r/actuallesbians • u/MariaMagdalenaXXX • May 28 '24
Text Let's talk about genitalia NSFW
Dear community,
Yesterday, I happened upon a post on here - that in the meantime, went down - by a trans woman asking the community the simple question whether they liked women with penises. I clicked on that post despite my experience telling me not to expecting the comment section to contain the usual flow of love and wholesomeness that this community shares. But I was disappointed.
After I blew off some steam yesterday I decided to share a few thoughts on the matter in the form of this small essay. It is not meant as a call out post, rather, I wanted to offer a fresh perspective on that topic that I hope all people on here, explicitly including cis lesbians, can benefit from. I am happy about feedback in the comments.
I am currently reading a book by the great Alison Bechdel - if that doesn't ring a bell, do look her up - that reminded me of a simple fact: The lesbian movement, at its inception - obviously distinct from lesbianism as a whole - offered the promise that it would not simply replicate heterosexual relationships, adapted for relationships of women towards other women. It would rather strive to develop something entirely new, so profoundly distinct from heterosexuality that lesbian love and lesbian desire would be recognized as clearly distinguished from heterosexual relationships.
In my limited experience, what that has meant for me on the part of desire has been recognizing that what comphet made me believe about desire was that desire sprang from the partial fulfillment of a fantasy by something that happened in reality. As it always is, recognizing that has not yet let me stop holding on to these fantasies. So I get it. Especially when I am starved for affection and when my need to experience pleasure and desire is not met, it is soothing to make the trip to wonderland. And all of us, from time to time, need soothing.
At the same time, I am grateful for another experience: That where expectations end, true desire reveals itself. When I let go of this search of my touches of an experience some fantasy told me would be there, I am free to turn my touches into an exploration. It is such an immense joy to experience the never ending diversity of a body in this way, over and over and over. And it is a profound expression of love to be cherished in this way.
I was lucky to get a whiff of what posibilities desire harbours and I hope that my life will continue in this exploration.
I think that it is natural for any exploration to come to a crossroads from time to time and to explore down one path but not the other. I even think it's an integral part of it; some of the joy of exploring comes from making a decision and seeing where it takes you. And no one can judge you for not being pac-(wo)man: You don't have to go down every path.
That brings me to the diversity of women's bodies. As I said, for me, it has been a bottomless well of joy to get to know very diverse women and their bodies and to overcome my preconceptions to meet on a much deeper level. But I would lie if I said I overcame every preconception I have. There are women who don't inspire desire in me. This area of unknown is a temptation for me to fall into one of two judgements: Either I, myself, am a bigot for not experiencing this desire which I know could be there. Or this person is undesirable.
It should have become clear how ridiculous both statements are. Yet at the same time, I fall into these judgements every day, because it is easier to have the false security of knowing everything than to let the unknown be. At the same time, letting the unknown be, in this case, is the only option to not unnecessarily hurt myself or others with my preconceptions. So this is what I strive for, and I invite everyone to do the same. As I said, the unknown can be your greatest friend when search turns into exploration. But i know that it sometimes just isn't.
That said it is time to return to yesterday's post and specifically the comment section under it. The sentiment I found there numerous times, repeated over and over, condenses to the following: "I don't like penises on women, but I am sure there are other lesbians who don't mind." This strongly resonated with my experience of the false alternatives I mentioned above: First, people told OP that they themselves didn't experience desire for penises so far, then, they went on to tell that the highest they thought other lesbians would go would be accepting penises, which is very different from desiring them.
At this point I want to remind everyone that it is typically not people asking these questions who are already very secure in their belief in their capacity to be desired. Transphobia tells trans people that their bodies are undesirable because they might not 100% conform with the phantasies we soothe ourselves with. The same, I have been taught by others, goes for racism, perisexism and ableism. That doesn't mean that these bodies don't fall victim to fetishization. I am talking about the same, unbound desire I was talking about above. As I said, I think it is natural to not explore every possibility; but telling someone who is possibly asking for reassurance that they are not desirable is a whole other deal. And I think we should all strive to refrain from that in the future.
I firmly believe that all our diverse bodies are beautiful and desirable and hold infinite treasures for those willing to explore. And this is the sentiment I want to spread in this community.
I mentioned it above, but I once again want to thank all the intersex-ed people that shared their experiences under yesterdays post. For me, a perisex person, these things are invaluable to hear. I want everyone who is not perisex, not white, not able-bodied, not cis, not ..., to feel encouraged to share their experiences below, in support or in criticism.
***
Reddit sleuths skimming through my post history will surely find the post and comments I made yesterday in r/tgcj. As I said, I was personally affected by what happened in that comment section and needed to blow of steam. For those who can't deal with reading my and other trans people's bad impressions of their comments in a trans exclusive community, I strongly discourage you from reading this post. If you nevertheless did: What I shared in negativity there I wanted to share in positivity here. All of what I wrote above comes from the bottom of my heart; I do not hate anyone for expressing these sentiments and I am aware where I am guilty of this stuff myself.
EDIT: I can't take it any more. As far as I see it, the people piling on me to say there is no issue prove me right. And if you don't want to see the transphobia in the comments right under this post, well, that's your privilege I suppose. I am muting this now.
EDIT 2: To the people taking the first edit as an invitation to harass me in other subreddits, in my DMs and even on my tumblr: What the hell is wrong with you