A lot of the arguments I see against are that "the blades in-game are fanservice," "the game itself is NSFW," and while this is true, the NSFW fanart in question crossed a line between tasteful sexy and overly-explicit sexy that makes it basically softcore porn. Posting a NSFW screenshot won't get the post deleted. Posting a fanart of a character in a revealing outfit won't get deleted. But what will get deleted are posts with qualities that blatantly make it fall under the category of softcore porn, still being pornographic in nature despite the characters being clothed. What qualities did these fanarts possess that made them this way? Well:
Non-canonical body types/over-exaggeration of sexual aspects: In-game, Pyra and Mythra may have big boobs, but you sure as hell cannot see the outlines of their nipples and they do not utilize them in any sexual manner. They are big, but in a tasteful way. The fanart in question however was definitely not tasteful; characters such as Pyra and Mythra had aspects of their bodies such as their boobs and butt inflated and way bigger than anything close to how they are in-game. Furthermore, a lot of these fanarts had visible nipple outlines and vagina outlines. You cannot just think to yourself and say "oh thats definitely not sexual everyone has nipples so do the characters in-game!!1" The motivation of showing nipples in anime fanart 99% of the time is for explicit sexual purposes, most of us know that. And no, it is not just the artists style or the artist taking some artistic liberties, most of the time in these softcore porn fanarts, if it weren't for the outfit and color of the characters hair you would NEVER be able to identify the character becasue the body has been so misshapen and the sexual aspects have been so overly exaggerated from the source material. And big-breasts being sexual or not sexual isn't open to debate because, lets all face the truth, they are sexual and definitely portrayed in a sexual manner. And the entire point of a lot of these fanarts were portraying these females in a ludicrous-sexy manner. But like what was stated before, sexy doesn't make something porn; what makes it porn is how it is portrayed, in this case it is the over explicity.
To make this situation easier to see for a lot of you, lets not focus on the female characters for once. Instead, lets focus on a blatant case of the over-exaggeration of sexual aspects for a male character in a way that makes it softcore porn and definitely not suitable for this sub. I feel that most of you will agree because most of you are straight.
For educative purposes, lets make a scenario. NSFW warning ahead (please don't remove this post mods), features clothed character but over-sexualized aspects. Lets say that some person posted this fanart to the sub: source: lostanemone on tumblr
If you somehow told me that this wasn't blatant explicit sexualization of a character that isn't close to how the character is in-game at all for the purposes of masturbation, I really would like you to reconsider your mental state because you would be delusional and lying to yourself. This is exactly what is done to many of the female blades in-game with their fan-art, with the humungous boobs and ass and nipple outlines and vagina outlines. Said fan-art is then posted here under the guise of a NSFW tag, but they are far more fitting for the R34 sub because of their nature.
Expression: there is Pyra/Mythra blushing in a cutscene in-game, and then there are fanarts where they have ahegao faces with a large amount of blush, eyes rolling back, sweat and pleasure highly visible on their faces as if they are having an orgasm from getting Rex's schlong. While there may be no act of penetration, it is still the sexual image that is being delivered. And this really isn't subject to opinion or discretion because at the end of the day: most of us in the community are weebs, we ALL know signs of anime porn whenever we see it. There is a mental check that goes off in our minds whenever we see something that classifies it into: Porn, Not Porn. Just because the characters are wearing clothing doesn't make it any less sexually suggestive and explicit. I presume most of the people that argue against the ban of NSFW fanart know this, or at least they really should...
Clothing: a fanart depicting Rex in his swimsuit? post it! a fanart depicting Pyra/Mythra in their swimsuits? post it! a fanart depicting any character in a fan-made swimsuit? post it! a fanart depicting a character in their swimsuit with visible genitalia outlines, an expression of pleasure on the face, super humungous breasts/ass or super hyper muscle mass/definition while they do not look like this in-game anyway shape or form? Probably shouldn't post it. R34 is the place for you.
If you REALLY have to ask yourself if something is sexually NSFW before posting it, you probably shouldn't.
Artists intentions: when is fanart depicting a character with exaggerated proportions and lewd expressions NOT meant to sexually infatuate those that happen to gaze upon it? Not a lot. If the artist is being tasteful, you'll know because it is reflected in the fanart. If the artist is being overly explicit, you'll know because it is reflected in the fanart.
Tl;dr - at the end of the day, Xenoblade Chronicles 2 is rated T for Teen and PEGI 12. If most of the banned fanart in question depicting the characters in their swimsuits including all of the removed fanarts were placed in an in-game photobook in a new update, do you think it would still maintain that rating? It DEFINITELY wouldn't, like at all, dat shit would be rated M.
I hope this post influences everyone to step back from their view on these fanarts and really re-evaluate themselves because things were definitely taken too far.