r/YookaLaylee • • Jul 26 '17

Discussion Why Dunkey's Review was flawed

0 Upvotes

EDIT 1: PLEASE READ AND UNDERSTAND THE NOTE DOWN BELOW READING FIRST.

EDIT 2: This is just one small reason why the video was flawed, but I think it's a big one too. He takes a lot of small issues and blows them up more than he should have (Ex: Unity bashing, no pause music, the few reoccurring characters, etc.)

Note: Before I start this little criticism on videogamedunkey's Yooka-Laylee review, I DO NOT CARE if Dunkey liked or dislikes Yooka-Laylee. However, his personal opinion is different than his review. I can't criticize his personal opinion on if he liked the game or not, but I am 100% free to criticize his review on how he presents his opinion. Also want to mention that I LOVE Dunkey. Even after this post, I will still continue to watch and love Dunkey. This rant does NOT mean that I hate Dunkey, so please do not interpret this as a hate post. This is a criticism post about how he showed his opinions, not on his opinions on the game itself.

I was on Youtube having a friendly debate talking about whether Dunkey's Yooka-Laylee review was good or not. The person agreed with Dunkey's review, but I very very much disagreed with Dunkey's review, and I would like to share with you guys why Dunkey's review on Yooka-Laylee was terrible.

Dunkey's whole video rode on 1 thesis that he made very clear in his long intro: Banjo-Tooie was a terrible game, and thus Yooka-Laylee is a terrible game because it followed a lot of Banjo-Tooie's formulas. Already, this thesis is INCREDIBLY flawed. It wouldn't have been bad if Dunkey spoke like it was just simply his own opinion. However, Dunkey spoke like his opinion was the one and only opinion and he had to be correct (now I'm sure that's not what he meant, but that's for sure how he presented it).

Let's assume that Yooka-Laylee perfectly follows the Banjo-Tooie formula. Saying that Banjo-Tooie is a terrible game and treating it as fact like how Dunkey did is absurd.

For the Banjo-Kazooie Vs. Banjo-Tooie debate, it always comes down to preference. Banjo-Kazooie was more packed but easier, while Banjo-Tooie was bigger and more explorable, but harder. Both games are often VERY tied when you try to compete them against each other. Here's some examples.

  1. This straw poll voted Banjo-Kazooie (51%) vs Banjo-Tooie (49%), with other 300 votes. That's REALLY damn close, but Banjo-Kazooie with 1% more. http://www.strawpoll.me/11792212/r

  2. This Gamenesia poll doesn't show how many people voted, butit was Banjo-Kazooie (49.34%) vs. Banjo-Tooie (50.66%). Again, another VERY close tie, but with Banjo-Tooie in the lead. https://www.gamnesia.com/polls/game-clash-banjo-kazooie-vs.-banjo-tooie

  3. The Playtonic Games Forum did a Banjo-Kazooie vs. Banjo-Tooie poll. The results were Banjo-Kazooie (40%) vs. Banjo-Tooie (57%). Banjo-Tooie won the lead by a lot on this one. http://forums.playtonicgames.com/viewtopic.php?t=4227

  4. HOWEVER, Following #3's, I myself did a poll back in February, 2016 on what people's favorite Banjo-Kazooie game was. Only taking the numbers of BK and BT, Banjo-Kazooie (55.29%) vs. Banjo-Tooie (44.7%). This poll was much in the favor of Banjo-Kazooie. https://www.facebook.com/groups/YookaLaylee/permalink/1044746052215352/

Conclusion: The reason why I didn't like Dunkey's review is because he rode on the thesis of "Banjo-Tooie was a terrible game, thus Yooka-Laylee was a terrible game" so much, but he failed to realize that Banjo-Tooie is very highly regarded to be just as good as Banjo-Kazooie, and the 4 polls that I gave is proof that it is VERY difficult to show which game is better, but Dunkey still failed to recognize this, thus why his review was not good in the slightest. Again, I love Dunkey, but that was a terrible review...

REMINDER: I LOVE Dunkey. This post does not mean that I hate Dunkey. Please do not take it as that.


r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 10 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Feeling a bit disappointed honestly.

