r/Abortiondebate • • Jan 03 '22

I think we're close to making abortion unthinkable.

4 Upvotes

In the near future abortion will be unthinkable, legality won't be the issue.

Medical advancement, not legislation, will bring an end to the abortion debate. OBGYN & NICU research, not political authoritarians, will spare the woman trauma and spare the fetus from death. Here's how:

I genuinely believe that in 50 years of medical advancement, it will be equally safe for the mother to extract and incubate the fetus in an exo-womb [1] as it is for her to have a dilation/forceps or suction/aspiration or chemical abortion.

When there is no risk to the mother, the only question remaining is "can I kill this?" Bodily autonomy will then be completely off the table.

At that time, I suspect that abortion will be seen as a savage, racist, and barbaric medical practice, more so than slavery or blood-letting or Tuskegee or leeches.

No one on the right side of history every said "they're not actually people".

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/25/15421734/artificial-womb-fetus-biobag-uterus-lamb-sheep-birth-premie-preterm-infant


r/Abortiondebate • • Jun 01 '23

Understand the Pro Life Position Even if You Disagree

4 Upvotes

Greetings all. This is your friendly neighborhood pro lifer who is taking some time away from typing enraging responses (😉) to share a few insights from my interactions with you fine people on this august subreddit.

I want to help folks better understand the pro life position so that if you are not pro life, you can better understand where we are coming from and thus know better how to attack or oppose the pro life position.

Keep in mind this is how we as pro life folks think and process experiences. We in the pro life community acknowledge the humanity of the child in his or her mother’s womb. This means we conclude the child is a human person. In the pro life community we hold that the child being in his or her mother’s womb doesn’t mean that the child is somehow less than a human person. So one way to understand the pro life perspective - even if you disagree - is to ask would we think this is ok to do to a born child like a toddler, infant or newborn. That will help to clarify a ton of questions. Not that you will agree, but it will help understand the pro life thought process.

So a question I see a lot here is given the difficulties of pregnancy shouldn’t woman be allowed to abort at will. To know the pro life response ahead of time, ask yourself should the difficulties of raising a born child allow the mother to kill her child. Why? This is exactly how this question is perceived in the pro life mind given that we view no qualitative, humane, or moral difference between the child in the womb and any born human being.

If what you are asking cannot be done to a born child, then when you ask us in the pro life community about abortion under that circumstance it should be clear what we will say and why.

If a born child stretched your body or caused you distress in someway unintentionally can you kill your born child?

If you decide you no longer want your born child can you kill them?

If your newborn child needs help can you citing bodily autonomy ignore them and let them die?

If your born child constantly is a vector for debilitating colds and flues can you kill them?

If your born child causes you great mental distress can you kill them?

Since it doesn’t make sense to kill your child in these situations, it doesn’t make sense to us in the pro life community to kill the unborn in those situations given what I have stated above.

Now of course it makes sense to attack or debate whether or not the child in the womb is a human person, human, has rights, bodily autonomy, etc. I am just hoping that this helps to clarify and thus sharpen the debate points.


By the way I just want to say I am enjoying this subreddit so much. Thanks also to all the folks who take the time to engage with me. I am learning so much about how people I don’t agree with view the world and I am enjoying it. Please forgive my occasional snark - I am working on that so don’t abort…😳😂🙂I mean don’t give up on me. I am getting better. I respect everyone.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 15 '23

Question for pro-choice Tom and Suzy only aborted females

0 Upvotes

Dear PC'ers,

I've written a hypothetical scenario between a fictitious couple by the names of Tom (man) and Suzy (woman) where abortion would be permissible from a PC perspective, but goes strongly against our moral intuitions.

Tom and Suzy marry at the age of 27 and 25 respectively, and decide to start a family 1 year into their marriage.

Before getting married (while in early talking stages), they discussed the idea of raising a family consisting only of male children. They discovered, from research, that female children cost a great deal more than male children [1], and decided that a male-child-only household was best for their future goals.

After years of building their family, they're preganancy and abortion timeline looks like this:

F1 - Aborted (2023) F2 - Aborted (2023) M1 - Kept (2024) F3 - Aborted (2026) M2 - Kept (2025) F4 - Aborted (2027) F5 - Aborted (2027) M3 - Kept (2027) M4 - Kept (2028) F6 - Aborted (2031)

At no point in the relationship, or otherwise, was Suzy's bodily autonomy violated. She made her choice every time while of sober mind and in her full senses. Tom was never involved in her decisions. She knew from before starting a serious relationship with Tom that they were both going to start a male-child-only household.

Do PC'ers find anything wrong with Tom and Suzy deciding, as a couple, to perform 6 sex-selective abortions across the period of time?

Surely, since Suzy's bodily autonomy was not violated in this scenario, there is nothing wrong with this outcome?

To reiterate, they were sex-selective was because they viewed the female sex to be the more expensive [1], and harder to raise [2] sex and, therefore, opted to lovingly select for a male-child-only family.

Do PC'ers find anything wrong with this fictional case of sex-selective abortion?

(N.B. My stance has always been pro-life as I believe human rights begin at conception. This scenario is intended to highlight a weak spot in the case of the pro-choice side, which illustrates that a family could lovingly make the choice to select for a particular sex when having kids).


