Just "finished" the show. I put finish in quotation marks beacause what I actually did was fully watch the first 12 episodes and then bits and pieces of the last several episodes and the entierty of the finale. I'm posting this here because I really want to hear why people love this show so much when I just couldn't get into it. I feel I must be missing something. Obviouslly, spoilers.
First things first, I'll briefly go over the most common criticism the show faces, the most obvious one being the failed attempts at slapstick comedy that often ruin dramatic moments I got invested it. Part of the reason I skipped most of the show was that I felt I shouldn't get to attached to individual moments when they will just be ruined or ended abruptly by dumb slapstick.
Other common criticism seems to be that the show is too melodramatic, which I at the same time agree and disagree with. Depends on how you view melodrama. If you think melodrama is it's own subgenra you love then great, but for me, who expected a regular anima drama like A silent voice, it just kinda draged the show down and made it painfully boring at times. I just can't understand how someone can binge watch this show. The scenes where Kosei plays the piano are especially painfull, long and I just couldn't wait for them to end.
The charathers are also often criticized and here I look at the show a bit more favouribly. I really genuinly liked Tsubaki and it really angers me how often slapstick ruined her scenes for me. I liked the rivals as well. Kosei is often criticized, but to me he was just seemed like a regular protagonist.
Kaori is the only one I activelly dislike. She fells at the begining like the ultimate manic pixie girl and I really found that annoying. After watching the finale I can understand the way she acts and hell, even apreaciate her, but that comes a little bit to late. By then I already stared heavily disliking her. Going into the show, I knew someone was gonna die at the end. I assumed from the op it was gonna be Kaori, but as I watched the first couple episodes I though it might be Tsubaki that dies and that all the obvious hints of Kaoris death were red hearing. Honestly, if the story was different and instead of Kaori it's Tsubaki that dies, perhaps after Kosei realizes she liked him, it would have resonated with me much more.
However, the main reason I dropped the show was boredom. It was so slow, especially the piano competition scenes as I mentioned above. Everything that grabbed my attention was short lived and the stuff I disliked was put center staged and stretched out. I thought maybe the problem is I don't like drama as a genre, but I know that isn't the case. My favourite anime genre is definetlly romantic comedy, which is definatelly at least partially related to drama like this. Not to mention that A silent voice is one of the only pieces of anime media I tried sharing with non anime fans and my family. Outside animation, The father is one of my favourite movies released recently and it has no real plot, but just immerses you in the characters emotions.
So why do I not like this anime? Maybe I watched it with the wrong expectation; expecting a more dramatic romcom instead of a dramatic anime. Even then though, the staggering praise this anime is getting seems like something that should make my expectation of it irrelavant. I don't really like crime shows or dramas, but I love Breaking bad because, even though I don't care about the premise, it's such a well made show you just can't not like it. An anime example would be Death note or even Attack on titan and the Chainsawman manga. Premises I don't inharantly like, but stories I love cause they are that great. This just doesn't seem like one of those amazing shows.
As I said though, I'm asking for opinions. Why do you love this show and how do you not find it boring or frustrating?