We've recently revised and clarified several of r/Zune's rules, particularly those concerning self-promotion, software projects, and AI-generated content.
The biggest changes concern how self-promoted projects are submitted, approved, and updated.
Self-Promotion and Project Approval
All self-promotional posts require moderator approval before appearing on the subreddit.
This includes applications, websites, YouTube channels, services, and other projects being promoted by their creators. Compliant marketplace listings are exempt and remain subject to the separate marketplace rules.
To simplify the approval process, we've introduced a dedicated Self-Promotion post flair. Submissions using this flair are automatically held for moderator review. You do not need to contact us through ModMail before submitting.
When reviewing a submission, we'll consider its relevance to the Zune community, functionality, transparency, originality, and overall value to the community.
For software projects, our expectations include:
Functionality: Projects should offer meaningful, working functionality rather than consisting solely of concepts, mockups, or screenshots of unfinished work.
Documentation: Developers should provide sufficient information about installation, usage, functionality, and known limitations.
Transparency: Publicly accessible source code is encouraged, particularly for software interacting directly with Zune hardware or software.
Relevance: Projects should have a meaningful connection to Zune hardware, software, or the broader community.
Free and open-source projects will receive priority consideration. Paid software, applications with premium features, and closed-source projects are not automatically prohibited, but will be evaluated individually.
Projects that interact directly with Zune hardware, such as OpenZDK applications and device modifications, are particularly encouraged. Zune-inspired or adjacent projects may also be considered, provided they offer meaningful value to the community.
Approval is discretionary. We reserve the right to decline submissions that are primarily advertisements, lack meaningful functionality, or provide little value to tghe community.
Approved Posts and Future Project Updates
We're also changing how developers can share updates about approved projects.
Approved self-promotional submissions receive a pinned moderator comment upon submission identifying the post as approved. Developers should use replies to this pinned comment to share subsequent updates, including new releases, bug fixes, and other project developments.
This provides a central location where interested members can follow a project's progress without requiring a new promotional submission for every update. Members can enable notifications for the pinned comment to follow future developments. The pinned update thread is intended for project updates. Regular discussion elsewhere in the post is still welcome.
Approval of one submission does not automatically authorize future promotional posts. Additional promotional submissions remain subject to moderator review. Repeated advertisements, minor progress updates presented as new posts, and attempts to circumvent the approval process may be removed.
Clarification Regarding AI-Generated Content
A few weeks ago, we outlined our position on AI-assisted projects. Our revised rules formalize and clarify that position.
AI-generated post titles, post bodies, and comments are prohibited. Members are expected to write their own submissions rather than relying on AI-generated text. AI-generated artwork, fabricated content, and unreliable AI-generated technical advice are also subject to removal under our content rules.
However, using AI to assist with software development does not automatically disqualify a project from being shared, as long as its use is disclosed.
We recognize that AI-assisted programming tools are increasingly common. Rather than attempting to determine precisely how much AI was involved in development, we'll evaluate projects based on their functionality, documentation, transparency, relevance, and overall value to the community. If it is found that AI was used - but not disclosed - the post will be removed. Repeated violations may result in a ban.
Free and open-source AI-assisted projects will receive priority consideration, just like other software projects. Paid and closed-source AI-assisted projects will be reviewed individually.
Regardless of how software was developed, low-effort promotional submissions, unfinished projects presented primarily as advertisements, and misleading claims are not permitted.
Other Rule Updates
We've also revised the wording of several existing rules to make our expectations clearer, including those covering post flair, marketplace submissions, community conduct, and moderation enforcement.
Please take a moment to review the updated rules in the subreddit sidebar or under See More on mobile.
Final Notes
Community projects are an important part of this subreddit, and we appreciate the time people invest in creating them. At the same time, the subreddit should not become an advertising platform for unfinished applications, low-effort "AI-slop," or repetitive promotional content.
These changes are intended to strike that balance while providing developers with a clearer approval process and a reliable place to share their progress.
As always, questions and feedback about the updated rules are welcome in the comments or through ModMail.