r/YearOfShakespeare • • Mar 29 '24

Discussion Why is Kindle So Bad with Shakespeare?

1 Upvotes

Sorry ranting. Part of the reason I read on a kindle is so I can use the built-in dictionary. Unfortunately, actual words aren't even included, let alone archaic contractions.

Kindle is a reading service and Shakespeare is like the face of western literature, so it just blows my mind that the dictionary isn't better than it is.

Anyone else?


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Feb 21 '21

Discussion Much To Do About Nothing: Metamorphosis

1 Upvotes

r/YearOfShakespeare • • Feb 21 '21

Discussion Much To Do About Nothing: Language, Poetry, Anthesis & Other

2 Upvotes

r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jan 27 '25

Performances The Winter's Tale - Movie/Other Adaptations Discussion

2 Upvotes

This is the most diverse list of adaptations that I've researched for a play so far for this subreddit.  ‘The Winter’s Tale’ has been performed through so many different formats; from motion capture puppets to opera, a ballet, a silent movie and a YA novel. Henry IV could never! I loved this play so much and found it to have a unique mix of genres in it. It makes sense to me that such a play would inspire so many different takes on the story. Surprisingly, there seems to be a bit of a lack of recent on-screen live adaptations – I could really see Hollywood making a huge movie adaptation of this, or even a tv show that uses the play as a base for a longer series.

Next week we will be starting 'Twelfth Night' and reading Act 1 Scene 1 to the end of Act 2 Scene 3.

 Screen Adaptations:

  Stage:

  • Royal Shakespeare Company has produced several versions of the play, with a lot of big names playing the role of Leontes. From what I can see, quite a few of these productions had some experimental element in them. For example, the 1969 play had a strict, white-toned set and had Dame Judi Dench play the roles of both Hermione and Perdita. The 1992 play, directed by Adrian Noble, had a set with a lot of giant balloons on it. The 2009 production, directed by David Farr even had a fantasy style Bohemia, with paper scenery in it.   Past productions | The Winter's Tale | Royal Shakespeare Company

  • Kenneth Branagh, 2015 starring Judi Dench, as Paulina. This play seems to have keep some parts of the play (such as the setting) traditional, while playing into some of the darker moments of the story. The Winter's Tale review – Kenneth Branagh and Judi Dench offer intriguing touches | Theatre | The Guardian

  • Cheek By Jowl, 2016 directed by Declan Donnellan. This production was very experimental, playing into the darker, human side of Leontes while still embracing a lot of the fantastical elements of the original play. Leontes, played by Orlando James, was portrayed as younger and even more paranoid and nasty than in the original play. This production also included parts where actors were encouraged to ad-lib. It was toured all around the world and livestreamed at points too. The Winter’s Tale - Cheek by Jowl

  • Shakespeare's Globe, 2018 (2023) The Winter’s Tale review – Blanche McIntyre celebrates the play's problems | Theatre | The Guardian

 Other:

 

Further Discussion:

The discussion on these posts tends to be a bit more relaxed than on our usual discussion posts. Here are some prompts to get the conversation going:

  • What do you think it is about this play that has inspired so many different types of adaptations? I think it’s the mixing of genres – in earlier plays by Shakespeare we don’t see the same mix of tragedy with romance or comedy.

  • Have you seen any of the adaptations mentioned above? What did you think of it? Did any actors or actresses stand out to you as being a good, or bad, fit for the characters?

  • If you’ve seen any other adaptations, let us know in the comments. Would you recommend them?

  • What adaptations would you like to see? I would love to see a live action tv-show adaptation.

  • Are there any actors that you would like to see in an adaptation of this play? Are there any directors that you would like to see adapt it? I would love to see a Wicked style book or musical.

  • Conversely, are there any actors or directors who you think should stay well away from this play? As much as I would love a tv show, I think a channel like HBO could potentially ruin the charm of this play, if they got their hands on it.

  • Have you read either of the books mentioned above? What did you think of them?


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jun 24 '26

Readalong Timon of Athens Act 5.1 to the end of the play Reading Discussion

2 Upvotes

I definitely made a bit of a mistake with separating them into three since we've only got one act today. We're at the end of the play and Timon has made his choices.

Act 5, Scene 1

Timon is visited by the Poet and the Painter seeking the gold Timon is now rumored to possess. After he drives them away empty-handed, he receives a delegation of two Athenian senators, who plead in vain with him to return to Athens and rescue it from the approaching Alcibiades. Timon refuses and withdraws to die.

Act 5, Scene 2

Athens learns that it will surely fall to Alcibiades. Its senators seek shelter behind its walls.

Act 5, Scene 3

One of Alcibiades’ soldiers discovers Timon’s tomb and, since he cannot read Timon’s epitaph, he resolves to bring a wax impression of it to Alcibiades.

Act 5, scene 4

A victorious Alcibiades listens to the apologies of the senators and agrees to the conditions they set. Athens then opens its gates to Alcibiades and his army. Presented with Timon’s epitaph, Alcibiades reads it aloud and promises peace to Athens.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Feb 21 '21

Discussion Much Ado About Nothing: Themes

4 Upvotes

r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jan 18 '21

Orsino

14 Upvotes

So, a lot of people seem to not like Orsino, or not "get" him. It's something multiple people have said here.

I feel like he can be one of those semi-blank-canvas characters, who actors/directors/the imagination can take in a lot of different ways. (e.g. the fanservice Orsino in the Lincoln Center production that was linked in the Productions thread). The flipside of characters like this is that it's easy to keep him bland by just going by the text and not adding anything.

As for my thoughts on him... he's melodramatic and I think that's pretty fun. He also brings in Feste to sing a song about death when he's... trying to woo Cesario, mostly unaware of his own intentions --

Yeah, he's fun. It's also a nice contrast how stable Viola is in contrast to all that.

I also do think it would fit well with the text to make him really sexy and sensual, something that even that production that has him shirtless doesn't quite do. It's more to do with tone of voice, pacing, body language... I was drawing some storyboards, but they didn't turn out... presentable... I might try again. I have a production design/direction in mind that I've been wanting to draw a comic of for... years... but I haven't yet.

So, what are your thoughts on Orsino?


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jan 22 '25

Mod Post Going forward, links from Twitter/X will be banned

44 Upvotes

Hello all,

Things have been changing rapidly. I'm not American, but like the rest of the world we have been watching the change of regime there to see how the next four years will be. I'm sure you all have seen the clips by now, so I won't beleaguer the point, but going forward all links to Twitter/X will be removed if they are posted.

We also won't allow links from places that require a login such as Instagram/Facebook/Twitter.

If you have any comments or questions, please feel free to comment here.

Also as a friendly reminder, we do not allow anything which has used generative AI. This includes pictures, videos, text, and sound clips.

Thank you all and here's to a great year.

Edit: After further discussion between the mods, we won't be allowed screencaps either.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Aug 25 '25

Readalong Antony and Cleopatra Reading Discussion Act 3 Scene 2 to End

2 Upvotes

The ending of this play really wowed me. I vaguely knew how the play would end but Cleopatra’s ending scene was truly captivating.

Next week we will be discussing screen and stage adaptations of ‘Antony and Cleopatra’.

Next month we will be reading Macbeth.

Summary:

Act 3:

Scene 2:

Enobarbus and Agrippa discuss Antony’s marriage to Octavia. They joke about which ally Lepidus loves more: Caesar or Antony.  Octavia is sad to go. Caesar is sad too but hopes that the marriage will make the alliance between Antony and himself stronger.

Scene 3:

In Egypt, Cleopatra receives a report of Octavia looks like from a messenger. She is happy that Octavia doesn’t seem to be a beautiful or as elegant as her.

Scene 4:

Back in Athens, Antony is worried about the state of his alliance with Caesar, noting that Caesar has taken actions against Pompey that didn’t really include him. Antony talks to Octavia about it. Octavia says she doesn’t want to be torn between her loyalty to her husband or her brother. Antony sends Octavia off to Rome to ensure that the alliance remains intact. Once she is gone, he begins raising a new army though. Which is not at all suspicious.

