r/academia • • Oct 16 '21

Men at conferences, are you aware of how much space you take up?

0 Upvotes

I am attending an online conference with excellent female representation in terms of the organizers, keynotes, invited and guest speakers. Yet at every Q&A session the same few men organize themselves to speak first, to speak at length, and with multiple follow-up questions effectively blocking any other participants from engaging. One of the conferences themes is inclusivity. Men: how can you still be so unaware of your domineering behavior?


r/academia • • Dec 23 '23

University of Minnesota professor who denied Hamas atrocities on Oct. 7 a candidate for school’s top DEI job

75 Upvotes

r/academia • • Jan 04 '24

Why this sub is turning so political recently?

0 Upvotes

And I see both left and right comments getting downvoted very badly


r/academia • • Dec 12 '23

The genocide denial in this subreddit is ridiculous

0 Upvotes

People don't seem to understand the mechanics of settler-colonialism or ethnic cleansing – goes to show what happens when the humanities are defunded and marginalized.


r/academia • • Apr 11 '24

Venting & griping Women and BIPOC academics, let's raise awareness about what we go through.

2 Upvotes

Women in academia! Tell me about the most hurtful sexist or misogynistic thing you've heard or experienced in your career.

BIPOC people in academia! Tell me about the microaggressions you go through on a daily basis in academia.


r/academia • • Dec 11 '23

New York University suspends student for removing Zionist posters

Thumbnail
wsws.org
6 Upvotes

r/academia • • Dec 08 '23

Why is Academia silent on the the bombardment and distraction of Gaza's Universities, the last was IU school of Medicine

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/academia • • Nov 15 '23

My Zionist Friend No Longer Feels Safe in Academia

25 Upvotes

I have a Jewish friend who is a huge Zionist. The whole nine yards -- did Taglit, fell in love with the country, became modern Orthodox, and started a PhD. program. He is wrapping up his defense now but doesn't want to do a postdoc because he doesn't feel safe. His PI apparently made some snide remarks about apartheid.

Is he overreacting?


r/academia • • Aug 14 '25

My Professor sends entire textbooks that are not searchable.

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone

I am currently doing a graduate program to further my career, and I've been out of academia for quite some time now. However, my professors love scanning entire textbooks as one massive PDF.
Ctrl+F is useless, the file takes forever to load, and I waste hours trying to find one citation for a paper.

Does anyone have a workflow to make these monsters searchable without manually scanning every page? I feel like there has to be a better way, and that people working in academia full-time must have a system to do this!

I feel like my age is coming up against me, and that I don't know the latest technologies to help me in this.

If you have any suggestions, I would be SO grateful.


r/academia • • Jun 09 '23

Seriously, what's up with the "western civ" thing? Science and knowledge-making have always been global, a product and practice of humanity.

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/academia • • May 04 '23

The incessant marginalization of POC in academia is exhausting, & really needs to be a bigger part of the DEI discussion.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/academia • • Jul 11 '23

[VENT] (Computer science) academia is hugely unwelcoming to people with invisible disabilities, and (inadvertently) ableist

3 Upvotes

Some of this is specific to computer science (CS), but a lot of this might also be true for other parts of academia.

I am an autistic PhD student. I could create a long list of issues in CS academia that greatly harm people with invisible disabilities (such as autism, ADHD, anxiety etc) but here's a few:

  • Unspoken, unwritten rules: a lot of PhD programs and departments have it informal where everything is not written down, or it is not easily accessible. This is greatly distressing to autistic people who struggle without documented instructions.

  • Strong reliance on connections: CS academia seems to place a lot of emphasis on connections made through socialization at conferences, your advisors etc. For example, recommendation letters play a massive role. This is extremely disadvantageous to people with social anxiety and autistic people.

  • Given the pace at which CS is growing and the complexity of papers, it becomes important to present your work well at (say) a conference. Since most people are neurotypical, this directly creates a disadvantage for neurodivergent people.