0 Upvotes

As someone who's favorite game of all time is Banjo and who really enjoyed the original Yooka Laylee despite its faults, I was extremely excited to see them take the time to really flesh this game out, fix the problems, and make the game it's own thing. Unfortunately it just feels like we've gone from being "Banjo-Kazooie from Wish" to "Mario Odyssey from Wish".

Don't get me wrong, a lot of things like the graphics and fixes they made to the way the character controller and camera feel are extremely good improvements, but the first time the "You got a Pagie" screen showed up I got nervous. Then I saw the coins, then the health bar circle, then the way Yooka's spin feels now, then the "Multi-Pagies", and then Trowzer's new shop, and then the quills, etc. I mean it wasn't bad enough to just make the quills have the same function as the purple coins but you actually made them purple? I get it, Odyssey was a wildly successful modern 3D platformer and a great game, to take some inspiration from it is fine, but a lot of this feels blatantly copied one for one. It's like rather than taking the existing BK formula and using their experience to build it into what it should have been they just pivoted into copying a different game that they knew worked well more recently.

I haven't really seen this talked about much yet, just wondering if anyone's feeling the same way?

Edit: For some reason everyone keeps thinking I'm talking about mechanics, just to clarify I am talking specifically about the way the things they borrow from Odyssey are PRESENTED exactly the same way where they're a 1 to 1 rip off (like how when you get a pagie or moon the exact same animation/text plays in both games, or how they changed the health bar UI to be literally the exact same, etc). I'm not at all saying the mechanics they borrow are bad, just that they should have put their own spin on the way they're presented rather than just copying the exact presentation style the game they're trying to draw from uses.


r/YookaLaylee • • Dec 11 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Original was better in my opinion

0 Upvotes

I got this with the owner of the Original sale and play it with my son together.

He likes it off course but me 😂 hmm.

Wasn't it that the orig crowdfunding had the goal to make an good old jump n run like banjo & kazooie?

Damn the original yooka lailee nailed it in my opinion, it was like N64 times i loved it so hard.

Getting new moves (the flying now is an cloud world item 🙄), fewer pagies so you had harder to work to get to the endboss ect.

You had the Boss of each level not at first when you enter. I like (not the boss thing) that you now have the whole word and the graphics now, also 60 fps but like everybody sayed its now like mario odysee and for this Game i just want Banjo Kazooie feeling not mario 🤔.

Whats your thoughts? Original or Re Replaylee?


r/YookaLaylee • • May 04 '15

Discussion DAE not want the fully orchestral score?

5 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, I want them to get as much money as possible, but I actually much prefer the simplicity of synthetic tones or small ensembles for video game music. I've always felt that orchestral soundtracks tend to fade away into the background and don't deliver on the really strong melodies that older games used to be so memorable for.

Maybe I just haven't heard a particularly grabbing orchestral soundtrack yet but I've never been a fan. I went to the Zelda 25th Anniversary Orchestra thing and they just didn't hit me the same way.

Edit: Can this sub not be one of those ones that downvotes anything remotely and in any way negative? This was a question. Come on guys.


r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 05 '22

Impossible Lair The Impossible Lair was never meant to be "impossible", and that's why the game feels so bittersweet and disappointing...

0 Upvotes

Everyone keeps parroting the line that the Impossible Lair is "Impossible" and that you shouldn't complain that the difficulty spike is so high. But, if it were actually impossible, it wouldn't even be able to traverse at all. You know, "not capable of being accomplished".

Consider:

  1. First Chapter: Baby's first platformer.

  2. Subsequent chapters: DK Country difficult at best.

  3. Impossible Lair: Celeste Chapters 8-9, but is designed for cheap hits and limited tries.

Instead, the game is actually just very, very difficult, beyond the scope of the entire game. The game's final level is actually an overly long, tedious, frustrating CHORE of a gauntlet that had only ONE quality of life fix: the checkpoints. And for most, even that's not enough, since the whole lair is essentially FOUR very hard levels with no Checkmates. I could, but why bother when I could put the skill to use on something like Celeste (with doesn't punt you all the way back to a stage)?

