r/acotar • • May 28 '25

Rant - Spoiler Ugh I hate him Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

No one can tell me this is not manipulation. IF SHE IS IN HE'S COURT THEN SHE IS HE'S SUBJECT and it's not a fucking bad thing ffs. "Someone who sat on he's ass for 50 years" says the guy who was fucking the enemy and reporting all of tamlin's progress to her you lying bitch. "Then sat on he's ass when you were being shredded" he was healing SLOWLY YOU MOTHERFUCKER besides he was the one who shredded amarantha not you and you also sat on YOUR ASS AFTER SHE BEAT THE SHIT OUT IF YOU SI SHUT THE FUCK UP. UGHHHH HE'S PISSING ME OFF WITH THE LITTLE LIES AND MANIPULATION TACTICS. And all feyre says is stop it? Really? If it was my man who was being lied against I'm throwing hands and I don't give a fuck if I die in the process. Tamlin doesn't see her as a trophy, you do that's why you're trying to steal prythian savior for yourself Rhys. She's no one's trophy huh? Oh a little birdy told me you made her wear basically nothing so you could tell tamlin you have the love of he's life doing lapdances and a deal with you ABD BASICALLY BRANDED HER SO STOP FUCKING BITCHING AROUND. are we brushing this off? Really? Ugh I hate him.


r/acotar • • Mar 24 '26 Wholesome Seal WOW Bravo

Cosplay "Bow."

Post image
15 Upvotes

This throne gave me CoN vibes (and was perfectly shaped for Illyrian wings). Unfortunately I didn't have my High Lady to sit there while I perched on the arm of the chair. Next time though! Hopefully y'all enjoy this one as much as my last


r/acotar • • Dec 12 '23

Spoilers for MaF I can't look at my partner the same after ACOMAF Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I just finished ACOMAF and I'm having a hard time getting turned on by my partner. I feel horrible because he's so amazing and we have great sex, but how does any man even begin to compare to RHYS????

I guess I'm looking for support - I haven't seen anyone talk about this but I can’t help but feel like there's no way I'm alone in this sentiment.

After reading the cabin scene I just didn't want my partner touching me. I know it's such an unrealistic standard (like obviously my man can’t grow wings and wrap me in them while he f**gers me lol) but I can’t seem to shake the feeling off.

Anyone else?

UPDATE:

WOW some of you are MEAN 😭 thank you for the handful nice comments - they helped me not spiral.

  1. My bf is incredible in every way, and no we are not breaking up over a BOOK. This has been a short lived situation - so short in fact he is oblivious to me feeling this way at all. I will get over it as quickly as the feeling came about. I thought I made it pretty clear in my original post I knew how dumb my feelings were, but maybe I wasn’t explicit enough.

  2. I do not need therapy because I had a crush on a fictional character & was briefly down about the fact that my bf wasn't a "500 y/o fearie designed by a woman". Some of you are so quick to throw mental illness at opinions you don't agree with. I'm not dismissing therapy - it is a wonderful tool and think everyone should take care of their mental health if they can afford to. But crushing on a main character designed to elicit feelings of lust does not warrant me being thrown in a mental ward, are you guys okay???

  3. I will not be checking this post again - some of you are vicious as hell and I'm protecting my mental peace. Goodbye 💋


r/acotar • • Jun 18 '25

Rant - Spoiler I do not feel pity for Tamlin and I do not dislike Feyre or Rhysand and here’s why

0 Upvotes

I realize I misspoke on some things in my previous post and people were trying to hit me with receipts as if I have not read the entire series so here is my OPINION with a list.

  1. After under the mountain it’s like he was blind to her deterioration and hardly ever tended to those wounds she had especially when being newly turned Fae.

