r/YAlit • • Jan 30 '26 This

Review Fourth Wing is the Worst Book I've Ever Read, and I'm 2 Chapters In.

1 Upvotes

I got this book for Christmas as a gag gift. I love a good joke, but oh my god. Thank god I knew it was a joke so I can power through this ironically like a "so bad it's good" read.

I'm not talking about the story or the characters, which are already awful and ridiculous. I'm talking about the literal words on the page. Yarros is trying SO hard and it results in the dumbest prose I've ever read:

"A chill of apprehension lifts the hairs on my neck

Girl, WHAT?

"... the woman says, holding a pen like Mom uses over the roll."

Do you mean A PEN? Also "Mom" isn't a proper noun, but that's more of a nit-pick.

"...vibrates with rage,"

WHAT.

"a dozen feet"

WHAT?!

"carved into the mountains... tall stone buildings, built to withstand fire, for obvious reasons."

Yeah, not like those FLAMMABLE MOUNTAINS made of FLAMMABLE STONE.

This whole book is like this - it reads like an alien learned english by reading nothing but Tumblr fanfics and high school essays written the night before they were due.

  • "I feel my lungs threaten to hyperventilate"

  • "He has to be more than four inches over six feet tall."

  • "there's nothing but pure malice in his features"

And this is just the sentences with severely distracting and awkward as fuck wording. Theres also the

  • re-treading of how Violet is "that" Sorrengail FOUR TIMES. WE KNOW. WE ALL KNOW.

  • Characters explaining to each other about a rebellion that happened recently as if they don't know.

  • an ENTIRE chapter that's just Yarros going back and forth between finding various ways for Jack to say "imma kill ya!" and various ways for violet to narrate "I was scared, but I walked forward."

  • blatantly losing track of the blocking/geography of her own scenes

  • Violet replying in Chapter 3 to the dialogue that ended Chapter 2.

  • fantasy characters saying the phrase "fucking badass" is cringe.

Frankly, I will be SHOCKED if this doesn't set this subreddit off but I need to vent, and this is one of the only places where I can guarantee that other people have read this book.

What makes it so frustrating is how easily Yarros could just rearrange everything to sound like normal english language telling a normal story, but it's like it's been finely crafted to be wrong on a primal level.

I'm absolutely planning to finish this book, but the cringe is SO bad that I had to vent.


r/YAlit • • Nov 12 '25

General Question/Information What's a popular book series that you will never read

0 Upvotes

I will start Zodiac Academy and Fourth Wing. The author of Fourth Wing is problematic, and how she misrepresents the Gaelic language in her book is a huge problem for me. Regarding Zodiac Academy, no hate to the authors—it's not about them, really. It's just that you can publish so many books before you start to lose me. If this series was an interconnected standalone, I would have read it. But after finding out that they are all connected and you have to read them in order, and it's not just one series you have to read but multiple, I lost interest.


r/YAlit • • 7d ago

Seeking Recommendations Gay YA books actually written for gay people?

1 Upvotes

Please respect the post as you are free to scroll if you dont like anything I say here. I wont engage with anyone debating that all gay books are written for gay people, because in this time and age of Heated Rivalry the genre is so oversaturated with stories clearly catered towards straight females with some sort of kink.

Anyway, this isn't even supposed to be a niche ask but it is. I want to read a gay YA book written for the gays like me. No oversaturated and unrealistic romance, no overly nice environment cause that doesn't happen, and definitely nothing that would raise my already high expectations of life 😭

I want the pain, the gloom, the sadness, and the beauty of being gay. I want the doomed yaoi. I want the Adam Silvera style books cause I already read all of his work, or something similar to Don't Let The Forest In. I want the aching prose. I want the book to break my heart and put it together again.

Only contemporary books. Absolutely no romantasy please. Only leeway Im willing to make regarding that is supernatural romance still set in contemporary cause I've been recently obsessed with The Vampire Diaries and The Originals lately. Would be cool if there's a gay YA book out there with a Klaus and Camille or Stefan and Caroline type dynamic. So Im cool with vampires, werewolves, witches, or even fallen angels as long as its this world.

