r/activedirectory • u/javajo91 • 21h ago
Active Directory Cleanup of AD Sites and Services after DC Demotion
Hey guys. What is the proper way to safely clean up “AD Sites and Services” after a DC demotion?
We have two sites: Prod & DR
(3) DCs at each site.
I demoted an older DC at my DR site. I waited a bit and then manually deleted the old DC from Sites and Services at that site. Aftrrwards, my remaining DCs at my DR site set up proper replication with the Prod site.
So from the point of view from my DR site:
DC01-DR replicates with DC02-DR
and DC01–PROD.
DC02-DR replicates with DC01-DR and DC02-PROD
From the point of view from my Prod site:
If I try and delete the old DC-DR server object from AD Sites and Services, it warns me that I need to demote it first, (which I obviously have).
DC01-PROD still trys to replicate with the old DC controller at my DR site. None of my DCs at my PROD site are trying to replicate with my DR site.
Do I need to manually delete the NTDS objects for the old DC-DR controller from AD Sites and Services at my PROD site?
Looking for the proper way to do this cleanup. I had thought that after demoting the old DC, the site-to-site replication would work itself out on its own.
I ran dcdiag and repadmin tools prior and all came back clean.
Edit
The old DC in DR was responsible for intersite replication. All my DCs are Global Catalog servers and the FSMO roles reside on a DC at my Prod site. What should my gameplan be at this point? Should I just create a manual NTDS link between one of my DCs in Prod to one of my DCs in DR to get he KCC working? Right now my Prod site is only trying to replicate with the demoted DC. Thank you again!
Thanks guys.
Edit:
It sounds logical to manually add one of the new DCs at my DR site as an NTDS link at my Prod site. I’m thinking this should kickstart the replication again? This way I’m manually intervening and creating the link that can’t get created. Would this work, is this safe to do? Thank you again!
Edit: OK - just ran repadmin /showrepl from DC01-Prod and It can't connect to the DR site:
Last attempt @ 2026-11-20 07:13:15 failed, result 8524 (0x214c):
The DSA operation is unable to proceed because of a DNS lookup failure.
Edit:
So the old demoted DC was a bridgehead server. Do I need to manually create another one over at the DR site? Now there are none.