r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Aug 29 '22

Discussion Even If The Transphobia Doesn't Bother You, Please Don't Buy (or Even play) The New Hogwarts Game

15.9k Upvotes

Stole the following from FB, and it's a pretty good commentary on why you shouldn't buy, or even play the upcoming JKR Hogwarts game

So let me get this straight. There's a new, very polished video game set in the Wizarding World of committed transphobe JK Rowling. The plot of the game is that there is a rebellion of goblins who are fighting against racial discrimination and prejudice by the Ministry of Magic and the wizarding community as a whole. From the Harry Potter Compendium - "The Goblin Rebellions were a series of rebellions in which the goblin population of the Wizarding world revolted against discrimination and prejudice toward their kind by wizards and witches. They were most prevalent during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, but even in modern times there are subversive goblin groups working in secret against the Ministry of Magic, according to the Daily Prophet. The historical rebellions have been described as "bloody and vicious." ...These rebellions may have occurred because of lack of goblin representation [in magical Parliament], attempts to enslave goblins as house-elves, stripping of wand privileges, wizard attempts to control Gringotts, or the brutal goblin slayings by Yardley Platt."

And you, the hero, are a wizard whose ultimate task it is to quash the rebellion and put these goblins back in their rightful place under the rule of the wizards.

The goblins of the HP series have long been criticized as offensive Jewish stereotypes, with critics pointing out their control of the magical banking system, their greed, and their exaggerated facial features. And the game is set in 1890, around the time the antisemitic hoax "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" was being developed (published 1903 amidst a new wave of antisemitism in Europe). Part of the official gameplay reveal shows the two villains, Ranrok the goblin (pictured) and Victor Rookwood the dark wizard, discussing what appears to be a child abduction scheme. From a fandom site: "Ranrok was a very greedy individual who sought to claim a magical power he caught a glimpse of that wizardkind hid even from themselves. His worldview was skewed by his hatred for all wizards and witches, who he sought to destroy entirely."

The lead designer for Avalanche Games, Troy Leavitt, has been a harsh critic of social justice movements, was a proponent of Gamergate, called the MeToo movement a "moral panic," and claimed that society gives deferential treatment to LGBTQ+, POC, women, and disabled people. And Warner Brothers knew this before they hired him to make this game. This game where the player fights against greedy, child-abducting Jewish stereotypes. The game where the player suppresses an uprising of an oppressed race who are pushing back against their own disenfranchisement, disarmament, slavery, and murder, in order to maintain the supremacy of the dominant culture.

Um...

WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK IS THIS NONSENSE?

Listen, friends. I know a lot of you still love the Wizarding World of Harry Potter. You've got a lot of emotional baggage tied up in whether you're a member of House Braggadocio, House GiftedChild, House SamwiseGamgee, or House EugenicsAreGoodActually. But I beg you, please, don't buy this game. Walk away from both Rowling and the Wizarding World. Don't give Warner Brothers any more money."

ETA: I got the above from Kevin Rhodes, facebook.com/heraldic, good dude.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Feb 06 '23

Discussion hot take but dude/bro isn't gender neutral.

465 Upvotes

In my opinion is patriarchal to think masculine terms are gender neutral and using it as a default term for everyone you meet is harmful.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Feb 17 '24

Burn the Patriarchy Finally saw Oppenheimer and I feel like it's gross

1.7k Upvotes

As a woman in STEM I went into the film interested to learn about a huge impact in the history of science. And while watching I was doing a lot of pausing and googling to learn more about events mentioned or fact-check them. There are way too many stories for me to say I have a good understanding of what really happened. I'm happy that this movie made me look into these parts of history, but I also feel like the movie as a whole is gross.

It's gross to me because it glazes over, minimizes the impact of, or misrepresents the stories of non-white people and people who aren't men. Meanwhile, it hyperfocuses on a narcissist who receives glorification and respect for being the father of the atomic bomb when he is one guy managing many people who had a hand in its creation. The movie feels like a white male fantasy, that white guys with main character syndrome can watch to feel important. I get that Oppenheimer was impactful as the project director at los Alamos, and I can see that the stories of him and his popularity with women have historical backing, but it feels like Nolan picked a guy who is a stereotype of a male ideal from decades ago and then made a 3 hr tribute to how important this guy is, even though I don't think Oppenheimer deserves all that glory. Yes the film picks at Oppenheimer's egotistical philandering traits but I still wonder why we are giving attention to someone who sucks so much.

