r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 18 '21

DISCUSSION Why I believe the show failed

14 Upvotes

It is a shame the show is over, I need to watch the new episode tonight but it seems rather pointless when Fox has embarrassed themselves in the Mickey Mouse era of ownership. I also blame the general audience for the show failing, people complain they want new concepts and story lines, but flake when it's right in front of them. I'm not gonna dive into too much detail on other shows, but you have heaps of trash on Netflix that somehow stay relevant and you have overrated shows like The Boys that are still getting high ratings ( tired of super hero content). This series is a highly acclaimed graphic novel and in my opinion, better than the Walking Dead; yet that show has been mediocre for 6 years, struggled to compete with Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones in the early to mid 2010s.

All I can hope for is someone to renew it, I will only accept HBO or Amazon money, because everyone else, especially Netflix will cut corners. The show had problems that I will address

  • Slow burn, you need to engage the audience within 2 episodes, attention spans for the average American are 10 seconds on average. This show got traction when the Amazons were introduced, too late,

  • You need to make it more violent

  • I personally liked Yorick's portrayal, but throw a bone to the toxic men online calling him a "beta male". I know it violates the comic continuity, but give Yorick a little bit of a spine just to shut the haters up.

  • The show should focus more on the interpersonal relationships between women, less so on the Walking Dead post apocalypse crap that people are tired of

  • The political jabs were cringe worthy and in the post Donald Trump era, you need to tone it down or you will lose viewers. When I hear lines like "my mom was a democrat, so I voted for Reagan" or "feminism is for liberals only" I cringed hard, can relate to why people would turn it off.

I'm still pissed off though, just goes to show movies are the linchpin in American entertainment, when TV shows don't break viewing records from Game of Thrones or have double digit Emmy nominations like Breaking Bad, studios get sensitive and rage quit before the show is even over.

I hope the show returns, fuck Fox and fuck Hulu!


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 14 '21

DISCUSSION Meh.

0 Upvotes

Not that far along, but I don't buy the complete descent into post-apocalyptic chaos within weeks of the die off. All energy and telecommunication infrastructure just immediately goes offline because half of the workforce is dead? Sorry, what? Where did the national guard go? And why did they run out of food so fast? There are half of the people eating it and they are all grieving.

The early scene with the new female president just standing around with a bunch of dumbfounded dipshits - weeks later - doing nothing seems so unrealistic. The bodies rotting everywhere are fucking gruesome. Why are there always 30 women standing around the president doing literally nothing? It's not a pothole crew, they are extremely ambitious staffers and policy experts. Go drag some bodies out at least.

The briefings where the president is supposed to advise on every minor detail for city emergency management are annoying. Like, shouldn't the remaining government leadership be developing a plan to consolidate the surviving population into regions where they can guarantee the provision of services and food and planning the delivery of said necessities? What the hell is going on here besides interpersonal conflict and pearl clutching?

I guess the above points are my issues with the story devices and not so much a focus on plot holes, but I am irritated that several episodes in there is still no mention of how intersex people are affected by the crisis.

The whole thing feels like some kind of schadenfreude fantasy of someone who treats men's economic contributions as irreplaceable and can't conjure up what women leading in a crisis environment would look like.

I love an economic apocalypse but this is meh.


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 18 '21

DISCUSSION Unpopular opinion: I don’t mind that it’s getting cancelled

5 Upvotes

It sucks that we won’t see a second season but to me I feel like the show would have went on far too long much like walking dead did. Shows with no clear ending in mind just end up sucking ( I don’t know if there’s an ending in the comics) but most tv programs that don’t end themselves and would likely just keep running itself into the ground ruining the quality just to make money. Shows like Netflix’s YOU. Stranger things. 13 reasons. would be good to end after the first season but they see profits and choose to keep it going despite terrible quality. I have a feeling this would have happened to the last man.


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 13 '21

QUESTION Yorick is lame.

0 Upvotes

How dumb is Yorick? Jeez, they wrote that guy as an absolute moron. Watching his character is absolutely painful.