  • Conferences are a sensory hell: travel, speaking, meeting people, breaking routine, 'networking', giving talks are impossible to do in an unstructured way for most people. I feel extremely depressed and completely exhausted at conferences, and am unable to achieve anything at all.

  • Unspoken rules about getting papers accepted at conferences: I once met someone who described how a top conference seems to largely accept papers in a specific, informal format which is not written anywhere. I am not talking about font size etc, but ways of organizing the paper etc. And this format seems to vary by conference. If most reviewers are making this an informal requirement, why not just mandate it?

  • The unfettering focus on results, results, results.

  • Faculty acting as HR and as administrators. This one is particularly nasty because it has so many downsides. Autistic people won't know who to approach with a specific issue. People with depression won't know who to bring it up with. People with anxiety will be worried about things not being discreet etc. It's so easy for the power imbalance to harm students. Is there any other office job in the world without proper HR at least?

I want to emphasize that none of it seems intended. A vast majority of people I have worked with have no ill intentions. I've been lucky enough to not suffer through some items in the list above. I think it is not a matter of malice but a matter of priorities: accommodating people with disabilities doesn't seem to matter to anyone.

Edit: thank you everyone for engaging in discussion, even if we disagree. I'm no longer able to reply to every comment, but I appreciate you engaging with something you didn't have to. I've also gained some understanding of the challenges involved.

Edit 2: based on all the comments, I have decided to quit academia after my PhD.

Edit 3: a lot of people here seem to think that accommodations to disabled people and academia's productivity are inversely correlated. I don't think that's true - accommodations of any sort to any oppressed group increase the overall productivity in the long run.


r/academia • • Sep 11 '24

Is /r/professors seem to be >80% teaching faculty at SLAC's, CC's, and VAP's/NTT instructors?

2 Upvotes

It seems like the majority of the posts are complaints about students and teaching and service, and almost like a a more grown-up version of /r/teachers.

For me teaching is only 50% of the contract. Where do people discuss the other 50%?

Reminds me of this repeated post about someone asking for help establishing a research that got voted up in /r/academia, but heavily downvoted in /r/professors

https://old.reddit.com/r/academia/comments/1fc0whm/how_to_run_a_lab_without_grad_students/

https://old.reddit.com/r/Professors/comments/1fc0w4u/how_to_run_a_lab_without_grad_students/

What gives?


r/academia • • Jan 21 '24

Claudine Gay's responses at congressional hearing were not as big a failure as they were made out to be. Why was she so brutally targeted?

0 Upvotes

Many have expressed they found her responses at the congressional hearing to be disgraceful. The plagiarism accusations that lead to her resignation surfaced secondarily in what appeared to be retaliation as a direct result of the hearing. However, the claim that Gay failed to denounce genocide simply isn't true and there seems to be a double standard.

False claims

During the congressional hearing she denounced the genocide of Jews multiple times, saying she found coinciding language to be personally abhorrent and against Harvard's values (https://youtu.be/5f-E6LiYReM?si=rRaIClheZvLECM4J&t=51 until 1:44).

The answer to the question she was asked about whether it's against the code of conduct isn't black and white as the congresswoman presented it. Harvard upholds the right to free speech, under which even horribly offensive speech is protected. Once it's targeted at a specific individual is when it becomes against their code of conduct. Moments before Gay is asked a similar question (whether calling for the genocide of African-Americans is against the code of conduct) and has the same answer, so Jews aren't being singled out (https://youtu.be/5f-E6LiYReM?si=r6-nMGMidgt08rJ2&t=5).

The congresswoman brought up Harvard's past of rescinding admission to students who had shared racist memes, and many voiced the opinion that antisemitism isn't taken as seriously as other types of racism. Gay's response to the congresswoman's question about African-Americans debunks this claim IMO.