Bonus points too if it has a mystery and intentional/unintentional philosophical value.


r/YAlit • • Sep 10 '25

Wrap-Up My Tier List of young adult fantasy books

Post image
10 Upvotes

I hope i don't make too many enemies😅​ :)

(Some books i haven't read are on my “to read” list)

( I did not choose the names of the categories)


r/YAlit • • 10d ago

Spoilers Here's why I hate Aaron Warner from the shatter me series.

6 Upvotes

1.) SA'd Juliette in the first book. (I can prove it if anyone needs me to). (He was also an adult while he sexually abused Juliette who at that time was a minor)

2.) Tortured and almost killed Adam

3.) Tortured Emmaline (I understand his reason but I still hate him for doing that)

4.) Made extremely rude comments abt how Kenji eats knowing full well that Kenji wasn't as privileged as he was

5.) Rude to everyone except her.

The first reason is actually more than enough for me to hate him but I had more. (I might have more.)

There is absolutely no amount of tragic backstory that will ever make me like an abuser.

I feel bad for the child who went through all of that but none of that excuse his actions.

And yes, I've read all the books.


r/YAlit • • Apr 16 '25

Discussion Young Adult Books that would have a Taylor Swift soundtrack!! <3

0 Upvotes

I love books and Taylor Swift!! I was thinking which books would have a Taylor Swift soundtrack!! Please suggest any ya book of any genre!! The first book series that came to my mind is The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes!! Thank you in advanced!! Have an amazing day/afternoon/evening/night!! :)


r/YAlit • • Oct 09 '22

Discussion Twilight & ACOTAR are not badly written.

124 Upvotes

No Spoilers. If you have spoilers in your comments please use > ! Text ! < without the spaces to hide your spoilers.

Stephenie Meyer and Sarah J. Maas catch so much flak for their novels, and I'm so tired of hearing about it. People who have never even read the novels (or the movies, for Twilight) have such strong opinions about how they're bad writing/undeserving of the attention they receive just because they're teen romance novels (ACOTAR is new adult, but you catch my drift).

It's gotten to the point where even fans of the novels will justify their interest by saying stuff like "I know it's bad writing, but I love it" or "It's my guilty pleasure" or "it's trashy, but...". I just want to tell these people that you don't need to prematurely insult the things you love in anticipation of others' criticisms. You can unashamedly say that you love Twilight & other fantasy romance because they're good, compelling, richly crafted stories.

Several years/nearly decades after the release of these books they are still being talked about, still have active communities & a huge following, and still have people that write fanfics/make art/get tattoos/daydream about these worlds and characters. That is not bad writing! That's an incredible impact to have on your audience, and obvious evidence of very good writing. And I'm not saying that everything that is popular is good craftsmanship; I'm just saying that it being popular, containing romance, being written by women, and being consumed predominantly by women does not make it bad.

Thank you for listening to my rant :) It's just that I'm frustrated with how long it's taken me to come to the realization that I don't need to be insecure about the genre I love, and I hope others realize the same thing.

Edit: Thanks for all of the interaction here. Most people on this sub disagree with me, which is totally fine. I do like the analysis that some writing majors have done in this thread, and I've come to accept that my criteria for good writing is different from a lot of people's.

As said in a comment below, I think most people have issues with their prose, which I can understand, but I argue that's only a part of good writing. Others have also said they're good "storytellers" and a bad "writers", which I have a hard time wrapping my head around because I think of storytelling as falling under the umbrella of writing. So, yes I think they are good storytellers, and I see that most people think their prose is subpar. I think both can be true and still make them good writers, but most people disagree.

Special thank you to the people who disagreed but were very respectful and courteous in their replies. I love to see it :)


r/YAlit • • Sep 06 '24

Discussion Why is modern YA so grating no matter how hard I try to get into it?