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 27 '21

DISCUSSION The Hulu series... what happened? My gripes and wondering what you all think. Spoiler for first 3 episodes I guess Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm a fan of the comics so I was excited for this...

I made it 3 episodes and I find myself criticizing the writing too much each episode to even enjoy it. So I'm curious why you love it (not sarcasm, I really am because I want to like it too).

I'll give you examples of what bothers me...

Half the population is dead meaning less mouths to feed. It's only been like 2 months and you're telling me every Target, Walmart, Costco, Supermarket, etc are cleaned out of food and the "helpless" women just can't figure out where to get any more? While the pentagon is feeding Yorick pad Thai noodles with fresh fruit? I know a number of women who grow their own vegetables. You're telling me the intelligence gene was wiped out with the X chromosome too?

Hero is a murderer. I'm supposed to sympathize with her, but all I can think is maybe the guy saw red flags and made the right decision staying in his marriage. Oh she feels really bad? awwwww

Agent 355, she's bad-ass, confident, tactical, and in control of the situation in the books. Why does it seem like she keeps shifting from "oh shit what is going on, I can't handle this, let me just wing it and hope no one notices I'm not qualified for this" and the character she should be? The actress pulls off the scenes and fits 355, but I feel like the director thinks they're "humanizing" her by making it appear she's scared and losing control in some scenes. The shaky voice, the facial expressions, and that scene where she teleports to her handlers to see them all dead and teleports back to the pentagon (when others are having so much trouble getting from point A to B). 355 and Yorick playing off each other was some of the appeal of the original. He was a clown with a heart of gold, and she was a trained spy - all business. Him chipping at her wall and revealing her humanity was great.

Beth... omg why would I want Yorick to even find her? He's basically simping for a woman who was like I want to go cheat on you in Australia because you've only amounted to a street magician. It makes me like him less, and there's not much to her character to care about.

Ampersand is just the monkey plot device to make Yorick get into trouble. Literally no character development or personality unlike the book version. Show couldn't even give me a reason of why Yorick hasn't abandoned this creature. No positive interactions between the two showing the human/pet/friend bond.

Hero's trans friend and his group. They're stockpiling testosterone and acting like there's so little, it's more valuable than food, that's the focus. Estimates are that .5% so .005 of the world are trans. All the trans women are dead with the men, so even less. There's testosterone in every pharmacy and the cis women sure as hell aren't taking it. Why not do it more like the book and show us why they're actually stressed out! not just low whispered quick lines that if you missed it you have no idea wtf they're bothered by. The real problem for the group, is everyone is acting crazy and assume they're men who survived the plague. They're being attacked by groups or captured for trade (like Yorick almost was in the cleaners). If you wanted trans representation, why not actual character building, like a funeral for their friend who died instead of a fast shot of a memorial picture?

Something like 3.9 Billion people are still alive on the planet, why are all the the streets and buildings empty like every human is wiped out? Why aren't we seeing what normal people are doing? What tribes may be forming and how people are coping would have been interesting. Instead it just seems everyone is starving and hanging outside the pentagon.

The "bad guys" are Trump women? Really? Out of the entire book of villains, that's what we had to go with because of what's going on in the world? Don't we get enough of this from the news? You shelved the book Israelis to put Marjorie Taylor Green trying to steal the presidency with her split skull and brain damage? Where are the Amazonians?

I could go on but I'm just venting too much at this point. They're dragging out the material because that's what Hollywood does for more money. The problem is the changes aren't contributing to the story in a positive way, and they're not adding anything interesting so far. You wanted to drag this series out? Then why not build characters and get me to give a damn about any of them. Instead it just seems like a great set of books was highjacked for name recognition


r/YTheLastMan • • Dec 11 '22

DISCUSSION Idiocracy

2 Upvotes

I didn't think I'd ever get to watch a series where the characters were more stupid than those of The Walking Dead, but this show has them beat.