And the game starts out as being friendly to newcomers.

I get that the developers wanted to make an easy game to make the Lair seem even harder by comparison. And I don't have a problem with the Lair as it is. What I have a problem with is their judgment including it as the final level. The final level should be the final exam of all that you've encountered thus far, in proportion to the rest of the game. So what does it say about the game when the Checkmate tell you there's no shame in taking the easy way out, yet the Impossible Lair is designed to be a precise, grueling platformer experience with cheap hits galore. Which is it? I ignored the Checkmate's help, thinking it would be adequate practice for the Lair, but even based on what I've played the Lair is just too much for the sake of being too much (a reoccurring problem of Playtonic's final levels).

I just think this level should've been nerfed further (to match the difficulty of the whole game more or less for first time players). How? I propose several ways (either/or, or altogether):

  1. Easiest way: With every Capital B boss fight successfully vanquished, all the bees you entered with in the Lair replenished. For example, if you entered the Lair with 10 bees, yet lost some, each time you beat Capital B, you get all the bees you've lost back.

  2. Each chapter has ten T.W.I.T coins. If you find them all, a switch in the level can be activated that'll make the Impossible Lair less of an unreasonable pain. For example, in the 5th chapter you encountered saws. Why not make it so that when you have all ten T.W.I.T coins for the chapter, you have a switch that you can toggle that'll turn on or off the saws in the final level.

  3. On that note, why not include a way to change the level using berries? Maybe fire berries sets the whole Lair on fire, melting the ice portions, etc.

  4. Add Checkmates in each section of the Lair.

  5. Bring tonics in the Lair. Some won't help, but it's weird that you can't use any of them at all just for this part of the game.

  6. Remove some obstacles until after you beat it (add them for subsequent challenge runs IF you want something harder).

  7. Shorten the lair. Take the first three sections of the Lair, cut them in third and splice them together for one long run. Fight Capital B beat ONCE after the gauntlet, with one hit for each phase. Make the last run escaping the Lair a cool looking formality with the regenerated bees taking all of the hits (and you lose none). The "REAL" Lair as is should be a hidden requirement AFTER you beat it once, for the endgame real challenge.

Of course, also toggle these options, so players can choose the most difficult settings if they want.

Some of these solutions won't be feasible as the lair stands now, since they'd have to go back and change a lot. But I wish they would have implemented all these ideas from the beginning. This would have brought a whole new dimension to the game. It would have made the game a BETTER Tropical Freeze. But, oh well, missed opportunities just to stick to a misguided "literal" interpretation of the lair's name, after all.

"Get gud" just doesn't cut it here, and anyone saying that doesn't quite understand what I'm saying. The level itself is a fine challenge, but doesn't quite fit for the main game. It's too long and the skill level jumps significantly to a boring, exhausting endurance test. Seriously, there were times playing the Lair and I thought "OOOOOH, MY WORDS!!! Are we back on THIS again?!?!" or "Come on, I get it! When does it end???". Like always, the last part is TOO LONG. Short but sweet, fellas, it ain't that hard. Quality. Over. Quantity. (Like the rest of the game.)

That's too inconsistent of a jump to just And most people don't care to "get gud" on such an unfair difficulty skip (there are more fair challenges to play). This is why saves states are a Godsend, and I sorely missed them while playing this game.


r/YookaLaylee • • Dec 31 '16

Question Will Yooka-Laylee follow the Banjo-Kazooie model where you must collect all Quills in 1 sitting before exiting the world, or will Yooka-Laylee follow the Banjo-Tooie model where your progress in collecting the Quills are saved when you exit and re-enter the world?

