mathematically equivalent to the normal interaction between THAC0 and descending AC.

Benefits

  • Higher THAC0 is better.

  • THAC0 still means THAC0, it's not a bonus to hit or something. Not only does this keep things in better alignment with the rules-as-written, it also preserves compatibility with character sheets and stat blocks that have THAC0 fields.

  • To-hit is calculated before the die is rolled. This keeps all the math in one place and heightens the tension.

  • To-hit numbers can be thought of as your chance-in-20 to hit. A final to-hit of 5 means you have a 5-in-20 chance of hitting the opponent. Similarly, this means that a THAC0 of 7 means that you have a 7-in-20 chance of hitting an opponent with AC 0 (without taking into account any modifiers).

  • It becomes more intuitive that lower AC is better: it is clearly your degree of vulnerability; with a higher AC, you have more chinks in your armour, and the enemy has a wider range of successful rolls.

  • You perform addition, not subtraction, which is easier on the brain.

  • The operands are smaller most of the time (20 THAC0 becomes 1).

  • Negative AC is more intuitive, and easier to calculate: you've always been adding AC, and so if the AC is negative you're just adding a negative number. You never have to subtract negative numbers.

  • The math is symmetrical: the target number is simply the sum of all the modifiers.

  • Attack rolls are brought into closer unity with other rolls, most of which are roll-under.

Drawbacks

  • This system requires either A. the players to know the AC of enemies, or B. the DM to compute the target number entirely, incorporating the player's THAC0 for them, and then let the player simply roll the d20. [Feedback from u/smokeshack]

  • Rolling high is bad, and rolling low is good. This is unintuitive. [Feedback from u/cookieChimp]

  • If you are referencing stat blocks that already have normal THAC0 figured in, you will have to cross out or ignore these values. It also defeats the purpose of the pre-calculated THAC0 values. The 2e monstrous manual and compendiums have THAC0 figured in, and I imagine the 2e modules do too, along with many third-party modules and monster books. This won't be a problem for 1e: none of the THAC0 values are figured in.

  • It brings your rules into greater friction with the rules as written. Beyond all the places where THAC0 is explained in the normal way, there are also tables (I only know of the 2e punching table, personally) that assume that higher to-hit rolls are better. Also, the rules for crits and guaranteed hits will be the opposite of what they should be.

  • As with any house rule, this will need to be explained to the players.

Comparison to Target20 [Prompted by feedback from u/Harbinger2001]

  • In Target20, you roll first and do math second. In the above system, you figure out your to-hit number first and then roll.

  • In Target20, you roll d20, add stuff, and compare to 20. In the above system, you just compare the d20 to the stuff.

  • In Target20, high rolls are better. Personally, I like roll-under systems, but of course, that's a matter of opinion.

Feedback

If anyone has a further improvement to the method, an unlisted benefit or drawback, or a correction, please tell me, and I will edit the post and credit you.


r/adnd • • Dec 17 '25

Adnd characters seem kinda lethargic given the round time scale.

0 Upvotes

Like 1 round = 1 minute, your telling me it takes a while minute for a fit guy to walk up to someone and hit them once? (This was probably a remnants of DnD being built on chainmail right?)

No wonder they changed it to 10-15seconds in the players options series, this is impression breaking especially sense I've done a bit of longsword training


r/adnd • • Jan 10 '23

Any non-bad or good stores of women starting out in AD&D?

0 Upvotes

I find horror stories all over the web about women playing AD&D or other TTRPGs for the first time and having a bad experience. I'm sorry for those women and girls who went through those things.

But I'm wondering, is every first time playing AD&D and D&D as a women a bad experience? Or are there any good ones or even 'meh, just alright' ones.

Gosh this sounds corny asking, but I really want to know.

Is our view skewed because of all the bad stories, or is that the reality?

Ladies, when did you start playing? Can you remember your first game session and/or campaign?

Any non-bad or good stories of women starting out in tabletop gaming?


r/adnd • • Jan 20 '25

In game reasons for restricting the purchase of Magical Items

5 Upvotes

Note: if you're going to tell me I'm playing AD&D wrong by allowing PCs to buy magical items, save your breath. I don't want to hear from you.

