r/acecombat • Aces of Ice-cream • Sep 17 '26

Meta What the hell Project Aces? Thoughts on Episode 2 of Hour Zero, as a Muslim fan of the series

Important update 26/09/2026: According to a review from gamerfridge, the final release isn't shackled by Hour Zero's dated depiction: "Wings of Theve also boasts the series’ strongest writing to date. I’m thrilled to say that prequel miniseries Hour Zero’s decidedly dated portrayal of the Republic of Sotoa (relying on some bygone “War on Terror” tropes) isn’t echoed in the game itself—while there’s some superficial connections one could draw between them and contemporary MENA countries, Sotoa is far more a technocratic khanate than a rogue terror state." (https://gamerfridge.com/2026/09/25/ace-combat-8-wings-of-theve-review/)

This is a source of great relief, and I am glad to have retained some hope in PA. Still, of course, however, we'll only know how the game actually is come release day.

OG post below:

----

Forgive me for if I ramble. I am very emotional right now, and in shock.

About two months ago, I wrote a post on how excited I was for Sotoa, specifically for this reason:

As someone coming from a non-Western, non-White, Muslim heritage (Pakistani), it is also nice to see more stories where the Muslim-coded faction (obv Sotoa is not Muslim, but in terms of how Muslims are perceived in the Western imagination: Arab, Iranian, South Asian, etc.) are not portrayed as insane terrorists who exist solely be defeated by the so-called ‘civilised’ Western ‘good guy’. I understand that Sotoa is the antagonist force in 8, but considering PA’s history of portraying enemy nations sympathetically and humanely, I am both confident that, and am excited to see fellow brown characters’ portrayed human beings rather than stock villains.

While this is only episode 2 of the series, and though the game is still upcoming, my expectations have seemingly been upended. This episode stands out as one of the most Orientalist, Islamophobic, and racist regressive pieces of media I have encountered recently.
The captured Sotoan pilot was nothing more than an Islamophobic caricature: seeking ‘war-brides’, aspiring to martyrdom so he can enter the Promised Land (Sotoa’s version of heaven), and brazenly attacking civilians.

If this were framed as a fringe faction, or if the game later (as in, when it finally launches) makes clear that he does not represent Sotoan civilisation as a whole, it might be more palatable. Instead, the very first sustained depiction of soldiers from the series’ first major non-Western, non-white nation has them acting like modern extremist groups — groups that, it must be said, do not represent Muslims or the peoples of the regions they claim to speak for (Muslims were by far the largest victims of Daesh). In doing so it leans hard into tired Orientalist tropes of the hypersexualised1, hyperviolent Arab/Brown man/Muslim is frustrating. It felt like an episode of Homeland! Edward Said described the trope best:

In the films and television the Arab is associated either with lechery or bloodthirsty dishonesty... an oversexed degenerate, capable, it is true, of cleverly devious intrigues, but essentially sadistic, treacherous, low. Slave trader, camel driver, moneychanger, colorful scoundrel: these are some traditional Arab roles in the cinema. The Arab leader (of marauders, pirates, "native" insurgents) can often be seen snarling at the captured Western hero and the blond girl (both of them steeped in whole someness), "My men are going to kill you, but-they like to amuse themselves before."... In newsreels or news photos, the Arab is always shown in large numbers. No individuality, no personal characteristics or experiences. Most of the pictures represent mass rage and misery, or irrational (hence hopelessly eccentric) gestures. Lurking behind all of these images is the menace of jihad. Consequence: a fear that the Muslims (or Arabs) will take over the world.2

The resulting rhetoric is evident in the comment below. (Names cut off. I am upset, but I also don't want to break any rules)

I know this is just one comment, and I know some may respond by saying its just online chatter, but any Muslim and/or person of colour here surely understands the danger this rhetoric can trigger.

What makes this more frustrating, beyond seeing the dehumanisation those adjacent to my skin colour and faith (via characteristics, obviously Islam itself doesn't exist in Strangereal) have endured for decades regurgitated, is that Project Aces already has a history of humanising enemy forces in the past. Ace Combat 7’s DLCs, for example; Yuktobanians having the capacity for victimhood in the technical school attack in Ace Combat 5, and your later allegiance to them at the end; the Belkans who resist their own nation’s nuclear terror and surrender part-way through Zero, and their later victimisation on Tyler Island in Ace Combat 7; that Estovakian commander who defects in Ace Combat 6, or even Strigon Squadron, who are able to retain their humanisation without having to defect to your side… But nothing for the first Sotoan we see? Not even a combatant, but rather an injured soldier?

And, as I wrote above, this may yet be clarified in the main game. Perhaps most Sotoans rebuke the beliefs of this specific soldier, and whatever faction or sect he may follow. Still, the fact that this is our first extended look at a Sotoan is concerning. If the soldier’s behaviour is presented as simply following his culture, I fear that any future humanisation of Sotoans will be conditional on how closely individual characters or factions approximate “Westernness."

I hope this post doesn’t break any rules. I’m not trying to spark controversy or drama. I simply can’t be the only one who noticed this. More than anything, I want this to be heard, and I want to assure other POC members of the community that what they saw isn’t just them overreacting.

  1. A good pre-9/11 example is Republican propaganda during the Spanish Civil War. Despite their liberal and (sometimes) leftist tint, they utilised Islamophobic and racist anti-Moorish propaganda to encourage anti-Francoism, based on the fact that Franco filled his ranks with African colonial troops from Morocco (known as the Regulares and the Army of Africa), deploying orientalist tropes that painted these soldiers as hypersexualised, homosexualised (implying de-masculinisation) and uncivilised invaders. Elisabeth Bolorinos Allard, ‘The Crescent and the Dagger: Representations of the Moorish Other during the Spanish Civil War’ Bulletin of Spanish Studies 93:6 (Edinburgh, 2016)

  2. Edward Said, Orientalism (New York, 1978) pp. 286-287.

Edit: fixed tense

30 Upvotes

Duplicates