0 Upvotes

Will Yooka-Laylee follow the Banjo-Kazooie model where you must collect all Quills in 1 sitting before exiting the world, or will Yooka-Laylee follow the Banjo-Tooie model where your progress in collecting the Quills are saved when you exit and re-enter the world?


r/YookaLaylee • • Jul 30 '21

Impossible Lair Impossible lair isn't fun imo

0 Upvotes

When I play yookalaylee and the impossible lair I died alot of times but I still felt like it was my fault, but the impossible lair is just so, unforgiving, you land on a platform but you slip down because of the controlls, you get hurt becuase your leg slightly touched something, it's just so nitpicky I'm gonna continue trying to beat the level, but even if I do it won't change my view, the level is simply not fun (imo)


r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 10 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Re-Playlee is fun, but more than a little disappointing

4 Upvotes

[Gameplay spoilers perhaps - not story]

I'm 42 Pagies in and have been enjoying it. The additional content is nice, and the addition of a map and fast travel points is a very welcome change. But it's nowhere near the amount of new content that 'Double the pagies per level' makes it sound like. The reality is a lot of those extra pagies are just things from the original game that now have a Pagie as a reward (i.e. you get one for every Ghost Writer you collect.) To be fair I've only reached the 2nd world so far, but it doesn't look like the worlds themselves have been changed at all.

The disappointing part for me is the removal of pretty much every Banjo-Kazooie inspired element of the gameplay. You no longer unlock moves. Trowser is still in the game but he's just like... another generic upgrade shop. The new coins, the world-specific currency for cosmetics and upgrades...it's just so obviously trying to emulate Super Mario Odyssey and/or Donkey Kong Bananza to the point it's kind of funny. Not that I dislike either of those games - I just finished Bananza last night, it is peak) - but it feels weirdly like a sort of betrayal to the game's original roots.

I guess I feel disappointed because while I definitely didn't think the original game was perfect, it seems that all my gripes where about the wrong things. To me, the biggest issue with Yooka-Laylee was that it only had five worlds, and they were all too big and lacked focus in their design. As a result, the Banjo-related elements like learning new moves in each world didn't work as well as they could have. It's sad to see that instead of expanding on the game, Re-Playlee abandons Banjo entirely. I guess it'll appeal to a different audience. Maybe the original game was more 'for me.' But for all the changes they made, I feel like this should've been a sequel with new worlds and a new story, rather than just 'the same game, but it's Mario Odyssey now.'


r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 19 '25

YL Series Not a fan of Playtonic's PR on Social Media

0 Upvotes

I finished the game and had a blast, but over the last few days I've seen Playtonic's social media on both X and Bluesky post things that in my opinion, reflect poorly on the company and its employees as a whole.

I try to look at these situations by not treating a company as one person. However at the same time, it's the job of the person running this account to represent Playtonic in the best light that they can.

Generally I think whoever this person is was doing a fine job... except for exceptions like reposting foot fetish fanart, posting their own generated AI art and how its "just for fun" (and locked comments), and Im sure theres more if I look harder. I'm hoping they take this experience to think harder before posting because in my opinion it feels sorta tone-deaf towards the community. I dont think anyone needs to be "replaced", just set better boundaries. Thats all

https://bsky.app/profile/playtonicgames.com/post/3m3feyq62ns25 https://x.com/PlaytonicGames/status/1979105848900157486?t=OJZyFvfhG6BZbtZpVsUXHw&s=19


r/YookaLaylee • • Nov 05 '17

Issue a literal gamebreaking bug

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 12 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Did they not think this through? All abilities at the start...

1 Upvotes

So I mentioned this in another thread, but at first I thought this was either a bug, or that after the tutorial there was gonna be some crazy cataclysmic story event where I somehow get robbed of all of them and have to get them back.

But nope, this is how it is.

Never mind the fact that collecting them as you go kinda gave you more time to learn and appreciate them and what they do - but every level (except the overworld due to gates) is now 100%able on the first visit.

And if you do that in Tribalstack Tropics alone, you can after that unlock the entire Overworld up to where Capital B is (but not fight him) and every level up to Galleon Galaxy.

Though that's not entirely the fault of the abilities - it's the incredibly cheap costs of the progression gates, considering the game has 300 Pagies. What the hell are they all for, bragging and achievement rights and nothing more? You need less than half of that for the final boss!

And yes I know "you don't have to do it all in one go, you can come back later" - but there isn't really much of an incentive to wait. You don't get 'stronger', you don't get 'older and wiser', so might as well while you're there.