Scene 5:

Also in Athens – Enobarbus and another follower of Antony, Eros, discuss recent war updates. Caesar and Lepidus have defeated Pompey, making the alliance between Caesar and Antony less certain. On top of this, we also learn that Caesar has used the recent battles to basically oust Lepidus from the Triumvirate. This means that the entire empire is now possibly up for grabs between Caesar and Antony (if their alliance doesn’t hold). Enobarbus ends the scene by heading off to tell Antony the news.

Scene 6:

A little while later, in Rome. Caesar discusses recent news he has received about Antony with his men. We learn Antony has returned to Egypt, reunited with Cleopatra and the pair have taken part in a royalty-style state procession. Antony has officially claimed certain lands and crowned Cleopatra as the queen of Egypt, Syria, Cyprus, and Lydia. The couple have declared their son as their heir and the ‘king of kings’ too.  

Octavia arrives from Athens, still believing she is there on a mission of peace between Antony and Caesar. Caesar enlightens her to the truth. Octavia is sad. Caesar’s men console her. Caesar claims that he held off from fighting Antony because of Octavia prior to this, but now that Octavia is in Rome that may change.

Scene 7:

This scene takes place near Actium in Greece. Caesar and Antony are at war. Cleopatra plans to take part in the coming battle. Enobarbus warns Cleopatra that there are rumours that she and her people are leading this war, which would be bad for Antony. She doesn’t care.

 Despite his advisors (and the odds) being against it, Antony decides to fight Caesar on the sea.

Scene 8:

Pre-battle still. We see Caesar give orders to his top commander, Taurus, for the coming battle. They intend to fight mainly at sea, as it is their strongest advantage but Taurus will lead the land army just in case.

Scene 9:

Back in Antony’s camp, Antony gets Enobarbus to send soldiers up a nearby hill to get an idea of the number of Caesar’s ships.

Scene 10:

The battle has started. Caesar and Antony’s navies fight at sea, with things becoming evenly matched.  Enobarbus is with the land army and watches as first Cleopatra and then Antony retreat from battle, seemingly without any real reason. Enobarbus and the other watchers are furious and ashamed of Antony. Following Antony’s lead, the rest of his navy breaks and flees.

Antony’s top land commander, Canidius, joins the watchers. He tells Enobarbus bluntly that he is forsaking Antony and plans to join Caesar. Enobarbus’ loyalty is torn but he decides to remain on Antony’s side.

Scene 11:

This scene takes place in Cleopatra’s palace in Alexandria. Antony is ashamed of his actions and believes that the war is lost. He blames Cleopatra for his actions. Cleopatra doesn’t really explain why she fled in the first place. Antony advises his advisors to seek mercy from Caesar, as he himself plans to surrender.

Scene 12:

Back in Caesar’s camp, an ambassador arrives from Antony’s side, seeking Caesar. The ambassador brings messages from Antony and Cleopatra. Antony surrenders on the condition that he gets to live, either in Egypt or Athens, as a free man. Caesar refuses. Cleopatra’s message is simple; she admits Caesar’s greatness and begs for mercy. Caesar considers this. He wants to divide Antony and Cleopatra, offering her mercy on the condition that she either kills or hands over Antony. He sends a man, Thidias, to persuade Cleopatra to turn on Antony.

Scene 13:

In the palace, Cleopatra and Enobarbus discuss the battle. We learn that Enobarbus doesn’t blame Cleopatra for losing the battle. Antony and his ambassador enter. Antony is angry Caesar’s response to his surrender and plans to challenge him to a duel. Cleopatra learns of Caesar’s offer to her. Enobarbus doesn’t think Caesar will take Antony up on the challenge, because he is already at an advantage. Antony leaves.

Thidias arrives and seems to be successful in persuading Cleopatra to turn on Antony. Enobarbus questions his loyalty and leaves. Antony returns, with Enobarbus, to see Cleopatra seemingly agreeing to Caesar’s offer. He becomes angry and sends Thidias for a whipping. He shouts at Cleopatra until she says she would rather die than betray him. Antony believes her and decides to fight with the last of his army against Caesar, this time on land. He doesn’t think the chances of success are high though and decides to spend the night drinking and partying. Enobarbus is angry about this and decides to forsake Antony.  

Act 4:

Scene 1:

Caesar learns of Antony’s initial challenge of a duel with him. He finds it funny and tells his men that the coming battle will be the deciding, and last, battle in this war.

Scene 2:

Enobarbus, still seemingly loyal to Antony, tells Antony that Caesar has refused his challenge. This confirms Antony’s plan for a final full-scale battle. Antony thanks Enobarbus for sticking by him, then begins to make plans for a night of feasting. Antony speaks and kind of says goodbye to his men. Enobarbus challenges him on this and Antony claims that he believes he will win the next battle, but he wants to party his doubts away.

Scene 3:

While discussing their odds in tomorrow’s battle, some of Antony’s soldiers hear a strange music. Some of them superstitiously think that the music is an omen that Hercules (Antony’s chosen deity) is abandoning them.

Scene 4:

The next morning, Antony gets ready for battle. Cleopatra tries to help put on his armour but doesn’t know how to do it correctly. Antony tells her that she doesn’t need her to help arm him, because she is the armourer of his heart. They kiss and say goodbye. Cleopatra tells her entourage that she wishes Caesar had agreed to the duel.

Scene 5:

While in camp, Antony is informed that Enobarbus has abandoned him but has left his stuff – including treasures – behind. Antony sends men to bring Enobarbus his stuff, with a polite goodbye from him.

Scene 6:

This scene takes place in Caesar’s camp. Caesar decides to put the people who have deserted Antony to battle in the front lines. The plan seems to be to demoralize Antony’s remaining men by making them feel like they are fighting themselves. Caesar believes that this battle will bring about “the time of universal peace” for the Roman Empire.

Enobarbus is not impressed and feels that Caesar has not treated Antony’s deserters well. His doubts are solidified when Antony’s messengers arrive with Enobarbus’ stuff and Antony’s message to him. Enobarbus decides to not fight Antony and resolves to die.

Scene 7:

On the field of battle, Caesar’s forces retreat. Antony is with a wounded friend, Scarus, when Eros arrives and tells him that he has won the battle.

Scene 8:

The battle is over. Antony returns to the palace and gives instructions to his men to track down the rest of Caesar’s army and kill them in the coming days. Cleopatra learns of Antony’s success and offers to make him armour made of gold. They leave to celebrate the victory.

Scene 9:

Back in Caesar’s camp, we meet two soldiers who are on watch. They witness Enobarbus’ last moments as he declares his regrets for leaving Antony and then dies, possibly from poison.

Scene 10:

The next day, Antony makes plans to battle most of Caesar’s remaining army at sea. He discusses his next moves with Scarus.

Scene 11:

In Caesar’s camp, we see Caesar making plans to fight Antony at sea.

Scene 12:

Antony and Scarus watch as Antony’s forces surrender to Caesar’s at sea. Despite it not being clear that it is her fault, Antony blames Cleopatra. She enters and he shouts at her, threatening to hit her. He also tells her about what Caesar will do to her next; she will become a trophy prisoner and will be paraded in front of Rome in a triumphal procession. Cleopatra gets upset and leaves. Antony curses her.

Scene 13:

Cleopatra tells her entourage about Antony’s anger at her. Charmian, one of her ladies in waiting, suggests that she goes to her monumental (future burial) tomb and send word to Antony that she is dead, in order to force Antony to mourn and apologise to her. Cleopatra does this, sending a messenger to Antony with news of her death and her devotion to him.

Scene 14:

Antony talks with Eros about how changeable life is, comparing people (and himself) to clouds. During this discussion, Cleopatra’s messenger arrives. The messenger tells Antony that Cleopatra’s last words were his name and that she died devoted to him. Antony breaks down. He tries to get Eros to kill him, but Eros kills himself instead. Antony stabs himself with his sword but manages to not make a clean cut. He remains alive but fatally wounded. His guards enter and he orders them to kill him. None of them comply.

