526
u/Over_the_line_ Jul 10 '22
Iām literally in this situation right now. I have a cancerous spot on my nose and I need to have it removed. I finally got an appointment with a surgeon that takes my insurance, out of state. So Iāve got to travel, itās insanity.
189
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 10 '22
Sorry to hear that and happy you found a surgeon. Remember you can pay your inevitable bill via a payment plan and negotiate the payment amount too. I learned this from my mom who is in healthcare. She jokes that most of the friends in her industry are on a $10/month payment plan for life especially since the plans are often interest free.
54
u/choconamiel Jul 11 '22
It depends on the state you're in and the medical provider you're dealing with. My regular doctor belongs to a medical group that expects payment in full withing 6 months or they send it to collections. If you need to pay for longer than 6 months they refer you to a financing company.
→ More replies (2)13
57
u/Rickrickrickrickrick Jul 10 '22
I have ulcerative colitis and my doctor tells me all the time how he has to argue with insurance companies that deny me and other patients medicine. They ay we don't need it. He says "I'm the doctor. I'm the one who says what they need!" That and they'll also say they'll approve meds and then actually approve a completely different cheaper medicine and say it's the same thing. I tried a biologic and it didn't work. Now that I've stopped I built up an immunity to it. Doc wanted to try Remicade but they approved me for Hunira again instead and said I need to try that again first.
34
u/choconamiel Jul 11 '22
That's really frustrating. My son is dealing with something similar. He's not been approved for a biologic. They wanted him to stay on prednisone even though he was having horrible side effects. Doctor wanted him on a different drug with far fewer side effects. Insurance companies shouldn't get to deny a patient a drug or procedure that his or her doctor says is best.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (1)12
u/mscftw Jul 10 '22
Damn. Your insurance company just sounds plain incompetent.
I was able to get on Medicare thanks to the IBD, and I have a Medicare HMO plan through a private insurance. The bureaucracy sucks and I've spent way too many hours on the phone with them, but to their credit, they have covered nearly everything I've asked for. This includes out of network care, of which there's been quite a lot as you probably understand with these diseases.
The fact that we even need to worry about this crap is absurd, but hopefully you can get some more help that's available to people like us.
→ More replies (4)58
u/DesertSpringtime Jul 10 '22
I love this example, since one of the "anti universal healthcare" arguments I hear is "you can't pick your own doctor". And yes, yes, I can. It's you that cannot.
Sorry about your personal situation there though, that sucks.
25
u/CaffeineSippingMan Jul 11 '22
I say fuck the insurance companies (United Health Care) told me that my doctor prescribed too much cream so the pharmacy didn't give me the amout the doctor prescribed. The first week I ran out in 4 days (I could only get 1 week at a time). I rationed the cream using it only on my arms, not my legs so I had enough. The legs got bloody as my arms healed. I fought the insurance company, my clinic fought the insurance company, the pharmacy said it was a joke and it passed them off. My legs took 2x to treat, so ironically it would have cost the insurance company less if they would have followed the doctor's orders.
I asked what the cost of the cream was, $25 a week, or it would have cost $50 a week if they would have given me the correct amount.
I spent hours and hours on the phone with them arguing. I had a 2 hour drive and called them for fun. I called them instead of working while on the clock.
My favorite was when I needed a glucose test and strips they denied because.... I never needed them before.
Tl;Dr Health insurance for profit needs to end.
→ More replies (2)11
u/TexMexxx Jul 11 '22
Right? Two years ago I had back surgery. My orthopaedic suggested 3 surgeons in three different clinics. I searched the web, called and asked how many of these surgeries they do per year and then decided which clinic and which surgeon should perform the surgery. The health insurance didn't have a say in it. This was in germany.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)17
u/Charming_External_92 Jul 10 '22
You can pick your own doctor. I had universal healthcare for 34 years and always had the option to choose my own doctor. In fact I had the same family doctor since the day I moved here.
Idiots would believe anything you say without verifying if it's true or not9
u/kimoshi Jul 11 '22
I'm in the same situation. Have a mass that 100% needs to be removed surgically, even if it's not cancer. Oncologist ordered a PET scan two weeks ago to plan for biopsy and surgical options, and my insurance still hasn't approved it yet. I legit thought I'd have my surgery scheduled by now until the term "prior authorization" fucked everything over.
Good luck to you and I hope the procedure goes well.
3
u/Jealous-Memory461 Jul 11 '22
Reach out to your stateās DMHC I was in this position and insurance still has way to much control but in my case the DMHC overruled it.
They are extremely valuable and amazing. They referred me to a community lawyer, and I make a decent 6 figures and still qualified (Iām in California, making six figures is still not enough to afford surgery out of pocket.)
My life was changed and forever grateful. There are laws to protect you where insurance faces huge fines if they delay you after a DMHC ruling.
Ultimately in my situation they still tried to fuck with me, but one call from the community lawyer fixed it. My health is so much better and so happy I found this, itās this massive state resource that no one seems to know about
3
u/Nkechinyerembi š Cancel Medical Debt Jul 11 '22
currently in limbo with this situation as well. a couple years ago I had knee surgery, which went over relatively fine, but my insurance only approved ONE WEEK of physical therapy after the surgery. doctor prescribed 3 months. fast forward to now, turns out if I had actually had proper physical therapy, an issue would have been noticed and I would not be having mobility problems now. So I might need a second surgery in both knees. great.
→ More replies (7)2
u/ZurakZigil Jul 10 '22
I just can't believe your employer signed up to offer such crap insurance... like what? Is it a super specialized operation?
→ More replies (1)
146
u/yellowzebrasfly Jul 10 '22
And it won't even be fully paid for. You'll still receive a bill for thousands of dollars, if not tens of thousands.
83
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
Exactly. I had surgery a few years ago and it was very expensive. I had to pay 20% of the cost AND I got a separate bill from my surgeon. I got on a payment plan for 16 months and didnāt take a vacation that year because I decided to use that money to pay off my medical debt.
→ More replies (1)70
Jul 10 '22
And regular people fight tooth and nail to make sure that continues becauseā¦.freedom? I guess?