  2. He often let his anger go unchecked and uncontrolled which led him to continuously seek out Feyre despite her telling him to leave her alone. While I know that she was illiterate before she left, I don’t care. If she wanted to come back to him, especially as the type of character she is, she would have found a way to AND this is not the first time Tamlin completely disregards something she said. The only excuse anyone can give me is maybe he thought Rhys wrote it. I don’t care, it’s not like he did not disregard her several times before she left or anything lol. He had a chance to save his relationship with her and couldn’t see past protecting her long enough to realize he was actually aiding in destroying her.

  3. Yes yes yes. I know it was Ianthe that sold her sisters out. I don’t care about Tam’s attempt at attacking Hybern, I care about his actions after. Did he really think she would be okay and happy with him when her sisters are now creatures they despise, their humanity snatched away, and then neither of them being nowhere near her afterwards? I get that he was not the direct cause but once again, he pays no attention to her or had any common sense to think “hm, maybe that was fucked up.” I get that it was not directly him but I still can’t get over him even going to the King to attempt to sever Rhys and Feyre’s bond AND agreeing to assist in taking down the wall all for a woman is just insane to me. Also, constantly siding with Ianthe when it seems like alot of High Fae Males think she’s weird and gross is definitely a…choice. I know he didn’t know she was bringing Elain and Nesta but everything could have been avoided if he listened instead of saying “You don’t know what you’re talking about” but what do i know 🤷🏾‍♀️

  4. I ultimately think Tam was created as a sort of buffer character. I don’t hate him and I don’t love him and I think that’s how it’s supposed to be. I see alot of discourse about feeling bad for him and disliking Feyre and Rhys and I don’t think it’s fair to dislike Feyre without acknowledging what Tamlin did before and after. I hope he’ll have a chance at healing and happiness but I am not going to say I feel bad for him or that Feyre was terrible to him. She tried reason first and got nothing in return.

EDIT: Can’t believe I have to say this but feel absolutely free to comment your opinions. I really don’t have a problem with your opinions. I was being accused of deleting and reposting because I didn’t like people’s reactions to the original which is untrue, I don’t CARE about people’s reactions I just realized from the original post that I had misspoke on a few points which I thought was the freaking point in people commenting lol. I stated that in my very first sentence but clearly some of you don’t want to respect that i can own up to misspeaking.


r/acotar • • Apr 11 '25

Rule 7: Take this to the scheduled post Worst sister Nesta Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I feel like a lot of people don’t like Nesta. (including me) She makes my skin boil. I’m currently reading a court of frost and starlight and the way Nesta treats Feyre almost as if she nothing but an annoying piece of gum stuck under her shoe makes me wonder if Nesta ever CARES for Feyre. I seriously don’t want to read the last book in the series. No way am I getting myself through 800 ish pages of Nestas nagging and bickering. Idgaf if she’s powerful or any of that just why was she written like that. Such wasted potential.


r/acotar • • Apr 04 '25

Rule 7: Take this to the scheduled post No excuses for Tamlin he is an actual literal ABUSER Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I am so sick and tired of people saying they like Tamlin or Feyre was unfair to him. Tamlin ABUSED Feyre. He committed acts of domestic violence against her. There is NO excuse for this. EVER.

Feyre did not leave Tamlin, she ESCAPED him. She SURVIVED him. She is a survivor of domestic abuse.

Stop pretending like he's anything less than abuser and deserves any kind of grace. It's literally so gross.


r/acotar • • Dec 22 '23

Spoilers for MaF Rhysand is a Swiftie

0 Upvotes

If there’s anything I’ve never been more sure of it’s that Rhysand would love Taylor. You can’t tell me he didn’t blast Enchanted when he went back UTM after meeting Feyre and then You Belong With Me when he sent her back to the spring court that first time. What other swiftie songs would he love??


r/acotar • • 25d ago

Miscellaneous - No spoilers ACOTAR and Taylor Swift fans? (bare with me)

3 Upvotes

I know it’s been asked a few times on this sub 🥹 but all the posts I could find are years old (idk if the search engine just sucks and there are more recent posts), and I’m new (ish) to the sub. I hope it’s okay to be asking again. I’m sorry if it’s not.

