This past weekend should be a major eye opener for Xwing TMG community. This game is on its way out with the current OP, rules, and game support strategy. A hard change has to happen and it starts here in the community discussions. This is my plea to the community, the players, the influencers, the podcasters, the streamers, judges, play testers, and the player base that left to come together to save this game.
NOVA and Italian Open occurred. At NOVA there was 85 players in total. At Italy there was apparently only 17. Back in 2019, there was 88 players in day 1A at NOVA 10. There was a total of 186 that year. Something is wrong with XwingTMG . Poorly put together on my phone, down below are event attendance numbers. You can compare them for yourself, some major events and minor events form 2019 to now.
First and foremost, to me it is very clear that AMG 2.5 rule set and approach to OP has hurt the game. How can I say it is both? Well, online play spiked in 2020 for obvious reasons. Players wanted to play Xwing and found ways to play in community OP events held by tons of groups. Even with point changes that drove many of us nuts (Spamtek) people played Xwing. All the numbers were up and through 2021 that normalized. Players found the groups they liked playing in and would consistently show up for online or even dare I say it, in person!!!!, events. Players would still show up for the online major events. Things rapidly change in late 2021. The 2.5 rules come out. I am not talking about ROAD leak or no bid, no the actual 2.5 rules.
I have never seen such a big crash in player count, after a spike, like this ever before. Locally, we saw a decent number of new faces, veterans giving it a shot, and people return to the game. As someone that ran a local charity tournament only a few months after the new rules came out, it was like pulling teeth to get players to show up (down form 40 locals to just 14). I have never heard, "well i think it is time to move on", or "it is just not for me", or "nah driving an hour to play is not worth it." that many times in a row. I had another game at the event and players from multiple other states came for that game. Driving 6+ hours. Heck, i thought I messed up cause adepticon was going on at the same time - the locals didn't even go to that! The point is, players are not showing up to events now. This version of the game doesn't have staying power. Players are not showing up and there is enough data to show it is not due to limitations in the surrounding environment (travel cost, marketing, etc). Players are not watching it, podcast numbers are down, stream/youtube views are down, sub goals are not being met, patreon numbers are down.
Second, the community split and AMG approach to criticism/hate. It is clear who the vocal players and promoters of 2.5 are. They teamed up with AMG on the most idiotic approach to criticism (and the unjustified awful comments). I have been personally told, 'Then just quit." Who in their right mind tells community members to leave? Even in the heated moments of 1.0 to 2.0, I have never personally told people to leave. All we did back then was provide encouragement or listened to the feedback/concerns/hate. Guess what, people played 2.0. Lots of players showed up for events. Worlds was packed from players all over the world in 2019. People again played through a pandemic. So AMG's approach was effective, players left and haven't come back. My question is then, Why are the all the supporters not going to the events? The so called real fans. Those that truly understand the 2.5 game. The ones that said, new players will come in and we will no longer see the same faces win events. Why aren't you supporting the game by being there? Where are the constant list building discussions that a one upgrade tweak would cause hundreds of players to weight in on?
So, lets be reasonable here and have a real discussion on how to bring the player base back. This is going to be a group effort. I loved playing Xwing. I really haven't found a game quite like it before and since. It drives me to comeback and pay attention. it drives my spouse nuts that I talk about it and due charities around it. The staying power was there, the ability to update and evolve is there, the chance for a player to actually grow/develop was there, and the community discussions were amazing.
Here are my first set of real questions to ask:
Do you enjoy 2.5 rules?
a) favorite element(s) of 2.5?
b) unfavorable element(s) of 2.5?
Will you travel over 2 hours for a 2.5 OP event (tournament, narrative, etc)? Why or Why not? 3) If you left the game, what would bring you back?
Do you like the standard loadout in standard play? Should AMG separate competitive OP and thematic/narrative OP?
How important is OP to you (local and national)?
Player Count Data:
Reviewing IRL and Online Xwing Tournaments from 2019 to 2022 (information comes from List fortress and TTT for confirmation) that exceeded 50 players. Note, main focus was on standard rule sets at the time (2.5 standard, 2.0 extended). I did my best to remove team, major game modification events, side events, top cut counts (repeats of events). Player count if confirmed with TTT was those that actually played a minimum of 1 game. I typically only review 80+ events when analyzing meta data, but had to reduce it to 50 for 2.5.
2022 (Up to September 6):
Total of 3 IRL events that achieved above 50 players. Gencon 119, NOVA 85, UK 75. Online events so far are GSP Oricon 94, Sullust 80, Malachor 72. Special mention to Kyber Cup Season 6 tournament with 241 players.
2021 (the week past labor day weekend):
Online only - GSP Mon Cala 209, Jeda 198, Scarif 178, Bespin 133, Firecast 113. Going on Last Chance would have 255 and Alderan would have 255. Special mention to Kyber Cup Season 5 having 413 players. Flight Club would also average around 140 per event.
2020 (the week past labor day weekend):
LVO 233, Uk System open 390, Dallas hyperspace - 137. Space Jam around 148 per players, Galatic Conquest Quals - 180 players on average and would max out GSP servers for the finals at 255. Kyber Cup Tournament Season 4 would get 88. XVT events were around 60 players and up at this time.
2019 (the week past laber day weekend):
UK event with 562 players (i think there is overlap here so take with a grain of salt), Worlds 415, EU champs 265, Austrailia Open 255, Adepticon 251. Past September UK nationals 195, Madrid open 270, Spain Championship 172, Alanta Open 173, Moscow Open 177, Paris Open 182, Phoenix open 216.