I hate that thereās so much ignorance towards health care. And fighting over trying to not die or be ruined by bankruptcy
→ More replies (18)13
8
u/Erekai Jul 10 '22
I mean, don't get me wrong, I'm grateful that my recent cholecystectomy only cost me 4k instead of the 12k shown on the bill...
But considering how long I've been paying premiums and getting next to nothing back, that procedure should have been free.
Insurance is a scam and a racket.
→ More replies (2)6
u/HeartofLion3 Jul 10 '22
I had multiple epileptic seizures back in February that resulted in a multi-day hospital stay. Thereās something about getting an $80,000 hospital bill that really puts life into perspective. Like I was not conscious as I signed any of the forms that confirmed I wanted to be hooked up to the machines that were keeping me alive. If I hadnāt been on my parentās insurance I donāt have any idea what I wouldāve done.
2
u/superspeck Jul 10 '22
I went to the hospital for viral pneumonia in the middle of a viral pneumonia pandemic. The insurance company said all tests to figure out what caused the viral pneumonia were ānot medically necessaryā and declined them, but because I had been hauled back into a room and put on high flow oxygen (aka āreceived careā) I had apparently āagreed to treatmentā and had to pay whatever charges I incurred.
(It wasnāt Covid, āhuman metapneumoniovirusā took a healthy 40 year old that had hiked 12 miles in 100 degree heat the week before to āunable to sleep from drainage and 85%spO2ā in three days.)
32
u/nealageous Jul 10 '22
GP Doctor Here. This is exactly why I quit my job in for profit medicine and started a practice using Direct Primary Care. I have patients who literally trade me vegetables in exchange for their healthcare. I make house calls, stitch folks up on weekends, and get to practice the way medicine was designed to work, just a doc and his patients. Beyond me, I contracted with several local hospitals to get x-rays for a fraction of what they typically bill. $45 per X-ray. Opened a pharmacy in my practice with the average price for 30 days supply on almost every medication at $2. Amazing how affordable healthcare is when you cut out the middle men. Oh, and to top it all off, I absolutely love my job! If you are tired of the system, find a Direct Primary Care Doctor and thank me later.
4
10
Jul 10 '22
I'm intrigued by the direct primary care model. My GP recently went that route but we couldn't do it because it's not a replacement for health insurance, it would be in addition to. Still have to have that health insurance if you get cancer or get into a car accident, or need surgery. We couldn't afford $200/mo extra for the family on top of our health insurance premiums, so had to find a new GP.
→ More replies (1)3
u/disabledimmigrant Jul 11 '22
Context: I'm a medical secretary / personal assistant for clinicians; I do lots of patient pathway stuff, record keeping, managing communications, etc.
I'm not sure how staffing works out in Direct Primary Care models, but I would love to work for any clinic/service/doctor providing this type of care to patients.
It would be less bullshit paperwork, and more of the actually important stuff; Follow up letters to patients, actually being helpful and having the time to keep records and notes typed up and tidy, and so on.
Efficiency, quality of patient support, and job satisfaction would go through the roof.
Just chiming in with this to say 1) anyone doing DPC please hire me, I'm good at my job and I genuinely have a CV/resume ready to go instantly, and 2) even non-clinical staff despise for-profit medicine.
Literally nobody wants any of this nonsense to be the way that it is.
35
u/crewman087 Jul 10 '22
I recently had to get all of my remaining molars pulled. The cost of the procedure was $15,000 with insurance, without insurance it was $7700.
21
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 10 '22
Simply ridiculous. My dentist does great work and is a rare very jovial dentist who actually convinced his kids to become dentists as well but Iāve had to refute random invoices from his office months after my bills were paid.
The answer Iāve always received is āinsurance reimbursement changes.ā Dentistry is definitely a racket too.
26
u/ThrowRA_000718 Jul 10 '22
I was paying my monthly out of pocket fee for this medication I was on and finally 3 months in, the pharmacist told me the if I pay 100% out of pocket, the actual cost of the medication is less than my co-pay. I was fucking pissed.
22
u/jessot3103 Jul 10 '22
My husband used GoodRx for his ADHD meds because itās about $100 cheaper than if he were to use insurance. Itās ridiculous.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)7
Jul 10 '22
My medical plan doesnāt let me pay out-of-pocket for medication. If they say I donāt get it, too bad, I have to do without.
This is called, āControlling costsāā¦
→ More replies (2)5
u/Teledildonic Jul 10 '22
The cost of the procedure was $15,000 with insurance, without insurance it was $7700.
My wife had the same experience with a different procedure. What exactly is the point of insurance if it's cheaper not to use it?
→ More replies (1)8
u/-ihatecartmanbrah Jul 10 '22
Dental work seems like the scummiest health related field. I have not been to the dentist for like 15 years so when I got my first cavity I finally made it in to get a filling. The first dentist told me I had like 17 cavities and it would be like $400 a filling and if I wanted the composite fillings that actually blend in with the teeth it was extra. I went to my moms Dentist and he said I had like 3 small cavities and a cracked tooth and he did composite fillings for like $80 each.
3
u/awkwardconfess Jul 10 '22
I was just billed $4000 for a single blood test through insurance (of which I only have to pay $3000) that would have been $450 without insurance. It's all such a racket.
2
u/FanDoggyGate Jul 11 '22
Similar thing happened to me at hospital a year ago. Had tests done on my heart after insurance my bill was $1200. I asked how much insurance covered they said some nonsense like $90. While mad I said so I pay all this money in premiums and they don't even pay enough for 1 month of a premium. The hospital person said actually if you wanted me to process this without insurance the bill would go down to 900. I took that offer called up my insurance and cancelled so fast. Haven't had insurance since and not looking back.
5
u/Freejack2000 Jul 10 '22
A few years ago my wife had intense and constant pain from Endometriosis and Andenomyosis. The Doctor and her agreed very early on that a Hysterectomy was going to be the best way to go. All the paperwork and sign-offs were complete.
