448
u/gyunexX Nov 20 '25
And in the end it turns out it was a mythology episode and Mulder was right.
211
u/Waytooboredforthis Call me "Fox-y Mulder" Nov 20 '25
Knife alien gets beamed up by a swirling tornado of knives, Scully catches a glimpse and goes right back to calling shenanigans the next week.
108
u/gyunexX Nov 20 '25
Alien could look her straight into the eyes and Scully be like
"No, Mulder, everything I learned..."122
u/ghoulish891011 The poles are reversing. Nov 20 '25
Scully spends hours observing and taking photos of the knife alien. Calls in a team to examine it. Goons come and take the body.
Scully:
"I don't know what I saw, Mulder"
36
u/valentino-white-bag Nov 20 '25
Ah but remember, despite having the best 90s photographic technology at their disposal, Mulder and Scully NEVER TAKE PICTURES OF ANYTHING. And then they have the nerve to complain when the Syndicate destroys the hard evidence 🫠
6
u/Enough-Ad-7084 Nov 21 '25
They don't take pics b/c every room they enter, they forget about this little thing called a "lightswitch", "Nah, we don't need to see the whole crime scene, just whatever glints we get from our little tubie flashlights..."
13
16
u/Briankelly130 Agent Fox Mulder Nov 20 '25
The funny thing is, doesn't Scully become the Mulder after Doggett is brought in?
7
39
u/WySLatestWit Nov 20 '25
"No, Mulder, it's not aliens, aliens are ridiculous, anyway, off to church!"
38
u/BridgingDivides Nov 20 '25
13
19
u/AgrajagsGhost Nov 20 '25
She was so excited to finally have some real, solid, scientific proof in that episode too. Then she gathers up all her scientist friends to show them her findings and FINALLY PROVE that she and Mulder aren't crazy and...
Boom. No evidence. Everyone looks at her like she's a crackpot and she's sputtering like "No. No. You don't understand. It was just here. IT WAS JUST HERE!"
10
u/Fit_Reveal_1511 Special Agent Sculder Nov 20 '25
"well, he IS invisible, after all!"
My poor girl :(
14
u/ghoulish891011 The poles are reversing. Nov 20 '25 edited Nov 20 '25
That's why they call him Spooky
20
u/WySLatestWit Nov 20 '25
Isn't just about every episode resolved with "Mulder was right" in the end?
22
u/AgrajagsGhost Nov 20 '25
He was usually right but also there was also no proof other than "Trust me bro."
10
u/WySLatestWit Nov 20 '25
That's fair, but if I deal with someone at work who is correct 99.9 percent of the time...eventually I'm going to just start assuming they're right.
8
u/AgrajagsGhost Nov 20 '25
I mean totally, fair.
From a meta-perspective, the writers of the show needed an unreasonably skeptical person as a foil to the unreasonable believer that was Mulder. The character of Scully sometimes took the skepticism a little too far and suspension of disbelief became a little unreasonable after however many seasons though.
Looking for a in-universe reason, we could say that Scully was hired specifically because she was unreasonably skeptical and the FBI brass wanted that to shut up ol' Spooky in the basement. In several episodes she even says that she can't explain what they just saw, but there's no hard evidence that a rational third party will accept. She never drops that desire to find evidence to convince someone else, even when she personally saw and believes in whatever weirdness, it's probably part of why she keeps her job. If she went Full Believer, she'd be replaced with another skeptic (which eventually happens in S8 and S9).
8
u/WySLatestWit Nov 20 '25
I will say that I actually find Scully's sudden 180 into just being Mulder once Duchovny was (mostly) gone from the show more irritating than her years of unreasonable skepticism.
You mean to tell me you've spent the better part of the last 7 years denying everything you see and now suddenly you're willing to believe damn near everything!? You're annoying! haha.
10
u/ghoulish891011 The poles are reversing. Nov 20 '25
The denial was foreplay. She was just trying to get Mulder worked up.
6
u/lmthatguyurGFcalls Nov 20 '25
I just started watching this but does that imply that the cases that weren’t in mythology episodes could be explained using science? And was therefore not some paranormal phenomena?
16
u/BloatedSnake430 Nov 20 '25
No, Mulder is always right
14
u/ghoulish891011 The poles are reversing. Nov 20 '25
Mulder is almost always right, but his brain works on another level. It's Scully's job to sell it to the normies.