Another messenger arrives from Cleopatra, revealing that she is alive and in her tomb. Instead of being angry, Antony has his men carry him to her.

Scene 15:

In her tomb, Cleopatra predicts that she will never leave it. She gets news that Antony is injured and dying. Antony seems to be at peace with the situation and tells Cleopatra that it is good that he died by his own hand and not Caesar’s. The couple share a last kiss. Cleopatra tells Antony that she will die rather than surrender herself to Caesar. Antony tells Cleopatra to seek Caesar’s forgiveness, in order to live. Antony tries to console Cleopatra. He dies and Cleopatra faints. When she awakens, she sends Antony’s body for a traditional Roman funeral.

Act 5:

Scene 1:

Caesar is about to send a man to demand Antony’s surrender when he learns from a messenger that Antony is dead, by his own hand. Caesar is upset by this. A messenger arrives from Cleopatra, asking Caesar what his plans are for her. He tells the messenger that he intends to be merciful. However, once the messenger is gone, Caesar starts planning the victory parade and how he can use Cleopatra in it. He sends one of his men to placate Cleopatra into staying calm and alive.

This done, he starts working on the pr damage control. He brings attendants into his tent to view letters that prove he was forced into this war, as it would be dishonourable for him to have started a civil war.

Scene 2:

Caesar and his men come for Cleopatra. She goes along with whatever they say (aware they are deceiving her), then kills herself via snake. Her maids follow suit. Caesar is a bit put out in the end, because he can’t parade her in front of Rome in a triumphal parade, but he acknowledges the honour of both Cleopatra and Antony in dying on their own terms. He plans to have them buried together, and that he and his army will attend the funeral before returning to Rome.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jul 28 '25

Readalong Love’s Labour’s Lost Reading Discussion Act 4.3 to END

3 Upvotes

Overall, I think this is one of my favourite comedies/lighter plays by Shakespeare that we have read so far. I liked how silly the King and his men were in general and thought it was nice to see the women portrayed as having the upper hand in a lot of the conversations.

Apologies for the late posting of this discussion. The movie/screen adaptation post will go up later this week and we should be back on schedule for August with ‘Anthony and Cleopatra.'

As usual, the questions will be in the comments.

Summary:

Act 4:

Scene 3:

This scene starts with Berowne in a palace garden, just finishing his read through of his newest letter to Rosaline. He hears someone coming and hides because he doesn’t want to get caught. The interloper ends up being the King with a poem of his own for the Princess of France. The King reads his letter aloud but ends up having to hide too before Berowne can confront him. The King hides as Longaville arrives with a poem of his own for his lady, Maria. Longaville reads his poem aloud and then in his turn ends up hiding as the fourth member of the group, Dumaine, shows up. Dumaine reads out a love poem of his own, this time for the final woman in the Princess of France’s entourage, Kate.

When he is finished Dumaine is accosted by Longaville. Longaville hypocritically claims that Dumaine has broken his oath to the king. Just as it looks like Longaville has gotten the upper hand, the King comes out of hiding and scolds both men. The King is furious and somewhat embarrassed, mentioning that they are lucky that Berowne has no idea what is going on, after his initial complaints about the oath. Not one to shy away from the spotlight, Berowne takes this moment to come out of hiding. He exposes the King’s own love letter and begins to give out to everyone. However, he is stopped with Jaquenetta and Costard arrive with his letter to Rosaline. The King, not knowing what the letter contains, asks Berowne to read it out. Berowne sees what it is and rips it up. His friends suspect something is up, so they take the torn pieces of paper from him and discover that Berowne is in love too.

The King asks Berowne to use his wits to find a loophole in the oath they all swore. Berowne comes up with an argument that women are the pinnacle of beauty and that scholarship should study beauty, therefore it was illogical for them to swear off seeing women. The King likes this line of thinking. Everyone calms down and they have a friendly debate over which woman is the best looking out. They end the scene deciding to woo their women as soon as they can.

Act 5

Scene 1:

Holofernes and Nathaniel discuss Armado, who the pair have been getting to know. They are mean about Armado’s accent and don’t think much of his intelligence. They have to end their mocking when Armado shows up with Moth and Costard. Armado tells them that they King has tasked him with putting on a play for the Princess of France and her entourage. The group decide to band together to perform the ‘Nine Worthies’.

Scene 2:

The Princess and her ladies are walking in the park and discussing a gift the King has sent the Princess. Each lady mentions that they have also received letters from one of the King’s men which a gift or ‘favour’ from each man in turn. They debate what is going on and how it will impact the oath and the political reasons behind their visit. Boyet arrives with news that the King and his men are own their way to see the Princess, dressed up as Russian travellers. The Princess and her ladies decide to test the ardour of the King and his men by putting on masks and switching ‘favours’ to trick the men into courting the wrong woman. For example, Rosaline and the Princess trade favours and take on the other’s role for the duration of the trick. The men arrive and the ladies pull the trick off. After the men leave, they exchange information on what was said to them while in the disguise of each other. Each woman reveals that her respective man has pledged his love to her, and they note happily how gullible the men have turned out to be. They realize that the men will soon return, so they switch their favours back. They also agree to continue with their trickery of the King and his men, just in a different way.

The King and his men return, now out of costume. The King approaches the Princess and offers to sidestep the oath and let them enter his court. The Princess, with some amusement, tells him that she doesn’t want him to break his oath. She gives a speech on why she thinks oaths are important. She then tells him that a group of weird Russians recently visited them. Rosaline complains that the Russians were fools and mocks them. Soon, though, the women reveal that the costumes did not fool them.

The King then confesses that he was just there, in costume, and the Princess asks him what he told his lady. She warns him that he must keep his oath, and he ensures her that he will. She then asks Rosaline what the Russian told her, and she repeats the words of the King. Confused, he says that he knew the Princess by the jewel on her sleeve, but he soon realizes the trick that the women played on them. The men, Berowne in particular, are upset by this.

Costard arrives and asks the King if he is ready for the show. The King is hesitant to give the go-ahead for the play, because he is embarrassed by his failed ruse earlier. Berowne tells him that they are past embarrassment now. The show begins. The ‘actors’ in the play are all terrible and keep confusing themselves. Berowne and the other men make a mockery of them and are about to get into a debate with Holofernes when a messenger arrives for the Princess. The play pauses. The news is bad: the Princess’ father has died. The play is abandoned. The Princess thanks the King and his lords for their entertainment and tells him that she and her ladies will leave that night. The King entreats her to stay and marry him, and the lords each make a similar appeal to their ladies. But the Princess, who must go into mourning for a year, tells the King that he should become a hermit for twelve months and then seek her again if he still feels the same about her. Katharine and Maria tell Dumaine and Longaville that they will receive them again in one year under similar conditions. Rosaline tells Berowne that he must spend one year using his wit to make the sick laugh. 

As the women are about to depart, Armado enters and asks the King if his players can perform the song that would have been sung at the conclusion of their play. He gives permission, and the cast of the play reenters to perform a sung dialogue between Spring and Winter. The lords and ladies then part ways and the play ends.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Oct 28 '25

Performances Henry VI Part 1 Adaptations Discussion

4 Upvotes

Henry VI is an interesting beast of a play. A lot of the information I could find on it was combining Parts I, II, and III into a single play and picking and choosing the signs.

On its own, it isn't acted very much, but there are some notable productions for us to talk about!

Next week, we will have a little bit of a break and then we will be reading Henry VI Part 2.

Since I noticed after looking into it that the adaptations for both versions are fairly similar, we are considering changing next month's adaptation discussion into the Sonnets that we were supposed to cover last Winter and missed.

We hope you join us!

Stage:

  • In 1953, Judi Dench played Joan in a theatre production.