It took 4 years of insurance saying "You should try this first, or this surgery procedure first... Are you on birth control? Oh get on that first." Every 6 months we tried to get the Hysterectomy with full support from our doctor (6 months was the earliest you could attempt again). The doc even did a call-in where he spoke with insurance directly... and was met with a "barely qualified nurse who read from a script" -his words
4 YEARS of my wife having to go through repeated invasive procedures for absolutely nothing, just because insurance didn't want to pull the trigger on removing a uterus. I was FURIOUS all the time because of it.
3
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 10 '22
So maddening. You were furious. She was furious AND in pain Iām sure.
8
u/fuckmeuntilicecream Jul 10 '22
OR just don't have insurance like me and a lot of others, and you don't have to worry about surgery because you'll never afford it anyway.
I'm thinking about going to the ER for my athsma as I am really struggling to breathe but is it worth hundreds or thousands of dollars? It's cheaper to be miserable!
6
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 10 '22
But people have died from having asthma episodes..
8
u/fuckmeuntilicecream Jul 10 '22
Yeah it's really scary. My rescue inhaler isn't helping much anymore which is even scarier. I can't breathe. My chest is so heavy and I'm wheezing bad. I just can't afford any more medical bills.
I know I sound like an idiot but I literally have no funds at all. I don't know if my truck would make it to the Dr.
9
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
Iām concerned about you. I know where I live you can apply for free transportation to medical appointments and we also have free clinics. Please look into those instead of suffering.
My mom and brother have asthma so Iāve seen how debilitating it can be. Sorry thatās happening.
5
u/fuckmeuntilicecream Jul 10 '22
I appreciate your concern. I have my boyfriend here watching me and I am absolutely calling my doctor tomorrow. I'll check out some clinics near me too.
Thank you
→ More replies (4)
3
u/RipVanWinklesWife Jul 10 '22
I love living in a "non-free" country. Boyfriend is having necessary dental surgery in tow days and the only thing we have to pay for is taxis to and from the hospital.
1
3
u/ParticularAnxious929 Jul 11 '22
and somehow they got the poorest slobs screaming āSociulizm!ā whenever you suggest a single payer system like the rest of the developed world...
2
u/Character-Stretch697 Jul 11 '22
All while being treated with Medicaid Insurance
→ More replies (1)
936
u/El_Rey_247 Jul 10 '22
Shoutout to Dr. Glaucomflecken for presenting these issues in scathing yet comedic and easily digestible videos. Here's a series of ones on health insurance and prior authorizations:
"United Healthcare celebrates Doctors' Day"
245
u/Nibbler1999 Jul 10 '22
And a shout-out to him for turning my peer to peers into a 30 second instant approval.
Now all I say is "excuse me, what's your name? Ok, I will put your name at the bottom of the note and document that, I the practicing physician believes he needs this, but [insert name] is also apparently practicing medicine on my patient and believes that no treatment is appropriate."
"Oh no no no no, sir. We're going to approve it. We just have to ask a few questions."
"I'm not going to answer any questions. Either I'm practicing medicine on this patient and this is what we're doing. Or you're practicing medicine on this patient and you can schedule an appointment with them."
"Ok sir, your claim is approved. Have a nice day."
Also, I swear I'm getting fewer peer to peers and more instant approvals since employing this method.
This is all influenced by Dr. G. He truly is an absolute G.
58
u/MossSalamander Jul 11 '22
Nice. My doc tried, but the peer to peer "medical director" said while he agreed with my doc, he did not have the power to overturn the denial.
52
u/Nibbler1999 Jul 11 '22
I'm a surgical specialty, so pretty much everything I order is what would be considered routine standard of care. With the way I document, nothing should ever require a peer to peer unless they simply did not read that I documented exactly what I know requires them to cover what I've ordered.
It is insane the specific terminology that I need to use in order to get things approved ( or even get paid ) by a lot of insurance companies.
→ More replies (6)10
u/chickenstalker Jul 11 '22
Report him to the Medical Board of your country. In my 3rd world country, he would lose his license and fined.
→ More replies (1)24
u/hiyer2 Jul 11 '22
Dude what?! I have never ONCE been successful at a peer to peer. First off, theyāre never a fucking peer. Iām always talking to some other random specialty. And second, no matter how much I threaten to put them in the medical record they always call my bluff and push through with their garbage denial.
Any doctor who works for the insurance company on peer to peers is a traitor to our profession imo. Fuck all of them.
16
u/Nibbler1999 Jul 11 '22
I almost never get them, fortunately. But when I do they are unfathomably stupid. They haven't called my bluff yet. But ultimately, it's not a bluff. I'll document extensively the ways the insurance refusal is harming the patient, potential consequences and post operative complications associated. If there's a lawsuit the insurance company will be part of it. But again, for my stuff it's just having the right verbage in the note and they approve it. I also have a few good assistants who clean up a lot of my messes :)
→ More replies (2)11
145
u/MrsMurphysChowder Jul 10 '22
It's NOT funny because it's true!
81
→ More replies (13)28
Jul 10 '22
The funniest thing is Americans have the power to change this at the ballot box but refuse to. They would rather get the dry weenie on the regular than be labeled socialist. That's fucking hilarious
47
u/Ryozu Jul 10 '22
Do we though? Do we really? Bernie Sanders is the only one I've heard of that even remotely suggested doing something, and last I checked he never made it onto the ballot for... reasons.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (6)31
Jul 10 '22
Nonsense! There is NOBODY who you can vote for, that will make any difference in this whatsoever. It would take nothing short of a very extended complete lock-down peaceful protest for as long as it took or, a revolution
→ More replies (3)23
4
→ More replies (11)3
u/ResponsibilityDue448 Jul 11 '22
This wonāt be a popular post but I process Prior Auths as part of my job.
Doctors donāt know fuck all about prior authorizations. So many get denied because the MDO is too fucking lazy to fax over chart documentation.
We have a whole department that basically just reaches out to doctors offices to obtain needed information before we have to deny a claim and 9/10 the need more information outreach times out and claim gets denied.
Literally some forms have the specific questions needed for approval in yes/no format and they just donāt answer them.
All day long the PA requests pile in, they donāt have drug names on there, quantity or day supplies, the diagnosis, duration of therapy etc etc.
If they would take literally 5 minutes to do the prior auths correctly the turn overs for denials would be significantly lower.