32 Upvotes

Ok, so bare with me, but the only YA fiction I’ve read thats from the 20th Century was Harry Potter and The Sorcerer’s Stone (debatable whether that is even considered YA), but I’ve recently been trying modern books, trying to finally leave my 20th century media obsession behind and finally try something newer. So far, it’s been a pretty fun and smooth ride, but there’s just something in the YA missing. I don’t know if it’s the language or the story or the tone, but these stories all seem so empty, cold, and just so moody and manufactured. I’ve seen heroes/protagonists left depressed and victimized and never coming back, I’ve seen underdogs stay the underdogs and victory rarely explored as a theme. Also the way it’s written and just the language in general is grating. Is it just my book selection, or is YA dying. The only book I’ve recently enjoyed is Tilly in Technicolor which I’m just getting into and so far that book does incredibly well.

edit: Thank you all so much for the recommendations, this community is so great and makes me definitely want to get into ya considering I am the current audience and there are so many gems out there that I haven’t even stumbled upon in the slightest!!! Thanks and much love!


r/YAlit • • Jan 02 '26

General Question/Information Is there a subreddit specifically for YA?

15 Upvotes

By which I mean, is there a subreddit for YA ONLY without NA? To me, the two genres are pretty different and it muddles things up tossing them in the same mega-genre.

EDIT: or -- mods-- is there any chance of making THiS subreddit (it is after all, called r/YAlit) confined to YA?


r/YAlit • • Sep 10 '24

Wrap-Up God forbid anyone hate Suren Spoiler

0 Upvotes

God forbid anyone wants to see Suren from the stolen heir duology suffer everyone loves her. Everyone except me some people say they’re neutral but god forbid you want to see her suffer for everything she did to Oak. She literally used the bridle on him when she stated how horrible it is but everyone else loves loves loves her. They will defend her with their lives. God forbid you dislike Suren. They will always say you’re wrong. No one else dislikes her despite the fact she abused Oak. But god forbid you call her abusive.


r/YAlit • • Feb 27 '25

Discussion Fourth Wing

1 Upvotes

I recently made a post and I was looking through my replies, and the most common answer I got was "Fourth Wing sucks." May I understand why? I plan on reading the series once I am older because I will be old enough to withstand the spice, and all five books will be published by then.


r/YAlit • • Jan 07 '26

Discussion First Kiss

2 Upvotes

This might be off-topic but... anyway..... Non-American reader here~ There's one thing that's been (kinda) bothering me since reading the Harry Potter and Percy Jackson series [and now watching the pjo series, seeing how young (and age-accurate) the actors are]. Both Harry and Percy were in the age of 15 (as far as I could remember) when they got their first kiss. I thought that it was waaaayyyyyy to early for that. Now that I'm an adult, a 15 year old is a KID. I mean... is that how American/western culture works? 😆


r/YAlit • • Aug 04 '26

Discussion Do you guys dog eared your books?

1 Upvotes

I never do, I did it when I was younger like in middle school, now I never do
I don’t dog eared my own books or books from the library


r/YAlit • • Mar 29 '26

Discussion Why is the “pregnancy trope” so hated? Why do you hate it?

64 Upvotes

I truly don’t understand why the “pregnancy trope” is so hated, or why it’s even called a “trope”. Sometimes an author wants the story to end with the couple having a child, is that so bad? Having a child, being pregnant, etc. are all fully normal things and can add interesting new dynamics or problems within the story.

I personally am neither a dislike nor a like person - I just don’t care if it’s there or not, as long as it is well written.

I just don’t get why it’s called a “trope” and not just a plot point like any other think, like a character death, or a wedding, or a graduation?

Just curious, no offense here about people disliking it. Just general genuine curiosity.


r/YAlit • • Apr 11 '25

General Question/Information Guys should I read Caravel by Stephanie Garber?