Hilariously low IQs for everyone. Utter dross TV.


r/YTheLastMan • • Feb 23 '24

COMIC SPOILERS!! Well this was a weird ride, what a weird comic...

2 Upvotes

i just finished y the last man comics, took me about 4 days. And i dont know wha to think of it

Generally the world building was weird, nothing made sense and the scale of things were off. Like 8 girls being able to starve half of the country by themselves just by blocking a road. The white house attacked by 5 middle age housewives, the israelis just taking a chooper just like that.... everything was off

I didnt like yorick for the most part (god what a weird name) he is extremely dumb, he is naive and got many people killed by being dumb, most of the characters were also very dumb, except for 355 (was that the number)

Many thing were predictable, some of the "filler" was pretty bad and boring.

The political commentary is non-sensical and stupid, i am not american but the whole president jokes, hillary clinton references, the whole comic keeps revolving around womans hating man and then the man comes out and says "hey you are all wrong!" and repeat. just plain stupid

even after that.... the ending broke me. There arent many times where i wish a character haven't died and this is one of those. Seeing yorick grow old and the monkey dying... i guess they grow on me in these 4 days.


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 29 '21

DISCUSSION Probably super blasphemous, but does anyone else just FF through entire side character plots?

0 Upvotes

I totally get needing multiple story arcs to keep a show going and make money and so on. But I couldn’t care less about the Washington aid and her daughter arc, and I hate the presidents daughter political agenda drama (I watch some of hers but not all of it). I love the hero’s journey (not the character, the storytelling philosophy) to the point that I wish I could essentially “choose your own adventure/observer” style watch the show (and others). I’d rather watch a whole season just following Y, 355, and get science thrown in the mix. Maybe I’m jaded from to many seasons of TWD where irrational drama is all we get for every other episode and they never explain anything scientific. Utopia laid down heavy on the science side of the show, which had me locked in full time. I hope science becomes a part of this show, and it’s not just several seasons of travel, drama, baddies, drama, travel, politics, travel, and on and on. So far I’m super into it. But it’s already on thin ice. Again, I probably have to many botched Netflix dystopian scifi drama feathers in my cap.


r/YTheLastMan • • Aug 04 '21

COMIC SPOILERS!! Anyone else offput by this scene? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 30 '21

DISCUSSION The Show really outshines the source material

17 Upvotes

I read the comic series at least ten years ago, probably even longer. I remember thinking it was pretty damn good, but don't remember many of the details.

I started watching the show with fairly low expectations, simply because these kinds of adaptations are usually mediocre at best. But just the first episode was enough to let me know that this was an extremely well written and produced show. And since then it's maintained that level of quality. Just one of the handful of TV shows that reach that kind of level.

It got me curious to see how much of what I was loving about the show came straight from the comics, so I looked them up and reread the first few issues and...the comic is kinda bad?

The politics of it really haven't aged well, but I can forgive that for being a product of its time. But the plotting is gonzo, breaking my suspension of disbelief almost immediately, and the characters do not feel at all real (versus the show, whose characterisations are what really makes it shine). Yorrick, especially. I remembered him as being a loveable goof stuck in a terrible situation, which is basically how the show portrays him, but when a reread the comics I discovered an unlikeable asshole.

The show has really elevated this material far beyond its source. It makes it even more disappointing that it's been cancelled.


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 19 '21

DISCUSSION This show is a tedious mirth vacuum with totally unlikable characters

0 Upvotes

What a disappointment!

The comics were lively, witty, and gripping. Although the setting was horrific, the writing captured the multifaceted, nuanced responses of all the characters to this, which conveyed the gamut of human emotion. This show is the complete opposite. It has one emotion and that is misery. Every scene is like a pissing contest, with extra points for pouting, acting bored, and putting out scornful contempt. It’s like watching the original comics interpreted in the style of a Twitter argument. It seems as though the director has decided, in a totally condescending way, that complete solemnity and gloom is the only respectful way to convey a post apocalypse setting, but the result feels less like compelling gravitas and more like sullen moodiness - like being lectured to by a teenager. The (admittedly great) visuals do not make up for this tedium. This series is a sinkhole of mirth. It makes you glad the apocalypse happened to the characters in it because they are each and every one of them utterly insufferable.

