Hi, everybody. I comment all the time, and the mods have got to be a bit sick of seeing my looong speech about abuse and how it works going up on posts as often as it has been lately. I am on mental health leave from my job right now, so I have time on my hands and an overactive brain. I am on leave because I have a wonderful job that supports me as a person and because I am four years out from surviving something that only happens in true crime Netflix documentaries. The road to healing from severe emotional and physical abuse is such a long one, and I know my lovely friends in here know all about.
I have had a lot of mental health issues in my life. Going from wandering around lost in the void and suffering mentally to getting a diagnosis and treatment for MDD, ADHD, BPD, and PTSD is a journey of self-doscovery and healing of the kind I would *never* want to deny anyone their own version.
All that being said, surely we realize that no one in this community who *is* a credible psychologist would diagnose *anyone* with *anything* based on the descriptions in one post or one set of screenshots *because no one can ethically do that.* The thing about human brains is that we all have one. All brains can only perform a set number of functions. We all have the same limits to our behavior, (though some are not functioning at full capacity or potential.)
To put it another way: None of us can fly, but that does not mean that everyone who is walking is coming from the same direction. The point is that the visible symptoms of wildly different mental health disorders can look *extremely similar* but have completely divergent causes. No one can just assess the patterns in a short exchange between 2 people and learn enough to be definitive.
I know most people do not come here and expect to get an accurate diagnosis of a mental health condition. I know people largely understand that our commenters are not acting in the capacity of a doctor or a lawyer when we give our two cents. I know we aren't stupid in here by any stretch. However, there is *still* a huge problem with saying an abuser "seems to have untreated BPD or NPD or ASPD or LMNOP..." Being abusive and having a personality disorder *are very different things.* Obviously, the two conditions can exist in the same person, but they do not as often as everybody seems to think they do in this community. That is probably due to so many abusers using mental health issues for an alibi and so many victims/survivors using that delusional justification to make sense of their reality when they don't have any other explanation and don't want to leave.
**Throwing around the idea that abusive people have personality disorders or bipolar is extremely dangerous for victims of emotional abuse.**
When victims of abuse are told that their abuser is behaving like a monster because they have a mental illness, that can be *detrimental* to the mind of the victim because our trauma-bonded brains are desperate for any explanation that will hold intact our delusions about the abuser being a good and loveable person deep down.
**I stayed for 5 years, even after being *set on fire (!)* AND after he was put in jail for again *attempting my murder (!)* because I thought his mental illness made him do it.** I did not stay because I was stupid.
THIS IS THE MASSIVE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN HAVING A PERSONALITY DISORDER AND BEING ABUSIVE: The former is a mental health problem and the latter is *not.*
Anyone in this community who knows anything about how emotional abuse (the type of abuse that precedes every other kind) works absolutely *can* identify when a person is abusive based on the descriptions in one post or one set of screenshots *because abuse is not a mental illness.*
We **can** spot abuse but have no business guessing at mental health problems because being abusive is about the way abusive people view *the world.* Being abusive is not an inability or a disability. People who are abusive act in *very repetitive, very recognizable patterns* because of the hamster cage that they see around them that we will never see. (We can not see the world the way they do. In that way, it can be similar to mental illness, but only in that way. More on this further down.) They do the things they do for very, very different reasons than people with BPD or NPD or schizoaffective or PTSD do them-- but because all brains can only perform in a set number of ways, being abusive and having a health problem *can easily look like the same thing.*
Compound that with the fact that abusive people certainly *can* have mental health problems just like anybody else, and the whole thing gets very murky very fast, and the trauma-bonded brain can use this shit to keep a victim underwater forever.
This is in the research. **Having a mental illness and having an abusive mindset *do not* correlate.** I know that it makes our brains buck to think that *not* everything bizarre that a person might do is related to an illness. Because we conflate the symptoms of personality disorders with abusive tendencies, we have already confirmed our own bias on this topic before anybody cares to read the articles and review the statistics. Surprise! Now, somehow, *everyone* who cheats is a narcissist. Now, somehow, *everyone* who push-pulls is borderline.
*Someone being habitually mean and difficult does NOT an abuser make!*
When one person screams, it is because they are childish and think that expressing themselves that way is necessary to get what they need.
When another person screams, it is because they are childish and love watching the person they are screaming at get scared and upset.
*Do you see the massive difference here?*
**Both are screaming the same thing-- so how do I know which is which?** That is why I am a stickler for the language we are using and the appropriate definitions of things because it does not help anyone when we get it wrong.
**What happens if I choose wrong?** If I choose the abusive one instead of the sick one, they will hypnotize me with emotional abuse and eventually murder me. I tested this theory out *twice!*
To repeat, so no one thinks I forgot while writing this, people who are abusive can also be mentally ill. All people who are mentally ill need professional guidance, not a magical partner with a delusional belief that they can heal another telepathically because "their Love is special-er." Mental health is more complicated than that. Abuse, however, is not!
That is because when I refer to *abusive patterns,* I am not talking about *antisocial behaviors* or *emotional outbursts* or *maladaptive coping.* Abusive behavior *includes* those things, and the symptoms of cluster B disorders include those things, but an abuser has *patterns* that a purely mentally ill person does not. Just because a sick person *has patterns* does not make them *abuse* patterns, either.