I do have one question though, without any spoilers though please. I just cleared Glitterglaze Glacier, haven't touched the other three levels.

I am a bit curious though since according to the menu, defeating the final boss does have Pagies behind it. So I do have to wonder if there's some minor postgame content where additional Pagies can serve a purpose. I DON'T want to know what it is - I'm not expecting a whole level, even if it's just cosmetics or random stuff, is there an in-game purpose for the remaining whopping 180 Pagies?

Just want to know if there is or not - because I'm heavily considering doing Capital B now and then going to the other levels - not just because of the constant notification to go fight him - but also because if there's additional postgame content after the Pagies - even if it's very small, I'd rather have it available to unlock as I go rather than beat him later and get it all at once.

So all I want to know is, is there anything at all?


r/YookaLaylee • • Aug 31 '16

It's a real shame there won't be an NX port

0 Upvotes

It's arriving Q1 2017, so is the NX... And it won't happen because we only funded for the consoles listed, which only includes the Wii U on nintendo's part.

I feel as if the Wii U port is gonna be quickly forgotten if we only have a few months of gameplay on the Wii U before the NX is released, Would you lot donate again for an NX port if that were ever to happen?


r/YookaLaylee • • Dec 14 '20

Media So i started yooka laylee let's play series, i love this game!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/YookaLaylee • • Jan 24 '17

Fluff Gamecube Startup Theme - YL Edition

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 11 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Can we stop the whole "that's how it was supposed to be" fallacy?

4 Upvotes

I'm enjoying the remake, and I did enjoy the OG back then, but can we stop the idea that YL was supposed to be a Mario Odyssey copy (a game that released later) since the beginning?

I see a lot of people commenting this, but the OG, while it had lots of flaws that, imo, are still present in the remake, did a good job trying to catch the Banjo-Kazooie feeling in a way. You had the notes, the Jiggies, and the moves you needed to progress in the main hub. I never got the hate from the book expansion gimmick tbh. Banjo-Kazooie and Tooie were my favorite games back then. I could see some potential in YL that was held back by gameplay and minor design issues.

I can understand now why they changed things for a more modern audience, such as putting tons of easy collectibles (like moons), giving all the moves from the start, etc., but it's not an improvement; it's just a design philosophy change. We have to remember the game was funded with a promise of being a Banjo-Kazooie spiritual successor. It's sad they just gave up to be another Mario copy, but hey, I can enjoy that too. Just don't think the OG was that way because it was rushed or poorly directed. It just tried to be BK so much but never reached its highs, and that's okay. The same way, I don't think the remake is not even 1/3 as good as Odyssey, but I can enjoy that too... i just dont like the general ideia that BK design is bad because the OG had lot of other problems


r/YookaLaylee • • Aug 24 '16

please don't make quitting the game be a game over

0 Upvotes

Especially when you say "Save & Quit", don't have that lead me to K.Rool destroying D.K. Island, that's a punishment for using a necessary game mechanic.


r/YookaLaylee • • Apr 15 '21

YL Series Hey friends I made a poll on twitter: When you think Playtonic Games will announce their new game. Participate if you can.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/YookaLaylee • • Apr 11 '17

Question It's the 11th everywhere in the world. Why can't I play the game?

1 Upvotes

Honestly extremely disappointed by not being able to play a game when it's supposed to be out. Especially after backing the kickstarter. Well, fuck be to this game I guess.


r/YookaLaylee • • Dec 03 '25

Yooka-Replaylee The dev finally commented on the 60fps patch, but I wish he hasn’t, because it’s ridiculous.

39 Upvotes

You can hear his answer here, in the first couple of minutes:

https://youtu.be/yQrUcRybri8?si=80ktSecitTHOoq4z

I honestly don’t even know what to say — it came off as completely tone-deaf and dismissive.

GameXplain simply asked if there would be a 60 FPS patch, and the dev replied with something along the lines of “we’re facing more challenges than expected” and that we should “keep our expectations in check.” Then they even gave this absurd example, saying that when the game was running at 30 FPS on the original Switch, it was considered the definitive version and nobody complained — but now suddenly people want 60 FPS.