The dearth of likeability or charisma in this show brings to mind another failed comic adaptation, Jupiter's Legacy, which was equally patronising. This should make any self-respecting comic fan seriously concerned about the growing trend of the forces of judgmental, posturing mirthlessness colonising our beloved stories and turning them into dreary poutfests.


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 14 '21

COMIC SPOILERS!! Missed opportunity for a great female anti-hero in his sister, Hero. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In the comics, Hero is flawed. The rest of the ambulance women don’t like her because she shags all the men. She does not kill anyone before The Event. Likes that dude - no problem.

Joins a murderous cult, kills innocent people on command.

She goes bad after that. Goes full Amazonian and genocidal. Great! Love it! Get dark!

I’m up to Ep4 in the series, but so far I really haven’t seen any darkness to her character. I hope they do, and don’t soften her into a bland goody two-shoes.

Let her be awesomely awful!


r/YTheLastMan • • 12d ago

COMIC SPOILERS!! Y The Last Man Ending

0 Upvotes

I just finished this and I have to say. Disappointed. Don’t get me wrong, I cried. Something I don’t do often in any media but man could there not have been a somewhat happy ending. I mean fuck Alter, absolutely hate her and wish Yorick had just offed her. 355s death felt like shock value more than contributing tbh and then the Hero/Beth thing just felt out of nowhere. And Alison and Amp too😭😭. Idk I wouldn’t even say I’m a sucker for happy endings but this one was just outright sad and felt so disappointing after one of the best journeys I’ve taken through media. Still an incredible comic and my favourite by BKV (as of now, we’ll see if SAGA ever gets finished). Sorry for the rant just wanna hear others thoughts, how did it feel for ye?


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 31 '21

DISCUSSION The insufferable characters

9 Upvotes

Anyone else find all the characters as annoying as humanly possible? Like every single one of them


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 20 '21

QUESTION Why is there no power, water, etc

6 Upvotes

Just watched the first few episodes, and i get being massively short-handed, but I don't get why the women can't learn how to turn some knobs or push buttons at the damn power factory or water plant.

Am I missing something?


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 21 '21

QUESTION 355 Stripping Yorick (rant) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This has got to be one of the strangest scene I have ever seen. 355 tells Yorick to strip, in front of her, so she can wash his clothes by the river, pretty much out of the blue. He could have gone into his tent to change, she could have turned around like he asked. Am I the only one who thinks this scene is really regressive? Could you imagine if the genders were reversed in this scene? Was this put into the show just to show Yorick's physique? Rant over.


r/YTheLastMan • • Sep 26 '21

DISCUSSION Why yorick wouldnt be needed irl

2 Upvotes

I feel this is a fairly large plot hole but here it is: modern medicine has brought the world something miraculous, with the help of doctors, a womans stem cells can be extracted from her blood, and by doing certain treatments that are beyond my understanding, they can convert the female stem cell into sperm cells, all carrying an X chromasome. These sperm cells can be used to create an embryo that can be implanted via IVF No men could be produced this way but the world could go on without men, at least after rebuilding.


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 03 '21

MISCELLANEOUS Agent 355 is an alien

4 Upvotes

So I had a dream last night and when I woke up all I could remember was Yorick and agent 355 in the woods at night and Yorick asking her where she's from and she looks up at the sky and smiles while the camera is zooming in on stars. Yorick then says "no, no........" in disbelief. Would definitely make a different show lol

Yes I watch The Foundation too so thats probably how my wires got crossed.


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 29 '21

MEME/FLUFF Gritty and depressing. Until Yorick takes his shirt off.

5 Upvotes

Just watch episode 4 where our badly miscast main actor is told to strip down.

He's dark haired with a full beard, been living on scraps for weeks and yet when he takes his top off he looks like he's just stepped out of the gym and is fully shaved from the neck down.