**Abuse patterns do not vary.** Every single abusive relationship will follow the same exact shape because that is how the mind of an abuser functions and how the damage of the cycle of abuse affect the human brain of the victim.
This is the shape of an abuse relationship:
**1** First off will be a line that shoots upwards at a steep incline to represent a sudden, overwhelming, life-changing, whirlwind romance that *will* accelerate the appropriate timeline for a new relationship in order to get the victim drunk on infatuation. A person being lovebombed is intoxicated, and the abuser is getting them as high as possible while moving them (mentally) to an isolated second location-- *like a kidnapper.*
**2** The initial abuses are emotional and very subtle. These are tailored to the victim just like the lovebombing. Each abuse is a circle because it is followed by love bombs, hoovering, and maybe promising to change. The most important thing about this part of the shape is that the circle *always, always, always* get bigger every time. Even if they have progressed to hitting and then stop for a while, the emotional abuse *still* gets worse, even if they change tactics or styles.
**3** The end of an abusive relationship, if the victim does not escape, is increasingly large circles that *never, ever, ever stop coming* until either the victim or the abuser is dead.
>The unfortunate thing is every situation is different...
While it is true that every person is unique, no situation is special. When it comes to identifying an abusive person, every situation is *exactly* the same. The shape of an abusive relationship never varies. Ever. It can be chopped mercifully short when a victim escapes and survives. Left to continue on its natural path, the escalation of the cycle will always look the same. The way an abuser thinks, talks, and walks belies the kind of world they think we are living in because only someone who thinks the world works like they do would act this specific way. In this pattern. In this sequence. For these reasons.
I wrought havoc in my personal relationships when my BPD was untreated. I was manipulative, selfish, volatile, mean, prone to outbursts and threats.
**What I did not understand:**
*Abusive* is a term with a specific definition. *Abusive* is NOT a synonym for being manipulative, selfish, volatile, mean, or prone to outbursts and threats. Abusive people *are* often manipulative, selfish, volatile, mean, and prone to outbursts and threats, too-- but their reasons for being that way are **very different** than someone who is mentally ill.
What I think gets *mistaken* for an abusive relationship oftentimes is a loving relationship between two deeply unwell and deeply co-dependent people. These two are treating each other very poorly, just as an abusive person treats their victim very poorly, but this is what I mean when I say they have the same symptoms but different causes.
**1** When *both* partners know that the relationship is unhealthy-- that can't be an abusive relationship. By definition.
**2** When *both* partners seek individual therapy to work on their own mental health issues independently so they stop hurting each other-- that can't be an abusive relationship. By definition.
**3** When an unhealthy, co-dependent relationship *improves* incrementally over time through hard work and dedication to a treatment plan-- that definitely is not an abusive relationship. By definition.
(At **2** is where it is usyally best for two sick people to part ways, if possible, at least for a while. **This shape is not abusive.**)
WELL, HOW DO I KNOW IF IT IS ABUSE, NOT ILLNESS?
You come to a community like this so we can examine the evidence and tell you if it is abuse!!! I can't tell you if they have a cluster B disorder, but I can call out abuse with almost unfailing accuracy. (It is easy when you are *not* the one being abused.)
The cool thing about abusive patterns is that *they never vary.* Even the most mentally ill person on Earth won't act out the shape of an abusive relationship. They can make some crazy unhealthy shapes-- but not the abusive one. **If it is shaped like abuse, it is abuse.**
Because of my life experience, I have gotten exceptionally good at recognizing abuse when I see it. I have found that it is sometimes easier to see abuse in the statements made by victims. **We all say the same things.** Abusers, though, do not have any new tricks and are just as easy to spot even from a very short description. (Mental illness is not like that. STOP talking on here like it is, if you care about helping.)
MAKE NO MISTAKE. IT DOESN'T MATTER if it is abuse or not, because if someone is treating you poorly enough that you come here to find out if it might be, *then WAKE UP NOW!* You are *way* out of your depth and need to stop being delusional and quit dreaming that your magical fairy princess manic pixie energy or deeply impressive and manly need to save everybody but yourself is going to do fnck-all for someone who needs medical treatment. Get real.
Regardless of how mentally ill someone is or how badly they behave when they are sick, what they are suffering from is always related to a need for Love and Care. Very often, they lack Self-Love.
An abusive person is *never* saying what they say and doing what they do because they need more Love and Care. **No.** (Come to my profile if you want to read more about what abuse does to victims and what abusers need.)
When a victim gets these two confused and tries to pour Love onto an abusive person, thinking they are mentally ill, they are *lighting themselves on fire.*
Please don't help them light themselves on fire to keep an abuser warm.
Everyone who does has a heart in the best place, but.....
When victims come here to ask if what they are suffering is abusive, *they want us to tell them that it is **not** abuse but some kind of bizarre illness that can be healed* because they are deeply trauma-bonded!!!
I thought my abuser needed Therapy and Love and Help. People on the internet told me that was true because he clearly had NPD or BPD or ASPD or XYZ *and I was desperate to believe them* because that meant my abuser could get better and "the good times" would eventually come back *if I tried hard enough* to get him help. WE ALL KNOW THAT IS A PROBLEM. An abusive relationship hinges on one belief. It is one destructive belief that keeps a victim locked in Hell: the belief that if they try hard enough, "the good times" will come back.
I barely survived believing it was true. <3
Please stop saying abusive people are ill. It is cruel even when it is well-intentioned and gets people killed.