r/acecombat • Aces of Ice-cream • Sep 17 '26

Meta What the hell Project Aces? Thoughts on Episode 2 of Hour Zero, as a Muslim fan of the series

Important update 26/09/2026: According to a review from gamerfridge, the final release isn't shackled by Hour Zero's dated depiction: "Wings of Theve also boasts the series’ strongest writing to date. I’m thrilled to say that prequel miniseries Hour Zero’s decidedly dated portrayal of the Republic of Sotoa (relying on some bygone “War on Terror” tropes) isn’t echoed in the game itself—while there’s some superficial connections one could draw between them and contemporary MENA countries, Sotoa is far more a technocratic khanate than a rogue terror state." (https://gamerfridge.com/2026/09/25/ace-combat-8-wings-of-theve-review/)

This is a source of great relief, and I am glad to have retained some hope in PA. Still, of course, however, we'll only know how the game actually is come release day.

OG post below:

----

Forgive me for if I ramble. I am very emotional right now, and in shock.

About two months ago, I wrote a post on how excited I was for Sotoa, specifically for this reason:

As someone coming from a non-Western, non-White, Muslim heritage (Pakistani), it is also nice to see more stories where the Muslim-coded faction (obv Sotoa is not Muslim, but in terms of how Muslims are perceived in the Western imagination: Arab, Iranian, South Asian, etc.) are not portrayed as insane terrorists who exist solely be defeated by the so-called ‘civilised’ Western ‘good guy’. I understand that Sotoa is the antagonist force in 8, but considering PA’s history of portraying enemy nations sympathetically and humanely, I am both confident that, and am excited to see fellow brown characters’ portrayed human beings rather than stock villains.

While this is only episode 2 of the series, and though the game is still upcoming, my expectations have seemingly been upended. This episode stands out as one of the most Orientalist, Islamophobic, and racist regressive pieces of media I have encountered recently.
The captured Sotoan pilot was nothing more than an Islamophobic caricature: seeking ‘war-brides’, aspiring to martyrdom so he can enter the Promised Land (Sotoa’s version of heaven), and brazenly attacking civilians.

If this were framed as a fringe faction, or if the game later (as in, when it finally launches) makes clear that he does not represent Sotoan civilisation as a whole, it might be more palatable. Instead, the very first sustained depiction of soldiers from the series’ first major non-Western, non-white nation has them acting like modern extremist groups — groups that, it must be said, do not represent Muslims or the peoples of the regions they claim to speak for (Muslims were by far the largest victims of Daesh). In doing so it leans hard into tired Orientalist tropes of the hypersexualised1, hyperviolent Arab/Brown man/Muslim is frustrating. It felt like an episode of Homeland! Edward Said described the trope best:

In the films and television the Arab is associated either with lechery or bloodthirsty dishonesty... an oversexed degenerate, capable, it is true, of cleverly devious intrigues, but essentially sadistic, treacherous, low. Slave trader, camel driver, moneychanger, colorful scoundrel: these are some traditional Arab roles in the cinema. The Arab leader (of marauders, pirates, "native" insurgents) can often be seen snarling at the captured Western hero and the blond girl (both of them steeped in whole someness), "My men are going to kill you, but-they like to amuse themselves before."... In newsreels or news photos, the Arab is always shown in large numbers. No individuality, no personal characteristics or experiences. Most of the pictures represent mass rage and misery, or irrational (hence hopelessly eccentric) gestures. Lurking behind all of these images is the menace of jihad. Consequence: a fear that the Muslims (or Arabs) will take over the world.2

The resulting rhetoric is evident in the comment below. (Names cut off. I am upset, but I also don't want to break any rules)

I know this is just one comment, and I know some may respond by saying its just online chatter, but any Muslim and/or person of colour here surely understands the danger this rhetoric can trigger.

What makes this more frustrating, beyond seeing the dehumanisation those adjacent to my skin colour and faith (via characteristics, obviously Islam itself doesn't exist in Strangereal) have endured for decades regurgitated, is that Project Aces already has a history of humanising enemy forces in the past. Ace Combat 7’s DLCs, for example; Yuktobanians having the capacity for victimhood in the technical school attack in Ace Combat 5, and your later allegiance to them at the end; the Belkans who resist their own nation’s nuclear terror and surrender part-way through Zero, and their later victimisation on Tyler Island in Ace Combat 7; that Estovakian commander who defects in Ace Combat 6, or even Strigon Squadron, who are able to retain their humanisation without having to defect to your side… But nothing for the first Sotoan we see? Not even a combatant, but rather an injured soldier?

And, as I wrote above, this may yet be clarified in the main game. Perhaps most Sotoans rebuke the beliefs of this specific soldier, and whatever faction or sect he may follow. Still, the fact that this is our first extended look at a Sotoan is concerning. If the soldier’s behaviour is presented as simply following his culture, I fear that any future humanisation of Sotoans will be conditional on how closely individual characters or factions approximate “Westernness."

I hope this post doesn’t break any rules. I’m not trying to spark controversy or drama. I simply can’t be the only one who noticed this. More than anything, I want this to be heard, and I want to assure other POC members of the community that what they saw isn’t just them overreacting.

  1. A good pre-9/11 example is Republican propaganda during the Spanish Civil War. Despite their liberal and (sometimes) leftist tint, they utilised Islamophobic and racist anti-Moorish propaganda to encourage anti-Francoism, based on the fact that Franco filled his ranks with African colonial troops from Morocco (known as the Regulares and the Army of Africa), deploying orientalist tropes that painted these soldiers as hypersexualised, homosexualised (implying de-masculinisation) and uncivilised invaders. Elisabeth Bolorinos Allard, ‘The Crescent and the Dagger: Representations of the Moorish Other during the Spanish Civil War’ Bulletin of Spanish Studies 93:6 (Edinburgh, 2016)

  2. Edward Said, Orientalism (New York, 1978) pp. 286-287.

Edit: fixed tense

30 Upvotes

192 comments sorted by

•

u/DriftingNitro Mobius Sep 17 '26

u/vritngh There is a lot on this that needs to be digested, and the mod teams wishes to do so respectfully. We are also consulting one of our mods who is Muslim on how to go about this. I want it stated on the record that any islamaphobic comments will be met with a ban, as would any bigotry.

I also want to mention the story of AC8 may end up not turning out as it looks (I'm hoping), given we haven't seen the story in full. (Maybe its just belka again, idk. Or the corps).

To prevent any conversations from devolving we're keeping the thread visible but locked.

Please be patient with us. Thank you.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/FlyAwayNoVV Project Wingman Producer Sep 18 '26

This is one of the most articulate responses I've seen to this and I'm really glad you posted it, thank you,

1

u/vritngh Aces of Ice-cream Sep 18 '26

Thank you for this comment Matthew. You're a rare example of media literacy in discussions surrounding the series (also I can't wait to destroy capitalism in Project Red Sun)

2

u/9oooooooooooj Sep 19 '26

I hope we get the wingman art book before that though....