  • In 1977, The Royal Shakespeare theatre presented all three plays. Alan Howard played Henry and Helen Mirren was Margaret. Apparently this version was notable for Howard interweaving the madness of the real Henry into his performance. Another notable thing was that the production was meant to be apolitical since Shakespeare was considered beyond politics.

  • In 2000, the Royal Shakespeare Company presented the three Henry VI plays along with five other plays under the title "This England: The Histories". The Octology included the Henry the IV plays, the Henry VI plays, and both Richard II and Richard III. It was a gory representation of the play and audiences would sometimes be hit with viscera.

Film/Television:

  • In terms of film, there's only one known adaptation of the play. It was released in 1973 and was a horror comedy called Theatre of Blood. A spurned actor who wanted accolades recites part of the play while murdering his critics. It's a small part as each act is inspired by a different play, but it's the only one.

  • On television, it was adapted in 1960 in An Age of Kings. It was a show that serialized all eight of Shakespeare's historical plays originally showcased in "This England: The Histories".

  • A filmed version of the stageplay was broadcast in 1965 and then again in 1966 after being re-edited.

  • The most well-received television version was likely the BBC's version in 1983. It included all three plays and was considered a fast-paced, thrilling entry. The plays were on a single set that looked like a child's playground since the squabbling seemed childish. They ride hobby-horses instead of horses and things like that, but the actors are playing their roles with the utmost gravitas.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Mar 25 '25

Julius Caesar Reading Discussion Act 4, Scene 3 to End of the Play

4 Upvotes

And thus we see how things come to a head. I liked this play a lot! We're going to be talking about adaptations and the like next week, but I'm also going to go look at more Roman history now.

Act 4, Scene 3

Brutus and Cassius exchange accusations in Brutus’s tent. They grow angry with each other but are quickly reconciled, and Brutus tells Cassius of Portia’s death. With Titinius and Messala they plot their military strategy. Brutus overrides Cassius’s objections and insists that they march to Philippi to challenge Mark Antony and Octavius. As Brutus reads in his tent after the meeting, he is visited by the Ghost of Caesar, who threatens to visit Brutus again at Philippi.

Act 5, Scene 1

The opposing armies confront each other at Philippi. Before the battle, Brutus and Cassius exchange insults with Antony and Octavius. Cassius is troubled by an omen of defeat, and he and Brutus say farewell in case they die as a result of the upcoming battle.

Act 5, Scene 2

Brutus sends Messala to throw all Brutus’s legions into the battle. (This is the shortest scene I've ever seen, but it carries an important weight).

Act 5, Scene 3

Cassius, mistakenly believing that the battle has been lost and that Titinius has been taken captive, orders Pindarus to kill him. When Titinius returns, he puts his wreath of victory on Cassius’s head and kills himself. Brutus orders his legions into battle again in order to conquer the still undefeated Antony.

Act 5, Scene 4

Brutus’s forces are defeated in the second battle. Lucilius calls attention to himself and away from Brutus by announcing himself to be Brutus. Lucilius is captured, but Antony spares him.

Act 5, Scene 5

Brutus begs four of his followers to assist him in his suicide. All but the fourth decline. Brutus kills himself. Antony praises Brutus as the only honorable conspirator, and Octavius orders Brutus’s funeral rites.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Aug 11 '25

Readalong Antony and Cleopatra Reading Discussion Act 1 to end of Act 2 Scene 2

4 Upvotes

Well, this play is off to a roaring start. I love political drama, so I'm loving this play so far. This play seems to be following on from 'Julius Caesar', with the alliance we saw there between Mark Antony, Octavius Caesar and Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, now in full swing as the official (second) triumvirate. That means that they are basically a three-person council in charge of the entire Roman empire.

As usual, the questions will be in the comments.

Next week we will be reading from Act 2 scene 3 to the end of Act 3 scene 1.

Summary:

Act 1:

Scene 1:

The play opens with two friends of Antony, Demetrius and Philo, talking about the relationship between their friend and Cleopatra. They don’t approve of the relationship. Antony and Cleopatra enter, and we see them together. They seem to be besotted with each other. A messenger from Rome arrives, either from Antony’s ally, Octavius Caesar, or his wife, Fulvia. Anthony doesn’t want to take the message, either way. Cleopatra suggests that he should hear the messenger out. Antony replies by telling her that, now that he is in love, Rome means nothing to him. Cleopatra urges him to keep an interest in politics and advises him to return to Rome for a short time. The scene ends with Antony’s friends despairing of him, privately.

Scene 2:

Cleopatra’s attendants get their fortunes told. They are prophesied to outlive their queen but that their pasts are brighter than their futures. There is a lot of banter and bickering, until Cleopatra arrives. This is the first time we see her without Antony. She is upset that Antony has turned his attention back to Roman politics, despite her earlier suggestions to him. She nearly sends Antony’s friend/advisor, Enobarbus, to find him, but backtracks when Antony appears. Instead of speaking to her lover, she leaves. Antony receives some messengers. The first tells of how his wife, Fulvia, and his brother have gone to war with Caesar, but have lost their biggest battle. Antony gets angry when the messenger suggests that none of that would have happened if he’d remained active in Rome. As Antony is pressing the messenger to speak more openly to him, a second messenger arrives with bad news: Fulvia is dead.

Antony has mixed feelings on her passing. He seems to have wanted her to die for a long time but regrets that she is dead anyways. Enobarbus arrives and tries to console him, suggesting that this is good news and meant to be. Antony blames himself for Fulvia’s death and decides to go back to Rome for a bit to deal with the politics. The biggest political issue that he needs to deal with is the growing tension between his allies – Octavius Caeser and Sextus Pompeius. Pompey has taken control over the seas around Italy and seems to be getting ready to attack Caesar's power base.

Scene 3:

Cleopatra summons Antony to her chambers, matching herself to his mood by acting sick to get his attention. Antony fills her in on Fulvia’s death and the news from Rome. Cleopatra notes that Antony doesn’t seem to be visibly mourning his wife and claims that he will react in the same way if she dies before him. They bicker over how genuine their love, particularly on Antony’s side, is. Antony swears that he loves Cleopatra but that he must depart for Rome.

Scene 4:

This scene takes place in Rome. The two other members of the triumvirate, Octavius Caesar and Lepidus, discuss the ongoing problem with Pompey. Caesar is upset that Antony has been so absent of late, because Antony is a great solider. Lepidus tries to stand up for Antony. They agree to move against Pompey, on their own if need be.  

Scene 5:

Cleopatra talks to her entourage about missing Antony. One of her ladies, Alexa, arrives with a gift from Antony, a pearl that he kissed before he departed Egypt. Cleopatra questions Alexa on how Antony seemed during his departure. Alexa says that he came across as neither overly sad or overly happy. Cleopatra thinks that this is for the best and feels assured in his love, and commitment to her. She then sends Alexa to set up a bunch of messengers, twenty at least, so that she can send messages to Antony every day.

Act 2:

Scene 1:

Pompey discusses the military situation with his lieutenants, Menecrates and Menas. We learn that Pompey sees Antony as his biggest obstacle to taking over the empire and that he is very happy Antony has been staying in Egypt. More messengers arrive and we learn that Caesar’s and Lepidus’ army is on the move. The next messenger reports that Antony has returned to Egypt, but that there may be tensions between Caesar and Antony. Menas wants to play Caesar and Antony against each other but Pompey is certain that the triumvirate will remain allies as long as they have a common enemy (himself) to fight against.

Scene 2:

The triumvirate meets in Rome. Lepidus warns Antony that Caesar is in a bad mood and that he needs to be careful with him. Caesar complains about the rebellion Fulvia and Antony’s brother attempted against him, as well as Antony dismissing Caesar’s messengers while in Egypt (act 1 scene 1). He claims that Antony is failing in their alliance, as he has yet to bring military aid to either Caesar or Lepidus against Pompey. Antony defends himself. Things are looking rough until one of Caesar’s men, Agrippa, suggests an additional political alliance between them: Antony, now widowed, could marry Caesar’s sister. Antony agrees and they decide to move against Pompey, aiming for his current stronghold in Mount Misenum.

