r/YourLieinApril • • Jul 08 '25

Media Can y’all please stop!

0 Upvotes

The your lie in april fans are in every single video about classical music, raiding the comment section, spamming the same gif and ”i cant hear the notes” on every post. And commenting “is this a your lie in April reference” on a random video of someone playing any classical song acting like this anime invented classical music. We get it, some anime guy couldnt hear his own playing. It’s getting kinda dragged now and I’m getting real tired of all the spam, it’s enough!!!


r/YourLieinApril • • Dec 05 '21

Anime Is It Just Me, Or Would You Accept ANY Bull**** Excuse To Get A Season 2?

20 Upvotes

So hear me out...

Part of me, wants any reason for them to eventually be together. Anything even crazy out of place, like some super secret scientist people testing on Kaori, or some stupid rich guy swapping bodies and someone else was buried cause he crushed on her and wanted her all to himself etc. I don't care what rubbish reason, just as long as in the end they are together with their long healthy lives ahead.

Part of me, feels this is practically criminal. The anime is so beautiful and damn near perfect at what it sets out to do all by itself, that it feels wrong to sour it with something like that.

Thoughts?


r/YourLieinApril • • Apr 07 '26

Rewatch Discussion My honest opinion after watching YLIA Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Hello people, I hope everyone is doing well

Want to share some thoughts here as someone who first watched YLIA last year (only once) here's an honest review of it.

Overall, it's good. the story, characters, OST, the music scores and how emotions were conveyed. The whole story was nice watching and the ending did make me feel sad.

With that out of the way, here is what I really felt after I completed watching it. It wasn't in the higher tier of peak anime as many would say. Nor it's an anime that had a massive impact on me. I did say I felt sad but as the fandom has expressed many times (to a point now I feel like it's exaggerated) that people cry a lot after watching it, I'm the minority who didn't. Didn't feel any tears not nothing.

After thinking a lot and having this discussion with ChatGPT (I know, lame right?) Here are 2 major reasons why;

  1. **Saw alot of spoilers before my first watch:** I only got into animé in general in 2022. And since then all my social media feeds were full of anime shorts, edits and those sorts of content. It wasn't like I did on purpose at first, but I saw a lot of memes about this story and how people act depressed and the reason is they saw this. Or they cry dramatically in those TikTok/Insta edits, quotes from characters like Kousei & Kaori. Since I was already spoiled by this so I decided to read the plot on Wikipedia (that's on me). After reading, I decided to give the anime a go and watched through the whole of it.

  2. **Handling humour:** While in a story like this elements of humour are appreciated to lighten the mood. But if done correctly will make the anime more memorable. Idk if it was just me, but in some scenes the humour was too out of place. Like during emotional scenes, there's cheap, almost slapstick humour. And imo Tsubaki's character was always the one used and it just ruined the whole scene. I kid you not there were some scenes that had me so invested in, but cheap humour ruined it. A good example is the ending. The end almost made me cry, but having Tsubaki kick Kousei hard in the shin made my rating for this scene drop from 10/10 to 3/10. This is just one example. There were other times with Kaori as well when comedy butchered the emotional built-up. At times it even irritated me like "really is this supposed to make me laugh or something?"

These two reason in my view is why the story didn't make me enjoy it as much - basically ruined the viewing experience. Other minor details I'd say made me feel a bit iffy is the use of musical scores. Sometimes, just too much of focus on the musical element (I'm not into any type of music so no offense to people who are into it.)

So yeah, just wanted to share this opinion. Reading the posts here, and watching on YouTube as well how much the story is exaggerated and marketed as a really emotional story that will make you cry your eyes out and be depressed for a prolonged period of time. I'm not denying it is, but people over exaggerate this and it goes for a majority.

That's why, overall I have rated this anime as: **6/10**

Good...but not the best. A really honest review from myself that I feel many people don't mention about this story (I think it's the 'go with the flow' attitude to not get hated on)

I know I'm going to recieve a lot of hate for this, but what are your guys thoughts on this? Let me know 😄

Have a nice day/night!

(P.S. not hating on anybody)


r/YourLieinApril • • Sep 02 '22

Question What am I missing about this show? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Just "finished" the show. I put finish in quotation marks beacause what I actually did was fully watch the first 12 episodes and then bits and pieces of the last several episodes and the entierty of the finale. I'm posting this here because I really want to hear why people love this show so much when I just couldn't get into it. I feel I must be missing something. Obviouslly, spoilers.

First things first, I'll briefly go over the most common criticism the show faces, the most obvious one being the failed attempts at slapstick comedy that often ruin dramatic moments I got invested it. Part of the reason I skipped most of the show was that I felt I shouldn't get to attached to individual moments when they will just be ruined or ended abruptly by dumb slapstick.

Other common criticism seems to be that the show is too melodramatic, which I at the same time agree and disagree with. Depends on how you view melodrama. If you think melodrama is it's own subgenra you love then great, but for me, who expected a regular anima drama like A silent voice, it just kinda draged the show down and made it painfully boring at times. I just can't understand how someone can binge watch this show. The scenes where Kosei plays the piano are especially painfull, long and I just couldn't wait for them to end.

The charathers are also often criticized and here I look at the show a bit more favouribly. I really genuinly liked Tsubaki and it really angers me how often slapstick ruined her scenes for me. I liked the rivals as well. Kosei is often criticized, but to me he was just seemed like a regular protagonist.

Kaori is the only one I activelly dislike. She fells at the begining like the ultimate manic pixie girl and I really found that annoying. After watching the finale I can understand the way she acts and hell, even apreaciate her, but that comes a little bit to late. By then I already stared heavily disliking her. Going into the show, I knew someone was gonna die at the end. I assumed from the op it was gonna be Kaori, but as I watched the first couple episodes I though it might be Tsubaki that dies and that all the obvious hints of Kaoris death were red hearing. Honestly, if the story was different and instead of Kaori it's Tsubaki that dies, perhaps after Kosei realizes she liked him, it would have resonated with me much more.

However, the main reason I dropped the show was boredom. It was so slow, especially the piano competition scenes as I mentioned above. Everything that grabbed my attention was short lived and the stuff I disliked was put center staged and stretched out. I thought maybe the problem is I don't like drama as a genre, but I know that isn't the case. My favourite anime genre is definetlly romantic comedy, which is definatelly at least partially related to drama like this. Not to mention that A silent voice is one of the only pieces of anime media I tried sharing with non anime fans and my family. Outside animation, The father is one of my favourite movies released recently and it has no real plot, but just immerses you in the characters emotions.

So why do I not like this anime? Maybe I watched it with the wrong expectation; expecting a more dramatic romcom instead of a dramatic anime. Even then though, the staggering praise this anime is getting seems like something that should make my expectation of it irrelavant. I don't really like crime shows or dramas, but I love Breaking bad because, even though I don't care about the premise, it's such a well made show you just can't not like it. An anime example would be Death note or even Attack on titan and the Chainsawman manga. Premises I don't inharantly like, but stories I love cause they are that great. This just doesn't seem like one of those amazing shows.

As I said though, I'm asking for opinions. Why do you love this show and how do you not find it boring or frustrating?


r/YourLieinApril • • Jun 12 '23

Question What you guys think about it??

2 Upvotes

I just wanted to know what You guys think

If the writer Somehow decide to Create a new season Making kaori somehow alive by changing the direction of story?? ( Not possible but also not impossible)

Just curious To know your views !!


r/YourLieinApril • • Jan 14 '24

Question Is Kaori real? Spoiler

24 Upvotes

I just finished the anime btw and it's the saddest thing I've ever seen. Don't watch much anime because I know how good it is and don't want to binge lol.

Anyways came across this through an Instagram post where I heard the introduction music and thought I should watch it because the intro music was so good.

Yes I cried a lot pretty much every episode, but the last few episodes killed me.

Okay getting to the point of this post. There are a few instances where Kaori reads Kousei's mind and finishes his sentences, she also does a few more ethereal things like playing the violin made of angel dust, I know that could potentially just be poetic justice showing her heart instead of the physical world but the reading the mind thing was quite surreal. Was Kaori real?


r/YourLieinApril • • Jun 03 '25

Rewatch Discussion I hate kaori Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Everyone likes her I literally hate her, She knew arima had depression and trauma and she knew she will die yet she put him again on stage only to cause him more trauma! Not to mention she was avoiding him (regarding to romance) rather than tsubaki who was always by his side, I got sad when she died but I still hate her


r/YourLieinApril • • Jul 08 '23

Question Is this true ? It was a Accidental murder ?

0 Upvotes

I was listening to the intro On youtube and I saw a comment That the flowers flowing out of her chest is actually blood depicted during intro , she died because the doc actually accidentally cut a very important vein near the heart and she dies due to blood loss That means its all doctors fault


r/YourLieinApril • • Jul 05 '26

Question I’m on episode 8 and I’m finding the show really boring so far does it get any better?

0 Upvotes

r/YourLieinApril • • Nov 27 '22

Meme your lie in april but in 100 years

1 Upvotes

i wanna see this anime remade in like 100 years but instead of all the classical music it’s just ticktock songs like imagine love sorrow swapped with 1985


r/YourLieinApril • • Mar 20 '23

Question Is there going to be a season 2

0 Upvotes

r/YourLieinApril • • Jun 28 '25

Rewatch Discussion Am I the only one who finds this overrated?

0 Upvotes

I know im gonna get destroyed for this opinion but I think this anime is very overrated for what it is. The plot is alright but not really unique in any way that makes it stand out. Every second of it is written like the characters are a wannabe poet, with just over the top metaphors that get thrown in at every chance. I can see why a lot of people like it because the dying female main character is usually interesting to see but your lie in April doesnt really do anything that stood out with it. The plot twist was alright too, I mean the name already gives it away so it wasn't anything shocking. The thing I hate the most is how everyone acts like the ending is the equivalent to their whole family getting hit by a train then blown up, its not particularly sad or anything, it just tries really hard to. Its like those animes where the character gets even more sad backstory piled onto them high enough to reach the moon, just to try to make it sad. TLDR: very overrated, overly dramatic writing, wannabe poetry, not sad one bit, and just beats a dead horse with all the attempted sadness


r/YourLieinApril • • Apr 25 '22

Anime Am I the only one who didnt cry once? It was kinda sad but people kind of exaggerated the amount of sadness.

7 Upvotes

r/YourLieinApril • • Nov 23 '25

Question Did anyone else didn’t like the 1st episode of ylia that much or found it boring?

0 Upvotes

I don’t think of it like that but when I recommended it to my friend because it’s one of the only romance anime’s I ever liked (others being love is war etc.) she said it seemed like another typical romance anime and it’s so sad because I find it so sad and funnier than ur typical romance anime I made a deal that if I drew some fanart of her fave series for her she’d have to watch 2 more episodes did I make the right call and did u feel the same way when u watched episode 1? She did seem to like other slow-paced,non-action packed anime’s like TAD


r/YourLieinApril • • Apr 11 '26

Question Should I continue?

2 Upvotes

I started watching Your lie in April a few days ago, and currently are on Episode 8, and so far I absolutely hate it. I can't stand the characters, aside from the mc who is decently interesting. The Story seems mediocare to me. Not saying it's bad, I just don't like it...

So should I continue watching it or just stop?


r/YourLieinApril • • Dec 08 '25

Anime I hate this anime Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I honestly ended up hating this anime.
What’s the point of Tsubaki loving Kousei while he’s in love with Kaori, and Kaori pretending she loves Watari, and Watari pretending he loves her while he’s literally dating another girl?
It just feels like everyone is emotionally out of sync on purpose.

