r/YookaLaylee • u/pandaboy78 • Jul 26 '17
Discussion Why Dunkey's Review was flawed
EDIT 1: PLEASE READ AND UNDERSTAND THE NOTE DOWN BELOW READING FIRST.
EDIT 2: This is just one small reason why the video was flawed, but I think it's a big one too. He takes a lot of small issues and blows them up more than he should have (Ex: Unity bashing, no pause music, the few reoccurring characters, etc.)
Note: Before I start this little criticism on videogamedunkey's Yooka-Laylee review, I DO NOT CARE if Dunkey liked or dislikes Yooka-Laylee. However, his personal opinion is different than his review. I can't criticize his personal opinion on if he liked the game or not, but I am 100% free to criticize his review on how he presents his opinion. Also want to mention that I LOVE Dunkey. Even after this post, I will still continue to watch and love Dunkey. This rant does NOT mean that I hate Dunkey, so please do not interpret this as a hate post. This is a criticism post about how he showed his opinions, not on his opinions on the game itself.
I was on Youtube having a friendly debate talking about whether Dunkey's Yooka-Laylee review was good or not. The person agreed with Dunkey's review, but I very very much disagreed with Dunkey's review, and I would like to share with you guys why Dunkey's review on Yooka-Laylee was terrible.
Dunkey's whole video rode on 1 thesis that he made very clear in his long intro: Banjo-Tooie was a terrible game, and thus Yooka-Laylee is a terrible game because it followed a lot of Banjo-Tooie's formulas. Already, this thesis is INCREDIBLY flawed. It wouldn't have been bad if Dunkey spoke like it was just simply his own opinion. However, Dunkey spoke like his opinion was the one and only opinion and he had to be correct (now I'm sure that's not what he meant, but that's for sure how he presented it).
Let's assume that Yooka-Laylee perfectly follows the Banjo-Tooie formula. Saying that Banjo-Tooie is a terrible game and treating it as fact like how Dunkey did is absurd.
For the Banjo-Kazooie Vs. Banjo-Tooie debate, it always comes down to preference. Banjo-Kazooie was more packed but easier, while Banjo-Tooie was bigger and more explorable, but harder. Both games are often VERY tied when you try to compete them against each other. Here's some examples.
This straw poll voted Banjo-Kazooie (51%) vs Banjo-Tooie (49%), with other 300 votes. That's REALLY damn close, but Banjo-Kazooie with 1% more. http://www.strawpoll.me/11792212/r
This Gamenesia poll doesn't show how many people voted, butit was Banjo-Kazooie (49.34%) vs. Banjo-Tooie (50.66%). Again, another VERY close tie, but with Banjo-Tooie in the lead. https://www.gamnesia.com/polls/game-clash-banjo-kazooie-vs.-banjo-tooie
The Playtonic Games Forum did a Banjo-Kazooie vs. Banjo-Tooie poll. The results were Banjo-Kazooie (40%) vs. Banjo-Tooie (57%). Banjo-Tooie won the lead by a lot on this one. http://forums.playtonicgames.com/viewtopic.php?t=4227
HOWEVER, Following #3's, I myself did a poll back in February, 2016 on what people's favorite Banjo-Kazooie game was. Only taking the numbers of BK and BT, Banjo-Kazooie (55.29%) vs. Banjo-Tooie (44.7%). This poll was much in the favor of Banjo-Kazooie. https://www.facebook.com/groups/YookaLaylee/permalink/1044746052215352/
Conclusion: The reason why I didn't like Dunkey's review is because he rode on the thesis of "Banjo-Tooie was a terrible game, thus Yooka-Laylee was a terrible game" so much, but he failed to realize that Banjo-Tooie is very highly regarded to be just as good as Banjo-Kazooie, and the 4 polls that I gave is proof that it is VERY difficult to show which game is better, but Dunkey still failed to recognize this, thus why his review was not good in the slightest. Again, I love Dunkey, but that was a terrible review...
REMINDER: I LOVE Dunkey. This post does not mean that I hate Dunkey. Please do not take it as that.