Before anyone can jump down my throat based purely off of the title unsubtly critiquing this very game, labeling me as a nitpicker or what else have you, I am going to preface my argument against recent PA boss designs with this: I really liked this game. I also don’t know how to format spoiler bars on Reddit, so I’ll slice this paragraph up with a major spoiler alert.
SPOILER ALERT, SPOILER ALERT, SPOILER ALERT.
ANOTHER SPOILER ALERT PARAGRAPH, ANOTHER SPOILER ALERT PARAGRAPH.
Despite its observable flaws that assuredly exist, one of the biggest ones to me is the lack of mission variety compared to previous titles, among what I will primarily discuss in this post. No, seriously, if you disregard what is visually occurring or narratively occurring in the story, mechanical-wise, a lot of the missions are solely focused on escorting a slow-moving vulnerable target that can’t go five seconds without beeping and blinking and calling for help against a single enemy. Like an APC.
You escort a slow-moving LCAC unit… numerous times in numerous missions. You fight against a pair of supersonic bombers, but just kidding, you’re also on a time limit because you can’t let the bombers destroy too many ships. So it’s both a boss fight AND an escort mission at the same time. You escort a slow-moving AC130 unit in a somehow even worse rendition of Mission 10 from AC7. You escort a pair of helicopter squads. So on and so forth. Again and again. Protect this useless ally, protect this useless ally.
If you avert thine glistening nostalgic-soaked eyes away from what the game is trying to make you feel, and instead look at what the game is actually doing, they can be remarkably different things. Bad things. Not just good. The Land Battleship missions in particular are annoying to me because they are obsessed with wasting your time. Which is in fact what almost all of the bosses in this game essentially do.
For the battleships, especially in Mission 9 and Mission 17, if you’re even halfway decent at the game, which almost all of you should be if you’ve played at least one other game in the series, you will find yourself in the uncomfortably boring predicament of waiting for the next phase of the boss fight to finally commence. You can simply evacuate from the area entirely in Mission 17 once you destroy all of the targets. It’s actually what I would recommend for everyone to do so you don’t have to deal with the oddly sometimes pinpoint accurate cannon fire. Mission 19 is a little less egregious for the final instance of a Land Battleship boss fight, simply because you CAN speed things up a bit whenever the ship gets bombed. You can attack the breach before it gets assigned as a target for you to lock onto.
Now, as for the big one: I didn’t like fighting Shadow 22 OR Moon 11, and I definitely didn’t like being bored out of my mind for the vast majority of the final mission. For my first run-through, though, I was suitably enraptured enough by what was happening to disregard some of the noticeable problems in all three boss designs. Let’s start with Shadow 22, since in my opinion, he’s the worst boss in the entire game.
To put it simply, I think it’s stupid that your missiles seemingly refuse to connect with any of the four planes. The game doesn’t even come up with a proper justification as to why your missiles are seemingly being deflected by them as if there’s a magic force field preventing them from being hit. The SU57 apparently DOES have an on-board jammer or something akin to it, at least I think it does. So they could have at least justified the strange abrupt change in gameplay by someone pointing this out to you. Regardless, I don’t approve of the game forcefully taking away a huge method of attack away from you in order to artificially inflate the difficulty. Unless you use SASMS, or if you get somewhat lucky with QAAMS, you cannot rely on any other missile. You have to use your guns.
This phenomenon actually repeats itself for the very next boss, Moon 11. She’s weird mainly because it feels as if her boss fight is linked not to how much damage you deal, but her dialogue as well as the MUSIC. She’s a refurbished Mihaly encounter, and I think most people can agree with me on this: Mihaly was a bad boss encounter. All of them. Even the last encounter in Mission 18. She wasn’t all that challenging. Most people are simply going to be swept away by the admittedly brilliant music of the boss fight on their first playthrough and they won’t notice what the game is actually doing.
And yes, I have also noticed that sometimes, the same Shadow 22 phenomenon occurs with HER, too. Sometimes, my missiles just outright phase through her, even when I have a clear line of fire on her. So… could we all agree that these aren’t actually boss fights so much as heavily scripted encounters in the shape of boss fights?
Not to be a pointless (BUT WHAT ABOUT PW?!) contrarian, but if you want to look at a legitimately decent, if not extraordinary Ace Combat boss fight, look no further than Crimson 1 himself. THAT, to me, was a brilliant boss fight that legitimately tests your skills in combat. It felt like a Dark Souls boss fight, with planes. How could anyone not like that? Narratively, he had decent build-up but nothing quite like Toprak and Tewy, but mechanically? He is leagues above most Ace Combat boss fights. It felt fun to fight someone that could actually chase me, shoot me down, someone that could get on my tail and try to stay ON my tail instead of quickly fluttering away because I wasn’t attacking him. Someone that didn’t need any overt cheap gimmicks in order to attack me. Each phase in Crimson One’s boss fight gradually ramps up the difficulty until he’s essentially become a Touhou boss. And I don’t mean that in a negative way. He has four phases in total, and I believe the boss is meant to be draining. It’s a battle of attrition.
And to briefly talk about Mission 30, I… I don’t like it. It primarily suffers from a different problem compared to 22 and 11, it’s BORING. It’s boring. Narratively, it’s acceptable, but mechanically, you are simply forced into spawncamping a bunch of missiles and that’s it. It’s a neutered robot version of Torres, minus the Crisp White Sheets and impressively deranged aura. While I like the idea of it being controlled by an AI, Ace Combat 8 doesn’t do anything significant with this. For a game that takes place only a short few months, or maybe only a month before Dission gets sublimated and some of the main events that lead up to AC3, it’s weirdly LESS futuristic compared to AC7. Kind of. The submarine AI dialogue is a cool detail to notice, however.
All in all, after all of the subsequent replays I have made for this game and earning all of the campaign medals, I’ll have to say that I’m not that impressed by any of the boss designs, barring the Ladons.