1

u/Dumbassofouredbay The guy who made the F15 edit Sep 29 '26

10

u/itsMikel27 Strigon Sep 17 '26

The series already portrays the alternate version of France, Germany, Russia and most of Eastern Europe as repeatedly committing war crimes (specially Erusea who seems to have it as a national sport considering how many times Free Erusea try some bullshit). It also explains that a lot of the world is fed up with Osea because of how interventionist they are and the literal cause of the Belkan War is a 1:1 copy of Nazi Germany. All of these have bad stereotypes and NO ONE cares.

But now we have one (1) bad stereotype of another culture and suddenly it's racist?

7

u/vritngh Aces of Ice-cream Sep 18 '26

Except German people are rarely victims of hate crimes based on comparisons to Nazi Germany, and French people aren't at danger thanks to depictions of Erusea. Russians is the strongest example you bring, with Russians around the world having been targetted due to their national origins, following Putin's invasion of Ukraine. Narrative wise, however, Yuktobania still previous received the privilege of siding with the good guys in Ace Combat 5. As for Oseans and Americans: they still get the privilege of being narrative protagonists, despite Project Aces referencing real parallels to American expansionism from time to time.

However, Muslims experience real-world harm as a result of Islamophobia in the media. Muslims are already a marginalised minority.

Evidence submitted to the British Parliament by Ria Ivandic, Professor Tom Kirchmaier, and Professor Stephen Machin of the London School of Economics and Political Science found in 2019 a “clear correlation between media coverage and increases in Islamophobic hate crime” (Ria Ivandic, et al. 'Evidence on Islamophobia' Home Affairs Committee on Islamophobia (London, 2019) p. 2). Though the focus is on news coverage, there is a serious intersection between public-facing entertainment and informational media in constructing popular imaginations of certain groups.

The point isn’t that Ace Combat 8 itself will be harmful or racist, or that the rest of the miniseries can’t expand and add more depth to Sotoans. In fact, I have faith Project Aces will humanise Sotoans, since I know their history of humanising both sides. My concern is that this is the first, and most sustained depiction of a Sotoan soldier, and it is a caricature, and that is worthy of critique.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/vritngh Aces of Ice-cream Sep 21 '26

2

u/DriftingNitro Mobius Sep 21 '26

Probably both

51

u/LumpyWatercress8807 Mobius Sep 17 '26

I mean, there is a chance that the Sotoan government will be THE problem. I was hoping that we would see a Syrian-style civil war breaking out later on, followed by a massive wave of disinterest in resolving it, giving players a front-view seat on how fun it is to live and fight in a destabilised region, and they were part of it.
I trust Project Aces; they have never given me reason to believe the enemy would be portrayed as wolfenstein nazis.

14

u/MS_09_Dom Sep 17 '26

I can see a situation similar to Leasath where the Sotoans are getting whipped into a frenzy by their leaders of how the survival of their nation is at stake what with the desertification crisis.

We know based on the trailers that we'll see the Sotoan perspective of the conflict with Shadow 22 and his commander visiting that one Sotoan girl's home. I imagine that will go a long way in humanizing them.

68

u/FuttleScish Spare Sep 17 '26

I think people need to realize the “war bride” thing is just said by an FCU soldier and not actually verified by anything

31

u/Hresvelgr401_ Sep 17 '26

Also a very good point, though the dude didn't deny it

22

u/FuttleScish Spare Sep 17 '26

I mean he wasn’t saying much of anything, that’s kind of the plot

34

u/MS_09_Dom Sep 17 '26

And the whole theme of the game is propaganda and misinformation.

8

u/KingStatus2627 Sep 18 '26

The FCU doctor guy even mentions the importance of listening to reason instead of fear and exhaustion.

5

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 18 '26

It amazing the lengths people go to excuse blatant racism.

8

u/Shrek-It_Ralph Three Strikes Sep 21 '26

We get it, you want everyone to hate the game that’s not even out yet

-1

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 21 '26

Literally anything except admitting racism exists.

8

u/Shrek-It_Ralph Three Strikes Sep 21 '26

I’d be more surprised if racism didn’t exist in the middle of an all out war

-1

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 21 '26

Okay, why does project aces feel the need to stereotype brown people like this?

I have faith that they will make the "both sides are awful" argument, but that doesnt mean they had to portray them as barbarians like they did.

Its perfectly acceptable for people of color to protest this portrayal, and they should be listened to when they do.

8

u/Shrek-It_Ralph Three Strikes Sep 21 '26

My guy Ace Combat 7 had Eruseans executing their own civilians just for the hell of it

-2

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 21 '26

Okay? Are eursians portrayed as an exploited minority group in the western world where the game is primarily sold?

7

u/Shrek-It_Ralph Three Strikes Sep 21 '26

The Sotoans aren’t either, they’re a powerhouse where half of the FCU is willingly joining them lmao

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 24 '26

Okay, cool, there other brown people that do have an issue with, their voices are important as well as yours.

Just because you are from one of those countries doesnt mean you speak for everyone.

4

u/superearthjanitor0 Sep 18 '26

And remember the game has a huge focus on propaganda

4

u/ice_spice2020 Sep 17 '26

Except the point of this scene was to showcase a typical Sotoan mindset. If there's an indication that it was only an individual soldier the show would've indicated it. So there's no proof to him only representing himself.

15

u/FuttleScish Spare Sep 17 '26

No? This guy was specfically a war criminal

42

u/Muffin-Typical John Ace Combat™ Sep 17 '26

I’m Muslim too, but it’s probably and (I’m hoping) it’s either he’s a radical Sotoan or it’s hurling prejudiced insults between both Sotoan and Useans. After all a big element of this game is propaganda and misinformation.

7

u/UltraBooster Mobius Sep 17 '26

going off how ACE antagonists are usually written, he'll probably be one of the hawks versus more evenkeeled types.

that said, my feeling is that the writer(s) tried to avoid making it straight not-radical-Islam with things like the use of "promised land" since AFAIK it's heavily associated with Judaism or by giving him a Russian surname, but failed/didn't think to do more, if that makes sense?

1

u/Noha307 Sep 30 '26

AFAIK it's heavily associated with Judaism

You know, that's a really good point. I could definitely see this being an explanation.

31

u/Hresvelgr401_ Sep 17 '26

I agree with your point but to be fair a lot of Ace Combat games tend to have the enemy faction start off as appearing pretty evil to get you motivated to fight them before introducing nuance as we see more of the country. Our introduction to Yuktobania was them attacking a squad of trainees without any declaration of war, then multiple raids, still without any declaration of war. Similarly, Estovakia launched an entire invasion without any declaration of war, bombed a city indiscriminately and then fired Nimbus missiles into the air over the city, which probably caused more damage on the ground.

Hopefully this dude is a nutjob and other Sotoans like Shadow 22 and the like, are decent, reasonable people

31

u/KingStatus2627 Sep 17 '26

"Sorokin" (the captured Sotoan POW) is also a Russian surname, not a Middle Eastern or Central Asian one. Despite popular stereotypes, Middle Easterners are not the only IRL group of people that have expansionist goals and use that rhetoric--there is plenty of documentation of Russia describing how they wanted to "incorporate desirable populations" based in eastern Ukraine that dates back to 2014 while Mariupol and the occupied oblasts are being rebuilt to be next for Russian colonization after Crimea.