1 Upvotes

My sister loved it a lot but says that it might not be for me. I haven't read much books but the cruel prince was pretty cool. Should I read it?


r/YAlit • • May 09 '23

Seeking Recommendations Looking for YA/NA with FMC, no romance, no fantasy/sci-fi/paranormal/dystopia, no identity crisis

1 Upvotes

I just want to read about a girl going through some fairly mundane age-appropriate stuff, learning to handle it well, and having a healthy sense of humor about it without obsessing over a guy or a fae or whatever. Too much to ask?


r/YAlit • • Aug 01 '26

Discussion Hot takes? Do not downvote people who have different opinions, if anything upvote them bc they’re actually hot takes

0 Upvotes
  1. Kovit (Not Even Bones) is by far the best written morally grey MMC because I love him DESPITE the fact he tortured and murdered DOZENS of people, and that scares me.

  2. It shows how well written Kovit is because I am someone who dislikes Aaron Warner so much after reading Shatter Me that I dropped the series.

  3. ACOTAR is an annoying book. Feyre is annoying and dumb, her family is rude and also annoying, Tamlin is uninteresting, and Rhysand is pervy.


r/YAlit • • Oct 30 '21

Discussion Why does every new YA book have LGBTQ+ supporting romances these days?

15 Upvotes

Like really, can’t we just have a book where there’s an actual friendship between women? Or where the FL’s male best friend isn’t gay? I’m fine with representation, but I wish there was just more platonic relationships.


r/YAlit • • Apr 04 '21

Discussion Past and Future!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/YAlit • • Jul 24 '19

My father took away my books

9 Upvotes

I was enjoying the third Eragon book, I'm 14 living with my parents, my father told me to stop reading children's books and took it away from me. He told me to start reading proper literature or he would throw me out. He gave me a copy of this book called Child of God by cormac Mccarthy but I think it's boring and too violent for me what should I do


r/YAlit • • Nov 10 '24

Discussion The show does not need to be like the book

Post image
83 Upvotes

I would also like to read the book "A good girl's guide to murder" but the book fans have really fed up with me. What do you mean the series doesn't deserve it because ""different from the book""? It sounds to me like the same stupid reasons why anime and manga fans belittled the first adaptation of Full Metal Alchemist by deeming it bad because it "didn't follow the manga."

I really wish people would start thinking that adaptations belong to the directors of and screenwriters, not the original author of the book

Emma Myers proved to be very good as an actress (I didn't doubt her from the beginning), directionally the series is really well directed with shots that are not at all trivial, all with a narrative that honestly grabbed me more than expected.

Nothing incredible but the Netflix show is worth a viewing and comparisons to the book are really sterile .


r/YAlit • • Aug 16 '26

Discussion I can’t get into the fantasy/romantasy genre..

0 Upvotes

Maybe I’m just not a fantasy book girl because everytime I pick one up, I can never fully get into it and always find my mind wandering else where 😭 I keep seeing ppl rave on booktok about the acotar series so I’m trying to give it a shot but ugh it’s hard, rn it’s super boring but apparently the second book is super good so like do I keep going ?? And I have sooo many books on my tbr that I wanna read rn so I always have to remind myself to chill tf out and take my time and to enjoy my current book lmaoo, is anyone else like this tho with fantasy books


r/YAlit • • Oct 11 '24

Discussion Fourth wing knock offs

1 Upvotes

Am I the only one who hasn’t seen any clear rip-offs of FW? I mean, Yarros is not following the fae phase and has had succes with her dragon / school setting. In the past, I have seen different publishers suddenly flooding the market with similar books, chasing the same success. But I still haven’t seen any.


r/YAlit • • Sep 08 '25

Discussion Am I weird for reading YA books?

0 Upvotes

Hi. First time on this subreddit.

Uh, so my question is... do you think it's weird (or creepy) for adults to read YA books?

So for example, if I (20) read YA books because I'm not necessarily a fan of a lot of other genres (fantasy, dark romance, etc.), would I be weird for that?

Now, not all of my books are YA but a lot of them are. I've been making that list since I was 16/17 and based on the description of the books, some of them kinda resonated with me. And the reason why I'm asking this is because I've seen some comments (on YouTube) where there were discussions where other readers had thought that adults reading YA was weird

Another reason is that I've tried reading others and a lot of them had smut scenes and personally don't like smut scenes, soooo am I weird/creepy for this?


r/YAlit • • Apr 14 '22

Discussion Something is bothering me about The Cruel Prince… Spoiler

9 Upvotes

The Folk of the Air series has been really popular over the past few years, and I read the first book and enjoyed it more than other overhyped YA fantasy books. There were definitely many things that bothered me about The Cruel Prince, mainly the justification of why Cardan was so cruel to Jude.

(It honestly saddens me how many people actually believe this is "morally grey". It's not. This is a very toxic mentality told to girls that if a boy is mean to you, he likes you. NO! He is a person of power — a prince — bullying his subjects, and you really want to convince me he'll one day make a worthy King? If 2+2 is 4……… Some people will hate corrupt authority unless it consists of a sulking, white, black-haired male with trauma, huh. Anyways, this is just a quick FYI: How you deal with your trauma should not be at the expense of other people - and if it is, you certainly shouldn't be given leeway. Also it's not romantic to bully someone because you're jealous of them or because you like them :D that's a huge red flag, and you shouldn't be supporting it, fictional or not.)

BUT BACK TO THE MAIN POINT.

Something I haven't seen anyone discuss — and what's truly bothering me about the direction of this series — is Jude's blatant quest for political power. So here's what I know so far:

  • Jude has been brought to Elfhame and was raised there, but she has the means to return to the mortal world.

  • Jude has been bullied in Elfhame and has a love-hate relationship with it. She doesn't want to return to the mortal world; she wants to make Elfhame comfortable for her.

  • Jude has a hero complex, and thus wants power to rule over Elfhame.

Well, you see…… Jude calls her quest "a need for power." I wanna call it ~imperialism~!

This is probably a morally grey stance, but: I don't think you should enter a world that is not your own, living among beings that are not like you, then complain that their standards of living are unlike what you know from your world. You need to understand that that could be their "normal", even if it discomforts you. (It's like living in the underworld and complaining that demons are mean.) And if these people face injustice and corruption in their world, I think the people of that world should be the ones who take on the power to change it (of course acquiring help from others if they want, but even that is up to them, not you).

And yes, people can belong in a culture/country that isn't "theirs" — and they have every right to live there and appreciate different cultures! — but it is a whole different ball game when you seek political control. There are still limits to what people can do in a culture/country that isn't fully their own.

I'm currently starting The Wicked King, but I'm still put off by the fact that Jude thinks this is just a regular climb to power. She can, of course, want to save the humans that are mistreated there — but wanting to rule Elfhame in its entirety is a different kind of issue. I want to know if imperialism is ever considered/discussed in the series, and if someone takes Jude down a peg. I'm aware of her famous quote: If I cannot be better than them, I'll be so much worse (or something along those lines). When I heard it was from her, this sorta pulled me in the direction of thinking that, oh gosh, this is definitely imperialism. (Because what does "worse" mean? Harming locals for political power in their world which you like? Using military forces? Yikes??) Btw, please let me know if I got the context of this quote wrong (being spoiler-free if you can) because I haven't yet reached the point of the series where she says that.

Overall, I'm starting to think this shouldn't be her story, if you know what I mean. I would probably enjoy the story more if I knew these characters would get punished for their corrupt actions, but that doesn't seem like it would be the case here.

It's especially concerning that Holly Black is a white American author who's writing about these things without even noticing the implications. Jude is giving… white saviour complex. (I hate to say it, but she's also giving Oli London vibes.) Maybe the only reason why no one noticed this before was because Jude fought against fae, not POCs — otherwise, this would be a very different story, yes?

I'm Filipino (so I know about colonialism and imperialism and such lol), and I've been bothered by this premise since the beginning, but perhaps it's farfetched…? Maybe I forgot a detail? What do you guys think?

(Btw, I like Jude as a character. She's well-built, better than most YA fantasy MCs I've read, and she has a satisfying personality, but I just don't know if I can really support her motivations.)

UPDATE: See my comment below for my new thoughts on this discussion! (I honestly don't know how Reddit works, I'm new, so like… is this what you do?)