1.4k
u/shaodyn āļø Tax The Billionaires Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
Imagine if that worked with anything else. Like pizza. I have a company where, if you pay me a monthly fee, you can get all the pizza you want! But I get to choose where you can go for the pizzas, who can make them, who can give them to you, what toppings you can have, and how often you can buy pizza. And I don't pay one cent unless you buy at least $200 worth of pizza. Which isn't even enough for one small plain cheese pizza.
Sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? Why is it considered acceptable when it's healthcare (which you absolutely have to have) instead of pizza?
629
Jul 10 '22
Dude worse than that.
Pay us $30 a month, once you've purchased $300 in pizza for the year, you qualify for a 30% discount on pizza purchases for the rest of the year. You don't get to choose what's on your pizza. You simply ask for a pizza and we send you one.
Of course you are always free to buy pizza off-plan and choose your own toppings, but it will cost $800. And no, you can't just get a plan. Your employer, if they choose to, may deem that you are worthy of pizza. If, and only if, your employer chooses a pizza plan for you, you can order pizza for less than $800.
353
u/Taikwin Jul 10 '22
Also, if you don't buy pizzas you will just fuckin die
39
u/unosdias Jul 10 '22
One day you just happen to be struck with the munchies and buy a an XL large pizza, and as a result you lose your home and need to file for bankruptcy.
→ More replies (2)101
u/noobvin Jul 10 '22
I know weāre talking metaphors, but I kind of feel like this sometimes. With Tacos too.
→ More replies (4)42
u/OstensiblyAwesome Jul 10 '22
And then six unelected Supreme Court justices just decided that you canāt get a pizza anymore because itās against their religion. Freedom.
→ More replies (14)→ More replies (1)18
u/RedOwl101010 Jul 10 '22
That's the kicker right there. If another country set up a system where I can get off this crazy train called America, I would be out of here with my family so fast.
→ More replies (20)→ More replies (45)23
u/Bakoro Jul 10 '22
You can buy health insurance without an employer, it will just cost you $450 a month, on top of not covering anything until you hit the deductible.
→ More replies (1)14
Jul 10 '22
I put my information into the obamacare portal and they asked me to pay 10% of my income each month before I even looked any further to see what I was actually getting for that. Affordable my prostate.
→ More replies (3)21
u/fillmorecounty Jul 10 '22
Because you need healthcare so you don't die so they're able to exploit people who (naturally) do not want to die. I can go without pizza but I have no choice but to shell out thousands for my medications every year.
8
5
u/MadeByTango Jul 10 '22
California is showing us the model- we just build our own services like insulin creation
Iām all for starting up government run production facilities for peopleās basic needs, from food to medicine.
53
u/ThrowRA_000718 Jul 10 '22
I absolutely have to have pizza though. Where do I sign up for this?
36
7
8
Jul 10 '22
This wouldnāt be absolutely horrible if it was just another option. Because maybe it works better for someone.
But when itās the only option it fucking sucks.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Lietenantdan Jul 10 '22
And if the guy making the pizza dough is out of network, youāll be charged thousands for the dough.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Psistriker94 Jul 10 '22
Because you don't know how much the pizza costs because the pizza place doesn't display their prices and the guy making the pizza doesn't know the price. The guy is willing to make any kind of pizza I want but me spending $200 on pizza doesn't matter because I don't know how much a pizza costs. The price of pizza is negotiated by two random people that are not the two people in the exchange of pizza.
I get the premise of the OP example but bilateral consent between the surgeon and patient is not the only factor. The surgeon has no idea of the potential changes in surgery, pre/post-op needs, additional expertise, or pricing of disposables. They'll do the surgery and you'll agree to it, sure. We need more transparency for medical expenses instead of two people throwing codes and prices at each other through the phone.
→ More replies (3)6
u/HCSOThrowaway š¤ Join A Union Jul 10 '22
Sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? Why is it considered acceptable when it's healthcare (which you absolutely have to have) instead of pizza?
Because
lobbyingpolitical bribery. There's no such thing as the Pizza Lobby (yet).→ More replies (2)4
u/shaodyn āļø Tax The Billionaires Jul 10 '22
Yeah, I also refer to it as political bribery. It doesn't stop being bribery just because it happens to a politician. Which is weird in itself. If I offer a cop $100 not to give me a speeding ticket, that's bribery and I go to jail. If I offer a politician $10,000 to vote against a bill I don't like, somehow that's perfectly acceptable and he thanks me for my contribution.
4
u/mindharbinger Jul 10 '22
Great comparison, you made me think of it this way......with the pizza they determine how hungry you are before ordering pizza / health insurance they determine how much pain you're in & how your quality of life is affected before they approve said surgery. Either scenario an "outsider" determines what's best for "your" body and when. Crazy right?
4
u/Born_Ruff Jul 10 '22
You forgot to add in the part where the real reason that you have pizza insurance is because you might randomly need 500k worth of pizza one day with no warning and you want to be covered for that.
If the pizza insurance company just pays for whatever pizza you ask for whenever you want, the pizza insurance will cost an insane amount of money. So they have all these convoluted rules to try to ensure that they only pay for pizza that is necessary.
→ More replies (1)2
2
u/Dontblink666 Jul 10 '22
Also the 200 worth of pizza is so marked up it doesn't even cover a pepperoni
2
Jul 10 '22
Because if you had a business like that for pizza then you would have no customers because its obviously such a terrible deal.
But with helthcare you have no option so you take the shitty deal.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (17)2
372
Jul 10 '22
We had the death panels all along, they were the insurance companies. š
107
u/Harold_Grundelson Jul 10 '22
Insurance companies are legalized, racketeering, MLM monopolies.
→ More replies (4)58
u/Dr-P-Ossoff Jul 10 '22
My favourite ex girlfriend had her meds suddenly stopped after years of decent maintenance and she died not long after.