So I wanted to see who currently is an ACOTAR fan and Taylor Swift fan? I’m a huge fan of both and with the book coming out in a week my feelings have intensified and I NEED someone on the same wavelength as me!

(;-;) ✌️

***if you wanna chat about both, it’s okay, don’t be shy 🤗


r/acotar • • Jun 02 '25

Rant - Spoiler free This fandom is toxic

118 Upvotes

Whenever I post on here about anything involving my opinion, I get downvoted and hated so bad that I’m actually wondering what the fuck is wrong with me and other people.

I said I disliked Tamlin because, let’s be real, he is a bitch. DOWNVOTE

What is up with Az and Eris? Are they romantic? Why do people ship them? DOWNVOTE

I think SJM is (I don’t want to use the word stupid, but I need to) stupid for naming Illyrians after actual people. My people. And she made them barbarians and brutes. DOWNVOTE

Anything I say in this sub gets hated on. What the fuck is wrong with this fandom? Why are you all so full of complexes and so hateful? What happened to having normal, healthy debates because of different opinions. Do you all want all the same opinions so you can talk about how awesome Rhys is, how wow Ferye’s powers are, how this and that and so on?

What is the actual fucking point of being a fandom if you will hate on everyone who has a slightly different opinion from you?

(No hate to normal, emotionally and intellectually intelligent people. I love you guys.)


r/acotar • • Jan 29 '23

Rant Nesta being friends with Gwyn and Emerie makes 0 sense. Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Something that has bothered me about ACOSF is the friendship between the three. Not only did it feel like Nesta just replaced her sisters with Gwyn (Elain) and Emerie (Feyre), but it felt unnatural for them to become friends SO QUICKLY.

Nesta is not an easy person, which is why her and Amren getting along made sense- they’re both alike in that they arnt easy going people and they don’t care to be. They are who they are and don’t pretend. It’s admirable.

So Nesta being all buddy buddy with Gwyn and Emerie- who are quite opposite; strong, yes, but nice and easy going, didn’t click in. It felt forced, and Nesta reinvented herself around them. It was like reading another character. And yes, maybe it was her progress, but she lost her key character traits, and if felt inauthentic to herself.

Merrill, however, made perfect sense for a friendship with Nesta. She is is like Nesta in many ways- strict, stubborn, unrelenting, unbearable and fierce. I would have preferred to see a friendship between them two rather than Gwyn or Emerie.

I feel as though Nesta would respect Merrill more, rather than dislike her- which makes no sense, surely Nesta has no ground hating Merrill, they’re the SAME SIDE of the SAME COIN!

But anyways, I just feel it was wasted potential. Merrill was so much more interesting in the few scenes she had. Going around, making people’s lives Hell, Nesta would have joined her.


r/acotar • • Mar 18 '26

Cosplay When You Spend So Long Trapped in Darkness

Post image
34 Upvotes

"...You find that the darkness begins to stare back."

I absolutely love how this Rhys shoot turned out! This set gave me Under the Mountain or "the cave" vibes and the pics turned out so perfect. Can't wait to secure some more sets for my bookish characters


r/acotar • • Jun 13 '24

ACOTAR Fan Fiction Anti-Nesta Fic recs

0 Upvotes

Firstly, being so dead ahh right now but I do not want any Nesta fans commenting for gods sake on how I shouldn’t hate Nesta and bla bla bla. Secondly, I’m looking for fics in which Nesta gets called out on her BS and faces the consequences of her actions. I need actual Nesta bashing and more focus on the IC please and thank you

Small edit: Nesta stans! I see you, I validate you but unless you have any actual recommendations please don’t comment or try to change our minds!!! Thank you! And for all the people saying “ACOSF exists” why do people ask for fic recs? Because they wanna read something new! Plus ACOSF was not one of my favourite books and if you liked it? Good for you!!