So in my AD&D campaign, my PCs are at the level where they have enough disposable income and unnecessary loot that they are looking to swap some stuff out. As a DM, due to time constraints, my campaign has been a collection of unrelated pre-published 1e modules which I've loosely tied together as an overarching plot. And because I'm doing the 'minimum prep' thing, I have no desire to go and customize the loot within a module. Much easier for me to let the PCs deal with it.

Which brings me to 'ye olde magic shoppe'. I've informed the party that magic stores exist, but are very rare and only in big cities (like the capital of the kingdom they are in). Magic is highly regulated in the game world, as they will find out. The only magic shop in the kingdom is run by the government, in the main castle in the capital. It's heavily defended and you have to be authorized to even be in there. Basically, the place is open by appointment only. A high ranking gov't official works behind the desk and they have, on hand, a subset of the magical item list. Mostly this is going to be potions and what not, but there will be a collection of some misc magical items, some armors and some swords. There *may* be better items somewhere else for sale, but the PCs will need to get in better with the royals to even know of their existence. Prices go from between 125% - 200% the gp sale values in the DMG. Depends on the item. Some things (potion of human control, for example) will never be up for sale for very obvious reasons.

There is also the possibility of purchasing items from the black market / thieves' guild, etc... But that's going to be very expensive (200%-500% gp sale price or more!) and the PCs had better be able to figure out if the item isn't cursed, etc. I mean, they are thieves.

So now as to why - in game lore had a major empire about a thousand years ago that had none of these safeguards in place. They were very "we do what we want! Freedom!" and they completely imploded - very violently, very messily and that region is still a wilderness with at most scattered city states eking out an existence. The lesson of the old empire is fundamental to the new kingdoms - "keep the magic out of the public if you want to keep your heads".

So that's it. It gives PCs a place to get rid of their unwanted stuff, incentivizes them in-game to work with the local government and keeps magic items from being too easy to get.


r/adnd • • Sep 03 '26

AD&D2e Attribute increase

0 Upvotes

I wonder if many people here implement an automatic attribute increase at various milestones? Example: Allow you to raise one attribute by 1 point at levels 4, 8, 12, 16, 20

I don't expect or want every ability to be 16+. But I don't want to miss out on parts of the game I would enjoy (casting 9th level spells as a wizard, playing a paladin, etc)

I should note that I'm biased because I'm diagnosed with the Unrelenting Standards feature. So accepting a more mundane role in a game is very difficult for me


r/adnd • • Aug 16 '26

AD&D1e IQ and Intelligence Ability score.

0 Upvotes

Rolling 3d6 gives a bell curve between 3 to 18, and the average of 10.5. The chance of rolling an 18 is 0.00463. If people have the 3d6 ability scores, out of 2000 people, on average there should be about 9 with 18 intelligence. For IQ scores, that number of people is the same as about an IQ of 139. But remember seeing something saying that a 18 Intelligence ability score is the same as 180 IQ? That must be wrong?


r/adnd • • Jul 18 '26

The 50-Year D&D Problem Solved: We Asked a Better Question

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/adnd • • Oct 09 '24

Does AD&D Increase Gamemaster IQ?

3 Upvotes

So I started D&D with 3.5th about 20 years ago and have played each subsequent new edition as it came out. My father had lent me his old copy of the AD&D rules so I'd always had some interest in that style of game and eventually I was able to convince a few friends to try a short campaign (Village of Hommlet module) using AD&D 1st edition rules.

I don't like to run a game without a good grasp of the rules so going from 5e at the time to 1e was quite the steep learning curve, but dragonfoot forums and this sub have a wealth of information some of the more arcane complexities.

I've since run quite a number of different systems, Cyberpunk, Shadowrun, World of Darkness, etc. I feel like, once I was reasonably confident in the main things needed to run a session without constantly looking up rules for AD&D, it was as if most every other game system seemed simple to comprehend and learn in comparison.

I don't expect there's a scientific answer here but just wondering if anyone else has had a similar experience or if it's just the progression of learning different game systems? Of course it makes sense that AD&D had an impact on most game designers, especially for OSR type games. Just was interested in what others might think on this subject.


r/adnd • • Dec 28 '21

AD&D 2nd Edition Game Mechanics

2 Upvotes

At what level does do you feel the game starts to

  • break down?

  • Become unbalanced?