The core aesthetic of Sotoa-Usea War if anything seems to be a combination of Russia's invasion of Ukraine and nomadic civilizations vs sedentary ones. Bride stealing is a stereotypical trope of nomads in general, not for a specific ethnic group.

15

u/Hresvelgr401_ Sep 17 '26

Yeah, that too. While everything listed is considered a sterotype of Muslims, and Sotoa is defintely based on Muslim nations, none of them are remotely unique to Muslims. Russia also does a decent bit of all those things and AC8 defintely takes a lot of inspiration from the Russia-Ukraine war (Wings of Theve = Ghost of Kyiv), which isn't suprising given that it was happening as the game was being made

13

u/MS_09_Dom Sep 17 '26

A lot of Strangereal nations tend to be amalgamations of real life countries. Osea while largely America-coded has some Japanese influence, the OADF uses the JSDF rank structure and of course, Nagase. Erusea has elements of France, Spain and Vietnam. Emmeria is a fusion of Canada and Italy, and so on.

Considering Sotoa is in the same continent as Yuktobania, it makes sense there might be some Slavic influence there.

5

u/WhovianMuslim Sep 17 '26

Yeah, Russia did hideous things to the Muslims in the Caucasus region.

2

u/HongMeiIing Sep 17 '26

Isn't it Sorkin?

3

u/KingStatus2627 Sep 17 '26

The official captions say Azat Sorokin for Episode 2, and either way both "Sorkin" and "Sorokin" are Russian-derived surnames and not Arabic, Persian, nor Central Asian Turkic in origin.

1

u/WhovianMuslim Sep 18 '26

Azat seems to be a Turkic name, though it appears as an Armenian title as well.

3

u/KingStatus2627 Sep 18 '26

In the end, Sotoa--much like the FCU--is a mishmash of a variety of cultures, which was confirmed by the Nugget lore videos, and not a direct equivalent to a specific IRL country or culture. To drive the point further, the guy's first name (Azat) has both Turkic and Indo-European influence in its etymology.

If Verusa's Mediterranean Sea had the same importance that RL one did, it's likely Sotoa has seen significant cultural exchanges and influences from different groups moving in. Slavic and Armenian influence is likely, as Yuktobania is on the same continent and has interacted with Sotoa before, and theTonitrus satellite appears to descend from a Yuktobanian competitor to the SOLG.

34

u/SoundJakes Galm Sep 17 '26

OP has plenty of cause for concern, especially with how some people on this very sub reacted to episode.

21

u/KM4CK Garuda Sep 17 '26

I'm not Muslim but I also did cringe a bit at the Sotoan general. That being said there still is plenty of time for nuance to be applied to this series.

I dont think the game itself will be so reductive to be all stereotypes the entire time. I believe project aces are better than that and will deliever in terms of humanising the people of Sotoa.

Trailers have hinted there is a bit more to them what we have seen in this second episode.

I think this is a good post and a good discussion starter.

3

u/Kind-Ad-593 Sep 23 '26

Hard agree with how insensitive Hour Zero has been so far. Glad there’s a fellow ace with this opinion. A few others and I are holding out hope that it’ll be a rug pull to reveal Hour Zero secretly being an in-universe FCU propaganda flick though it might just be a huge cope. After all Kono has mentioned Sotoa being his favorite country and I assume he wouldn’t show favoritism to a purely evil nation. Plus there have been some hints showing how the FCU isn’t immune to making false propaganda with the whole Wings of Theve thing being a lie and Ace Combat as a whole does usually have moments of nuance so I’m hoping the conflict isn’t as black and white as the game has so far been showing.

1

u/razorracer83 Sorcerer Sep 23 '26

After all Kono has mentioned Sotoa being his favorite country and I assume he wouldn’t show favoritism to a purely evil nation.

(Ace Combat Zero taking place in Ustio)

(Ustio sharing the west border with Ratio.)

Ratio on the other hand......

1

u/vritngh Aces of Ice-cream Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

Ratio, and the rest of Eastern Osea, like West Verusa, holds untapped potential. While real-world analogies are good for certain narrative themes, such as imperialism, power-projection etc. I hope future titles (possibly taking a prequel approach, since we are getting closer to electrosphere), create more fantastical cultures and societies for some nations. It would give Strangereal a massive boost in character.

That's one reason I'm hyped for Delivery Must Complete: a mix of fighter jets and fantastical settings (not to say Strangereal needs to have magic, or floating islands, but fantasy-inspired cultures would make the world feel a lot more diverse, and rich)

47

u/Agent_Giraffe Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 17 '26

You’re coming to a conclusion before the mini series is finished and before the game is even out.

36

u/P_Fluke_W Avid CFA-44 pilot Sep 17 '26

We literally have an Antagonist Nation (who suspiciously Germany coded) nuke it’s own land and Civilians into oblivion before

This is nothing new lol

And look at the stuff that happening right now in Middle East…….Yeah…..

7

u/MS_09_Dom Sep 17 '26

Sorokin definitely isn't an Arabic/Turkish/Iranian surname.

3

u/P_Fluke_W Avid CFA-44 pilot Sep 17 '26

I think in the video they said it’s a Russian/Slavic name

5

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 18 '26

Yes but Germans are not marginalized IRL.

That difference matters.

39

u/Ok_Buy_6226 Schnitzel with no sauce please Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26

Not Muslim here but I felt a bit sketch about how the Sotoan soldier was portrayed in the episode. I'd like to think he's just a radical/that Hour Zero might turn out to be FCU propaganda, but reading your perspective on the matter gave some perspective I'd not have had otherwise. PA should be more careful about these pitfalls moving forward.

3

u/farlong12234 Sep 17 '26

hmm, that would be interesting, since the first episode talked about the wings, and we know the wings is fake.

how will they reveal that though.. have the final one be the propagandist character and show the other locations are sets in universe?

25

u/pinrolled Mobius 1 Sep 17 '26

Definitely feel for you, but as someone not of the Muslim faith, I didn't get that vibe and moreso just picked it up as typical "spoils of war" type of thing. Hopefully the next episode doesn't lean harder into those tropes, it was definitely out of the norm for the episode to get "dark" and head in that direction. Regardless, hope you're not taking it too hard, stuff like that is heavy on the mental.

10

u/WhovianMuslim Sep 17 '26

I'm Muslim myself, and had a worry that something like this might happen.

Hopefully it is a one-off.

11

u/BigCartoonist9010 Sep 17 '26

Of course you're not going to see the "crazy jihadist arab" stereotype right in your face if you're not Muslim. That doesn't mean it's not there. In fact, it's more likely to affect how you view people if you aren't actually conscious of it. That's how propaganda works.

8

u/pinrolled Mobius 1 Sep 17 '26

But I don't view Muslim people that way. So, the "propaganda" isn't effective to people with matter between their ears. I definitely get what you're saying though.