The triumvirate leaves. Enobarbus talks with Agrippa about his time with Antony in Egypt. He talks of the love between Antony and Cleopatra, how they met and how he does not believe Antony and Cleopatra are over, even with the new marriage on the table.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Sep 29 '25

Performances Macbeth Adaptations Discussion

5 Upvotes

Despite potentially being cursed, Macbeth must be one of the most performed plays out of Shakespeare’s entire bibliography. I don’t think it would be possible to cover all the stage or screen adaptations over the last century here, without reaching the word count. Therefore, this post is only going to focus on the best of the best.

Next week we will be starting Henry VI Part 1

Stage:  

 

Movies:

 

Inspiration:

 

Macbeth has also inspired a lot of movies, tv shows and books. Below are some notable ones:

 

  • Succession (HBO)

  • Gargoyles (Disney)

  • The Lord of the Rings (book and movies) by J. R. R. Tolkien

  • Nightcrawler (2014)

  • Scarface (1983)

 

Discussion Prompts:

  • Have you seen any of the adaptations mentioned above? What did you think of it? Did any actors or actresses stand out to you as being a good, or bad, fit for the characters?

  • If you’ve seen any other adaptations, let us know in the comments. Would you recommend them?

  • What adaptations from the list would you like to see?

  • Are there any actors that you would like to see in an adaptation of this play? Are there any directors that you would like to see adapt it?

  • Conversely, are there any actors or directors who you think should stay well away from this play?

 

 

 


r/YearOfShakespeare • • May 07 '25

Readalong The Merchant of Venice Reading Discussion - Act 1 to end of Act 2.2

3 Upvotes

Here we go with the Merchant of Venice! Although it's classified as a comedy, I saw multiple sources talk about its more dramatic aspects so I was curious to see how things would land for a modern audience.

Act 1, Scene 1

Antonio, a Venetian merchant, has invested all his wealth in trading expeditions. Bassanio, his friend and kinsman, asks him for money to go to Belmont, where Bassanio hopes to marry the heiress Portia. Antonio gives Bassanio permission to borrow the money on Antonio’s credit.

Act 1, Scene 2

At Portia’s estate of Belmont, Portia and Nerissa talk over Portia’s frustration at being unable to choose her own husband. According to her father’s will, she may marry only the man who chooses correctly among three small chests made of gold, silver, and lead. Portia likes none of the suitors who have so far arrived. A messenger enters to announce the coming of a new suitor, the Prince of Morocco.

Act 1, Scene 3

In Venice Bassanio goes to Shylock, a Jewish moneylender, to borrow, in Antonio’s name, 3,000 ducats. Shylock hates Antonio but agrees to lend the money provided that Antonio sign a bond to yield a pound of his own flesh if he is unable to repay the loan on time. Shylock insists that the bond is a kind of joke, a “merry bond.” Bassanio distrusts Shylock, but Antonio, confident of the success of his trading expeditions, agrees to sign the bond.

Act 2, Scene 1

At Belmont the Prince of Morocco greets Portia, who tells him the terms of the contest: if he chooses the wrong chest, he must never again seek to marry. He accepts these terms.

Act 2, Scene 2

In Venice Shylock’s servant, Lancelet Gobbo, debates whether he should find a new master. Lancelet’s father comes in search of him and asks Bassanio to take Lancelet into his service. Bassanio agrees to become Lancelet’s master. Bassanio also agrees to allow Gratiano to accompany him to Belmont, provided that Gratiano behave properly in public.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Aug 20 '25

Readalong Antony and Cleopatra Reading Discussion Act 2 Scene 3 to end of Act 3 Scene 1

4 Upvotes

I've been having way too much fun with this one. I love the political drama of it all and also have been fascinated with Cleopatra since I was a kid. Even though this is far from a historically accurate representation, I'm still enjoying myself immensely.

Act 2, Scene 3

Antony promises Octavia that he will henceforth live according to the rule. A Soothsayer advises Antony to keep his distance from Caesar. Antony admits to himself that he will return to Egypt.

Act 2, Scene 4

Lepidus sets off to do battle with Pompey, urging Maecenas and Agrippa to hasten the departures of Antony and Caesar.

Act 2, Scene 5

Cleopatra learns of Antony’s marriage and, in her fury, beats the messenger who brought the news.

Act 2, Scene 6

In a prebattle conference, Pompey is offered terms by Caesar, Antony, and Lepidus. After Antony thanks Pompey for his earlier kindness to Antony’s mother, Pompey accepts the terms, and feasts are planned. Enobarbus predicts that Antony’s marriage will divide rather than unite Caesar and Antony.

Act 2, Scene 7

At the feast on Pompey’s galley, Pompey refuses the suggestion that he kill his guests and thus become “lord of all the world.” Lepidus is carried off the boat in a drunken stupor.

Act 3, Scene 1

Having won a victory for Antony, Ventidius explains why it would be politically unwise to achieve further success. We learn that Antony is on his way to Athens.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • May 26 '25

Performances The Merchant of Venice Stage and Movie Adaptations

5 Upvotes

The Merchant of Venice is one of the Shakespeare’s most controversial plays. I feel that it is hard, but interesting, to read it from a modern perspective. I think humanity’s ability to dehumanize a group of people, making them into the ‘other’ is disturbing, but also fascinating. I am kind of surprised that there aren’t more modern adaptations of the play as I think the core theme is still a huge issue today and it should be explored more openly in popular media. More adaptations like the Māori Merchant of Venice would be ideal, as it seems to deconstruct the original play and view it from a post-colonial perspective.

Next week we will be starting Henry V.  

Stage:

Screen:

Radio:

Merchant of Venice: Jewish Adaptations/Reinterpretations (Eta 21/05/26)

  • ‘Shaylok, oder, der Koyfman fun Venedig’ by Yosef Bovshover – this is a Yiddish translation of the play that shows a more emphatic view of Shylock. This version of the play was first performed around 1901 with Jacob Alder in the role of Shylock.  It has had periodic revivals ever since, most recently in 2023.

  • ‘Shailok, ha-Yehudi mi-Venetsyah’ by Ari Ibn Zahav – this book is a Hebrew retelling of Shylock’s life, especially his relationship with his daughter Jessica.

  • ‘Shaylok un Zayn Tokhter’ by Maurice Schwartz  – this is theatrical adaptation of the book ‘Shailok, ha-Yehudi mi-Venetsyah’ by Ari Ibn Zahav. It was first performed in 1947 with Schwartz playing Shylock and sounds like a fascinating take on the character as a man seeking justice but who isn’t willing to lose his humanity in pursuit of it (aka it shows what could have happened in the Merchant of Venice if Shylock was given the choice over the pound of flesh in the end).  

  • 2017 mock trail presided over by Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg https://www.youtube.com/live/ljFaVJ6RNpE?si=nlrzaO4sWyP3NqGW

Articles of Interest:

  • This article looks at modern interpretations of the character of Shylock from the perspective of his Jewishness and how he would have spoken.

  • This article discusses different modern adaptations of the play/Shylock as a character.

Thank you to u/themaddesthatter2 for bringing this side of adaptations to my attention.

 Further Discussion:

The discussion on these posts tends to be a bit more relaxed than on our usual posts. Here are some prompts to get the conversation going:

  • Have you seen any of the adaptations mentioned above? What did you think of it? Did any actors or actresses stand out to you as being a good, or bad, fit for the characters?

  • If you’ve seen any other adaptations, let us know in the comments. Would you recommend them?

  • Are there any actors that you would like to see in an adaptation of this play? Are there any directors that you would like to see adapt it?

  • Conversely, are there any actors or directors who you think should stay well away from this play?


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Sep 22 '25

Readalong Macbeth Reading Discussion - Act 4, Scene 3 to END

8 Upvotes

We've reached the end of Macbeth and god, I love this play. I supplemented this week's reading with watching Sir Ian McKellan and Dame Judy Dench's version of Macbeth and they're so good.