13
8
u/Wikki_ Jul 10 '22
I'm Canadian and I remember them saying we had death panels (not true btw) and I was like "isn't that what the insurance companies are in the states". Insane what you guys have to go through for health care
3
→ More replies (4)2
u/GoDM1N Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 12 '22
We had the death panels all along, they were the insurance companies. š
TRU
My grandmother likes to bring that up every time we talk about universal healthcare and my counter point is always basically this. It's a problem that exist in both systems inherently until we discover how to clone organs and shit. Theres simply always going to be a supply problem in this regard
434
u/JFreedom14 Jul 10 '22
America the land of Gun Care and Health Control.
22
Jul 10 '22
Oof. Youāll have nothing but a sig and a Bible and youāll be happy
→ More replies (5)7
u/Naptownfellow Jul 10 '22
Youāre not kidding. My wife needs hip surgery. Weāve been to three different doctors just to make sure weāre getting the right information since sheās only in her early 50s and In good shape/ health. Weāve gotten everything approved but now the insurance company is not approving this particular surgery center, and the PT approval could be an issue after the surgery. Also, we found out that theyāll only approve one joint replacement every three years. FYI, this is a gold plan through the affordable care act and I pay over $2500 a month for it.
→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (39)2
63
u/Donutannoyme Jul 10 '22
Medical biller here. Can confirm and I fucking hate it. Also if you have ANTHEM/Blue Cross Blue Shield through your work, I urge you to write to your HR and ask them to change payers and plans. Anthem is horrible.
14
u/SomeDumbPenguin Jul 10 '22
I have UHC with a $10k deductible, which they cover nothing before, but everything after.
Have been having severe, debilitating, pain in one of my legs. X-rays are showing concern in the knee & hip on that leg. Been fighting with UHC to allow me to get an MRI. I've been walking with a cane for at least 5 months now, should have used a walker at times when the pain was worse.
Oh, and a couple weeks ago, everyone on the company insurance got a letter saying they are increasing our policy costs by 20.5% at the next policy renewal point beginning in November. I'm sure everyone knows I'm the cause.
Don't have much for personal time off left, so I have to go to work
4
u/mydogisthedawg Jul 10 '22
Itās only going to get worse because all insurers follow what CMS (centers for Medicare and Medicaid services) does and they just announced ANOTHER 4.4% physician fee reimbursement cut (which includes other healthcare professions/services)
10
u/neepster44 Jul 10 '22
Why? Iāve had them a few years and havenāt had much problem.
43
u/Donutannoyme Jul 10 '22
Imagine if you will you saw 1000 patients who have anthem. 750 of them had claims deny even though anthems website says youre in network. The provider has a physical copy of the contract in his HAND. Now the patients are PISSED because anthem put the bills out to patient responsibility. You call anthem. You speak with 10 reps so the bills that didnāt go the patients already get reprocessed. Each rep takes patient names, dates of birth, ID numbers, socials. All the reps tell you the call is handled by another department youāre transferred and listen to the same shitty music for 2 hours. At the end of the call you were on hold for 5 hours talking to āSteveā who makes the rupee equivalent of $4,500 USD. He doesnāt know whatās wrong with the bills. Heās reading from a script. All they can tell you is to allow 30 days for review. You call 30 days later. They didnāt reprocess the claims. They refused, actually. So not only have you given that patients info to 10 different reps who didnāt need it, youāre told upon calling back to bill the patient because the claim āprocessed correctly.ā You canāt hold the bills, and itās not the patients fault. You have no choice but to call the patient and let them know youāre sending them a copy of anthemās website reflecting in network and that they need to file a complaint with the insurance and then the state insurance commission for false advertising to have them reprocess the claim. Itās ridiculous and itās harmful to the patients because the last thing they should have to do is stress over a bill that doesnāt belong to them. I experienced this with two hospitals in two different states.
11
u/neepster44 Jul 10 '22
Dude I 100% agree that if this is your experience with them then they suck. But I only have 2 choices at my employer and the other one sucks even worse for me so⦠what can you do?
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)15
u/thelumpybunny Jul 10 '22
They just keep denying claims for no reason. Of course I fight them and they will pay it but it's happened multiple times
→ More replies (1)18
Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
This is actually more a product of how much your employer is willing to pay for your medical coverage. I worked for a company that I retired from a few years ago and for the last dozen or 15 years I was there we had Anthem Blue Cross. A few years before I retired I had surgery and the total cost for the surgery and related care was over $100,000 I paid $1,100 why? because that was the out of pocket maximum for the plan. A few years before that I had a different kind of surgery and the total cost was about $85,000 I paid something like $890 because again that was my out-of-pocket maximum for the year. I'm not an expert on how Insurance works but I'm pretty sure the deal is your employer went to Anthem and said we have X number of employees and we want to spend x amount a year on insurance what can you give us? If you could convince them to change insurance companies tomorrow and they went to another Insurance Company and gave them the same numbers the insurance plan you get from that other company would pretty much be the same as what you have now from anthem. It's not about the insurance company it's about what your employer is willing to pay. I worked for a big company with a very strong union so we had excellent benefits. People want to talk shit about unions but that's because a lot of people don't know what they're talking about. I'm retired now and I still have the same coverage that I had when I was working and I pay $40 a month.
5
u/alien13ufo Jul 10 '22
True, I have blue cross from my union (teamsters) and it's pretty damn generous for what I pay (40ish a month in union dues).
8
u/-ihatecartmanbrah Jul 10 '22
BCBS is a fucking scam through and through. When I was paying $700 a month premiums with a high out of pocket and deductible they wouldnāt cover almost anything. Pretty much everything was denied and it ended up being cheaper dropping them and paying cash for everything, because thatās what I was doing anyway.
5
5
u/MrMichaelJames Jul 10 '22
We had anthem and they were really easy to work with. We have Cigna now and they are absolutely horrible.
→ More replies (2)2
u/mixingmemory Jul 10 '22
We had Anthem at work, then they switched to Aetna, which seemed even worse. Which for-profit health insurance corporations aren't horrible?
21
u/Mellowjoat Jul 10 '22
My wife had multiple doctors (some in specific fields) finally say yes, she needs "x" medicine. To get there she had to go through years of trying different meds and a surgery. Insurance STILL said "Nah we good. She's already cost us too much and this med is a high cost so no". Even the medicine maker gave her a year for free because the doctors say "Yes, she needs this".
