r/Zettelkasten • u/jmaquoi • 2d ago
question Looking for advice to teach a "Scientific methodology" course with a collaborative Zettelkasten
Hello everyone!
I am a teaching PhD student, meaning that I have a half time doing a PhD and half time giveng practical sessions of courses in computer science. I use the Zettelkasten method for my research on Green IT, following the practices discussed in the book "A system for writing" from Bob Doto, and one of the course for which I give practical sessions is about scientific methodology. The course will have about 20-30 students working in small groups of 3. One of the main goals of the course is to teach them how to search for academic papers, synthesize what they read, make links between papers and write a solid State of the art by the end of the semester.
I'm trying to teach the students the Zettelkasten methodology to propose them to use it while reading research papers, but it's quite difficult, because the method itself, even if its core is quite simple to understand, is not so easy to implement. For example, it's quite difficult to make the students create a Zettelkasten from zero because they don't have the time to create enough main notes within to really make the most of this methodology. My idea to resolve this issue is to use a copy of my own Zettelkasten (in Obsidian, synced via Git for those who know this tool) as a starting point and have the entire class collaboratively grow the network over the semester. Each group would work on a sub-cluster of Green IT.
I'd love to get this community feedback on my plan, and if u/taurusnoises happens to see this, I would especially love to hear how you manage to teach Zettelkasten to your students!
Here are the main steps I have in mind:
Seed the vault: I share my existing PhD notes (hub notes, main notes and reference notes) with the class. Each group gets assigned a different sub-topic of Green Software Engineering and maybe a few starter papers to get going.
Search and read: After those first two papers, groups have to search for and read new academic papers in their sub-topic on their own, and to take notes while doing it.
Create reference and atomic notes: Using the workflow from Bob Doto's A system for Writing, students create reference notes for their papers and extract main notes written in their own words.
Connect across other notes and the class: Students have to link their new notes to my PhD notes and to other group's notes (and add backlinks with a brief context sentence, like in Bob Doto's book), without altering anyone else's original text.
Synthesize: When something emerges from the notes from the papers they read + the other notes from the Zettelkasten, each group builds a Structure note to organize their connected ideas and use it as the backbone to write their final State of the art at the end of the semester.
What do you think of my workflow? I have already read the beautiful post of Bob Doto about collaborative Zettelkasten (see here) but I'm trying to get as much information as I can about this way of handling a Zettelkasten. Are there any conceptual or practical pitfalls I should watch out for?
Thanks in advance for any advice, ideas, or feedback!