Another edit: Guys I just saw another post that was asking for Anti-IC fic recs (no hate) and instead of people ripping the poster to shreds they actually gave fic recs. Kindly if you have nothing to add other than bashing me than ignore this post. I legit saw no comments on that post that were like “Oh read one of the OG books” or “Oh this is why you SHOULD like the IC”. This is very annoying and it’s double standards frankly


r/acotar • • Sep 25 '24

Rule 7: Take this to the scheduled post Spoiler alert. Anyone else tired of Nestas shit? Spoiler

18 Upvotes

Is anyone else through with Nestas crap after 5 books? I’m onto the last book, not finished but nearly. And she’s FINALLY had her breakdown and is being nicer. I’m relieved because it was making me almost want to skip some chapters in annoyance. It just went on and on and on and onnnnn and it felt like wasted book that could have focused more on Feyra, Rhys etc and their equally as intense journey. I know books are sipped to make you feel, but reading Nestas constant hatred became tiring and almost stressful.

Thoughts?


r/acotar • • 12d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH ACOSH spoilers: Can we talk about the "We can find a bedroom" scene Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Edit: After reading the comments and crosschecking with my never read this book sister I was made aware that i completely misread this scene. I admit my wrong but they will drag this ship out of my cold dead hands. So am I the only one who didnt take this scene as Elain only trying to bone? He's opening up and she suggested they find a more private place for what was going to be a super serious conversation. Like I took it as "Oh we should probably have some privacy and not have this serious conversation while dry humping in the kitchen." Azriel with his three month blue balls was the one who went right back to making out.

I mean I could be wrong. We never got Elain's POV or anything but to me her behavior said comfort and understanding.


r/acotar • • Jul 02 '24

Rule 7: Take this to the scheduled post Calling what Feyre went through “a violation” is silly Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I was told so by a using in an argument about her experience UTM. Not the forced Kiss, we are all fully aware of the situation at that time. However I am talking about the drugging and using her body, not the kiss. The whole situation imo is such a low point of their relationship.

Now, I’m fine with Feysand, they have cute moments as they have icky moments. I don’t like Rhysand, but I like Feyre a ton (however I definitely criticize some of her actions). But this less so about their relationship, and more of how some view this sequence. Saying simply she “twerked” after being forcibly drugged and “that is that” is a gross over simplification. Now, in the book itself, they call out Rhysand’s behavior a violation to Feyre, saying she wasn’t violated “Beyond touching my sides”** (Meaning, yes Readers, she was indeed violated, it’s not “silly” to call it out for what it is). And as seen in others, Rhys, Nesta, Gwyn, SA is not something any of them would accept as “silly”

Now, going as far to defend it, saying “the guards or someone would’ve done worse” like, yes, not denying that. But remember, Rhys could have those guards into actual Vegetables, and no one would’ve questioned him or Amarantha is Rhys claimed her as Amarantha’s plaything. On top of that, bringing Feyre out probably brought even more unwanted attention to her, backfiring bc he wanted a lap dance. Also abusing her into submitting for his help?? We know he can “turn off pain” (for lack of a better term) mentally, he did so to the Claire lady.

“It’s enemies to lovers” “Dark romance, don’t read if you don’t like it” “it’s fictional, don’t read too deep into it” I don’t even know what to say to (I actually do, just wanted to sass). Specifically that last one, which couldn’t be further from the truth. Look at every tiny detail SJM puts, from the trauma the characters suffer, nameless background characters, literally anything that could be overlooked in a first read, it could have a callback in the future. It’s just ridiculous to call anyone who has issue with the lack of addressing to this “silly”. Anyway, Rant over, forever a Rhys downer but he treats Feyre nice sometimes*.