If you're going to make the book even more grim and depressing at least be consistent.


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 02 '21

DISCUSSION i don't understand why anyone in the show is loyal to existing countries or political parties. help?

0 Upvotes

i am having difficulty looking away from this show. there's this familiar alienness to the whole thing i'm having trouble putting into words and i'm wondering if anyone here would help me.

it's in how so many of the characters are worrying about burying bodies and finding bodies instead of how they're going to get food in a month or a year. all the men are dead. you know they're dead. you're running out of food. so why prioritize that? why would so many characters have opinions on what happens to the bodies at all?

why would anyone be loyal to the concept of an existing government? why would anyone be interested in sneaking contraband into the government, or protecting the government from having it sneaked in? why would a leader have time to sit quietly in a room reading papers when the entire planet is on fire because half of everyone is dead? why are you ruling with tanks?

and what the hell is it with people being republicans or democrats? one is a position of dominance and submission and to be one is to be like a beaten person looking for a new abuser. and the latter is a compromise with those dominators that is like, controlled opposition and if most of the enforcers of that regime are gone you can just win. you don't have to make compromises.

and why are people stealing food? and more importantly, why would anyone want to not give food to people starving? i get that people would want to not starve and need food but if you see someone hungry why wouldn't you? (and if someone offers you help, why would you hurt them?)

and it's like, shows about post-apocalypses are usually all, "grr we got guns and we'll kill ya grr we got gangs and guns and cigarettes" or whatever, and this show is doing a thing where it pretends women aren't as likely to get out the guns and shoot, or that even a woman president would be appalled at the idea of someone shooting down to pilots for the sake of secrecy, which seems sexist and unrealistic. like, you wanna win don't you? there's real stakes there and probably a lot more people would die if some wacko is in charge so assassinate Regina and move the fuck on. and you talk to the goddamn pilots because it's perfectly normal to be very confused by the improbability that a leader's son just happens to be the only man to survive, and keep them around to help unless they betray you. killing them was unnecessary.

it's almost like no character in this show but 355 and the militia leader Hero ran into are playing to survive, and the rest are wildly off in their priorities. and 355 isn't much better because for some reason she's decided to act as if any of her spy bullshit hierarchy matters.

and i guess it's realistic. because i know a lot of women are collaborators with the patriarchy, but i guess this show just throws that into such sharp relief that it's jarring and alien to act that way.


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 09 '21

QUESTION I'm confused

10 Upvotes

I think the most confusing part watching the show is why is the world so post apocalyptic? Half the world is still alive (roughly speaking) but they can’t keep power on and people are needing to raid stores. Like why? I get the grief and the loss can knock you on your butt and that would’ve impacted in every woman but why did the world actually turn to shit just because the men were gone?


r/YTheLastMan • • Nov 01 '21

DISCUSSION If you don't like the show so don't watch it or left this sub

0 Upvotes

title


r/YTheLastMan • • Oct 31 '21

COMIC SPOILERS!! WARNING: Do not read Issues 18-20 if you are triggered by depictions of rape in media

15 Upvotes

Early 2000s comics don't have content warnings, so here's one from me for those who want to dive into the comics.

If depictions of drugging/rape bother you, DO NOT READ ISSUES 18-20. There's a very unsubtle "it's OK because he wants it" vibe to it, to be expected for the time period this was published but still deeply unsettling.

I found this out the hard way and wanted to warn anyone who decides to check the comic out. It's good overall, but is very much a product of its time.


r/YTheLastMan • • Nov 05 '21

QUESTION Does this show get better?

8 Upvotes

The first episode was so intensely boring that I skipped from the 20 minute mark to the 45 minute mark. I don't feel like I missed anything, but when the magician started begging his girlfriend to marry him I just decided that I could not care any less about was going on. I don't feel like I missed anything and the final 10 minutes wasn't anything special.

I liked the comic when I read it a decade or so ago, and I want to like the series, but I'm not certain if it's worth the time investment.