Sources / Citations:

1: https://www.refinery29.com/en-us/2016/06/113597/boy-or-girl-baby-more-expensive

2: https://www.google.com/amp/s/turnto10.com/amp/news/nbc-10-news-at-4/poll-easier-to-raise-boys-girls-gender-sex-popular-baby-names-drop-out-college-finish-high-school-adhd-cognitive-decline-sons-daughters-births


r/Abortiondebate • • Aug 12 '26

General debate Pro choice people: genuine question about why late term abortion is acceptable

0 Upvotes

I saw in the news that the Massachusetts governor is allowing abortions up until birth. I am pro life so to me that sounds horrible. Why would someone decide to abort their baby late in the pregnancy? What is going through a woman’s mind when she decides to get one? When I think of an abortion i think of the baby. How far they have developed and can’t imagine putting a stop to their growth. Hearing their heartbeat, seeing them in the sonogram, imagining their tiny body. I am genuinely curious, please don’t be mean in the comments to anyone.


r/Abortiondebate • • Nov 21 '22

General debate You are sometimes morally obligated to let others use your body

0 Upvotes

This post does not concern the moral permissibility of abortion, but just provides some counterexamples to a premise commonly used to support arguments for the moral permissibility of abortion. That premise may be expressed as:

P: No one is ever morally obligated to allow another to use their body

On its face, this premise seems reasonable. In the violinist thought experiment, which does not need to be elucidated upon in this subreddit, it's clear that there is no obligation for you to provide your organs for the violinist to use. You can if you want to, but it's not morally necessary.

But I would contend that the parent-child relationship raises issues for this premise. Consider the following thought experiment:

Case 1: Your child is rushed to the ER. The doctor hurriedly informs you that she has contracted a rare blood disease, and she needs a blood donation immediately or she will die painfully. Due to the nature of the disease, she needs the blood of a close genetic relative. You are the only person who can donate the blood in time.

Are you morally obligated to donate your blood in Case 1? It seems obvious that you are. What I mean by a moral obligation is a duty to act a certain way out of moral necessity. In the violinist thought experiment, there is no morally right or wrong answer. Staying connected would be heroic, but ultimately there is no blame if you decide to disconnect; you're not required to go the extra mile. But in Case 1, there is a clear wrong answer: letting your child die. Legally, the state has no say in what you do with your body. Morally, you have no choice. If you let your child die, we wouldn't merely say that you failed to go above and beyond for her; we would judge you harshly and call you a selfish and immoral person. You have done something wrong.

Therefore, P is false. We expect parents to provide all sorts of things for their children (or find someone who can), whether that's food, water, shelter, clothing, love, emotional support, etc, and suffer minor and major inconveniences to do so, and reserve our most severe criticism for those who can but fail to. It doesn't seem to be the case that there is a line drawn at the parent's bodies that can never be crossed.

It also doesn't seem to be the case that it matters that blood donations are minimally invasive (compared to donations of other body parts) and temporary. Consider the case of a parent of a child with End-Stage Renal Disease who will die soon if she doesn't receive a kidney from that parent. We'd come to the same conclusion: you would be an immoral person if you let your child die and refused to donate your kidney, even though kidney donation is very invasive and permanent.

I would maintain, then, that the limits of parental obligation do not have to do with the *kind* of resource that must be provided to the child (financial, emotional, corporal), or the temporal duration of the provision, but the risk and burden to the parent. Given that the mother-fetus relationship (assuming the fetus is a person for the sake of argument) is a parent-child relationship where the parent cannot find someone else to provide for the child's needs, the question for the abortion debate is whether pregnancy and childbirth are the types of things we'd expect parents to go through to keep their children alive. I will not argue either way; my only intention was to disprove P.

Now, if you've gotten this far, you may be wondering why the moral permissibility of abortion matters when it's the legal permissibility that determines whether abortion is widely available or not. Of course, in Case 1, the state cannot come in and tie you down and extract your blood to give to your child. While legalizing abortion would certainly be a win for pro-choice advocates, I'd argue that pro-choice people have an interest in portraying abortion as more like the violinist thought experiment (a personal decision to which there is no wrong answer) than Case 1 (letting your child die), as this would mean that women who seek and obtain abortions would not be discouraged and stigmatized.


r/Abortiondebate • • 11d ago

General debate Did having kids change your view on abortion?

0 Upvotes

Recently my wife got pregnant and we started having ultrasounds and such. She's at like week 11 now.

I've started to feel a little differently about abortion now that we're doing this. I think I used to feel a little more open about it, but even at 10 weeks the fetus was really start to look like a baby, and we could see her flipping around and stuff during the ultrasound.

I think its still good to allow abortion in cases of rape and when the mom's life is in danger. But I thinking having an abortion after 10 weeks is a lot more brutal than I would have thought before.

I know though that its really hard for most women to carry. My sister in law for instance had extreme nausea and vomiting her whole pregnancy. It's hard to judge when abortion should or shouldnt be allowed, but I think it is a pretty heavy decision to make.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jun 01 '19

Thee is no such thing as forcing a woman to be pregnant. There is no such thing as a forced pregnancy. These things literally do not exist.

0 Upvotes

There are things you can do to another person. Legal or illegal, good or bad, these are things that are physically possible: You can insult them, kick them, cut them, imprison them, experiment on them, execute them, dismember them, punch them, break them, feed them, provide for them, kill them...

But it's not possible for me or anybody else to force a woman to be pregnant. Her body does that. Her body does that whether she wants to be pregnant or not. Her body provides a place for an embryo to attach and develop. Her body grows a placenta. Her body provides nourishment for the her fetus/child. Her body provides it with oxygen.

These are all involuntary; It's not a willful choice. It's like her heart beating. It's like her liver filtering her blood. It's like her stomach digesting food. It's like her hair or fingernails growing.

I don't make women grow hair. It is literally impossible for me to do that. It's her body doing it, and there's no physical way for me to cause it to happen.

Pregnancy is the same. (To be clear, it is physically possible to rape a woman or otherwise inject semen into her to impregnate her against her will. This is evil and wrong, obviously.) But it is not possible to force a woman to be pregnant. It's literally, objectively, impossible.

So, if it's literally impossible to force a woman to be pregnant, you can try to argue that if I ban abortion, in effect I am forcing a woman to be pregnant. I reject this wholesale. Because, still, I am not forcing the condition on anybody. That is still, objectively, what is happening. By stopping Option B, I am not forcing Option A. Option A is what already was. I didn't bring about Option A, and I'm not causing Option A.