8

u/tacobelltitanpu Sep 17 '26

we're getting off topic but the easiest person to trick with propaganda is someone who thinks they're above propaganda

6

u/ForerunnerKnight Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

I agree with you completely

Just like the most ignorant person is the one who claims to be the most knowledgeable and most certain and believe they have the entire world figured out.

0

u/pinrolled Mobius 1 Sep 17 '26

What makes you think I said I’m above propaganda? I’m saying the form of “propaganda” isn’t effective based on the world view I currently have. Everybody is subject to being influenced by some sort of propaganda, it’s human nature.

1

u/UltraBooster Mobius Sep 17 '26

the next episode will be about that news anchor being censored when she attempts to report on the initial attacks/invasion, so i think any darkness we see will be in the vein of government mismanagement/hiding the truth.

21

u/Fathoms_Deep_1 F-15 S/MTD Enthusiast Sep 17 '26

Yeah I feel your points. The whole “war bride” thing felt like it could be the show writers making the FCU soldiers just plain biggots (which wouldn’t be surprising, given it’s the military) and he probably was caught in a raid, but the whole “promised land” thing just feels a little too on the nose. We don’t know anything about Sotoa yet, so I’m really hoping this is just a radical subfaction, which is par for the course in Ace Combat

18

u/LuckyPlatypus5052 Sep 17 '26

For better and worse, Sotoa is based on middle east nations. And they suffer from severe desertification, so "promised land" does track as a propaganda narrative pushed by their government to fuel war efforts.

11

u/wort-arbiter It wasn't on my bingo card Sep 17 '26

OP has made a good observation tho, the "Promised Land" that the Sotoan Commander mention in the episode dosen't sound like a physical place.

Sound like he is talking about being rewarded to go to heaven for what he was "choosen" to do, he even look up when he says it the first time.

There's also the doctor reaction, he dosen't want to treat him at the beginning and when the Sotoan Commander mention to gladly take is place in the promised land the Doctor tell the FCU Commander "Let him have what he wants" implying let him die like he wants so he can reach whatever they think afterlife is.

6

u/KingStatus2627 Sep 17 '26

On the operating table, the Sotoan POW says "even if I die here, I'll live in the promised land."

The Promised Land could have multiple meanings: a literal, physical one in the form of conquered Usean territory prepared for Sotoan resettlement, a metaphysical one in the form of some Electrosphere or Sublimation related stuff, and lastly a fully figurative/religious one in the form of an afterlife. Thus, a Sotoan fighting in Usea gets to live in a "promised land" regardless of whether the campaign succeeds and they live, or if they die in combat.

Alternatively, there are specific conditions that need to be met during death for a Sotoan to ascend to the Promised Land according to Sotoan faith and customs, and the POW was stating that his death would satisfy said criteria.

67

u/AWACS_Bandog <<Best Waifu is Solitary>> Sep 17 '26

I wonder how the Germans feel about Belka, or Eastern Europeans about Estovakia, or Russians about Yuktobania....

65

u/Laflamme_79 Sep 17 '26 • Bravo

No, don't you get it? When it was depicting bad stereotypes of other cultures it was fine, but now that it's depicting bad stereotypes of their culture it's racist.

4

u/Threedawg Ghosts of Razgriz Sep 21 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

Or power and influence matter.

Racism and stereotypes can hit significantly harder to groups that are fighting oppression as opposed to those with privilege.

2

u/Zestyclose-Lab4897 Sep 28 '26

Oppression? There's like 2 billion muslims in the world, concentrated mainly in their own nation states.

I feel the issue is that this isn't a stereotype, it is an archetype... and people can't handle that reflection of the real world.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Zestyclose-Lab4897 Sep 28 '26

What exactly have I said that is racist?

I'm an atheist. Tell me what does the quran say has to happen to me as an apostate?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Zestyclose-Lab4897 Sep 28 '26

I notice you didn't answer the second question.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Zestyclose-Lab4897 Oct 01 '26

Right... bad faith questions... sure.

How is it racist dogma? A lot of attacks are made on the grounds of religion.

Look man if this was the 1930's I'd be criticising Catholicism for its open alliance with fascism and and antisemitism. Right now however it isn't.

Right now only one religion offers a paradise reward for martyrs.

→ More replies (0)

14

u/Larry_Pixy_Foulke Local Buddy Sep 17 '26

bandog always have a card up his sleeve

3

u/LumpyWatercress8807 Mobius Sep 17 '26

I think we/they were fairly represented. It took me more than half of 0 to realise Belka was inspired by the Third Reich. They did not believe that they were the People of god, and it was their birthright to rule over everyone. Instead, I felt like they were more like Serbia, trying to keep their realm united during the crisis, even if it meant by force, but they lost their way. I really liked Estovakia. Whilst Eastern Europe is not a culture, even less a nation, I could highly relate to Estovakia: poverty, civil wars, coups, choosing the slightly less horrible side, embargos, horrible war tactics, outside spectators just looking. All that culminating in the government looking for solutions in the worst places.
I hope that Project Aces will pull this one masterfully like every other "enemy".

2

u/Chri_cat90 Sep 17 '26

Belkan and Yuktobanian weren't so cartoonishly evil though, the latter especially are painted as victims as much as the Oseans once the grey men plot is revealed.

22

u/AWACS_Bandog <<Best Waifu is Solitary>> Sep 17 '26

theres literally a mission where they gas civilians...

12

u/Splatneck Sep 17 '26

And another where they launch a surprise attack with the intent to bomb a stadium full of anti-war civilians.

6

u/Chri_cat90 Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26

Is implied that they gassed bana city in retaliation for the attack on the Yuktobanian university that the 8492th does during "Blind Spot", so they didn't do it for the lolz.

14

u/MS_09_Dom Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26

It's still a war crime to use chemical weapons in civilian areas. And the Belkan War started after a fascist political party took power and launched a war of aggression against a sovereign nation in the name of territorial revanchism.

I think it's best we wait and see how the Sotoans are depicted and portrayed when the game comes out before concluding that they are mustache-twirling cartoon supervillains based on one scene. If all you had to judge Yellow 13 on was him orphaning the narrator in the intro to 4, you'd think every Erusean was a brutish fascist that deserved no mercy.

1

u/Muctepukc Sukhoi Enjoyer Sep 17 '26

Don't see any problems, aside from giggling at yet another misspelled name. And even that was fixed pretty fast in AC8.

-17

u/BigCartoonist9010 Sep 17 '26

I don't remember the last time Germans or Russians got invaded and lost a million people in the last 50 years. The middle east however...

28

u/FuttleScish Spare Sep 17 '26

That 50 years is doing a lot of work

28

u/aelemayo Sep 17 '26

I feel you and agree with pretty much all your points, although we should keep in mind this episode was not written by PA but by the creators of SWAT, a literal US propaganda show.

Still sucks that PA hired them but we should ultimately wait until the full game comes out to properly understand Sotoa and its motivations.

12

u/-GhostFOx- Galm 4 Sep 17 '26

Wait really? they outsource the writing to those guys? No wonder why

8

u/Chri_cat90 Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26

Yeah i hope that the actual game paints sotoans as more naunced like prior antagonists and this is just the fallout of hiring americans to write the miniseries.

