Been using Shoes For Crews as my daily drivers since high school in 2003 (can't remember the name of the first shoes but switched to Voyager in 2004 then Rowan around 2015-16). Got hired into Albertsons in 2019, and I went from my boots lasting 3ish years down to a little over a year because I wear holes through the soles in the ball of the foot due to clocking over 3000 miles across asbestos flooring, concrete and asphalt for 40hrs/week (minimum 60 miles per week). And because I was raised to be frugal when at all possible, I would buy my boots during their 30% off Bliack Friday sale then put them away until I needed to replace my current pair.
Queue this year: switched to my backup pair last August after vacation and everything seemed fine except for some pain in the balls of my feet not going away after the break-in period. Was tolerable so didn't bother thinking too hard about it. Issue came up though around Halloween when I found my right boot was getting water inside despite having just conditioned+oiled them a few days before. Discovered that SfC went bankrupt in 2024 & the new owners have cut corners in multiple product lines to reduce production cost while raising prices - for both the Voyager & Rowan lines, that meant axing the shank that used to run the arch. This budget cut paired with the crappy redesign of the sole has led to a crack developing between the ball of the sole & the perimeter of the ball that has progressed to a full-blown hole allowing water & debris into the boot - after less than 3 months of use. I caled in but the Customer Service Rep said that my only option was to buy new boots because I was past the warranty date.
I'm willing to give them one last chance because they still have a single line of boots that meets my needs (Providence), but I need to have a backup in case this last chance is also a shit sandwich. My needs are:
* Steel toe - personal safety, both because of how frequently I deal with pallets weighing up to an actual ton & bumping my feet against things like uboats/flatbeds/carts
* Steel shank - not sure how effective fiberglass shanks are as anti-puncture protection; arch support plus protection from shit that can jab through a basic rubber sole if I'm not careful
* Ankle support - comes up over the ankle instead of stopping below like regular shoes, lots of heavy lifting plus needing to establish/maintain solid foot placement
* Slip-resist - because I can find myself dealing with spills, puddles and any other instance of wet floors at the drop of a hat, company policy explicitly states that every single store-level employee must have slio-resistant footwear so long as they are on the clock
* Sturdy/durable soles - as I mentioned, I walk over 3000 miles per year for my job across multiple unforgiving surfaces, so the sole needs to be able to handle that; if the boots are designed so that a repair shop could replace the soles with minimal difficulty, that'd be a plus & make me inclined to spending a bit more
I also prefer my boots to be black both for a more professional look and because I wear a black kilt+long compression socks for work. The insole isn't a big deal because I'm going to be removing it anyway for the custom-made orthodic inserts my podiatrist gets me annually.
Any help in this struggle is appreciated.