5
u/_Mobius1 Nov 20 '25
Technically that's scullys whole purpose in being part of the x files
5
u/ghoulish891011 The poles are reversing. Nov 20 '25
She was assigned to debunk the work, but his Foxy charm captured her.
3
49
Nov 20 '25
Just recently started watching X-Files, and I always find it funny when she's experienced so much odd and supernatural shite and the next episode is still like, "I don't believe in this, you're looking for something that isn't there, Mulder!" And she, once again, gets proven wrong 😂 I love this show
25
u/SrGrimey Nov 20 '25
I thought the same when I started watching it (1 month ago), but then I read or heard that she needs evidence for the new thing Mulder is telling her.
Basically is “not because I saw someone transformed into Mulder I believe this person can move things with their mind”.
19
u/BloatedSnake430 Nov 20 '25
To be fair to Scully, even if Mulder was right about Big Foot last week doesn't mean alien vampires are disguising themselves as mosquitos this week. You need evidence for both things. Even though Mulder is right quite often, Scully makes him better at his job by helping him ask the right questions and look for more proof.
4
u/Afraid_Magician_9462 Nov 20 '25
I was considering watching the series. Does it hold up well?
24
u/ritrgrrl Agent Fox Mulder Nov 20 '25
We're still talking about it after 30+ years, so I'd say yes. 👽🛸🐝
13
3
u/ZobiWanKenobi91 Nov 20 '25
Finally got around to it on our watch-list this year. Started in about July and we’re already onto Season 6. Highly recommend if you’re in any way curious.
2
Nov 20 '25
Yep, I loved every second of it; think I only got to about season 6 or 7 before my sub ran out on Hulu, but I watched every episode intensely and even cried a few times! The series finds a way to make you love every character you meet (or passionately hate!), it's def worth it.
2
1
u/IneffableOpinion Agent Dana Scully Nov 20 '25
She has to see the evidence with her own eyes. 837 more times
63
12
u/Auregon44 Krycek Nov 20 '25
Scully : Mulder, not everything is a labyrinth of dark conspiracy, and not everybody is plotting to deceive, inveigle, and obfuscate.
Meanwhile, inside a house of a random suburban in Whatever State :
*Spooky noises*
Second victim of the alien stabber : "Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah"
21
u/Wise_Fox_4291 Agent Fox Mulder Nov 20 '25
I don't know what is crazier, when Mulder throws something wildly insane on the table without flinching or when Scully doesn't immediately start a laughing fit.
7
7
4
u/urbanwanderer2049 Nov 20 '25
The Alien Bounty Hunter minimizes collateral damage. That victim was one of the few exceptions.
4
4
4
3
3
3
3
2
2
2
2
2
u/garth54 Nov 21 '25
The way Mulder always has a related case file for whatever random cause of death...
2
2
2
u/SickMinder Nov 22 '25
Synopsis of this episode: "-I'm finally alone." I said to myself alone in my room. "-No you're not." said knife-guy.
3
2
2
3
173
u/daybreaker Nov 20 '25 edited Nov 20 '25
“But Mulder, the majority of these cases occur in a town known for its knife making. Isn’t it more likely that people who work with knives for a living will suffer more knife-related accidents?”
Then it turns out to be rival knife makers killing each others' families
…by controlling a knife alien.
Who then winks at mulder just after being set free and transporting away, while scully is knocked out from a fight with the previously enslaved knife alien who she never saw because it was super dark.
52
13
u/M4DDIE_882 Nov 20 '25
Need to have Scully use more scientific jargon. If the lines don’t sound like a phd dissertation, you’re doing something wrong. But then they’ll both make it sound perfectly natural, of course
4
3
28
Nov 20 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
20
u/WySLatestWit Nov 20 '25
He's rewarded by being right 98% of the time, if that were the case for me I'd start picking the wildest choice too just to see how my day is gonna go.
25
Nov 20 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/Mz_Biddie Nov 20 '25
Unless it’s X Cops. Then Mulder’s the skeptic.
12
u/WySLatestWit Nov 20 '25 edited Nov 20 '25
Or anything to do with religion whatsoever, then Mulder thinks it's all poppycock. He's also surprisingly selective on which Psychic he's going to believe and which he's going to immediately dismiss as frauds no matter what from case to case
4
u/AmaranthWrath Nov 20 '25
Ironically the case that had the most continous shot cameras around them.
3


4
u/ConversationMajor543 Nov 20 '25
I've never seen this meme before. Thank you for the chuckle.