4

u/ED_Cantu Heroes of Razgriz Sep 17 '26

I didn't know that, this could explain why this episode felt so different from the usual AC stories. Was episode one written by the same people too? Because that one still felt more like an AC storyline, even the dialogue.

Still Kono said that PA supervised even the details so it's still weird, I just hope the game presents a much more nuanced take on Sotoa.

1

u/Noha307 Oct 05 '26

this episode was not written by PA but by the creators of SWAT

So, without spoiling anything, having played a good portion of the game, I'm more and more convinced that this is the answer. I'm not seeing any of the portrayal of what was in episode 2 in the story. (Although there are aspects of Middle Eastern culture portrayed.) I think it was the bias of the SWAT showrunners that was responsible.

8

u/farlong12234 Sep 17 '26

im white and I think its to much and im also going to ramble.

like on one hand, it is war, and the player needs to be motivated, but like, it feels like this is to much to start with. a medic conflicted about saving an enemy solider is a nice little plot story. but I think they should have gone with either he got caught trying to get war brides, or rambled about the promise land, both is just to much.
especially since he killed him self.

the one thing that I think might alleviate fear of needing to be western for humanity is that the wheelchair lady seems to be the enemy leader based of vibes and she seems pretty western.

I saw some people thinking the "promised land" might not be religious and might be the electosphere.

but I dont know, feels like the only nuance were going to get was the FCU guys wanting torture him right away and perhaps that's why he killed him self, to make sure he didn't break.

2

u/DriftingNitro Mobius Sep 17 '26

The afterlife being the electrosphere would be a wild twist.

23

u/Karasaw Sep 17 '26

I feel for you. AC lore has never been particularly subtle or nuanced, but even by their standards the character was very crudely coded. Felt like an early 2000s terrorist characture. Fingers crossed they do better moving forward.

42

u/FourFunnelFanatic Shilage Volunteer Corps Sep 17 '26

If you think that them depicting behaviors that are extremely well documented and common in the certain militaries that Sotoa is based on and think they are talking about you and the people you associate with, then that says more about you than Project Aces. You sound like a German being offended by Inglorious Bastards portrayal of Nazis.

12

u/fasterthanraito Sep 17 '26

Th key difference is that German populations are not currently being subjected to mass violence and discrimination on account of media associations with nazis while Muslims are with jihadists

5

u/CommunistsAreCancer Sep 26 '26

The biggest sources of subjugations that Muslims experience are Islamist governments.

-14

u/BigCartoonist9010 Sep 17 '26

It's odd that Osea isn't depicted as indiscriminately carpet bombing small nations then.

26

u/FuttleScish Spare Sep 17 '26

They‘re depicted as doing that exact thing multiple times

25

u/courcyplayer Sep 17 '26

Bro did you play ace 0?

39

u/FourFunnelFanatic Shilage Volunteer Corps Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26

They… have. Avril literally says in AC7 that they pissed a lot of countries off with their constant interventions, in addition to them parodying a lot of other American and Japanese issues in their depiction of Osea. Not to mention Hoffnung

8

u/bmraysss Sep 17 '26

You're definitely not the only one feeling these things. As a Muslim myself, I really do hope that my favorite series doesn't continue playing into these kinds of stereotypes, every other enemy faction/country we've fought was given some nuance, but having a brown person spouting off about a "Promised land" while claims of him taking "war brides" really doesn't sit well with me. Still holding out hope, but I can't support the game if they're going to perpetuate harmful stereotypes with no nuance like that.

0

u/amaranthe13 Sep 24 '26

the "war brides" things definitely play into tropes of poc coming into communities and "stealing women"

5

u/9oooooooooooj Sep 17 '26

I thought the promised land was a physical location somewhere in usea and not their heaven or smth?

5

u/MS_09_Dom Sep 17 '26

The speculation is that the purpose of Sotoa's invasion is to annex Usean territory and resettle those displaced by desertification.

5

u/Shrek-It_Ralph Three Strikes Sep 20 '26

I never heard of a single German complaining about Belka, get outta here with that lmao

0

u/WonderfulReception49 Sep 26 '26

You ever heard of punching up versus punching down?

17

u/ice_spice2020 Sep 17 '26

Yeah it can't be a coincidence that throughout the entire episode, the one and only bad guy was coincidentally a colored bearded man which has the resemblance of the middle eastern/south Asian characteristics.

Y'all can go ahead and downvote me for 'thinking too deep', but we have seen the same subconscious propaganda with COD (especially 2019). And Japan is no stranger to xenophobia so it shouldn't be surprising to see this coming. The point is to realize this is a subconscious casting choice by the producers to push a propaganda (however little it may seem it always starts as little).

19

u/Hresvelgr401_ Sep 17 '26

Estovakia, which is based on Eastern European countries, was introduced as indiscriminatly bombing a city but by the end of AC6 they were shown to be far more complex and nuanced, with plenty of good people fighting for them. Ace Combat regularly does this kind of thing with anatagonist countries

3

u/ice_spice2020 Sep 17 '26

I don't doubt they'll add nuance to the antagonist nation. However it's the little things like this that goes a long way and it should be addressed regardless of how insignificant it may seem. Bad enough we are still in a time where Islamaphobia is still rampant, and this episode helped push that narrative in some way or form.

Had there literally be another bearded colored FCU member I wouldn't have any issue with it, but because the one and only Sotoan was consciously casted as that race warrants at least a discussion.

And no amount of nuance can undo the damage that has already been done to the minority, that's where I have most issue with.

7

u/Hresvelgr401_ Sep 17 '26

Had there literally be another bearded colored FCU member I wouldn't have any issue with it

Wasn't the FCU Captain who brought the Sotoan also a bearded man of colour? He looked like he could have also been Middle Eastern tbh

4

u/BigCartoonist9010 Sep 17 '26

Exactly. I'm tired of the superficial, uneducated (white) redditors who always aggressively try to silence important political discussions on here because they want to protect their comfort in their escapist fantasy instead of critically engaging with what they're consuming and what's going on in the community. They'll probably remove this post too. It's just disappointing over all.

6

u/ED_Cantu Heroes of Razgriz Sep 17 '26

So I wasn't the only one, I must say even as a Latin American guy that has never interacted with people from the middle east that much I was taken aback a bit by this episode.

When they announced that Hour Zero would tell the story of a pilot a doctor and a news reporter I expected the stories to be full of cliches mixed with the usual Ace Combat cheese we like, so for the doctor story I expected that the FCU soldiers would capture a Sotoan soldier and mistreat him but the doctor would treat him and show that even the enemies are not just evil monsters invading like it has usually been in past entries, but no, instead they talk about War Brides and fighting and dying for the "promised land" painting the Sotoans as fanatical maniacs and the doctor didn't even want to treat the prisoner (I guess Hippocrates never existed in Strangereal huh?), it was a lot.

So yeah i didn't like this one a lot and was a bit disappointed, hopefully the other 2 episode are better and we get a much more measured take on Sotoa and its people in the game proper.