Double Standard

Chris Eisgruber (president of Princeton U) shared the exact same stance a little over 3 years ago and would have had the same response if he were to attend the congressional hearing (https://spia.princeton.edu/blogs/op-ed-princeton-president-eisgruber-free-speech-and-inclusivity-why-mutual-respect-makes-free). His statement following the hearing aligned with Gay's responses: https://president.princeton.edu/blogs/remarks-cpuc-about-criticism-higher-education-us-congress.

Why was there such an unrelenting witch hunt against Gay following the congressional hearing? UPenn's president resigned shortly after, but was the MIT president met with similar scrutiny that just didn't receive as much coverage?

I think it's obtuse to not point out race as a contributing factor, but I also understand that the congresswoman had a personal vendetta against Harvard.

Why weren't other Ivy League presidents there, specifically Chris Eisgruber since he's been vocal about free speech protections in the past?

I know a lot of people are over this at this point but I'd like to hear other's thoughts.


r/academia • • May 08 '22

This is why BLK women and BIPOC leave academia

0 Upvotes

So I’ve reached out to my university department in charge of tutors(GTAs) to let the know I could no longer doing grading for the course (only thing left is the final essay). I was hospitalized and needed emergency surgery. The head lecturer of my course took it upon herself to tell me I was “unprofessional” because I didn’t tell them and that I had four weeks of ungraded work (Not true). “ I am truly disappointed and surprised that you didnt find any time to or let us know of your situation as it started to happen - not to wait additional days and weeks just to notify us of your decision. It is very disturbing that you didnt come to us (any of us) and tried to work your issue with us days and weeks ago. I see that there is a huge number of assignments that are not graded - and I am not talking about the final essay - but your previous work that students submitted four weeks ago… You had plenty of time to reach out - instead you chose to deliver your resignation notice a day before the final essays deadline. It is beyond unprofessional, mostly because you are failing to understand that academia is ALL ABOUT TEAMWORK. “ as I lay in the hospital for days awaiting surgery this is the response I receive. White women can’t muster up the smallest amount of compassion. I told them this yesterday night only 3-4 days after being admitted to the hospital, what a disgusting person. I want to add that I clapped back with proof to attest to the BS she provided

EDIT: since many ppl aren’t reading. I attached proof in my response that all my assigned grading work was complete. I did not vanish I thought my last class April 25th and the last day of the trimester was end of last month.


r/academia • • Dec 11 '23

University of California Irvine targets students opposing genocide in Gaza

Thumbnail
wsws.org
0 Upvotes

r/academia • • Jan 28 '25

If You're an International Student, the Best Advice Anyone Can Give is to Don't Come Here

4 Upvotes

Every time I see an international student celebrate that they were accepted to a US institution and ask what to do, everything in me tells me to say to avoid the US at all costs for the next 4 years and to go elsewhere. That the US is no longer the only excellent option for upward mobility. I want to tell them to stay away if they want to be able to travel home to see their family freely and comfortably. 😔

Now, even domestic students are unstable academically, socially, emotionally, AND FINANCIALLY (done today smh). If you are an international student or know international students, the kindest thing is to tell them honestly the risks they're taking coming here. Nothing can be guaranteed. Not Visa status, no program continuation, not safety. It's been less than 10 days the foundations of US society have been cracked.


r/academia • • Sep 21 '23

DEI committees are deadly distractions and hinder actual change

6 Upvotes

DEI committees are infiltrated by HR or Deans/their representative to control the conversation. They are effectively turned into powerless, purely performative committees with no power to enact policy change. Members of DEI committee would make a bigger impact if they were actually distributed in committees where decisions are ultimately taken.

The chairs of such committees are often multi-minority employees with not enough social capital to afford to fight for change. At the same time, people with higher social capital (e.g., white man) would just look "bad" leading DEI committees.

A university with a DEI committee may actually signal its inability to foster DEI in its regular committees.


r/academia • • Mar 27 '24

Plagiarism Charges at Harvard Are Really About Rolling Back D.E.I.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
36 Upvotes

r/academia • • Feb 26 '24

Do some academics and/or researchers care more about publications than about pursuing the Truth?

