If you have been here a while you have probably seen the "Forced Birther" argument.
To be blunt: I think the argument is a red herring. I believe that in many circumstances, it detracts from meaningful conversation about abortion, and I will discuss that below.
THE CLAIM
The following is an attempt to "strongman" the argument. I've included as many elements of the argument as possible in as clear a format as I can. I am not trying to dismiss this argument, I am trying to represent it fairly.
"Refusing women the liberty to choose abortion forces women to be pregnant and makes the government, and PLers in general, complicit in a harm which is tantamount to rape and slavery."
There are good reasons to use this argument. It is a powerful argument, and it's hard to oppose because:
The harm of pregnancy is very real, and very significant. Nobody wants to cause human suffering, and everybody should want to minimize human suffering.
The government promises certain rights and liberties, such as self determination and the right to privacy. Government interference in individual lives should be as limited as possible.
THE PROBLEM
The "Forced Birth" argument ultimately assets that opposition to abortion is an inherently bad thing, and it does so with panache. But what it neglects is the argument that abortion is itselfna permissible act. It does not argue that we have a right to abortion, and it doesn't not prove that people should be entitled to pursue it.
There are strong reasons to believe abortion isn't a permissible act:
We know that the ZEF is a distinct living organism.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2672893/#:~:text=The%20somatic%20cell%20is%20something,developing%20and%20complete%20human%20organism.
2. We know that the ZEF is a member of the species homo sapiens.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15675036/#:~:text=It%20is%20an%20undeniable%20empirical,from%20the%20moment%20of%20conception.
3. We know that abortion causes the death of the ZEF.
https://www.siue.edu/~evailat/el10.html
4. We know that killing a human is homicide.
https://www.britannica.com/topic/homicide
5. We know that if a homicide is neither excused or justified, then it violates the spirit of the law.
https://law.jrank.org/pages/7401/Homicide-Justifiable-or-Excusable-Homicide.html
This leaves us with a very important question which is central to the abortion debate: is abortion legally justifiable? A justifiable homicide is fully permissible, but an unjustifiable homicide ultimately is impermissible in a just society. There are lots of arguments somebody could make here to support abortion: necessity, self defense, bodily autonomy, etc.
However: the "Forced Birth" argument makes none of these claims. It states that regardless of the status of abortion as permissible or impermissible, it is wrong of you to interfere.
REBUTTALS
Earlier I mentioned some strengths of the "Forced Birth" argument, and I think it ties into the statement I just mentioned.
Above, I mentioned that nobody wants to cause human suffering. However, our laws do, and they do so quite often.
When the actions which one takes to alleviate their suffering are unjustifiable or impermissible, the law halts those actions even. A starving man who could murder for bread would still be found guilty of murder. A terminal patient, whose only hope for recovery is to force another to donate organs, would be barred from harming others to promote their own recovery. There are countless cases where somebody could alleviate their own suffering through an impermissible act, and the government prevents them from doing so.
McFall v. Shimp, the landmark case which produced rhe doctrine of Bodily Autonomy, ruled that McFall could not compel Shimp to undergo medical treatment even to save his life. McFall was suffering, and ultimately died. The government prevented McFall from alleviating his suffering, because the vehicle through which he sought recovery was unjust. Was the government therefore complicit in McFall's suffering and eventual death? Maybe, but that complicity was insufficient to justify an unjustified act.
https://hulr.org/spring-2021/mcfall-v-shimp-and-the-case-for-bodily-autonomy
Above, I mentioned how the government promises rights like privacy and autonomy. However, these rights to privacy are not absolute.
As just one example, a law officer normally requires a warrant or permission to enter someone's home. People are constitutionally entitled to privacy within their own home. However, there are many exigent circumstances which would allow that same officer to disregard this right to privacy. For example, if an officer believes that a homicide is occurring or about to occur, they can enter a home without any legal authorization.
The government's authority to intercede in the lives of its citizens is justly curtailed by many factors. However, one of the most common and compelling interests of the state and federal government is the protection of life. This legitimate interest is further enshrined in the doctrine of Parens Patriae which states that the government has a duty to act on behalf of those who are unable to advocate for themselves, such as children. The government has a right and duty to interfere in the private choices of individuals where those choices cause the death of others.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/parens_patriae
CONCLUSION
It may be true that the government gets "blood on its hands" by preventing abortion. However, that blood does not justify abortion. If abortion is a homicide, and if no valid justification can be given, then the government not only can intercede: it should. We do so in countless cases already, even when it causes people like Robert McFall to suffer and die.
The "Forced Birther" argument is a strong one, and it has a place here, but it cannot answer the core question of abortion: is the act of abortion permissible, or is it impermissible.