It's still an ongoing issue...
18
u/ThePurpleComyn Jul 10 '22
And that third party's only motivation is their own profit.
Republicans talk about "death panels" with a straight face while we live in a system where accountants decide who lives and who dies.
168
Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 11 '22
I love my Patriot Plus insurance. It only recommends doctors who look and think like me. When I wanted Ivermectin instead of a Covid vaccine, Patriot plus said send it. It came in a neat box with the American Flag on top.
When the China virus finally put me in the hospital. Patriot plus made sure the hospital only served me Bacon cooked on a Rifle Silencer. That peppered Bacon went down good with all the sweet tea they gave me to drink.
I made it out of the Hospital and Patriot Plus insurance guaranteed an oxygen tank and a wooden stick for a cane to get back in my house. I canāt think too straight anymore, but Patriot Plus keeps the Ivermectin coming and promises to sue China for me.
God bless this country.
11
Jul 10 '22
PATRIOT Mobile
Mobilizing Freedom!
Americaās Only CHRISTIAN CONSERVATIVE Wireless Provider
Our Mission is to Defend our GOD-GIVEN Constitutional Rights and Freedoms
Getting Started is Easy
Patriot Freedom plan | Patriot Liberty plan
Multi-line discounts applied at checkout
→ More replies (2)46
u/JFreedom14 Jul 10 '22
You had me in the first half, not gonna lie!
22
u/toebandit Jul 10 '22
Same. I started reading and thinking āhowās this have so many upvotes? Ohhh..ā
→ More replies (1)2
30
u/SomeKindofTreeWizard Jul 10 '22
Say it with me now:
Private insurance is a mafia.
11
u/ScorchedChord Jul 10 '22
It really really is. Paid off politicians and media, back-room deals for government contract$, glitzy real housewives doing ācharity galasā to provide cover for the corruption, and more.
14
Jul 10 '22
Freedom is spending almost $200 a month for insurance that doesn't even cover a single penny, but you don't know it doesn't cover a single penny until 3 months later when you finally get a bill for $375.
5
u/SoloisticDrew Jul 10 '22
I wish it were only $200 for me.
4
Jul 10 '22
Ouch I'm sorry, it's brutal that's for sure. We all out here workin 40+ hours a week still living paycheck to paycheck. Unfortunately I don't think it's gunna get better anytime soon.
22
u/Bonn_Evasion Jul 10 '22
What a shithole country
2
u/AdSea9329 Jul 11 '22
the problem is the dictionaries. the definition of freedom is wrong. let's burn them /s
10
Jul 10 '22
As someone whoās about to lose his job because management is fed up with my lower back problems when their shitty insurance is running me around for 2 months not wanting to help FUCK AMERICA
7
7
u/GrendalsFather Jul 10 '22
My wife has MS. She has an infusion every 6 months. Somehow every six months, despite her calling and verifying everything has been approved, her infusion is postponed because the insurance wants a prior authorization for the meds AND the infusion. Hereās the kicker, they want it from her primary doctor. Her primary doesnāt prescribe the meds, her neurologist does. The neurology she has seen longer than her primary.
This last go round this week, the infusion center got the info from the insurance company to get a prior authorization. They got one from the neurologist. Insurance said nope need it from primary. They called primary, primary called insurance, insurance says they donāt need a prior authorization⦠neurologist calls insurance, insurance says prior authorization must come from her primary⦠what the actual fuck?
Sorry for formatting, Iām on my phone.
4
u/leggymeeggy Jul 10 '22
i feel for your wife. i do infusions for a neurological disease and itās the same shit. i changed insurance in march and have missed 4 months of infusions due to preauthorization issues, despite spending half my life making phone calls. i hope you both hang in there!
→ More replies (1)
13
u/adnelik Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
I had to pay a $3200 facility fee on the spot at a private practice before having wrist surgery⦠basically āpay or go homeā
Edit: that was at a place āin-networkā with my insurance
2
Jul 10 '22
I lost 20 pounds due to an infection and still needed to pay 4k to get it treated.
4
u/Competitive-Isopod74 Jul 11 '22
My fiance had to fork over $3,000 before they would fix his broken neck, I repeat, a broken neck. Took over a month to get the financing.
→ More replies (1)
12
u/BisquickNinja š§āš¬ Medical and Scientific Expert Jul 10 '22
So much freedom ... freedom to die from...er... I mean for.
5
Jul 10 '22
Hang on - gotta obtain your Perceived Societal Value score from your employerā¦
They say youāre paid too much and can be replaced by a dozen off-shore contractors at a significant cost savings? Whoops! No soup for you! The VP of HR, on the other hand, gets a 10% bonus for reducing health care expenditures. So WIN-WIN!
5
u/MrsMurphysChowder Jul 10 '22
Fn insurance company bean counters. My doc writes a scrip for 12 pills, and the bean counters allow 9. Need more? Suffer.
5
u/bad13wolf Jul 10 '22
If I could, I'd make a time machine just to go back and kick the father of the creator of insurance right in the plumbs.
5
u/jemappellepatty Jul 10 '22
currently at home on antibiotics sitting out a lap chole because my insurance decided I didn't need it <3 at least the pain is nothing compared to the kidney stones that also made an appearance at the exact same time
5
u/Z0mbiejay Jul 10 '22
A few years back I dislocated my shoulder at work. Went to the orthopedic specialist and determined I tore my labrum and that the best course of action given my physically demanding job was surgery to secure my arm in the socket. My first appoint my doctor told me surgery would be the best course of action. The workers comp insurance came back with "nah, let's just try some physical therapy instead"
My doctor's hands were tied. Flat out told me he'll tell them the same thing in 6 weeks so I could get my surgery. Ended up going the way he said. It's bullshit that companies can just decide what's best over the doctor's decisions
5
u/Desperate-Holiday-49 Jul 10 '22
I remember working in the Product department of an insurance company and overhearing how a few VPās were talking over someoneās burn treatment expense and how it was nearly 8 million dollars.
They said they shouldnāt have covered it but the hospital shouldnāt be allowed to charge that much. Frankly, the whole situation needs drastic regulatory action. Hospitals are gouging insurance companies and insurance companies are fighting treatments. The actual patient and doctors and nurses are all caught in the drama.
A doctor takes the Hippocratic oath but a hospital administration staff doesnāt. Neither does the insurance companies. Pharmaceutical companies also need regulation.
5
u/WinsomeWombat Jul 10 '22
I work in healthcare for a surgery clinic. Based on the misplaced anger I face daily, a lot of people DO NOT understand that this is the absolute truth in EVERY medical situation.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/uptwolait Jul 10 '22
Freedom...
... freedom to say "fuck all of you who want to make health care affordable, easily accessible, and with all decisions being made solely between you and your doctor."
Meanwhile, I have zero freedom to escape this wretched system.
4
4
u/spongebue Jul 10 '22
My wife had a baby a couple weeks ago. They wanted to discharge her last Saturday (almost a week later) but her blood pressure was a little high. Doctors gave her a prescription, insurance company denied the preauth. They would've cost a bit over $200, but we were able to get all meds for about $40 through GoodRx. Morals of the story:
Insurance would rather pay for an inpatient hospital stay through a holiday weekend than extra drugs
Drug pricing has so many variables it basically has no meaning
Because of their fuckery, insurance didn't have to pay for the hospital stay OR the drugs
That reminds me, I need to contact my congressman about that...
4
u/SirGingeVIII Jul 10 '22
It never fails to surprise me just how backwards the united states are, I just don't understand how they have this freedom mentality and a massive chip on the shoulder
4
u/s_0_s_z Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 11 '22
It doesn't happen often, but every time we've had a serious debate about healthcare in this country, the very same people who claim to understand the kind of shit system we have and claim to be all gungho about change end up backing down and let corporate-led right wing groups kills progress.
Our current awful system is not the healthcare system we want, but having lived through the rebates and watched support for universal coverage just fall apart, I see that it is the healthcare system we deserve.
4
u/kbhuntsman Jul 11 '22
My favorite is when they approve it and then the day before a surgery they call and rescind the pre-approval. You then have to fight it, and will almost always get the approval again. But this way they get to 1-hold on to the $ a little longer and 2- some people wonāt appeal/fight it for multiple reasons and the insurance never has to let go of that money. It happens a lot! Also - how wonderful that a physician that has gone to school, residency, often a fellowship and continuing education every year in that specific specialty has to explain to someone, often not a physician, or if they are they are NOT a surgeon, why they decided that this patient needs this surgery to be performed.
6
u/ThrowRA_000718 Jul 10 '22
Incorrect. It can still be paid for if you are rich or are middle class and willing to liquidate all of your assets and savings and be poor. If youāre poor then you just get to die. āMurica!!
3
u/Indigo-Knights Jul 10 '22
I needed a scan after being in the hospital. Doctor said yes letās do it today and I said yes letās do it. Oops sorry I have to wait for my new jobs insurance to kick in so better out if off for 1-2 weeks while they mess with paperwork.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Plaincircle Jul 10 '22
This was very weird for me when I first find out too. You can fairly say that insurance companies controls almost everything here.
3
u/turn_ncough Jul 10 '22
Just imagine you spent the last 30-40 years working hard. You got a decent pension, SS, and retirement savings. You get sick as most older people do. Now all your life's work is going towards medical debt instead of enjoying your retirement. Then life insurance MAY pay out if you died all because you couldn't afford that life saving surgery. Welcome to America
3
u/Seagullmaster Jul 10 '22
Another fun thing. I am a licensed health care professional, but need to be authorized by specific insurances before I can bill them.
3
Jul 10 '22
āPublic healthcare doesnāt workā, says country living next door to country where it works fine.
What really doesnāt work are politicians, well, they donāt work for you!
They work for rich corporations though and are paid heavily to lie to you and convince you to vote against your own best interests.
3
u/insightful_dreams Jul 10 '22
dont forget to mention that the third, for-profit party that could deny treatments for people are not medical professionals whatsoever.
3
Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
Stop that isnt even the half if the medical coder doesn't get it pre-approved properly and then codes it wrong so it gets denied. You're alone and have to get your doctor or hospital to appeal it, because otherwise if you put in the appeal they will just give it back to the same person. If your doctor or hospital appeal it will got to a medical professional typically a doctor.
3
Jul 10 '22
God fuck this system so hard. My wife just lost her kidney because of an inadequate, for profit healthcare system.
3
u/hotelmotelshit Jul 10 '22
The average US citizen has no idea what freedom is, they think it's gun violence and somewhat low taxes
3
u/-W4rwick- Jul 10 '22
You pay 20-40% of your income to an insurance company, they have to agree (terms & conditions blah blah), you get the surgery, you still have to argue with both the hospital billing department + your insurance... them some or most gets covered, you're STILL required to pay out of pocket for something, and then your insurance goes up because [redacted] reasons.
I hate it here, & I have VA.
3
3
Jul 10 '22
Itās ridiculous, I had surgery for the first time this year. It was majorly life changing and required if I wanted to live longer than 30. Not only were pre-op appointments delayed because of no response from insurance, the grand total was over $287k. God bless America amirite? š¦ š¦ šŗšø
3
u/DMMMOM Jul 10 '22
Americans talk about freedom, I doubt they know what it actually means outside gun ownership.
3
u/jdmDEEZ Jul 10 '22
Only the dumbest in the country actually buy the āfreedomā ruse. Quite effective on those undereducated minds though.
3
u/zxcoblex Jul 10 '22
But remember kids: Universal Healthcare will have ādeath panelsā which totally donāt exist right now anyway.
3
u/MrMurse123 Jul 10 '22
Definitely, yes. But the model we have in the US propagates this. Saline bag? 300$. Dantrolene? 5000$+? And why? For profit.
It doesn't need to be this way. These are arbitrary prices primarily due to insurance companies lobbying.
3
u/Brimstone-n-Treacle Jul 10 '22
It's also called "criminal negligence." Too bad nobody will be held accountable.
3
3
u/TheFemale72 Jul 11 '22
As a medical assistant, I can confirm. For example, my doctor (that I work for) can write the same prescription for 5 different patients and get 5 different outcomes. Some PBMās will approve and others wonāt. Like one patient may only have to pay $5, and another $500-It makes no sense.