Like, what kind of lame excuse is that? The Switch 2 is clearly more than capable of running this game at 60 FPS — games that are way more demanding graphically, like Hyrule Warriors: Age of Imprisonment, Metroid Prime 4, the new Spongebob 3D platformer, Tomb Raider DE, and way too many other examples can all hit 60 FPS.

So hearing them talk as if 60 FPS is some unreachable target is just baffling. It honestly feels like they’re telling us to settle for less, as if we should just be happy it even runs on the Switch 2 at all. That attitude is what really pissed me off — it’s not about expectations, it’s about effort and transparency.


r/YookaLaylee • • Dec 12 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Is the 60fps upgrade out on switch 2 yet?

0 Upvotes

I really want to play it but would rather wait till it’s upgraded so it feels better to play


r/YookaLaylee • • Jun 04 '17

[P]review Maj0r Lee: Yooka-Laylee - Most Underrated Game of All Time?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/YookaLaylee • • Mar 19 '17

Discussion Let's Play "Predict the Names of Worlds 3 & 5"! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I want to hear what we think the names might end up being. We have a swamp world and a space world. GO!


r/YookaLaylee • • May 07 '15

Fun Looks like we know the next round of Kickstarter Stretch Goals now.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/YookaLaylee • • Oct 31 '25

Yooka-Replaylee Yooka-Replayee - My short , disappointed review

0 Upvotes

I really, really want to love this, but the core gameplay structure is just, way too easy and linear.

I never played the original, and there is some serious effort on display here, but I think the core structure of the game was just not thought out enough.

I'm playing Mario Odyssey for the first time ever as well, and although I have issue with it being too easy and having too many moons, it works MUCH better, thanks to :

  • the bigger variety of worlds/enemies/environments/mechanics you can explore and interact with

  • a really thought out, fun risk/reward movement system

  • smaller , better built worlds

-

-

NO SENSE OF PROGRESSION

In YR, here's no sense of progression or accomplishment ( as I know that the moveset is unlocked from the start), so it feels like you're going in a straight line to nowhere.

-

-

CONFUSING LEVEL DESIGN

The worlds are static, and a bit visually overwhelming.

While some sense of scale and being able to "get lost" is a great idea, worlds are often so dense that even after 100%ing a level, I can barely make out the map in my head. Areas are just way too close together, and lack enough distinct structures to be able to clearly orient youself.

Doesn't help that the map is equally unintuitive, and so are the controls for it. Took me a combined, solid 10 minutes to figure out how the whole map menu works.

-

-

PAGIES ( MOSTLY) FEEL INSIGNIFICANT

Most pagies are a ground pound, sonar boom, or a couple of trivial jumps away. and they hardly feel like a reward for an actual accomplishment.

I'm not a fan of the micro-dopamine structure of game design, and would've much preferred whole areas built around less, more meaningful and challenging pagies.

Leave the smaller, less significant discoveries for quills.

-

-

A FINE GAME FOR KIDS/ CASUAL PLAY

Furthermore, I don't get why a "hard mode" is weirdly crammed in the tonic system? It feels like the devs coudln't be bothered to code in a second option at the start, or at least to put it as an option in the menu...

-

-

SO, WHAT DID I LIKE?

The most "fun" part of the game is actually scouting the world for harder to find quills and Pagies, but even then, having no vibrating tonic that helps you find the final quills, and having to resort to online guides feels like such an oversight in a collectathon. Same goes for Pagie pieces.

Mario Odyssey has a really smart way of giving you different levels of hints through the Parrot ( name hint) and Toad (location hint) system. Would've appreciated something like that, along with the vibration tonic.

Overall, I appreciate the the effort that has gone into this, but I don't feel like the final product is very appealing. I hope they use this as a learning oppotunity and as a stepping stone to a greater game.


r/YookaLaylee • • Jun 09 '17

Fan Creation Videogames, animated in Sonic-style! (features Donkey Kong Country)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes