I feel like in general, people don't like AI content, and there is a swing towards being authentic/an actual human being. However, when I look at all the thumbnails from top performing channels and videos, pretty much all of them look so heavily edited that they could be a straight up AI generation of that creator's picture. What gives? I mean, if people are turned off by AI or fake content, why are they so crazy about heavily edited/AI looking thumbnails of the creators?
Ok so I think I need to clarify more because a lot of people assume I'm coming from the "echo chamber of reddit, which is anti-AI". I'm not - this is literally the first time I've posted in this sub and I spend most of my time on Youtube, seeing what is actually happening, rather than in here reading what people are talking about. Based on what I saw happening on Youtube, I came here with a question to see what people thought about it. (Wow, that was spectacularly wordy and awkwardly phrased.)
My perspective comes from watching successful Youtube creators who give advice on what's working or not working for them. They are the ones saying that they've noticed viewers are repelled by content that looks obviously AI. One of them even had to start filming with a crappier camera because her comments section was full of people saying it was AI because she looked too perfect. These creators have also pointed out that Instagram posting has moved away from the perfect, polished, heavily filtered posts of the past to more raw, natural, 'authentic' - looking posts of people.
Obviously we're not far away from a time when this will be a moot point because AI will be able to consistently pull off avatars that look exactly like raw, authentic real people and also talk like them with pauses and unique personal anecdotes. But as far as I can see, we're not there yet.
So, this made me wonder why, if people seem to dislike AI avatar content in their videos and would prefer hearing from a real human, they are at the same time MORE attracted to heavily AI edited or AI created thumbnails, even as they are searching to consume real human video content.
I agree with the points people have made about optimizing for a small screen/tiny thumbnail, and also the point about it just being seen as 'packaging" - people recognize that the packaging is not an accurate representation of what they're going to find inside the box.