Lastly, is banning Option B a restriction? You bet! You bet it restricts one's actions and choices! But that is the debate. The question is "is this restriction warranted?" In other words, is restricting one choice—one possible outcome—a reasonable thing to do?

But the debate isn't about forcing women to do anything. Nobody is forcing them to do anything or to be pregnant. That doesn't even make logical sense. It's about restricting—or not restricting—a single choice.

Edit: TLDR SUMMARY. I'm saying this debate is about whether or not we will allow people to perform abortions. It is not a debate about forcing women to do anything.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 11 '23

General debate On the "Forced Birth" argument

1 Upvotes

If you have been here a while you have probably seen the "Forced Birther" argument.

To be blunt: I think the argument is a red herring. I believe that in many circumstances, it detracts from meaningful conversation about abortion, and I will discuss that below.

THE CLAIM

The following is an attempt to "strongman" the argument. I've included as many elements of the argument as possible in as clear a format as I can. I am not trying to dismiss this argument, I am trying to represent it fairly.

"Refusing women the liberty to choose abortion forces women to be pregnant and makes the government, and PLers in general, complicit in a harm which is tantamount to rape and slavery."

There are good reasons to use this argument. It is a powerful argument, and it's hard to oppose because:

  1. The harm of pregnancy is very real, and very significant. Nobody wants to cause human suffering, and everybody should want to minimize human suffering.

  2. The government promises certain rights and liberties, such as self determination and the right to privacy. Government interference in individual lives should be as limited as possible.

THE PROBLEM

The "Forced Birth" argument ultimately assets that opposition to abortion is an inherently bad thing, and it does so with panache. But what it neglects is the argument that abortion is itselfna permissible act. It does not argue that we have a right to abortion, and it doesn't not prove that people should be entitled to pursue it.

There are strong reasons to believe abortion isn't a permissible act:

  1. We know that the ZEF is a distinct living organism.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2672893/#:~:text=The%20somatic%20cell%20is%20something,developing%20and%20complete%20human%20organism.

2. We know that the ZEF is a member of the species homo sapiens.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15675036/#:~:text=It%20is%20an%20undeniable%20empirical,from%20the%20moment%20of%20conception.

3. We know that abortion causes the death of the ZEF.

https://www.siue.edu/~evailat/el10.html

4. We know that killing a human is homicide.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/homicide

5. We know that if a homicide is neither excused or justified, then it violates the spirit of the law.

https://law.jrank.org/pages/7401/Homicide-Justifiable-or-Excusable-Homicide.html

This leaves us with a very important question which is central to the abortion debate: is abortion legally justifiable? A justifiable homicide is fully permissible, but an unjustifiable homicide ultimately is impermissible in a just society. There are lots of arguments somebody could make here to support abortion: necessity, self defense, bodily autonomy, etc.

However: the "Forced Birth" argument makes none of these claims. It states that regardless of the status of abortion as permissible or impermissible, it is wrong of you to interfere.

REBUTTALS

Earlier I mentioned some strengths of the "Forced Birth" argument, and I think it ties into the statement I just mentioned.

  1. Above, I mentioned that nobody wants to cause human suffering. However, our laws do, and they do so quite often.

When the actions which one takes to alleviate their suffering are unjustifiable or impermissible, the law halts those actions even. A starving man who could murder for bread would still be found guilty of murder. A terminal patient, whose only hope for recovery is to force another to donate organs, would be barred from harming others to promote their own recovery. There are countless cases where somebody could alleviate their own suffering through an impermissible act, and the government prevents them from doing so.

McFall v. Shimp, the landmark case which produced rhe doctrine of Bodily Autonomy, ruled that McFall could not compel Shimp to undergo medical treatment even to save his life. McFall was suffering, and ultimately died. The government prevented McFall from alleviating his suffering, because the vehicle through which he sought recovery was unjust. Was the government therefore complicit in McFall's suffering and eventual death? Maybe, but that complicity was insufficient to justify an unjustified act.

https://hulr.org/spring-2021/mcfall-v-shimp-and-the-case-for-bodily-autonomy

Above, I mentioned how the government promises rights like privacy and autonomy. However, these rights to privacy are not absolute.

As just one example, a law officer normally requires a warrant or permission to enter someone's home. People are constitutionally entitled to privacy within their own home. However, there are many exigent circumstances which would allow that same officer to disregard this right to privacy. For example, if an officer believes that a homicide is occurring or about to occur, they can enter a home without any legal authorization.

The government's authority to intercede in the lives of its citizens is justly curtailed by many factors. However, one of the most common and compelling interests of the state and federal government is the protection of life. This legitimate interest is further enshrined in the doctrine of Parens Patriae which states that the government has a duty to act on behalf of those who are unable to advocate for themselves, such as children. The government has a right and duty to interfere in the private choices of individuals where those choices cause the death of others.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/parens_patriae

CONCLUSION

It may be true that the government gets "blood on its hands" by preventing abortion. However, that blood does not justify abortion. If abortion is a homicide, and if no valid justification can be given, then the government not only can intercede: it should. We do so in countless cases already, even when it causes people like Robert McFall to suffer and die.

The "Forced Birther" argument is a strong one, and it has a place here, but it cannot answer the core question of abortion: is the act of abortion permissible, or is it impermissible.


r/Abortiondebate • • Aug 09 '21

The ZEF is not an intruder and abortion is unjust.

0 Upvotes
  1. To intrude requires that one put themselves where they are not invited. The ZEF doesn’t exist until sperm and ovum combine in the uterus, so to label him an intruder is wholly illogical. You cannot put yourself somewhere before you exist since you can’t do anything before you exist.

  2. In 99 percent of cases, the mother allowed a penis to ejaculate semen inside her vagina. Sure, she may have taken steps to reduce the risk of conception through birth control and condoms, but so long as she allows a penis to ejaculate inside her vagina, the risk is there. Conception is 100% the parents’ doing and the ZEF bears no responsibility whatsoever.