r/acotar • • May 26 '25

Rant - Spoiler Why is everyone so eager to villianise rhysand Spoiler

14 Upvotes

This just makes 0 sense to me . Do i believe he's perfect? Absoluelty not he fucks up so much in the text but I've seen people staright up lie to try say hes a bad perosn? Like I've seen people say the old treaty is only in the night court? When does it say tht? Or tht hes purposefully keeping humans below where the wall is so he can manipulate the highlords. As if humans would effect tht? Its said in the text the new treaty isnt signed by all fae lands so getting humans and fae mixxing is stupid when there isnt really rules in place. Ive seen ppl mention him having to kill high lords UTM like yeah did we miss the whole reason why he had to? They made it out like he did it so there all younger and wouldnt know the old treaty so rhys could manipulate them like no we are told in the text why he had to. Also i cant nearly assure you they were all taught from a young age since they are all hl kids and would presumably rule. Like yes he fucks up but i dont get staright up lying to make him look bad. "Oh he did all tht to be high king and he want war" he wuite litreally shut all tht down in sliver flames.(this is genuinely what they said he wanted to be high king)

Like how did you enjoy the series when you hate the mmc for the first 3-4 books. Like yes dislike and criticise him but dont lie to make him look bad yk.

Edit 1 im talking about ppl lying to make him look bad. Stop bringing up bad things he acc did. i never claimed he was perfect 2. My keyboard makes spelling mistakes impossible to correct tht why theres typos . Ppl asked if i can acc grasp the book/comments over it, and yes, i can . I've been on a high reading level my whole life and get 80/90% in honours english


r/acotar • • Jul 15 '25

Rant - Spoiler enlightenment

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

i want to preface this by saying: art is art and the way we interact with it will always be personal to ourselves. i am in no way trying to shit on acotar fans, as i was once an avid acotar fan and regularly recommended the book to others. but then, i watched this video and learned some things and i don’t think i will be spending anymore of my money on the series personally. i just wanted to share in case there are others like me who were simply uneducated regarding maas and the acotar universe.

acotar is the first book (and only book of the series) she goes over, so you dont have to skip anything in the video. however, if you just want to hear the main grievance that i am posting this for, skip to 13min into the video. some of the stuff she discusses has been discussed on the reddit before, but this is the first time i’ve ever heard this specific thing be talked about, so i wanted to share in hopes of educating and started a productive conversation.

all credit to youtuber elle literacy, this video is phenomenal tbh. it was my first of hers ive seen and i dont think i disagreed with anything she said.

once again reiterating that this post is not made in anyway to spread hate or harm, but simply to educate and start productive conversations. i’m down to engage with anyone who is speaking respectfully, and i hope we can keep it civil.


r/acotar • • Sep 05 '25

Miscellaneous - Spoilers Acomaf and acowar smut makes me so uncomfortable. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I don't read that much smut, mostly non smut books, but I don't have a problem with it. However, in the 2nd or 3rd books, it was almost unbearable, and rhys and feyre aren't my favorites either, which makes it worse. Like I skip the parts mostly. Is there someone who has felt this way, too?


r/acotar • • May 16 '24

New reader - Don’t spoil the op! Just finished FAS (with tears in my eyes, mind you) and opened to SF to find… Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Nesta’s POV???

Oh, you mean one of my most disliked characters in the book?

I’m being ripped away from the only two people who’ve brought me joy for the past month and being plopped with this brat?

This feels like going from season 1 to season 2 of Bridgerton….

I’m genuinely heartbroken. For a moment I thought “I don’t even want to read it!” - please convince me otherwise. 😪


r/acotar • • Jun 14 '24

Rule 7: Take this to the scheduled post I hateeee Nesta Spoiler

38 Upvotes

I just finished ACOTAR and ACOMAF and I’m on ACOWAR, and let me just say I reallllyyy hate Nesta. This lady is the epitome of selfish and mean. From book one of her making Feyra hunt, and then not even saying anything or try to protect her when Tamlin came. Book 2 I thought she would become a little more tolerable with her helping Feyra and Rhys with the war, but right again at the end of the book when they where turned and she tried her hardest to save Elain, but didn’t give any of that effort to Feyra. But then the way she was acting towards her in the beginning of book 3 when Feyra was taken AGAIN and she still acted like she was angry with her. I even got mad at Feyra for defending her to Rhys . When he’s done more for her in the short while he’s known her than any of her family. I was honestly hoping for Nesta to apologize for treating her sister that way, or even Feyra not wanting anything to do with them any more. (and idc that she went through “trauma” cause they all did, but she’s the only one that act like a raging b I t c h and emotionally neglect her youngest sibling) I honestly stopped reading because she made me so angry 😴 but please tell me there is some retribution for her?! Cause I can not deal


r/acotar • • Jan 13 '24

Spoilers for WaR Feyre can be cruel Spoiler

23 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I'm halfway through book 3 so pls no spoilers past that