6 Upvotes

What incentives do academics currently acquiesce to? What is the impact of not pursing some sort of truth?


r/academia • • Jul 04 '23

The Hypocrisy of Mandatory Diversity Statements. Demanding that everyone embrace the same values will inevitably narrow the pool of applicants who work and get hired in higher education.

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
22 Upvotes

r/academia • • Mar 24 '26

Academic politics I rarely see academics directly engage with public to solve urgent social problems and fight inequality created by world systems.

0 Upvotes

Academics spend years training to question assumptions, test ideas rigorously, and get closer to truth. PhDs, postdocs, professors we’re basically professional problem-solvers. But when it comes to real-world social issues, most of that energy kind of vanish.

Outside academia, the world is dealing with very real social problems: bad education quality, hunger, clean water access, poverty, inequality. And yet, I rarely see academics actively engaging with these issues in public spaces, not on social media, not in coordinated efforts that go beyond publishing papers.

What’s even more strange is how fragmented academia feels. Everyone is working on something important, highlighting SDGs, clean energy problem, decarbonization, and so on but mostly in isolation. There’s very little collective action, even though the problems we’re studying are really interconnected.

I understand the constraints of funding, publishing pressure, teaching loads, and institutional systems. But still, it feels like we’ve accepted this systems where “impact” is measured in citations rather than actual change. I haven't see any collective action from academics to reform even the academia system itself, which we all know is becoming more unhealty.

So I’m wondering

Are we, as academics, unintentionally distancing ourselves from the very problems we claim to study? And if so, why isn’t there a stronger movement within academia to step out of the lab and engage more directly with society?


r/academia • • Jan 28 '24

Political activism in sociology

15 Upvotes

I recently came across a document on the American Sociological Association website (see the link at the end of this post). It presents a "theme" for their annual meeting. I must say, I was shocked and taken aback by how it seems to frame the role of sociology as overtly political. For example: "The 2024 theme emphasizes sociology as a form of liberatory praxis: an effort to not only understand structural inequities, but to intervene in socio-political struggles."

I don't mean to pose this as an attack, although I admit I do find it quite concerning. My knowledge of sociology is fairly limited. I am a recent PhD in a physics-adjacent field. Of course, I hope that my work is a net positive for the world, but ultimately I see my role as that of a truth-seeker, rather than an activist or active player in politics, etc. I'm curious how others feel about this, especially those in the social sciences or other non-STEM academic disciplines. Is this mindset representative in sociology and related fields? Is this a new development in how sociologists see themselves? Naturally, those studying political and human structures will be closer to politics than, e.g., mathematicians. Even so, it seems to me that openly declaring an activist stance goes against the core of what it means to do good science. I don't even object to scientists participating in activism outside of their work provided it remains wholly separate. However, it seems deeply misguided to intentionally combine the two.

EDIT: It seems like I might have stepped in it a little bit here. It wasn't my intention to troll with this post. I know this is an area of controversy and that sociology is inherently more connected to politics than some other fields. I am genuinely interested in how activism or "praxis" is presented as an overt part of the practice of the field and to what extent this is universal or controversial among practicing sociologists. I welcome all responses, both supportive and critical. Thank you.

American Sociological Association Annual Meeting Theme


r/academia • • Jan 01 '23

English Academic Writing Is Mostly Pretentious Nonsense Pretending to be Profound

8 Upvotes

I am willing to give a lot of professors the benefit of the doubt because it is hard to parse Lacan or Foucault, but then I come across a sentence like this:

"Rather than assuming that historical contexts explain a particular literary text, I assume that literature provides access to an otherwise irrecuperable history. In other words, I believe that the act of literary analysis (including formal analysis) can become an historiographical operation all its own."

I cannot imagine why, aside from pretension, this professor needed to make it that complicated. The truth is that the emperor has no clothes and all of these books are just drivel that other professors pretend to understand. Professional charlatans.