  3. It is not the ZEF’s fault that he must rely on the safety of his mother’s uterus to survive. It’s his parents’ fault, and they must bear the burden of that responsibility. Since no one can kill innocent human beings to rectify the consequences of their actions, to kill the ZEF who was forced by his parents actions to rely on a person’s body for nine months would be unjust.


r/Abortiondebate • • Aug 08 '22

General debate Most countries have abortion limits, why? Is this regressive/oppressive towards women?

2 Upvotes

Pick your liberal/progressive bastion and they have a limit

Norway, 12 weeks

Sweden, 18 weeks

Finland, 12 weeks

Germany, 12 weeks

France, 12 weeks

UK, 24 weeks

Netherlands, 24 weeks

Belgium, 12 - 14 weeks

etc...

The bodily autonomy argument posits that no person should have a right to any other person's body, no matter the circumstance... the sanctity of bodily autonomy should protect abortion with zero limitations or restrictions.

Given this, do you think these country's limits are an affront to women's rights? Why do you think they have set these limits?

EDIT: My questions are quite clear... I'm not asking about how these limits compare to the US, I'm not asking about exemptions they might offer, I'm not asking about the state of universal health-care... I am asking, do you think these country's limits are an affront to women's rights? Why do you think they have set these limits?

EDIT 2: Ima stop responding now... the complete inability to answer such impossibly simple questions is astounding


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 07 '21

Why is there no argument against having sex? NSFW

6 Upvotes

EDIt: I AM NOT PRO-LIFE!!!!! I AM ANTI STUPID

I don’t understand this. This whole thing should be simple.

If you want a baby, you have sex to make one. That’s kind of the point of sex after all.... in cast anyone cares about science or biology.

If you don’t want a baby, you don’t have sex.

I have yet to hear an argument for why people can’t be celibate or abstinent (is there a difference?) People just say “it’s natural” ....ok and?

Not sure if you heard, but it’s been scientifically proven that abstinence has been 100% effective in preventing unwanted pregnancies

Is self control not a thing? If you absolutely have to succumb to your cave man urges, Are dildos and flesh lights not a thing? It seems to me abortion is just a product of people being stupid. If people were smart and didn’t have sex if they didn’t want to roll those dice, they wouldn’t put penises in vaginas

———————————————————————

***EDIT Dang thank y’all, I should have worded this post better. Lots of assumptions being done on the part of dishonest actors here. Let me clear some stuff up.

  1. I am not against sexual activity

I’m part of many subs that are related to homemade porn, from milfs, to anal, to feet, to hentai (some of those are combined) I’m personally a serial masturbator. I have no issue with sexual activity. In the original post I said use your toys all you want. Even I’m not above succumbing to instincts. But sexual activity doesn’t have to mean getting pregnant. You can be sexual in a responsible way

2) I’m not even against casual sex if done correctly

If everyone who had sex without wanting kids either had their ovaries/uterus removed or had castration, I’d tell you to go out there and have all the non baby sex you want. Because you’re doing it properly and the responsible way. It is indeed possible to have sex in this way that prevents pregnancy

The main point of my post was addressing people who weren’t on this camp

The people who think having sex even if it risks pregnancy is ok. My point was that you can just not have sex. I will still actively maintain that sex Is not mandatory for humans (YES I’m willing to die on that hill) and that if you were in this camp, it’s stupid and abstinence makes abortion unnecessary (no one has refuted this yet)

Maybe you’ve read all this and still want to have sex that risks pregnancy. Then my only word to you is to live with the consequences. Get knocked up when you didn’t want to? Enjoy your bastard child for 18 years. I’m not defending abortion because all it does is give people the green light and a get out of jail free card to be reckless with where they ejaculate. And I don’t believe in rewarding stupid behavior. That’s all abortion does. It’s upholding and encouraging being reckless and getting pregnant.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 03 '22

General debate This is the basis of my pro-life stance, as simply put as possible

4 Upvotes

I’m sick in bed and wanna have some good conversations to distract me from how bad my throat hurts.

My pro-life reasoning goes like this

  1. The fetus is biologically human

  2. The fetus is a living being

Therefore, regardless of development, the fetus is objectively a living human being.

3. Abortion causes a fetus to no longer be alive

4. If the fetus is alive, no longer being alive means it has been killed

Therefore, abortion is the killing of a living human being.

5. The killing of an innocent human being is wrong

6. While not everything wrong should be illegal, certain things, such as killing innocent human beings, should be illegal.

Therefore, abortion is the killing of a living human being, which is wrong, and should be outlawed.

I know there are other posts like this, but this is my take on it. Hopefully numbering it out makes it easier to specifically describe what part of my argument people disagree with

Edit: to clarify, I support an exception for the health of the mother. I oppose elective abortion


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 10 '23

What If We Discovered the Child In The Womb Is Sentient?

0 Upvotes

I have always wondered what PC folks would decide about abortion if it was discovered that the child in the womb was indeed sentient. Engage with this question as a hypothetical if you wish.

If it were determined, scientifically, that indeed the child in the womb is sentient, would you still support abortion until before birth? Why or why not? If you don't support abortion up until before birth, would the discovery of the child's sentience matter or in any way impact your position?

While the question is directed mainly at PC, anyone can reply. I am curious to know people's thoughts.

Thanks good people.

Edit: To be clear, I do not think sentience is what makes abortion wrong. Abortion is wrong regardless of whether or not the baby in the womb is sentient. Abortion is wrong because a human being is being killed. That human being's level of development (e.g. sentience, verbal communication skills, etc.), age, type of dependency, etc. is irrelevant. Human beings have moral worth and value because of what they are - a human being.

