I'm not shitting on Ross. Accursed Farms is my favorite channel. But as an economics major, I have to point out the mistakes he makes in his Robot Jobs video. Many people in recent years are afraid AI will take out jobs in the near future. Big YouTube channels like Kurzgesagt and CGPGrey have made videos about it. Figures like Bill Gates and Elon Musk and academics at MIT have raised awareness on this. The problem with those predictions is that they usually focus on the tech aspect of things, not economics. And because of this, they are overblown. John Oliver and Vox made videos explaining why they are overblown.
Ross unfortunately makes the same mistakes:
He mentions that the economist John Maynard Keynes predicted automation would boost productivity so much, we would have a lot of free time. Ross then says productivity has grown a lot, but then shows a chart showing wages have been stagnant since the 1970's and have not kept up with productivity.
Ross is basing himself on a study by the Economic Policy Institute that is filled with gross mistakes. The chart shown in the video comes from that study. As economist James Sherk pointed out:
The difference comes from using pay and productivity data collected from different sources and with different methodologies—statistical apples and oranges that cannot be directly compared. (...) [The chart] includes only wages, not total compensation (which includes benefits [like health insurance]), and adjusts wages and productivity for inflation differently. Further, it does not account for factors that artificially boost measured productivity: increases in the rate of depreciation and inaccurate measuring of import prices. Adjusting the data to account for these factors eliminates most of the apparent gap between pay and productivity.
Economist Scott Winship also wrote on how to compare productivity and income accurately and has made his own chart, that also shows income growth matching productivity.
Furthermore, while it's not comparing with productivity, the Congressional Budget Office concluded income has continuously risen for americans for the last decades. Dispelling the myth of wage stagnation. When you take taxes and government benefits into account, the inequality between the top 20% and the bottom 20% of americans becomes even smaller.
By the way, in the Vox video there is an economist from the same Economic Policy Institute. And not even her is concerned with unemployment coming from automation.
2) Ross says this time, automation is different than it was in the past for 2 reasons:
"First, the whole point of having robots is to replace workers."
This is not exclusive to robots. Any automation has that goal. Farming, mining and manufacturing has lost a lot of its jobs in the US. Even when a machine replaces just a few functions of a worker's job, that still allows for the employer to hire less people to produce the same amount of goods and services. In fact, it's not just machines that replace jobs. Trade and immigration do to. And yet, economists are largely in favor of free trade and immigration. Why ? I will explain later in this post.
"And that brings me to the second reason this time is different. Again, some people are convinced that there's going to be all these magical new jobs because robots are taking all the old ones. Well, if that's true, what about right now ? Our current employment situation is not great."
This has not aged well. Before the pandemic hit, the US was at a record low unemployment. While he makes a point about "real unemployment rate", that doesn't change the fact unemployment have not gotten worse since then before the pandemic hit. Unemployment is worse right now, but that has nothing to do with automation. It's due to the pandemic.
3) He talks about new jobs paying people less and how the Trans Pacific Partnership will make things even worse.
Again, before the pandemic hit, the average american income was rising. And the Trans Pacific Partnership was largely supported by economists for being a free trade agreement with environment protection and worker's safety provisions. But the deal was canceled thanks to Trump's stupid protectionist ideas.
4) He says AIs will not become self-aware. Then he says "And if you think I'm wrong, I don't want to hear your argument. I want to see this AI consciousness speak for itself."
I agree with him on this. But I can apply the same logic to unemployment. I want to see automation cause massive unemployment for me to believe in it. I'm sorry, but Ross's prediction of massive unemployment is just as flimsy as predictions of AI destroying humanity.
4) He suggests robots will cause massive permanent unemployment of near 50%. He actually says that at the beginning of the video, but I'm talking about this last so it's easier to understand my point.
This figure comes from articles he points in the video. Of 30% to 50% of jobs being at risk of being automated. And while this is true, it doesn't mean it will lead to 50% unemployment. Ross says at one point "But some people might still be saying: This is just a transition, we'll invent new jobs. Ok fine, for every ten jobs we lose, we gain one designing and maintaining the robots."
The major flaw with predictions of robots causing massive unemployment is that they ignore how new jobs are created. I'm not talking about new careers, like programmers and engineers that will create and maintain the robots. I'm talking about jobs in general.
The unemployment rate is inversely proportional with GDP. When GDP grows, new jobs are created and unemployment goes down. GDP grows thanks to consumption, investment, government spending and trade. And this is how technology creates new jobs. This is the most important part of this post.
When businesses automate their production, and replace some of their workers with machines, they can lower their prices so they can sell more. With lower prices, consumers then have more money to spend on other stuff. The money they spend on other stuff will raise demand and help create new jobs.
So for example. When automation makes new cars cheaper (they are cheaper, adjusting for inflation), you can spend less money on a new car and use the money that you saved to spend on a new TV as well. That in turn, will increase demand for the TV industry. And the TV industry will hire more people to make new TVs. In this example, automation in the car industry helped create new jobs in other industries, for careers that already existed.
The same process happens with trade and immigration. When consumers can buy cheaper products made overseas, or made domestically with cheap labor, they can save money and spend on other stuff.
It's no wonder the number of jobs in farming and manufacturing have gone down while jobs in healthcare and education have gone up. It's also no wonder those last two sectors have become very expensive in the US: they require more (expensive) american workers than any other sector.
Even if a business decides to not lower their prices and simply give their stockholders bigger profit dividends or reinvest the money in the stock market, that still helps to create new jobs. Because that boosts the Investment part of the GDP equation. Investors will have more money at lower interest rates to invest in other businesses, that will also grow and hire more people.
In the long run, automation also makes us all wealthier. It helps to drive prices down, effectively making our income higher. And as I've shown in the articles I've linked, incomes have been growing for decades.
So there you have it. Robots are not an existential threat to unemployment. And the current trend is not different, economy wise, to previous forms of automation.