  • Too Powerful

What I'm getting at is the fact that a lot of people I have talked with feels the game is solid up to around level 10. But what do you think?

a. 1-8?

b. 1-9?

c. 1-10?

d. 1-11?

e. 1-12?

f. Some other level?


r/adnd • • Aug 09 '23

Create fully custom character sheets with Quest Bound

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/adnd • • Mar 11 '25

Nathan Dillon just referenced AD&D on GMA

0 Upvotes

He was talking about appearing as one of the Green lanterns, and in describing his character, who works for the Green lanterns, as a kind of bad guy but also good, he said "I think the technical term is chaotic neutral"


r/adnd • • Dec 02 '25

A faithful 2E-format rulebook in modern layout (cleanroom build, fully legal to publish for)

0 Upvotes

I wanted to share something that may be useful to people who still play AD&D 2E but prefer a modernized layout and clearer organization.

Over the last few years I rebuilt the 2E ruleset as a cleanroom project. The goal was simple: preserve the original mechanics exactly as they were, but present them in a coherent format that is easier to use at the table. Nothing was redesigned or rebalanced. It plays like 2E because the underlying structure is unchanged.

A few points people might find helpful:

• All core 2E mechanics preserved with no redesign
• Modern layout and indexing for faster reference
• Almost all Nonweapon proficiencies are in the core rulebook
• Kit creation rules included, replacing the old Create-a-Class section
• Expanded options like Appearance as a seventh stat, martial arts, new races, and ship combat
• Cleanroom text, legally distinct from TSR’s books

I also created a license for people who want to publish adventures, settings, classes, kits, or expansions using this ruleset. There is a free tier for credit-only usage, and a $50 per year tier for commercial use of my trademarks and logos. No royalties. Anything you publish remains yours permanently; the only restriction is that updates require an active license.

If you prefer AD&D 2E but want a modern-format book to hand to players, or if you’ve been looking for a legal way to publish 2E-style content, this might be a helpful option. I’m happy to answer questions if the moderators allow discussion.


r/adnd • • Sep 11 '24

Bestow Curse implies the existence of...

2 Upvotes

Bestow Curse implies the existence of Bestow Blessing. Such a spell would be a touch range instantaneous 1 turn / level duration spell of 4th level or higher that is unaffected by dispel magics. It could provide blessings to a target with effects similar to the reverse of normal curses. Effects like...

  • One stat raised to a racial max (random or DM selection)

  • Attack rolls and saves gain a +4 bonus

  • Subject is 50% likely to be hasted (without aging) each round

Is there anything like this in 2E AD&D?

Edit: I'd forgotten that the Bestow Curse is not itself permanent in 2E so we can say the Bestow Blessing is also not permanent but that it would have a similar duration to its curse counterpart.


r/adnd • • Mar 04 '26

AD&D General Questions about the rules

23 Upvotes

"Here's how I do it in my game" has NEVER been the right answer when a redditor is asking for the game's rules.

When somebody asks "what's the rule for x" instead of "how do you handle x", they are asking for the book's text. They are not asking how you interpret that. They are not asking for your permission to ignore the rule. They want to know what the rule is.

Once they know the rule, they can apply it, change it, or ignore it entirely, but if they ask for a rule, telling them anything other than the rule is at best a waste of time. At worst it's a distraction that muddles the conversation.

Yes, they know they don't have to follow it. Small children learning to play board games do that intuitively. Nobody has ever needed to be told they can change a rule they don't like in the history of games.

Here's an example of practically every single thread ever.

OP: How did you roll initiative in 1e?

Poster 1: At my table, we roll a d14, and then go in alphabetical order around the table. Poster 2: Whoever yells the loudest goes next (I actually know a GM who does something like this because she's so freeform she never keeps track). Poster 3: Initiative sucks. I use a real-time combat system. Here's a link to my YouTube channel where I talk about it. Poster 4. A d14 is stupid. We use a d12 and add 2.

At no point has anyone bothered to answer OP's question.

Note: this is not an official moderator rule. This is my personal statement. I just happen to be objectively right here.


r/adnd • • Jul 04 '25

Using video games character creators.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Just wondering if anyone else uses games character creators to get an image of what they want there character to look like? Soulcalibur & Elder Scrolls are 2 I like using. Are there other creators people use? I can draw but I prefer using character creators to get the concept and if I want something different I draw it afterwards.