It's always fighting with Titus Andronicus for first in my heart.

Next week, we'll be discussing adaptations of Macbeth including film and stage adaptations.

Act 4, Scene 3

Macduff finds Malcolm at the English court and urges him to attack Macbeth at once. Malcolm suspects that Macduff is Macbeth’s agent sent to lure Malcolm to his destruction in Scotland. After Malcolm tests Macduff and finds him sincere, Malcolm reveals that Edward, king of England, has provided a commander (Siward) and ten thousand troops for the invasion of Scotland. Ross then arrives with the news of the slaughter of Macduff’s entire household. At first grief-stricken, Macduff follows Malcolm’s advice and converts his grief into a desire to avenge himself on Macbeth.

Act 5, Scene 1

A gentlewoman who waits on Lady Macbeth has seen her walking in her sleep and has asked a doctor’s advice. Together they observe Lady Macbeth make the gestures of repeatedly washing her hands as she relives the horrors that she and Macbeth have carried out and experienced. The doctor concludes that she needs spiritual rather than medical aid.

Act 5, Scene 2

A Scottish force, in rebellion against Macbeth, marches toward Birnam Wood to join Malcolm and his English army.

Act 5, Scene 3

Reports are brought to Macbeth of the Scottish and English forces massed against him. He seeks assurance in the apparitions’ promise of safety for himself. But he is anxious about Lady Macbeth’s condition and impatient with her doctor’s inability to cure her.

Act 5, Scene 4

The rebel Scottish forces have joined Malcolm’s army at Birnam Wood. Malcolm orders each soldier to cut down and carry a bough from the Wood so as to conceal their numbers from Macbeth.

Act 5, Scene 5

Macbeth is confident that he can withstand any siege from Malcolm’s forces. He is then told of Lady Macbeth’s death and of the apparent movement of Birnam Wood toward Dunsinane Castle, where he waits. He desperately resolves to abandon the castle and give battle to Malcolm in the field.

Act 5, Scene 6

Malcolm arrives with his troops before Dunsinane Castle and speaks with them.

Act 5, Scene 7

On the battlefield Macbeth kills young Siward, the son of the English commander. After Macbeth exits, Macduff arrives in search of him. Dunsinane Castle has already been surrendered to Malcolm, whose forces have been strengthened by deserters from Macbeth’s army.

Act 5, Scene 8

Macduff finds Macbeth, who is reluctant to fight with him because Macbeth has already killed Macduff’s whole family and is sure of killing Macduff too if they fight. When Macduff announces that he is not, strictly speaking, a man born of woman, having been ripped prematurely from his mother’s womb, then Macbeth is afraid to fight. He fights with Macduff only when Macduff threatens to capture him and display him as a public spectacle. Macduff kills Macbeth, cuts off his head, and brings it to Malcolm. With Macbeth dead, Malcolm is now king and gives new titles to his loyal supporters.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Apr 29 '25

Performances Richard II - Adaptations

4 Upvotes

Richard II is probably the play we've done with the fewest adaptations. It's a historical play, but without the sweeping characters of plays like Julius Caesar. It was actually really hard for me to find any real adaptations about it and it certainly didn't have a novel from Buffy the Vampire Slayer named after a line in it, so that really shows how unpopular it is comparatively (I jest).

Next week we will be starting The Merchant of Venice.

 Screen Adaptations:

  Stage:

  • There have been multiple productions from the Royal Shakespeare Company of Richard II over the years have included many famous actors playing the title role: F R Benson 1896 - 1915; Michael Redgrave in 1951; David Warner in 1964; Richard Pasco and Ian Richardson in 1973; Alan Howard in 1980; Jeremy Irons in 1986; Alex Jennings in 1990; Sam West in 2000; Jonathan Slinger in 2007; and David Tennant in 2013.

Further Discussion:

The discussion on these posts tends to be a bit more relaxed than on our usual discussion posts. Here are some prompts to get the conversation going:

  • What do you think it is about this play that has inspired so many different types of adaptations?

  • Have you seen any of the adaptations mentioned above? What did you think of it? Did any actors or actresses stand out to you as being a good, or bad, fit for the characters?

  • If you’ve seen any other adaptations, let us know in the comments. Would you recommend them?

  • What adaptations would you like to see?

  • Are there any actors that you would like to see in an adaptation of this play? Are there any directors that you would like to see adapt it? I

  • Conversely, are there any actors or directors who you think should stay well away from this play?


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Nov 18 '25

Readalong Henry VI Part 2 Reading Discussion - Act 3 to end of Act 4.2

6 Upvotes

There's a lot of blood going on with our politics this time around! I have to admit that I wasn't expecting this level of bloodshed, but I'm always here for some craziness in Shakespeare plays.

I find it harder to follow than some of Shakespeare's other plays, maybe because there are so many moving parts, but it also makes me more interested in the history.

Act 3, Scene 1

In Parliament Queen Margaret and the nobles level charges against Gloucester, but King Henry remains convinced of his uncle’s innocence. Nonetheless, the King allows Suffolk and the Cardinal to hold him for trial. Fearing that Gloucester will not be convicted, the Queen, the Cardinal, Suffolk, and York conspire to murder him, and Suffolk and the Cardinal promise to carry out the killing. Word comes of an Irish uprising, and York, delighted to be provided with an army, agrees to quell it.

Act 3, Scene 2

The news of Gloucester’s murder makes King Henry faint and the Commons rise to demand Suffolk’s exile. The King obliges them. News arrives of the Cardinal’s imminent death.

Act 3, Scene 3

This is a short little scene about how the Cardinal dies.

Act 4, Scene 1

Attempting to sail to France, Suffolk is captured by shipmen and brutally assassinated.

Act 4, Scene 2

In a plot instigated by York, Jack Cade leads a rebellion against King Henry. The Staffords seek to put it down.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • May 18 '26

Readalong King John Act 5 to END Reading Discussion

4 Upvotes

This play was another one of what I’m starting to call Shakespeare’s hidden gems. I really enjoyed it. My only criticism would be that Act 5 was very fast paced. I kind of feel like Shakespeare should have either made this play longer or done a part 2 to end things properly. I’m interested to see what you all thought about this in the comments.

Next week we will be discussing stage and screen adaptations of this play.

Summary:

Act 5:

Scene 1:

In what seems to be a sudden turn of events, King John makes up with the church and submits to the pope via Pandolph. Due to this reunion, the war with France should be over. The Bastard arrives, with news that the nobles who were upset over prince Arthur’s death have gone over to the French side. John is baffled by this, because he believes the boy is alive. The Bastard catches him up on Arthur’s death and Hubert’s innocence in the affair. Once the Bastard learns of John’s new alliance with the church, he isn’t happy. He urges John to continue fighting.

Scene 2:

In the French camp, Lewis swears in the English nobles who have left John. His prospects in the coming battle are improving… until Pandolph shows up and tells him the war is over. Lewis is not happy about this change in events. He refuses to give up on the war, even when Pandolph commands him to stop.

Scene 3:

We return to King John in the heart of the battle. He isn’t feeling well and has a bit of a fever. His advisors, including the Bastard, want him to retreat. Hubert arrives with good news for the English side: the reinforcements that the French side were counting on to arrive have been shipwrecked, with many dead. John is relieved and agrees to personally retreat from the battle now that the English are in a position of power.

Scene 4:

The English nobles that deserted John and joined the French side earlier are worried about how the battle is going. The don’t like how the Bastard is doing well in the fight. A French noble, Count Melun arrives, fatally injured. He tells the English nobles that they would be better off returning to the English side, because Lewis intends on beheading them even if he wins the war.

Scene 5:

The battle pauses for the night. In the French camp, Lewis learns about Melun’s death/betrayal of him to the English nobles. Said nobles have officially returned to the English side. Lewis also learns about his shipwrecked reinforcements. Instead of fleeing for his life, he decides to stay with the remaining French forces overnight.  