As indicated above, this question is being asked to see what (mainly PC) folks think.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jul 07 '25

New to the debate Discussion Take: Abortion highlights the pliability of morals (and brings us face to face with ourselves)

1 Upvotes

This isn’t for or against abortion. It’s just something I’ve noticed. I’m not red or blue; honestly, both sides seem a little unhinged sometimes. I’m still in high school, but I remember when Roe v. Wade got overturned. And here’s the thing: to me, it all seems a lot simpler than people make it. Everyone’s skating around the real issue. I’ve heard the religious arguments, the moral arguments, the scientific ones, about whether it’s a fetus, a baby, a clump of cells. But at this point, that clarification doesn’t mean much to me. Because no matter how you label it, both sides are avoiding the same uncomfortable truth: nobody wants to say they’re okay with killing a child.

That’s a hard thing to say out loud. So instead, we argue about terminology. “Fetus” sounds sterile. “Tumor” sounds impersonal. But say “child,” and now you’ve got a moral crisis on your hands. So we soften the blow with words, wrap it in medical jargon or legal speak, and pretend we’re still good people. But something is being ended, and deep down, we know it. And that’s the part that scares people. We like to believe we’re moral. Civilized. Compassionate. But abortion forces us to look in the mirror and admit something darker: sometimes, we’ll choose to end a life—and not regret it. Some women do mourn. Others don’t. And that’s the reality. The idea that a woman might go through with it willingly, maybe even gladly, breaks the picture we’ve painted of women as natural nurturers.

So we attack the people who threaten those ideals. We threaten them with prison and call them horrible, awful people when in truth, this is a very human thing to do. Suddenly, people have to reckon with the truth that yes—if we want to, we’ll kill. And we’ll find ways to feel okay about it. Doctors get blamed. Mothers get vilified. Laws come down. But abortion never stopped. It just moved around. Because here’s the truth: all killing is terrible, but some, we’ve decided, is tolerable, as long as we call it by the right name. So what’s my point? As humans, we need to grow a pair and own the ugly sides of ourselves. Stop hiding behind pretty words and moral gymnastics. If we’re going to do the hard things, we should at least have the guts to admit what they are.

To pose some constructive questions to you all: Am I the only one who thinks the real debate isn’t about when life begins, but how honest we’re willing to be about ending it? Do you think most people on either side are actually being honest about what abortion really is?

PS: This is a repost because I violated rule 2. Sorry! Never posted here before and I should have read the rules.

PSS: I’m done, lol. You guys…keep trucking. I should have done my research.


r/Abortiondebate • • Nov 26 '22

General debate Where do you draw the line?

1 Upvotes

To me, drawing the line at conception is the only valid option.

(A lot of people may be annoyed at me for using the word conception, because technically the mother isn’t pregnant yet. This doesn’t matter, because it’s usually 4 weeks after conception before some realises they’re pregnant.)

Drawing it at a “significant developmental stage” is hard, because it’s a gradual process. If we were to draw a very specific line, for example, limbs being a very specific length, I struggle to see how it is moral that we value one life more than the other, potentially due to a couple of cm.

Also, what do we do if there are defects, causing the distortion of certain features, potentially meaning the foetus never crosses the line until birth.

Birth, or “first breath” makes no sense to me. This point also links to viability. Firstly, I don’t see why a child should be valued out side of the womb, more than inside of the womb. Yes, one is taking nutrients from the mother. But, does this mean we can abort 1 hour before birth? What about 3? 6? My point is, we still cannot draw a definitive line.

How about sentience?

“Thus, 18 to 25 weeks is considered the earliest stage at which the lower boundary of sentience could be placed.” https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.3109/14767059209161911 Again, very vague. Also:

“People who are genuinely in a coma have no cognitive function and no motor responses – they cannot think and they cannot move. But some people may appear to be in a coma even though they are in fact conscious to some degree” https://ec.europa.eu/research-and-innovation/en/horizon-magazine/brainwave-scanners-unlocking-hidden-lives-coma-patients

People who are genuinely in a coma have no cognitive function. Just like a foetus before 18 weeks.

If by any chance I got any details wrong, please correct me in responses. I would appreciate anyone who gives me a valid line to be drawn, without implementing other arguments such as “the foetus is intruding mothers bodily autonomy”. But, I’m happy to debate relevant arguments.


r/Abortiondebate • • Apr 18 '24

Can a husband get mad at a wife who wants an abortion?

0 Upvotes

This post got me wondering so I thought I'd ask it here. If a couple is trying to get pregnant, woman conceives, her and hubs are happy, then she changes her mind and aborts the baby, is there any validity to him getting angry with her? If abortion is truly no more than a woman getting a haircut or going to the bathroom after a bad Vietnamese dinner, what is there for him to be upset about? If the answer to this changes at a certain part of the pregnancy, which part?

I was surprised how many commenters were defending the hubby here, although I'm well aware the post itself was probably fake like most posts on that sub are. Maybe these answers will surprise me too.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 25 '19

What could be the pozitive effects of banning abortion?

3 Upvotes

The benefits are plentiful while there are few downfalls, if at all, any to the bill.

Here are some positives that will definitely result from the bill:

  • An unborn (not fatally defected) child will be granted the human right to life. (step up in human moral evolution here; people once considered slavery moral and here we are with the moral knowledge that tells us otherwise). They will also come into this world wanted (either from adoption or from the bio parents stepping up and choosing to keep and raise the child).

  • Women will take more responsibility for their reproductive systems. That’s right. Your body, your choice. When the option of easily getting rid of their pregnancy is taken, they will have to put more effort, thought, and choice into how they deal with their own bodies. They will be the ones to decide which method of birth control or sterilization best fits their lifestyle. They will be more insistent on their partner’s birth control or sterilization as well. They will be way more conscious of the choices they make and what consequences they may have.

  • Men will have the option to father and keep the child! With abortion, men had no option to father the child if the woman didn’t want to carry it. Now men have the right to choose if they want to be a parent as well.

  • Couples desiring children will find it easier and less expensive to adopt. They will not have to go through expensive international adoptions. Local adoptions are cheaper (with travel costs) They will not have to wait years on end for the opportunity for a baby to come along.

  • There will be easier access to birth control and sterilization. Insurance companies will find it cheaper to provide birth control and even sterilization procedures than to cover the cost of an average US pregnancy (which is $30,000).

Here are some positives that will most likely stem from the bill:

  • There will be LESS religious influence and bias with adoption. Lots of adoption agencies are through religious organizations because religion is often the reason for not getting abortions (some of which will use their religion to get the pregnant teen in their shelter to give up their baby and then gain profit from the adoption costs). With babies being born not in religious shelters, there will be a greater chance for atheists, same-sex couples, and anyone who doesn’t fit the “perfect Christian family” stereotype to be able to adopt a child.

  • SAME SEX COUPLES WILL HAVE GREATER OPPORTUNITIES FOR ADOPTION

  • Men will take greater responsibility for their reproductive systems as well. When the pregnancy isn’t allowed to be rid of, they will be forced to be more responsible for their own birth control and insisting on their partners. Increase in the interest in developing a male birth control. Now that men are made more responsible, they will be looking for more options than just condoms.

  • Increase in research and development in female birth control reliability, methods, and types.** Increase in knowledge of human reproductive systems (that comes with the studying of such systems for development of birth controls). Women are always complaining that female anatomy is neglected in understanding yet the research into contraception will lead to more information discovered.

  • Increase in fetal and pediatric medical knowledge (fatal fetal conditions will be investigated and debated which will lead to further research in the area).

  • Sex will mean more to some people. With increased risk, it will take on a more emotional meaning.

  • Better sex ed. People will be educated more on how babies can happen and how much responsibility it takes to care for them.

  • Adoptive families helping foot the medical costs of pregnancy. This is already a thing but it will probably be more common with the increase in adoption and the rising awareness of pregnancy costs.

The biggest positive perhaps is this:

As abortion is banned, the medical advancements will continue to improve so that the necessity of abortion will be almost non-existent. We will have developed almost fool-proof birth controls with our increased understanding of our reproductive systems. We will have also researched fetal development and female anatomy so that the invention of an artificial womb will also be in our future (taking away the need of carrying a child).

And if you look at all the perceived downfalls that most people list, most of them don’t even exist or barely exist to a degree that they aren’t of any concern.

Considering what the masses on the internet are panicking about, women are NOT going to die (as the bill allows for abortions in cases where the mother’s life is endangered and where the baby is fatally defected).

Women are NOT being oppressed as it is NOT their bodies they are killing and it was the baby’s body (which has separate consciousness and DNA) that was being killed.

They are just upset that they lost their opportunity to end someone else’s life to convenience them for a period of nine months (if an adult was killed for someone else’s convenience, there would be outcry and the killer would be seen as pure evil but since the victims can’t advocate for themselves in the case of abortion, no one cares).

No one is forcing the woman to take care of the child after it is born.

The amount of abortions stemming from rape are minuscule so the majority of abortions don’t even stem from women being forced to have sex.

The outcry isn’t over control of their bodies, as they would have clearly used their bodily freedoms to have been more responsible with abstinence or would have chose better methods of contraception or made better decisions. They had the complete freedom to get proper birth control or to abstain from sex but they didn’t use that responsibility and are now getting upset because the option of killing a life that resulted from that irresponsibility is being taken away.

The outcry is about having to be held responsible for a decision they made and facing the consequences for nine months.

The hilarious thing is that now they can’t complain about the man getting off the hook. Without abortion, the man faces just as much responsibility as the woman.

And, concerning the supposed hype about the prediction of an increase in illegal abortions, that is most likely never going to happen.

Times have changed. It isn’t the 1950’s anymore. Women don’t have to terminate pregnancies before others see and shame her. If a woman really, really wants an abortion, she will travel out of the state (as it hasn’t been banned in the entire US yet). People mostly take the path of least social and financial resistance anyway, which is what society and insurance companies push (which will be adoption in the absence of abortion).

Women will most likely just end up carrying the baby to term and giving it up for adoption if they don’t want to care for it. No one is going to take a rusty coathook to themselves unless they are completely stupid. Doctors aren’t going to want to perform illegal abortions either with the high risk involved. It is going to be more of a convenience for the woman to carry the child rather than finding a way to get an abortion legally.

Abortion occurred (and still occurs in other states) because it was the convenient choice. And now that it isn’t convenient, people will take the new path of most convenience which will be to carry the baby for nine months and then give it up for adoption.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 17 '24

General debate "My body my choice" is only a good argument if you're already pro-choice

3 Upvotes

Basically just the title. I'm pro-choice (well technically an evictionist) but "my body my choice" is circular reasoning since it assumes the PC conclusion that a fetus is not an independent being with rights.

If everyone agreed that fetuses don't have rights then there would be no pro-choice debate, so assuming a key pro-choice contention in order to make your argument is unsound reasoning.


r/Abortiondebate • • Oct 24 '21

I am so surprised that so many pro choice members argue this

5 Upvotes

I got an insane amount of backlash for saying that the purpose of an abortion is to kill the baby. So let’s walk through this. It’s very quick and simple.

To justify, Let’s use the Oxford dictionary:

Abortion: “the deliberate ending of a pregnancy at an early stage”

Ok let’s look at pregnant definition

Pregnant: “having a baby or young animal developing inside her/its body”

So being pregnant means you have a baby. Ending pregnancy means you must end the baby, ie, kill it.

If you try to end a pregnancy but the baby is still there, well then you never ended the pregnancy. So therefore it’s perfectly correct to say the purpose of an abortion is to kill a baby.

The purpose of abortion is the death of the baby. Once you admit this we can make some actual progress in this discussion.

Stop denying this and the incredible amount of denial from everyone shows how weak your position is. Basic facts are ignored.


r/Abortiondebate • • Dec 04 '20

A right to medical interventions regardless of other’s rights?

1 Upvotes

So I was thinking about why the organ donation analogy is just so offensive to me and I think I’ve figured it out.

First of all, organ donors don’t have the right to donate vital organs while they are perfectly healthy and fine. The most you can do is indicate that if something happens to you, you can donate your vital organs. This is because the right to life. We don’t kill people to make other people healthy or healthier even if it means that people will die with the limited availability of vital organs ready to be transplanted.

