Played ~10 runs. Here are my thoughts. Good work on the devs.
Forge Mastery and Wand awakening stack damage with levels much faster than enemies gain health. For example: Mangus rifle (max mastery, floor 6 acquired.) with Martial Prowess Lv. 10, Alchemy Power Lv. 5, Forge Mastery Lv. 10, Alchemy Awakening Lv. 6, Raw Power Level 5 gives me a weapon with ~1300 base damage that does over ~2300 damage. I could probably get over 4000 damage per shot after max skill tree and pass up damage nerf perks.
2.For threat level 5, Scholar difficulty: Floors 1-2 are the hardest. It gets easier after that because perks + weapon level increase. Of course, this is with the skill tree active. Threat 5 with no skills is grueling, barely doable.
3. Change how weapon damage is displayed in the character sheet. Give base damage values and perk multiplied damage. Clicking on the weapon should inform you about what perks increase/decrease damage.
4. There no amulet cooldown skill tree buffs. Amulet cooldown is too high.
5. Book worm skill tree upgrade would be nice. Even a variant that guarantees showing a character perk on level up.
6. Reroll skill tree buff for giving free re rolls would be nice.
7. Max ascension skill tree lets you get +15 health. Life awareness only lets you get +10.
8. Characters don't have enough personality. They should have comments like when a player dominates another in Team Fortress 2. Triggers could be boss clear, barely survived room, killed X enemies over Y seconds, killed X hated enemies. (Each character has a specific enemy they despise)
9. We don't need a new character after every story mission.
10. Some floors can have multiple shops, even without barter. I'd argue that floors without a masters key should always have a shop. I'm okay with multiple shops.
11. Need more side quest descriptions. Too many mayors kidnapped, knights killed, local heroes need help, village patties.
12. I'm still running around with 300-500+ health on later floors. Part of this is because I kill everything fast. It isn't clear what the barrier limit is, just that it increases with player max health. Culprits: barrier on level up skill + EXP perks, Barrier per floor, and +80 barrier with Ascension skill. Hard barrier limit equal to Max health + Max shield would fix this.
13. Conduit + boss minions + infinite minions should give you barrier, stricter barrier limits fix farming.
14. Infinitely spawned enemies should still drop money, just lower the chance each time a coin is spawned, Decay function is fair and will prevent farming.
15. Sludge slow down between rooms are annoying, and have no gameplay value. Please remove.
16. Damage from dungeon floor poison is too high per second. Please half it. Too punishing. Trap damage is also too high.
17. Standing on a moving platform has weird jitters on the platform. This visual annoyance has been around for a while.
18. Mana shield might not be working as intended, or it might not be clear how it stacks with damage modifiers. I had +80% mana shield but still lost way too much health and not enough mana.
19. For campaign maps, it should be clear how enemies stats scale per floor. Infinite dungeon has it.
20. Victory animation should show each characters personality. Current win/lose animations don't have any flair or voice-lines.
21. Scaredy cat is the best perk in the game. It lets you get out of tough spots. Damage isn't avoidable many times with projectile spam on later floors. Also lets you fly with the eye twilight. Fire rate doesn't seem to stack with Fervor character perk.
22. Retribution should have enhanced self knock back attribute, and ignore self damage as its passive. Let me rocket jump majestically through the air, maggots.
23. Mastery level 10 on a weapon should force add it to the curated options before a run. Okay, I just like rocket jumping. And eye of twilight flying. Maybe a skill tree perk to expand curated options.
24. Haste perk should probably be buffed to 7%. It is outclassed by weapon passives.
25. The best perks are the ones that give you a significant upgrade in stats, but have a cost. Example: Brute, Lightweight, Sensitivity, Black Orb, Dark Pact, High stakes, Arcane Absorption, Avarice, Consumption, Erudite, Power saving, Obliterator, Old School, Sure shot. Unnatural strength, Climax.
26. Second best perks are exp gain bonus perks and barter.
27. Worst perks are Revenge, Torture, other retaliation chance perks. These perks should come with a better stat bonus than standard perks. And always give a stat bonus if Dark Pack, Consumption, Arcane Absorption rolls them.