Scene 6:

Both Hubert and the Bastard arrive in Swinestead/Swineshead Abbey, separately, in search of John. It is dark and they don’t recognise each other at first. Eventually, the Bastard recognises Hubert’s voice. They exchange information. Hubert tells the Bastard the rebellious nobles have come back to John and been forgiven but that John has been poisoned. The Bastard can’t believe that someone got close enough to the King to poison him. We learn that it looks like it was the monk in charge of tasting John’s food who possibly did it. There is some hope that John may recover but his son has come to see him just in case. The Bastard reveals that some English reinforcements have been shipwrecked and he needs shelter for the night.

Scene 7:

We meet John’s heir, Prince Henry as he learns that his father is too far gone to recover from the poisoning. He is grief stricken. King John is brought outside because the poison is burning him up from the inside and he wants to cool down. We see the formerly rebellious nobles helping John. The Bastard arrives, upset over the situation. He tries to tell John about the shipwreck, but John dies before he can. The Bastard swears to get revenge for John’s death in the coming battle with the French. He believes that the French are now in a stronger position so the result of the next battle will be unsure, but he is still willing to give his all to protect John’s legacy.

Luckily, we learn, alongside the Bastard, that the war is over; Pandolph is in the abbey with a peace offer from Lewis. The play ends happily.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jul 11 '25

Readalong Love's Labour's Lost Reading Discussion - Act 1 to end of Act 2

6 Upvotes

Welcome to a (belated) reading of Love's Labour's Lost. Already, we're seeing a new kind of structure for the play with very short acts for Act 1 and 2 in terms of the amount of scenes.

I admit that I broke out laughing once I realized there was an oath about not flirting with women that was going to be immediately broken.

Act 1, Scene 1

The King of Navarre and his lords vow to retire from the world (especially from women) and study for three years. One of the lords, Berowne, reminds the King that the Princess of France is coming and that they will thus have to break their oaths immediately. Constable Dull arrives with a letter from Don Armado accusing a servant, Costard, of already having broken the King’s order about not consorting with women.

Act 1, Scene 2

Armado confides first to his page Mote and then to Jaquenetta herself that he is in love with Jaquenetta. He is given responsibility for the imprisoned Costard.

Act 2, Scene 1

The Princess of France and her ladies arrive at Navarre. The King greets them but refuses to admit them into his court, forcing them to stay in tents in the fields. Navarre’s lords each show an interest in one of the Princess’s ladies.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jun 23 '25

Readalong Henry V Reading Discussion – Acts 4.3 to End.

2 Upvotes

This week we finished Henry V. Overall I liked this play and it was nice to get back into the Henry(s) saga for a little while. I still think Shakespeare was holding back on how he portrayed these characters, in order to placate Elizabeth I, but I guess it is what it is. I am inspired to learn more about Henry V though, which is great. We will also be continuing this saga later on in the year with both Henry VI parts one and two.

As usual, the discussion prompts will be in the comments.

Next week we will be discussing movie and stage adaptations of this play.

Next month we will be reading ‘Love’s Labour Lost’

Summary:

Act 4:

Scene 3:

The battle is about to begin. In the English camp, some of the lords are worried and wish they had more soldiers, because the French outnumber them. Henry hears this and tells them that he is happy with the soldiers that he already has. He makes a speech about how every English soldier will gain honour from having fought in this war, so the less soldiers there are the more each individual gains. Henry also states that he only wants soldiers who are passionate about the fight. He says that this battle will become legendary and that this day (October 25 aka St Crispin’s day) will go down in history. Everyone is inspired and ready to fight their hearts out.

A messenger comes over from the French camp, offering Henry one last chance to stop the battle by surrendering himself. Henry refuses.

Scene 4:

This is a comic relief scene. The battle is underway, and Pistol has taken a French solider hostage. He is all for killing the man, but the man begs for his life. There is some funny miscommunication because Pistol can’t speak French. The boy translates and eventually Pistol accepts a bribe from the Frenchman to spare his life. The boy is not happy with this. We learn Nym has also been hanged for theft and that the main English camp is currently being defended by mostly boys.

Scene 5:

The French nobles, notably the Dauphin, Orleans, Bourbon, Constable and Rambures realise that the English are winning the battle. They are, understandably upset. They discuss what they should do – kill themselves, surrender, run away or to keep fighting. They decide to fight to the end.

Scene 6:

The battle continues. The English side realise that they are currently winning. Henry and his men are currently dealing with some French prisoners of war, transporting them it seems. He receives news that two of his cousins, the Duke of York and the Earl of Suffolk have died in battle. He is upset by the news, but midway through talking about it, something big happens on the battlefield. Men cry out and Henry acts quickly (fearing to lose the odds in his favour). He commands that all the French prisoners be executed on the spot, perhaps to free himself and his men to return to battle. This is a brutal tactic.

Scene 7:

Fluellen and Gower discuss the ongoing battle. We learn that a bunch of French soldiers attacked the English camp, killed most of the younger men/boys guarding it and stole from the tents. They are outraged, but due to this they approve of Henry’s recent decision to execute the French prisoners. The pair compare Henry V to Alexander the Great. Amusingly, they include Sir John Falstaff in this comparison, equating him with Cleitus, a solider that saved Alexander’s life and was later killed by him. They state Henry’s shift from a party boy to a responsible man killed Falstaff.

Henry enters the scene, having captured the Duke of Bourbon. He is angry over the attack on the camp and wants to execute more prisoners. The French messenger returns with a request from the French king.  The French side wants guaranteed safety so that they can enter the battlefield to collect their dead. Henry doesn’t seem to want to agree to this, until the messenger confirms to him that he has won the battle. The celebration begins.

Henry spots the solider he had a run in with the night before, Michael Williams. Williams is wearing the glove of his enemy in his cap, so Henry asks about it. Williams explains the situation to him and remains steadfast in wanting to duel with his unknown enemy. Williams leaves. Henry decides to set Fluellen up against Williams as a joke by giving him Williams’ glove to wear in his cap.

Scene 8:

Back in the English camp, outside Henry’s pavilion. Williams spots Fluellen with the glove and strikes him. Things look bad for Williams for a minute because Fluellen thinks he is a traitor or a French spy and tries to get him arrested. Henry shows up, amused by his joke. He eventually explains the situation to everyone and reveals to Williams that he is the mystery enemy. Williams makes a convincing argument to save himself, claiming that he was unaware that his enemy was the king because the king was in disguise. Henry finds it all very funny and rewards the man by giving him back his glove filled with coins.

Henry receives the official list of casualties from Exeter. Over ten thousand French are believed to have died, but only twenty-nine Englishmen. This number is crazy and seems unrealistic, but Henry takes it as a sign that God was on the English side. He tells the troops to be modest in their celebration.

Act 5:

Chorus:

The chorus tells us that a little time has passed. Henry and the English side returned to England and had a notably modest celebration. The play picks up just as Henry and the English side return to France to finalise the Treaty of Troyes, which basically sets out how Henry V and the English will rule France.

Scene 1:

Fluellen and Gower banter about Fluellen still wearing a leek in his hat, following on from St. Davy’s Day (March 1). This dates the scene to March 2. Fluellen explains that he had a run in with Pistol the day before where Pistol mocked the Welsh tradition of wearing the leek. Fluellen intends to get revenge. Pistol enters the scene. Fluellen beats him up and forces him to eat the leek. Pistol hates leeks but eventually does it. Once Fluellen leaves, Pistol vows to get his revenge. Gower tells him that he deserved what he got for making fun of Fluellen for his Welshness.

Once Pistol is alone, we learn that his wife, Mistress Quickly, is dead. He has been left with nothing, so he decides to go back to England and become a thief and the pimp.

Scene 2:

Henry and his entourage go to the French palace to finish up peace negotiations/ the Treaty of Troyes. An agreement is made that Charles VI will get to keep his palace and his throne, but he will work under Henry. A major part of the agreement is that Henry will marry Katherine, Charles’ daughter. This will ensure Henry’s heir will inherit both thrones properly. Most the court head off to finish off the signing of the contracts, leaving Henry with Katherine and her maid/translator Alice.