We don’t view this lack of medical intervention as murder. We don’t blame ourselves for these deaths. Overall, while medical interventions are generally good, people don’t have an absolute right to any intervention they want.

I haven’t made this connection before because in the abortion analogy, the person compared to the organ transplant recipient is always the child. The child’s life is always described as the one whose life is on the line because the child can’t survive outside the womb. The mother’s right to autonomy supposedly trumps the child’s right to life.

But while I agree with this to the extent that I’m against rape or forced insemination, she is the one in need of a medical intervention, not the child. As such, she is more like the person in need of an organ transplant insisting she has a right to demand another to be killed. But, unless we’re talking about abortion to save the life of the mother, she’s arguing from something less than the right to life.

No one has an absolute right to all medical interventions. You can’t even insist on it for blood or non vital organs not merely because of a right to autonomy but because those donating organs are sacrificing a portion of their health for you. You have no right to ask or demand that the medical community harm another person for the sake of your health.

But then let’s go further. Pregnancy isn’t a disease. Rather how healthy the pregnancy is depends on how healthy you were before you got pregnant. Beyond that, your monitored for developing health complications but the pregnancy itself is not a disease. So what you’re demanding is an unnecessary medical intervention at the expense and death of another.

Pregnancy itself is not a medical intervention, and organ donation doesn’t involve sharing organs. You literally have to invent a procedure that doesn’t exist to mimic pregnancy.

So no, I don’t believe you women have the right to a medical intervention that kills their child because they simply don’t want to be pregnant.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jan 21 '20

Bodily autonomy is a weak proabortion argument.

7 Upvotes

The main issue with abortion is whether a fetus has the right to life and whether we value its life.

If it does have a right to life then that right immediately trumps your right of bodily autonomy. Esspecially considering you are responsible for the pregnancy.

Abortion debates should focus on the value and rights of a fetus, bodily autonomy comes second to that.


r/Abortiondebate • • Sep 10 '26

Question for pro-choice (exclusive) Why is a bodily autonomy violation worse than killing?

0 Upvotes

One thing thats always stood out to me is how PC treat a violation of the womans body by restricting abortion as unconsciousable yet killing the ZEF, which some even call a baby, is acceptable.

I don't treat the ZEF and the woman the same because I view the woman as having more moral value and rights than the ZEF. Even if I viewed them as equal, I'd still call death, which is irreversible and not everyone wants to die, as worse between the two. Why do PC not view death as worse if you view the ZEF as equal to the woman?

My intuition is if the woman was killed or allowed to die, most PC would view that as worse between the two, but many don't.

Also, yes I consider abortion killing and don't find the "its just taking an action we know will result in their death" satisfactory. We wouldn't let PL get away with forcing pregnancy to continue and saying they're not responsible for it.


r/Abortiondebate • • Apr 26 '25

Why subjective application of human rights inevitably leads to moral disaster—an argument against abortion

2 Upvotes

Historically, whenever society has allowed powerful groups to subjectively define who qualifies for human rights, the outcomes have consistently been catastrophic. Slave owners denied personhood to enslaved individuals, enabling horrific abuses. Nazis labeled certain groups "subhuman," justifying genocide. Each society that committed these atrocities believed sincerely, at the time, that their subjective definitions of personhood and rights were justified.

Today, abortion similarly depends on subjectively deciding when a developing human life attains personhood and thus qualifies for human rights. We draw arbitrary lines—viability, consciousness, sentience—chosen by those in power or by social consensus. But history has shown repeatedly that any subjective standard inevitably leads to profound moral injustice.

Most arguments in support of abortion—such as bodily autonomy, maternal rights, cases involving assault or incest, or even the complexity of balancing conflicting rights—do not resolve the fundamental ethical issue at stake: If a fetus is objectively human and alive, then abortion involves intentionally ending an innocent human life, making it morally equivalent to murder. Unless we rely on a subjective definition of who qualifies as human, aren't we as a society repeating the same dangerous pattern that allowed past atrocities like slavery and genocide to occur?? 

Is there any logical way to avoid repeating history's moral disasters when we once again allow subjective criteria to determine human rights? If human rights are not objective, universal, and consistently applied, we inevitably risk ethical catastrophe. Why should we believe that "this time will be different?"


r/Abortiondebate • • Dec 21 '19

Abortion as self defence

5 Upvotes
  1. The fetus has unwanted and unconsented contact with the woman which is assault.

  2. It drugs her which is also a form of assault

  3. It steals her nutrients and violates arteries which is also assault.

  4. Birth is also assault and rape.

Self-defense is a countermeasure that involves defending the health and well-being of oneself from harm. The use of the right of self-defense as a legal justification for the use of force in times of danger is available in many jurisdictions.

In People v. La Voie, Supreme Court of Colorado, 395 P.2d 1001 (1964), The court wrote, "When a person has reasonable grounds for believing, and does in fact actually believe, that danger of his being killed, or of receiving great bodily harm, is imminent, he may act on such appearances and defend himself, even to the extent of taking human life when necessary, although it may turn out that the appearances were false, or although he may have been mistaken as to the extent of the real actual danger."

The question to be asked in the end is quite simple. It is whether the accused believed upon reasonable grounds that it was necessary in self-defence to do what he did. If he had that belief and there were reasonable grounds for it, or if the jury is left in reasonable doubt about the matter, then he is entitled to an acquittal. Stated in this form, the question is one of general application and is not limited to cases of homicide.

(1) No person in the state shall be placed in legal jeopardy of any kind whatsoever for protecting by any reasonable means necessary, himself or herself, his or her family, or his or her real or personal property, or for coming to the aid of another who is in imminent danger of or the victim of assault, robbery, kidnapping, arson, burglary, rape, murder, or any other violent crime as defined in RCW 9.94A.030.