28. Perks that give you a weapon scale to the floors level, while shuffle keeps the level of current weapons the same.
29. Perks that give you a weapon replace the currently held weapon, without dropping the previous one. I would appreciate a curated choice of two weapon options. Mostly, because I hate dragon bile.
30. Oaths are always worth it, but best wait until you have gold for a reroll.
31. On the character sheet, we should be able to curate whether we want additional levels of the same perk to be shown on level up. Yes I love scholar, no I want something else after +40% on floor 5.
32. Reroll should prevent every perk that was just rolled away from being shown again. Example: Scaredy scare to level 4 is shown with three other perks. I reject them all and reroll, but Scaredy cat to level 4 is shown again.
33. Lock sequence can pretty toxic with the wrong enemy combination.
34. No rewards dropped room modifier is unfair, especially for infinite dungeon high floor numbers. You just run out of mana with way too many enemies to kill and no healing. Modifier should be -50% drop rate. That way, perks that increase the drop rate can offset it.
35. I've had single Wand only rooms occur once in a threat 5, max length campaign dungeons. On separate runs. Not sure it is intended that high threat dungeons to frequently have a wand only room.
36. Find the purple crystals room modifier is more tedious than anything.
37. Challenge room chest rewards scale with floor level. Either lots of gold or EXP.
38. Enemy scaling per floor with weapon scaling per weapon level gives a situation where the best weapon is the newest one. For the most part, specific weapons don't matter at all because of how powerful weapon scaling per weapon level is. We should be able to spend gold to upgrade weapons to the floor's weapon level, not above it. Lets us keep the build going.
39. Even if there are different flavors of minion rooms, the gameplay is basically the same: Kill the minions, and do whatever ancillary objective is necessary. I.e it is always some form a minion battle or boss battle. I would like to seem a Dungeon of the Endless esque crystal escort mission to the next floor while fending off hoards of monsters that try to kill you and/or the crystal. Would add some tension.
40. I changed key bindings to shift sprint, q dash, f amulet, e character skill. Not sure why these aren't the default.
41. Game does a good job not giving you a redundant weapon when you have an empty empty slot when opening a chest.
42. Grant weapon bonus from oracle/gods can override an existing weapon...even if you have an empty slot.
43. I'd like a character whose skill is a quick flash shield/parry with a quick 2 sec cooldown. Not offensive. Faster than the battle mage. Would raise the skill cap here.
44. You can't dash through projectiles coming at you. Rigel should be able to.
45. Bosses can't be stunned with lightning attacks. They should be able to be stunned, but their attack speed never falls below their base attack speed. (Lighting would cancel out floor haste bonus. ). That way you can still proc effects that care about enemy status.
46. Quad damage for all is a painful modifier. Consider moving it to triple damage. A little more leeway for when this room also has spammy enemies.
47. Enemies that summon other enemies should always have their post process outline visible. Make it easier to hunt them down.
48. Make it clear how much more health champions get. It is at least 1.5, but I'm not sure.
49. Payload/capture the flag maps vs minions would add an extra layer of fun.
50. Skeleton targeting should be changed. If an enemy has not seen the player, but has seen the skeleton, it will attack the nearest skeleton first. If an enemy is attacking the skeleton, but sees the player, it will only move to the player if the player is closer. If an enemy is already attacking the player, it will ignore the skeleton unless the skeleton is blocking intended attack for player (or in the way of a melee strike). Enemies that are being mobbed by 3 or more skeletons (i.e hit by a skeleton projectile 4+ times over X seconds) will stop chasing the player and will attack the offending skeleton(s) if the skeletons are closer than the player. Groups of minions will work together to kill skeletons if there is a group of 6 more skeletons within a radius 2 carrot lengths. Skeletons take 150% damage from status effects. Skeletons attack more frequently, but have less damage. This would make skeleton placement more tactical, and player can use them as free walls. Maybe this isn't worth it.... Just a suggestion.
51. Thanks for reading.