7

u/doxy_me #1 Mihaly lover Sep 18 '26

I’m really glad other people are bringing this up because this was just all around an awful choice on PAs end. “War brides?” “promised land?” Really? I couldn’t come up with a more offensive caricature if I tried.
Too many people are saying “it’s not even finished yet!” “There’s still more episodes!” But this is a four part, max 10 minute mini series. How in depth do people think they’re gonna take this?

4

u/DriftingNitro Mobius Sep 18 '26

I particularly worry about people who would watch the miniseries and not play the game, even if the game does a better job.

4

u/doxy_me #1 Mihaly lover Sep 18 '26

The mini series has its own writer, and a significantly shorter amount of time to explore motivations and ideals.
I have a lot more hope for the game to accurately explore these topics.

5

u/lordquince Sep 18 '26

dropping Orientalism by edward said, you are truly a ball knower... you put a lot of things ive been thinking so much better than i could. thank you so much for this post.

2

u/Ambitious-Height-148 Sep 19 '26

I really hope Sotoa is portrayed in a nuanced & humanized light when Ace Combat 8,much like the Anime Jaadugar portrayed Persians & Mongolians with nuance & humanity.I really hope Sotoa is more than just a country filled with seemingly religious fanatics.

2

u/No-Initiative4136 Sep 20 '26

As a Christian fan of the series, I felt similarly about the scene. When I first watched it, I expected the doctor’s act of kindness to spark some kind of change in the Sotoan pilot, so the sudden suicide caught me off guard. I do think the moment can work as a commentary on how kindness doesn’t automatically resolve every situation, and how some individuals may be too overwhelmed or too far gone for a single gesture to reach them. But if that’s the direction the writers are taking, the game will need to make clear distinctions between individual tragedy and broader cultural or factional themes.

And to be fair, Project Aces has a strong track record of humanizing opposing factions. Even the Gray Men—arguably the closest the series has come to an irredeemable antagonist group—had a defined ideological background and didn’t represent their entire nation. Considering how AC7 ended with a fractured Erusian political landscape, it wouldn’t be surprising if the new game explores similar internal divisions within Sotoa. That kind of nuance is something the series has always handled well.

From my own experiences, I know that radicalization can develop in multiple directions, and it’s possible the writers are using this angle to critique how fear and desperation can be manipulated to justify extreme actions. Both the FCU and Sotoa have circumstances that could feed a victim mentality—the FCU is facing an invasion, and Sotoa is dealing with a collapse of its water supply. Those pressures can shape people in very different ways.

Plus, given the standards of modern storytelling, I don’t think a faction built purely on caricature would make it far into development. Zero Hour may have had some rough edges, but I doubt the intent was to portray an entire group through a harmful stereotype. But ultimately, we’ll have to wait and see how the full game handles these themes.

2

u/Chris881 Sep 23 '26

I am going yo wait until the game is out before anything. For all we know the game has nothing on it like this

2

u/meharr Oct 06 '26

Looks like the game didn't lean into any of that bs.

7

u/Andy-Fz Sep 17 '26

It is what it is. Just remember it’s a work of fiction, and there’s still a lot of episodes and a whole game to wait for.

As someone said above, they’re taking inspiration in some real life scenarios. But just like Belkans nuked their land it doesn’t mean all Germans would do the same

20

u/trainiac12 Sep 17 '26

I think there's a crucial distinction in that the first (to my knowledge) Belkan we interact with is a defector who denounces Belka and its ideology. We see non-evil Belkans who act in defiance of their country to tell us Belka is bad before we see true believers defending Belka; and very notably Belkans are not racially distinct from Oseans or people from Ustio in the way the one Sotoan we've seen is.

The first (and so far only) Sotoan we interact with, the one we can put a face to, is a vaguely middle eastern man with a big beard in a dress uniform who is introduced as attempting to kidnap a bride, screaming about the promised land, and kills himself in a flourish of fanaticism.

The first middle eastern representation is a walking stereotype of an early 2000s jihadist. We have nothing to balance this out with like we do with Belkans.

6

u/Emergency-Law-2054 Sep 17 '26

pretty sure our first Sotoan is D. Ishaq

the captain of the land battleship from mission 9 preview

3

u/FuttleScish Spare Sep 17 '26

Tbf he’s also pretty fanatical

1

u/Silver_Fayte Sep 18 '26

Mission 9 in a game that has not released yet. This character is the first canonical Sotoan introduced in a released product.

3

u/Hresvelgr401_ Sep 17 '26

Well, yeah. But that's because we've only got our first real introduction to Sotoans so far, Belkans have had 3 games to show us the other side. Plus Yuktobania and particularly Estovakia were similarly pretty evil in their first introductions, Yuktobania attacked a flight of trainees without declaring war and Estovakia launched a full invasion and indiscriminately bombed Gracemeria without declaring war

1

u/Andy-Fz Sep 17 '26

That’s fair. I’m sorry you feel that way, I can see why. Give it some time, hopefully they’ll make it a bit less black and white like they do with most of their factions

5

u/TorsionSpringHell Sep 18 '26

yeah, agreed with your entire post. unless this is revealed to be a made-up or embelished story that FCU cyberwar units are spreading then it's pretty wild to do unironic GWOT propaganda in 2026 (also politics aside, it would be interesting to see actual cyberwar represented properly for once). pretty concerning how 10 minutes of iraq war propaganda that would have been considered hacky two decades ago is enough to get the sub and yt comments looking like a school shooter manifesto. "war is bad but planes are rad" posters in shambles yet again

silver lining is that if the game itself were really this hacky and orientalist then it would be almost impossible to hide from the trailers and previews so far. probably a lesson for PA to be a little more discerning in finding b-list writers next time though

3

u/CandusManus Sep 28 '26

In the last year Pakistan has had over 1000 Islamic terrorist attacks killing over 1100 people. That's just your country, how is that a poor representation?

6

u/bluewardog Sep 17 '26

So was the whole Sotoans being a strangereal version of Mongolians/step people's lost on you. There not Arab aligorys or Muslim ones. Seemingly (this isn't from leaks, just what I've dedused from officaly released stuff) the Sotoans are resolving there problem of "we are loosing arable land to desertification" with "let's invade Usea and take THERE land. Of course there not going to be very sympathetic, they dropped rods from god on city's. Also your glossing over the fact that while some antagonists in ace combat have some redeeming factors they are also people who regularly commit mass murder of civilians (Hoffnung, the 7 city's Belka Nuked, the people Erusia disappeared in San Salvasian, Estovakia bombing Gracmeria TWICE). You look at ONE character who was the architect of Sotoas crimes and declear them ALL guilty when the game isn't even out yet. 

-1

u/amaranthe13 Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

yeah but you might be missing the point of how its not just based on a muslim country, its caricaturing one in ways parroting how the US stoked islamophobia in the early 2000s. At least in the miniseries. It doesn't read as a mongolian steppe people analogue so far to me. The flag is largely resembling middle eastern styles is one indicator.