The woman has the right to self defence as a impending rape victim - rape by birth.

Rape:unlawful sexual intercourse or any other sexual penetration of the vagina, anus, or mouth of another person, with or without force, by a sex organ, other body part, or foreign object, without the consent of the victim.

Ie the same as if you were being held captive by a rapist and knew rape or execution were impending and planned with 100% certainty.

To be legally justified in killing an attacker, a rape victim must reasonably believe that the rapist intends to kill or grievously injure her. In many rape situations, the threat of severe physical harm is clear; the rapist is armed or threatens death or grievous injury. Situations where a rapist does not explicitly or implicitly threaten physical harm beyond forcible intercourse are less clear regarding the victim's right to use deadly force against the rapist. Current law does not clearly articulate a basis for the right to use deadly self-defense when a person reasonably believes that harm will be limited to forcible intercourse. One factor which can justify the use of deadly force against a rapist who does not threaten the victim with death or grievous physical harm is the high frequency of murder and serious injury incident to rape. This could properly lead any rape victim to assume that her life and health are in serious danger. A second factor that could justify the use of deadly force is the high rate of physical injury and psychological trauma attending rape. The threat of venereal disease, an unwanted pregnancy, and psychological debilitation can be taken together as a threat of serious harm. Overall, rape can be viewed as a grievous physical and psychological attack that may be resisted by any and all means.

Working on updating with an example:

During birth, the fetus causes one of the biggest wounds in most (if not all) women's lives, plus extreme blood loss. C section is quite popular and causes even more damage to the womans body, yet outcomes are not better for the woman or baby. Fetuses can also kick so hard, they crack the pregnant woman's ribs and pelvises way before they're born.

No. The fetus does not work. The womans body is enslaved by the fetus. The fetus steals nutrients directly from her blood and drugs her so it can stay in place. Free forced labour. And so is birth. Free forced labor. The fetus is the one who impinges on the womans body by implanting in her. It is the one who assaulted HER.


r/Abortiondebate • • Jan 10 '25

General debate Causation and responsability: The logical flaws of the bodily autonomy argument.

0 Upvotes

Since the most commonly used PC argument and recurring statement in discussions regarding pregnancy here is 'Nobody should have the right to be inside another person's body,' I will proceed to dismantle this logically flawed phrase and the argument it upholds when applied specifically to pregnancy.

Foundational Premises for This Discussion:

  1. We agree that life begins at conception.

  2. We agree that unborn children are living human beings with inherent human rights.

  3. The dignity of life is a fundamental principle, so moral nihilism is not part of this discussion.

If we share these premises, we can focus on debating the central part of the bodily autonomy argument and avoid going off topic.

Note: This argument is specifically focused on consensual sexual encounters based pregnancies, not cases of rape.

The argument that "the unborn violated my bodyautonomy by 'inrupting' inside my body" is logically and biologically flawed and is completely invalidated by the universal concepts of cause and effect, specifically causation and responsibility.

What are the concepts of causation and responsibility?

Causation refers to the relationship between an action (or event) and the resulting outcome. In simple terms, it's the idea that every effect has a cause — something that directly leads to the result. Responsibility, on the other hand, is the moral or logical obligation to address the consequences of those actions. When you cause something to happen, you are typically held accountable for the consequences of that cause.

Causation and responsibility are universal because they form the basis of both logic and ethics in human society. Every action has consequences, and the principle of responsibility ensures individuals are accountable for the outcomes of their actions. This concept is fundamental in guiding decisions, laws, and ethical behavior, ensuring people consider the impact of their actions.

In everyday life, we rely on causation and responsibility to maintain fairness. For example, if someone buys a dog (cause), they are held accountable for the life of that dog (effect), these principles are essential for maintaining order, fairness, and ethical behavior, allowing society to function cohesively and justly.

When we apply the concepts of causation and responsibility to pregnancy (lead by consensual sex), the argument that "nobody should have the right to be inside another person’s body" becomes logically incoherent. Pregnancy is the direct result of consensual sex, where both parties involved typically understand the potential consequences. The act of sex (the cause) leads to conception (the effect), and this creates a situation where the person carrying the pregnancy is responsible for the consequences of their actions, that is the new life of a human being, such life was caused by your actions, therefore it didn't "inrupt" inside your body, to claim this would be logically and biologically flawd.

From a biological perspective, the fetus doesn't suddenly 'inrupt' inside the body; rather, conception occurs when sperm fertilizes an egg, typically within the fallopian tube, and the fertilized egg (embryo) travels to the uterus where it implants into the uterine lining. The embryo does not invade the body; instead, it is a natural, biological result of reproduction—an intimate, shared process between the individuals involved. This biological causation reinforces the idea that the pregnancy is a direct consequence of the actions taken, and not an intrusion or violation of bodily autonomy.

To claim that someone should not be responsible for the life growing inside them, after their deliberate (sex) actions caused the pregnancy, contradicts the principle of causation and responsibility.

In simple terms, if my conscious and consensual actions result in the creation of life, respecting that life’s dignity and acknowledging the principles of cause and effect should lead to a moral responsibility to protect that life—regardless of its location, even if it's inside my body

If we claim that a person who is inside my body shouldn't be there and I will terminate their life because it is inside of me and it’s my right, and ignore that: A) Such a person is only there because of the casual results of my actions, B) That person is a human being with inherent life dignity, then we totally violate the concept of causation and responsibility, as well as basic moral principles and logical reasoning.

As society we should strive to minimize exceptions based solely on emotions and uphold logical consistency as much as possible, especially in situations involving clear cause and effect, like the creation of life. Because, either way, we risk being doomed to justify atrocious acts without a sense of responsibility, eroding the very moral framework that holds society together and our logical reasoning.

Edit: If you disagree with the premises outlined earlier, the discussion would inevitably shift to an entirely different topic—namely, the concept and value of human life—which requires its own separate debate. To maintain focus on the central issue of bodily autonomy, I will only engage with those who share these foundational premises.