I've played almost every borderlands game as the resident melee character. The exceptions being TPS and 3 because i like jack more in TPS and Amara is barely able to be called a melee character imo. But in BL2 and 1? Brick and Krieg all the way.
And in my own experience melee in this game, for all they time and work they say theu put into it, fucking sucks. It is so astronomically bad. On ny first character I'm a blightknight (CB/BC) and I'm using plaguestorm, and it shreds bro. Its crazy. But anytime i try to concoct a melee build, its utterly useless. The damage never even comes close to catching up with my main build. So i made a new character, I'm grinding him up to 40 and tryna get gear on par with the gear i got on my main character. And so far, the melee is still not as strong as my main character was before he hit 40. This character is a frostwilder (SW/BZ) and the current melee damage i can do with something like dredwind is so ass compared to the second build i tried out with frostwilder, which is using blizzard.
So this begs the question, why is melee so utterly garbage in this game? Was it really that hard to make it viable? This is also made worse by the fact that there are SOOOOO many bosses that just can't be hit by melee attacks. Hell even in BL2 against flying enemies, Krieg could throw his axe at them. There's also the subject of bosses and enemies with KNOCKNBACK that they abuse all the fucking time, which comepletely nullifies the use of melee as well. Well what about the CB? That has melee abilities, well first off, cleansing flames is just....I've never once seen cleansing flames be used on any CB ever, I'll just say that. And storm dragons judgement? I've seen some pretty good builds with that, i mean theres a reason every CB ever uses it. But that brings me on to my next point:
I shouldn't have to min max, grind all the OP gear, farm enchantments, etc etc. Just to have my build be viable. Sure I've seen some pretty good damage dreadwind builds, but they had to farm for probably hours to get all that to make thay build. And from my knowledge most people, at least not me, want to soend 30 hours farming for loot when you could spend like 4 farming a spellshot build, or literally any other build. But theres also the part where, some people just don't wanna spend hours farming for loot at all, theu get what they get. They farm a bit and use whsy they get. But unless you spend your precious time on it, melee builds are comeplete dogshit. My blight knight build is just a conglomerate of whatever i found lying in the ground that would help me with the build, and its not even fully optimized. I have my less effective armor on because it looks better and my enchantments aren't all specced properly. But when i dedicate time to using whay gear i have into making a melee build, speccing everything the best i can, it still turns out ass
So why did they make melee so bad in this game? Was it a conscious decision? Or a result of sheer incompetence? Or was it because of game development being during the whole lockdown thing?