1

u/bluewardog Sep 25 '26

It's literally not, and it literally doesn't. 

0

u/WonderfulReception49 Sep 26 '26

Guy sees the only non-white non western character in the video acting like an arab in a shitty Jarhead sequel and saw nothing wrong with that.

2

u/bluewardog Sep 27 '26

Dumbasses see a brown person and immediately assume Arab despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary

0

u/WonderfulReception49 Sep 27 '26

Guy watches video with his eyes closed. 

"They're not Arab, they just look, act, and talk like a Hollywood Islamic terrorist, but the story doesn't call them that so it's completely different"

2

u/bluewardog Sep 27 '26

How about you go get a non American education, they are central Asian steppe peoples. 

0

u/WonderfulReception49 Sep 27 '26

"They're not evil Muslims, they're evil Central Asians. Completely different, don't pay attention to the part about war brides"

2

u/bluewardog Sep 27 '26

You do understand your the one being racist by soley prescribing this shit to Arab Muslims right, they don't have a monopoly on cruelty. 

0

u/WonderfulReception49 Sep 27 '26

"They're not evil Muslims, they're evil Central Asians. Completely different"

5

u/Serious_Nature_6882 Ustio Sep 17 '26

Here's the thing ... We don't know much about sotoa or satoan culture. We certainly can't say it's Muslim coded yet as we really only have one example of a sotoan on screen

Would you say the same thing if say Kai nagasi was the only example of a osean character we seen before we got ace combat 5? Would you say osea was Asian coded?

Calm your horses buddy, we know next to nothing about sotoa apart from the fact they are the antagonists and have super weapons..

That's it...

4

u/Lonely-Transition821 Sep 18 '26

“NOOOOO THE HECKING BAD GUYS IN MY WAR GAME ARE ACTUALLY TRULY EVIL NOOOOOOOOO”

1

u/WonderfulReception49 Sep 27 '26

Do you not see how weird it is when it's people that has historically been demonized by the west?

1

u/HazelRahRahRah Oct 05 '26

I mean, if the shoe fits...

3

u/Wolfyboi_1 there are three kind of aces? yes and no, its complicated Sep 17 '26

Heya,

I'm from a Islamic background as well and usually prefer engaging with fan arts and a few others. However, this time I had to comment as I think I can add a different viewpoint. I'm a 5th Gen South African living far away and we're generally chill people, stuff doesn't bother us that much. I might be not that religious, but that doesn't mean that this stuff doesn't hurt when it surfaces.

But the way I see it, this had been done before, caricatures of different regions and peoples and I guess many in the community feel something if it's their communities being portrayed a certain way. And generally they were done suitable for the in game purposes. But I do agree this one was kinda distasteful.

I do think this was a case of the series people going let's make this appeal to the western audiences and what they're familiar with and nothing more. The main story campaign antagonists hopefully should be of project aces usual variety, if not better I'm hoping! So don't worry hehe.

Project aces is trying to appeal to new gamers as evident by bringing in those streamers on their Bandai Namco America YT channel and going all out on multiplayer. And they always have been very pro US (for marketing purposes which is understandable given the market share). Hell, even the cover art steers clear of anything other than US jets, minus the Sukhoi in 3 and the Rafale on 5. Every antagonists plane is an ultra cool Russian fighter it seems if it's not fictional, but imagine being from those places and how it probably sits with them. It must be tiring having incredibly beautiful jets that never feature and now that I think of it don't even appear as licensed manufacturers in the pre menu titles. What an insult that must be to the designers of those jets and it's fans. I’ve seen people on this sub suggest seeing anything other than F22s on the covers and no matter how pretty the Raptor is, I'd like to see something new myself.

As for the stereotypes, I hear you. Been playing this series since I was 4/5ish. Been at it for nearly 30 years I'd say. It's my fav game series. Has the best community, best fans, best and most caring game devs of all time, best music, best mods on reddit I'd say (I mean look at them allowing this discourse, while a lot wouldn't). I love being an ace combat fan and yeah it does suck seeing them include this in the series and it's off putting given the amount of investment we ALL have in this series. But they haven't let us down in the past. Assault horizon felt super US preachy at one point if I remember correctly but to me at the time, it felt like project aces writing something to stay afloat and keep the series alive by marketing to the larger market. I imagine even American folk being all tired of it at times.

Islamic stereotypes, even normal Muslim folk generally are written shallowly and with a lack of humanity. Like I'm watching John Rambo rn, and there's a clear distinction between the murdering Burmese army guys and the innocent villagers. In most depictions of Muslims even the random market vendor would have guns and sell out the main character. But in my experience debating at campus, even as someone not that religious is that your either a very religious Muslim or your not Muslim at all to the media and the general public, there is no in between. Everything is super black and white, no nuance whatsoever. Like, its possible to criticize the bad things happening in Muslim communities and regions and see the good that exists there and use it as inspiration for writing something fun. Like, yes it would be cool to see better written Muslim characters both good and bad.

I appreciate you bringing this up, but don't dwell on it. This is our silly little military shooter after all. It's going to draw inspiration from conflicts from history and the contemporary. And I bet a lot of decisions made by project aces in the past must've affected someone.

2

u/Rare_Eye1173 Sep 26 '26

Most fragile people around

2

u/Past-Ruin7126 Sep 18 '26

The antagonists of this game have almost always been other “white” countries (countries that are allegories of USSR, Germany, France etc) but no one said they’re racist to people of those nationalities. The antagonist has to look like a distinct nation. Or are you expecting Project Aces to always cast white/western countries as antagonists yet again?

I’m afraid you’re overthinking it. You came to this conclusion just because a Sotoan general looks a certain way, ignoring the fact that the FCU military officer also looks similar (FCU seems to be very multi-ethnic)

There’s no place for “race” in this game, and you have jumped to conclusions from a single scene, in an incomplete live action series, on a game that’s not yet released.

0

u/Warcrimes_Desu Sep 17 '26

Genuinely turned me off the miniseries. If the game is as racist as that episode i am going to refund it. What the literal fuck PA. I think the day sunao katabuchi leaves the writer's room will be the day Ace Combat gets to have good stories again.

3

u/Son_of_Orion Cum historia, mutat valde Razgriz... Sep 17 '26

With you there. I genuinely liked the first episode, too... it sucks. I await the reviews with bated breath. We'll find out if this was an isolated oddity or if PA has in fact made a horrendous mistake. I really hope they haven't. It would break my heart so badly, I love this series too much. :(

1

u/Warcrimes_Desu Sep 17 '26

It's a shame too, i read in another comment that this live action series was comissioned by PA and they didn't write it or film it. So, hopefully that means the Sotoans won't be chechen caricatures

2

u/Ilm03 Sep 17 '26

But one of the antagonists in mission 9, the land battleship one, is named D. Ishaq...The show writer was perhaps given information by PA on the general demographics of Sotoans

5

u/Son_of_Orion Cum historia, mutat valde Razgriz... Sep 17 '26

Another comment said that the showrunners of SWAT handled this episode at least. This would explain a lot.