Feyre does a lot of stuff in the third book that gave me pause and made me a little sick. In Harry Potter there are three unforgivable curses that'll get you sent to jail one of which is the imperius curse for mind control.

Feyre takes over ianthes mind and others without any thought to the violation it is. When she makes ianthe break her own hand through the mind control I felt sick. Her attacking ianthe is one thing but making ianthe hurt herself was cruel. In multiple scenes in the book you see Feyre almost revel in the idea of causing pain whether it was to ianthe, Tamlin, or Keir. Even in the second book it felt like she was turned on when Rhys attacked Keir.

I highly doubt SJM would make her evil, but in many series it isn't uncommon for the person who believes the ends justify the means and will torture or manipulate to achieve their goals (for the greater good) to end up becoming evil.

Tbh it would be kind of funny if she ended up like Daenerys and Rhys or Tamlin had to kill her.

Edit:

Reading the responses I want to clarify that Ianthe was horrible am I'm glad she ends up dying. But Torture is Never Ethical. In our justice system we either arrest people or we assign a death penalty - we don't torture them for our own amusement. There's a reason we have an eigth amendment against cruel and unusual punishment. Beyond the fact that Hybern crucifying those girls was wrong because they were innocent it was wrong because there is never justification for something like that. It may make sense to kill someone to prevent them from hurting others in the future, maybe you can make an argument around disuading similar actions from others, but the idea of prolonging suffering, of relishing in people's pain the way Feyre describes how she and Mor killed certain people more slowly in Adriata that's the first step towards becoming the enemy you're fighting against. That isn't justice it's revenge edging towards sadism.


r/acotar • • Oct 16 '24

New reader - Don’t spoil the op! Feyre Spoiler

3 Upvotes

With every fiber of my being I hate Feyre and everything that she is so much I wish I could go into the book and rip her apart because holy crap, think before you speak


r/acotar • • Dec 28 '23

Miscellaneous - Spoilers ACOTAR Couples as TSwift Songs?

0 Upvotes

Yes I know I AM THAT PERSON OK

Warning ⚠️ I guess if you are unaware who the main ships are in this series, this could be considered spoilery.

I was listening to “Ivy” and I was like 👀 I’m sorry, is this written about Elaine and Azriel? Not just the lyrics, but it even sounds like gentle El and mysterious Az. All the IMAGERY of seasons and growth is Elaine all day.

So tell me- What other couples have Taylor Swift songs written about them?


r/acotar • • Mar 16 '26

Rant - Spoiler Tamlin & Elain mate theory Spoiler

0 Upvotes

From Sjm's interview on chd, she said it's doubtful she will write a Tamlin's redemption arc so what about this text in Acomaf:

"Lucien had the good sense to look horrified as he glanced between Elain and the High Lord."

After this, Lucien tells everyone that Elain is his mate! Like I always thought he looked between Tamlin and Elain to kinda cover up the fact that Tamlin and Elain are mates. I thought the reason he went to Velaris with Feyre is to look over Elain, inform Tamlin about her well being, etc...

Also the fact that Tamlin asked Rhys "will she ever forgive me" and didn't take Feyre's name had made me question he was talking about Elain instead because she was betrayed even more since she was turned into a fae.

The second part may not make sense but why did Lucien looked between them 😭. Did Sjm decide Tamlin and Elain were going to be mates and changed her decision later on or smtg? Because I know she wanted Nesta and Lucien to be together at first.