3
u/Felstorm1231 Jul 11 '22
Copying a comment of mine from another sub:
āThe insurance industry is such a scam across the board.
Donāt get me wrong: I absolutely understand that accidents and emergencies happen. That should absolutely be planned and accounted for in our society. But for the mechanical apparatus we have in place to be so nonsensically complicated as to impede its own proper functioning is just ridiculous. Thereās no reason why the insurance industry should be as hopelessly bloated and arcane as it is.
And at an even more fundamental level, how can we have whole industries that exist in their current forms that are too expensive for the average person to pay for them out of pocket? How does that make any kind of sense?
If your good or service is so expensive that no one can afford it, maybe the focus should be on reducing the price of that good or service, rather than creating a new, entirely artificial industry to justify that price and justify the existence of that unnecessary industry which now has veto authority over the actual dissemination of the daughter after service because theyāre the only ones with access to the necessary capital?
And donāt even get me started on all that āin network versus out of networkā bullshit.
Of all the various strains of capitalism, I have the least patients for finance capital. And of all the mutations of finance capitalism, insurance is one of the ones that confounds me the most.
The profit motive is going to be the death of our species if we continue to cling to it in the face of climate catastrophe. Thereās no reason to be burdened with that knowledge and still allow for the profit motive to kill each of us individually because we want to continue looking at healthcare as a profit-making enterprise. Thatās cruelty for the sake of cruelty.
Fuck that; access to healthcare should be a fundamental human right. The only people with any material reason to disagree with that statement are craven, corpse loving ghouls who genuinely want to sacrifice human lives on the altar of the Almighty Dollar.
We all deserve so much better than that; the world deserves so much better than us.ā
5
5
u/Ansanm Jul 10 '22
Just paid almost $700 in deductible fees so that my optometrist can use his fancy machines to check my eyes for glaucoma. Also, Aetna declined to approve scans for my wife, who was diagnosed with cervical cancer 5 years ago. Insurance Is all about making money, thatās all.
7
u/feignapathy Jul 10 '22
Well, technically, you and your doctor can agree you need a surgery, but you also need to hope authoritative right wing politicians in your specific state aren't in control, or else you can't have the surgery. Even if it's life saving.
→ More replies (4)
4
4
u/MrsEmilyN Jul 10 '22
Sometimes, the third party wants your doctor to do a peer to peer review. So basically, your doctor, a breast surgeon let's say, has to plead their case on why you need a mastectomy, to another doctor, that is a podiatrist, who gets to decide if the surgery is warranted... regardless the fact you have stage 4 breast cancer.
Fun times, amirite?
2
u/Touvejs Jul 10 '22
But what's the alternative? We have the CORRUPT goVeRNmEnT run the healthcare system?!? If we did that, we would need more guns to make our militia stronger so we can force them to run it correctly.
/s
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/MyCollector Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
It gets a lot worse than that too.
My wife is a licensed mental health counselor. 90% of her clients see her using their Aetna, Cigna, or United healthcare- private insurers, typically provided by her clientās employer. Her private pay rate is about $60-120/hour sliding scale⦠which is cheap for therapy but a lot of money in general, so itās obvious why most people only see therapists on insurance.
Aetna pays her like $78 per session, Cigna is like $109, United is around $90⦠needless to say, for the same work, Cigna pays her 40% more than Aetna š³
So in essence, 3 insurance companies that she doesnāt work for determine near 90% of her annual compensation šÆ.
The equivalent would be me, a systems engineer for a Fortune 500 company⦠being paid 45% by Microsoft and 45% by Apple with perhaps Dell paying 10%. Like⦠wtf!
So insanely broken. Your insurer might pay your physician more or less than John Doeās insurer. The next time a doctor says āsorry weāre not accepting new patients!ā⦠it might be because youāre on Aetna who is only paying him $90, when someone with United might give him $125 and heād accept the United patient first. Yep. Insane.
→ More replies (2)
2
Jul 10 '22
Happened with my petite sister and her 1st baby. Doc said Megamind aināt coming out naturally but the insurance was like, how about we wait weeks⦠you never know?
2
u/Mahatma_Panda Jul 10 '22
Even worse is Behavioral Health. Eating Disorders, severe depression, and substance abuse can take months of treatment, both inpatient and outpatient, but an insurance company will only cover a small number of days and a patient will get discharged out of treatment if they can't cover what insurance won't pay for.
2
2
u/OfficialGarwood Jul 10 '22
In America guns have more rights than women, and healthcare is pay-walled.
"land of the free" I think not.
2
2
2
2
u/itschopsaw Jul 11 '22
You want free health care!? That's communism and a free loading society! Pull yourselves up by the boot straps and let you parents and Medicare pay for it like back in the good old days!
People are so brain washed by rich Republicans they don't even realize they can't even have the good things in life because it's "un-American"
Fellow American redditors...we are fucked with a capital Freedom
2
u/itsmepingu Jul 11 '22
In Canada if you need the surgery, you get it. You might have to wait a while but youāll get it if you need it and itāll cost next to nothing or nothing if youāre insured
2
u/maximian Jul 11 '22
I met this guy at a campaign event once. He spend the whole conversation spouting platitudes and ignoring any questions about actual day-to-day governance or realistic priorities. He also ignored my wife completely and only focused on me (a man).
Heās right about this but Iād never vote for him.
2
u/mehxpat Jul 11 '22
Shit.
When I moved to the US I quickly found out about this bullshit.
I will never understand a country where a bunch of morons with no proper understanding of their own language, let alone laws and history, can march into a government building bearing firearms in the name of their own take on "civic duty", but won't do shit when laws and regulations constantly favor corporations over "we the people".
5
u/Ar3peo Jul 10 '22
oh it can be paid for.... BY YOU! (at whatever ridiculous rate the hospital/ doctor charge
ā¢
u/GrandpaChainz āļø Prison For Union Busters Jul 10 '22
Join r/WorkReform if you agree that universal healthcare is needed to end the employer-sponsored healthcare trap.