5

u/aelemayo Sep 17 '26

1

u/Son_of_Orion Cum historia, mutat valde Razgriz... Sep 17 '26

Ooooof. Yeah, that tracks.

1

u/Noha307 Sep 30 '26

I have to admit, I was really thrown off by the use of religion-coded speak like "promised land". I'll withhold judgement until the game comes out though.

Has Project Aces ever used religion in a previous game? (And I mean 'actual' religion, not just "person has insane delusions/fanatical" like Torres.) I can't think of one, but it's been a while and I haven't played every installment in the franchise.

1

u/No_Piccolo8361 Oct 02 '26

Religious fanatics are not exclusive to Islam. Very telling that you seem to think they are. History is full of more than its fair share of religious maniacs, from every Abrahamic religion, and more. Hell, there's a genocide being carried out in the name of Judaism right now

1

u/Gray_Productions Sep 17 '26

Absolutely agree with your points, but it also feels the point of satire with the depictions as well. The cheesy dialogue that fits with Ace Combat helps led that its really propaganda to try and belt-fed more people into the war

Plus, FCU has been constantly on the backfoot, especially since the Lighthouse War, it feels like victimhood on their angle

5

u/GoblinVietnam Warwolf Sep 17 '26

Absolutely that's what I've been getting from this entire series. The pilot who got shot down, has a kid brother that looks up to him. The eeeeeevvvillll foreigner who wants to take what's ours. The good hearted doctor who wants to save everyone. It's so over the top and propaganda laiden that it def feels like they are going for a satire of how propaganda works. And literally from the first trailer (and part of AC7) the entire theme has been misinformation, deception, and lies. We have a literal influencer on the ship to make up lies for us as the protagonist, who we are also a living lie.

7

u/aelemayo Sep 17 '26

Considering who the writers of Hour Zero are, I think it's more that propaganda is all they know how to write lol

1

u/GoblinVietnam Warwolf Sep 17 '26

True, but I'll let it play out until I make final judgement on it. That's just what I'm getting from it now and the OP has good reason to be concerned.

1

u/amaranthe13 Sep 24 '26

if it was meant to be propaganda all along, then it certainly worked for a lot of the game's audience. They ate it up.

1

u/shadowtempest91 Sol 2 Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26

I mean, we always had a great number of terrorists, and those terrorists always have been quite... Stereotyped to say the least. The terrorists in AC1 and 2 didn't have any description, but we had terrorists in Joint Assault having a society called "Valahia", all having Romanian last names, all talking with strong Slavic accents and having their bases scattered all around the Balcans. And we had conservative terrorists in AC7 committing genocides and such. And Belka (of all names) is a shit state with the very old flag of Russia.

I am with you: it was a rather stereotyped representation, but I think it fits what we saw in the last 30 years. The entire representation of Usea is basically inspired by 90s Europe... meaning it's strongly inspired by the shit that happened in ex Yugoslavia. Strangereal is stuck in a perpetual Bosnian-Herzegovina war.

Also as somebody pointed out the fact that this guy was talking about a promised land actually is mixing concepts of Hebraism in the character's culture. So: he looks randomly middle-eastern, but you can't pinpoint specifically to a certain culture or religion. And even if you could, I don't see much of a problem in having middle-eastern terrorists in the game. I mean: ISIS wasn't based in Australia. Every country does shit in the series, including Osea (=US) attacking a civilian city in mission 2 of AC7.

If the game will mix Arab and Israeli culture in a country and makes that a terrorist country, well... Kudos to them, they got balls of steel.

1

u/Efectodopler117 Sep 17 '26

Damn, i definitely need to see ep2 😳

1

u/Splatneck Sep 17 '26

It's the only Sotoan character we have seen so far, and there is no doubt the government is radical in some way, so radical soldiers will be about.

That being said, I would be disappointed and sympathise with you if Project Aces took the lazy path here. I hope they at least apply some nuance to Sotoans; previous games showed that not everyone on the opposing side was a total nutjob.

0

u/Working_Rise8592 Sep 17 '26

This isn’t really anything new or concerning. Look at other countries in game and real life. Emmeria-U.K? Russians-yukes. The eastern side ofEurope-estovakia. Etc. it’s just how the series is. And this mini-series isnt even over yet. I think you’re taking this deeper than it is. Other countries get represented in a “bad light” at first in the games and it turns out “not so bad”. And no one else is deeply concerned out whats going on and shown.

1

u/RandomMexicanDude Espada Sep 22 '26

Not muslim but I noticed that too, I hope its not the typical and stereotypical west vs middle east thing

-2

u/TactRelocatedCargo Sep 17 '26

Oh man, I wasn't even going to watch it. Episode 1 felt like a pretty ham fisted "War bad. War kill people."

Watching it now, and its about as bad as I thought it'd be. The bad guy is a weird mix of Middle east and Russian(the name). The medical stuff was holy crap bad. the "We're going to use the last of our pain killers on a dying man in a triage situation" was peak Hollywood BS.
The unrefrigerated storage of the drugs in a simple cabinet, the giving the last of vital meds to a patient who is 100% going to die, it all was pretty shit.

0

u/Warcrimes_Desu Sep 17 '26

"Mix of middle east and russian" i think he's based on a Chechen-type vibe. A small region of russia that is primarily Muslim. The live action stuff has been a massive disappointment lol

1

u/Muctepukc Sukhoi Enjoyer Sep 17 '26

His name is rather Turkic or Persian, so he's not from Caucasus region.

So it is a weird mix.

-8

u/indiepyx Sep 17 '26

PA/AC has always been a mouthpiece for American imperialism. Though that's similar for most Japanese games that engage into geopolitics since Japan itself is an American neocolony. Almost every AC game takes the Western/American side through the lens of Strangereal, whether it's the American planes being reserved for the protagonists/good guys(Moebius with FA22, Barlet with F14, etc) and the Russian planes reserved for antagonists/enemies/evil guys(Yellow 13, Yuktobania, Mihaly's Su-30, etc). Or the perspective always from a Western counterpart(Osea and its pilots being the focus of AC 5 instead of Yuktobania, and the villains of AC Zero being an organization that mirrors a caricature of Communists). Or an anacronistic view of history(Belka is admonished for using nukes on their own soil without any critical eyes on Osea grabbing their territory as if it's just normal and not as much or even worse of an action than a country trying to defend itself).

There's a reason China didn't let PA use their planes and they are completely correct in that decision, had they done so, those Chinese planes would've been reduced to be flown by some caricature evil villain overshadowed by whatever Western/American plane counterpart they want to be the focus on this time around.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BigCartoonist9010 Sep 17 '26

Guy who doesn't think fictional countries relate to real life politics

Not to mention assault horizon straight up drops the fictional names and turns into a propaganda slop CoD game.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/acecombat-ModTeam Sep 17 '26

Please be kind and respectful to those you share this subreddit with, Thanks!

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/acecombat-ModTeam Sep 18 '26

Discussion of politics, political figures, and real-world conflicts divorced from the context of the game is prohibited, including discussion about real world nation politics. Keep content focused on Ace Combat and its setting.