Both Tsubaki and Kaori broke my heart.
It would’ve been so much better if Tsubaki didn’t have feelings for Kousei, kind of like I Want to Eat Your Pancreas, where the childhood friend doesn’t fall for the MC, which makes the story cleaner.

And I’ll admit this: sometimes I even ended up resenting Kaori because of Tsubaki, which made me feel like a horrible person.
I’ve always liked Tsubaki more anyway, and the anime pushes way too hard on the emotional drama with the whole “Kaori is going to die” thing. Honestly, that part never felt right to me.

I actually did like the anime overall, and I cried during the final scene when Kaori says goodbye to Kousei.
But even with that, I couldn’t shake this constant discomfort the whole time, because Tsubaki’s feelings were always at the back of my mind.


r/YourLieinApril • • Sep 23 '21

Meme Change my mind. Spoiler

Post image
220 Upvotes

r/YourLieinApril • • May 02 '22

Anime well just like after completing a sad anime I'm here to give my (NOBODY ASKED) opinion Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Was pretty good.

But . You're gonna hate me for this. r/unpopularopinion

Kaori Was pretty annoying for me. It was kinda something like just don't enter someone's life if you know you're gonna leave him soon. it actually feels bad lol. Im pretty sure i said atleast 10 times just die already. Maybe it's just me who likes sad endings (like really sad just imagine She died and he left Piano for good and maybe isolated himself kinda ending)

Well atleast i was a bit sad when she died at the end . F

Edit - i was wrong . It hurts bro. especially completing it at the end on April. i feel my hear beating really fast.getting anxious. She shouldn't have die.it takes some time but you realise it.


r/YourLieinApril • • May 19 '26

Question Spin-off

4 Upvotes

guys why hasn't the author written an spin-off where Kaori survives i haven't watched the anime but still want to see an happy ending as an pacifist


r/YourLieinApril • • Nov 23 '21

Anime Kaori is literally psy/men abusing Arima..

0 Upvotes

People say they’re always the best ship, but never release she’s physically hurting him by kicking whatever and mostly mentally by FORCING him to play the piano.. then she’ll beg on her knees when he says no. Only on ep 6 rn


r/YourLieinApril • • May 07 '22

Anime “Clannad” , “Your name”, “Silent Voice”, “ I want to eat your Pancreas”, and “ Anohana” are not even 1/10 as sad as Your Lie in April Spoiler

0 Upvotes

There isn’t a single anime out there that is close to YLIA , emotionally lol


r/YourLieinApril • • Mar 23 '23

Anime Kaori Derserved better

0 Upvotes

She deserved someone far better than Kousei, she also deserved to have her so called “ friends” get more emotional and depressed after her death instead of the weak ending we got with Kousei shedding a tear or 2 .

Kaori was done so dirty , I can’t really get over it after 6 years. The Writer really pisses me off .


r/YourLieinApril • • Apr 01 '25

Meme Hey guys, look! It's a Lego minifigure of Kaori! :D

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/YourLieinApril • • Jul 31 '24

Anime For how much I like the show the endings are really dissapointing Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The problems are

  1. They are both heavily Kaori focused. I know very well that Kaori is the most popular character in the show, but making her the main focus kinda just makes them boring, when I like everybody in the maincast more than her.

  2. I don’t like the music. Well I actually like Kirameki, the song of the first ending, but the mix is bad. The second ending’s song is fine, but it just lacks hard compared to other songs in the show.

  3. They are visually boring. The first one is mainly stills and the second one is one visual with the color changing for the first half and then a looping animation.

For something positive, both of the endings are very reasonant on thematic and storytelling levels. The first is basically Kousei reminiscing about Kaori as we see in the final shots where Kousei lets go of the cherryblossom, something that has been used to visually represent Kaori and represents spring in japanese culture, calling back to the final line of the show ”A spring without you is coming”, and the shot of Kaori looking at the screen directly (basically looking at Kousei) The second one is one of the best heaven allegories I’ve seen alongside taking place in the same place where the final performance of Kousei and Kaori happens.

In the end these are meh EDs with some of the best storytelling I’ve seen