Henry tries to court Katherine, but there is a language barrier, and she doesn’t seem to be as lovestruck as him. She does agree to marry him though, because the decision is her father’s and he has decided. Henry ends the scene (and play) happy.

Epilogue:

In the epilogue the chorus briefly tells us about what happened next; Henry and Katherine had a son, Henry VI. We learn that Henry VI inherited the kingdom young and that he would go on to lose France. The play closes with the chorus thanking the audience for their patience/tolerance while watching the play.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Apr 07 '25

Readalong Richard II Reading Discussion: Act 1 to end of Act 2

5 Upvotes

This play certainly dives right into the action. I am liking this play, so far. After just over a year of reading through all of Shakespeare’s plays, I think it is safe to say that my favourites by him tend to be the tragedies and the more political ones.

The family lines are a bit confusing, at least to begin with.  If you don’t mind spoilers, there are some family trees available online, such as this one.  I believe that it is a case where a king had seven sons, and the oldest son of the oldest son (Richard II) is the current king. The duke of Gloucester was the oldest surviving son/uncle but he has recently died. The current oldest surviving son/uncle is the Duke of York. The Duke of York has a son, called Aumerle.  John of Gaunt, the Duke of Lancaster, is another son from the line, and his son is Henry Bolingbroke.

Another thing to mention: Richard II’s father predeceased the old king, Edward, making Richard II a very young inheritor of the crown. He officially became king when he was around ten, and his uncles – John of Gaunt, Gloucester and York in particular – acted as his regents. It also appears that Richard’s uncles struggled to give up their power when Richard came of age to rule for himself.

Next week we will be reading from the start of act 3 to the end of act 4 scene 2.

As usual, the discussion prompts will be in the comments.

Summary:

Act 1:

Scene 1:

Henry Bolingbroke accuses Thomas Mowbray, the Duke of Norfolk, of treason in front of king Richard II. Mowbray denies the claims made against him – that he has been embezzling money and that he had the late Duke of Gloucester (the oldest uncle of the king) killed. Richard II tries to make Bolingbroke take back his claims but ends up failing. Mowbray and Bolingbroke decide to fight to the death to prove which side is being truthful. A date and time are set for said fight.

Scene 2:

John of Gaunt and the widowed Duchess of Gloucester talk about the upcoming fight between Bolingbroke and Mowbray. It appears that both believe that Gloucester was murdered, possibly by Mowbray or someone else. John of Gaunt mentions his suspicion that Richard II had Gloucester killed .

Scene 3:

The day of the fight comes. Everything is set in place, and both Bolingbroke and Mowbray are ready to duel each other to the death. However, just as the fight is about to begin, Richard II stops the fight from taking place. He takes both men into a private room and declares that they are both banished – Mowbray for the rest of his life, Bolingbroke for the next six years. Neither is happy with this arrangement. Mowbray makes an interesting speech about how his age and lack of ability to learn another language while being forced out of England is like a death sentence. John of Gaunt is upset that his son is being banished at all, and fears that he will die before the exile is over. Richard II thinks that he is being dramatic. Mowbray and Bolingbroke swear to leave each other alone while in exile – they can’t even write to each other or try to reconcile.

Before Bolingbroke leaves, his cousin, Aurmele, tries to say goodbye. Bolingbroke, having kept calm in front of the king, is now upset with the exile. His father, John of Gaunt, tries to console him and urges him to see the bright side of the things – he gets to explore the world and have an adventure.

Scene 4:

Richard II, Aurmele and a couple of friends celebrate Bolingbroke’s exile. They make it clear that they don’t like him at all. It is suggested here that Bolingbroke may have been too good with the public, which is a threat to Richard II’s popularity and crown. We learn that Richard II plans to go to war in Ireland, where some of the native Irish have been revolting against English colonial rule. At the end of this scene, we also learn that John of Gaunt is very sick and likely to die soon. Despite what appeared to be an earlier closeness, Richard II seems happy with this.

Act 2:

Scene 1:

John of Gaunt is on his deathbed. He wants to talk to Richard II before he dies.  He has a lot to say about Richard’s recent governance of the country. Richard is not great with money and is facing some issues with the French. Richard’s decision to travel to Ireland and fight there is seen as foolish and costly. John of Gaunt tries to tell Richard this, but the two end up fighting. The fight gets so bad that John is taken out of the room to die in his bedroom. Once dead, Richard II decides to spite his uncle’s ghost by taking away all the money and land assets that, by right, belong to John’s heir (Bolingbroke). The Duke of York tries to stop this from happening (he is both Richard’s and Bolingbroke’s uncle) but fails.

This scene ends with some of John of Gaunt’s allies, notably the earl of Northumberland and the lords Willoughby and Ross, choosing to side with Bolingbroke if there is a dispute over his inheritance.

Scene 2:

Richard II has just left for Ireland. His queen is upset and has a sense of foreboding. Her servants try to cheer her up but before they can do that, news arrives at the castle that Bolingbroke has broken his exile and is on his way back to England. We learn that Northumberland, Willoughby and Ross have officially joined Bolingbroke’s side, along with the earl of Worchester.  The Duke of York, who Richard II left in charge, panics about what he can or should do – the army is with Richard, there is very little money left to fund a new war, and both Richard and Bolingbroke are his nephews. He resolves to remain loyal to Richard and tries to find a way to send a message to him. The scene ends with some servants of the king talking about what they should do to survive the coming war.

Scene 3:

Bolingbroke lands in England and meets up with his new allies, including Henry Percy, the son of the earl of Northumberland.  Bolingbroke claims to have returned not to start a rebellion for the crown, but to get his monetary inheritance back.

Bolingbroke and the Duke of York meet up. York confirms that he is remaining loyal to Richard and urges Bolingbroke not to start a war. York admits that he didn’t want Bolingbroke to lose his inheritance and that he hopes the situation can be rectified. Bolingbroke and his army remain doubtful, but he does agree to spend the night in a castle with York, in peace.

Scene 4

This scene is short and shows the earl of Salisbury and the Welsh regiment of Richard’s army, waiting for news of the king. They are waiting for word to join him in Ireland, but they haven’t heard from him in over ten days. They believe that Richard II is dead and, because of this, some of them want to disperse and go back to regular life.


r/YearOfShakespeare • • Jul 03 '25

Performances Henry V Adaptation Post

3 Upvotes

While I enjoyed this play, it feels like most of the adaptations are very heavily focused on the horrors of war, trying to make it clear just how bloody this would have been. I've seen the King and really enjoyed the cinematography! I didn't realize until we started this Shakespeare project that it even *was* from Henry V.

It was very cool to realize.

Next week, we'll be reading Love's Labours Lost.

Movies:

  • Henry V (1944) directed by and starring Laurence Olivier, is a colourful and highly stylised version which begins in the Globe Theatre and then gradually shifts to a realistic evocation of the Battle of Agincourt.

  • Henry V (1989), directed by and starring Kenneth Branagh, attempts to give a more realistic evocation of the period, and lays more emphasis on the horrors of war.

  • The King (2019), starring Timothée Chalamet as Henry V, was adapted from Shakespeare's plays Henry IV Part I, Henry IV Part II, and Henry V.

Television:

  • The Hollow Crown (2012) - A tetralogy that encompasses all of the Henriad. Henry IV (Part I and Part II) as well as Henry V.

Further Discussion:

The discussion on these posts tends to be a bit more relaxed than on our usual posts. Here are some prompts to get the conversation going:

  • Have you seen any of the adaptations mentioned above? What did you think of it? Did any actors or actresses stand out to you as being a good, or bad, fit for the characters?

  • If you’ve seen any other adaptations, let us know in the comments. Would you recommend them?

  • Are there any actors that you would like to see in an adaptation of this play? Are there any directors that you would like to see adapt it?

  • Conversely, are there any actors or directors who you think should stay well away from this play?