The movie reduces jean tatlock to a sex symbol lady who is passionate and mysterious but ultimately unattainable for marriage. Basically a stereotype for guys to fantasize about. But the real jean tatlock had more to her than that. She was an MD, who also struggled with her bisexuality and thought something was wrong with her (which some believe may have been why she died)

Kitty Oppenheimer worked in the los Alamos lab for a year

Lise meitner, who isn't even mentioned in the movie, discovered nuclear fission alongside Otto hahn. But only Otto received the nobel peace prize for his discovery because Lise was a woman and Jewish. Lise had been asked to work at los Alamos but refused to have anything to do with making a weapon like that. If they are willing to mention Einstein's theory of relativity from 1905, why not mention meitner's discovery of nuclear fission in 1938? It is very pertinent.

Moreover, this sub has mentioned Loyda Martinez , who herself worked at los Alamos for over 30 years and whose father died from handling beryllium at los Alamos. He worked at los Alamos after he and other hispano homesteaders were forced from their homes so that the lab could be built. While he worked there he and other hispanos were not given the protective equipment that their white coworkers used to safely handle beryllium.

We get one nod to a woman scientist getting to work on plutonium in the movie, but the movie is whitewashed to high hell. Also, the movie acts like the land was pretty much barren and up for grabs, when we know there are people there who were forced from their homes, lost their property, had their property destroyed, were forced to leave at gunpoint, worked at the lab as service workers and treated as less than by the white workers. Not to mention the aftermath of the fallout and it's effects on the natives of los alamos

And these are just the few things I looked up, imagine just how much more is whitewashed so that we can focus on this one guy. It just feels like, why are we making one white guy out to be so important, why are we ignoring the women and people of color to tell this story and make it seem as though the weight of the world will always rest on the shoulders of white supremacy because these white men are so "brilliant"?

I watched barbie afterward and that movie warmed my heart. I get that Oppenheimer is a hard movie to make, a lot of research would need to go in to telling an accurate and socially responsible story, but I don't think Nolan made an effort to be socially responsible, and I think the treatment of women and people of color in this movie was lousy and lazy. It also is obnoxious that right wingers are saying anyone who criticizes Oppenheimer "doesn't get it" and the movie is too "intellectual". Comes across the same as "you dont understand Jordan Peterson, you aren't intellectual enough"

EDIT:

I just want to thank everyone for their perspectives and the various resources provided. It's been interesting reading through all your comments.

My overall opinion regarding the film is unchanged, with the great historical significance of the innovation of the bomb and the impact it made on the natives of New Mexico and the people of Japan, I think there are better subjects that could have been portrayed. I also think that regardless of who the director is, even if it's Nolan who is not great at character development or writing women, they should strive to be more socially responsible when telling a story of historical significance. Leaving things out that deliberately minimize impact to people of color, or that reduce women to stereotypes is really irresponsible and leaves a bad influence on audiences that take things at face value and don't bother to do any outside research for other perspectives. I know that there are people who will deliberately ignore or misinterpret things to suit their narrative no matter what but I think that directors, especially ones as notable as Nolan should strive to produce narratives that are fairer to people who have had their voices muffled throughout history.

Writing from the perspective of a narrow-minded self important character about something so historically significant is problematic imo. Obviously at the end of the day, Nolan will make what he wants to, but I'm going to call it like it is, gross.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jul 22 '24

🇵🇸 🕊️ END GENOCIDE Time to pressure Kamala

137 Upvotes

Now that vice president Kamala Harris looks to be the next democratic presidential candidate, it is time to remind her how unequivocally pro Palestine her voter base is. We need an email campaign and we need a protest campaign, we need to apply pressure in every single way we can.

Below is the Email information for contacting Kamala Harris, every single American (non Americans also can’t hurt) who gives a fuck about Palestine needs to send an email to Kamala Harris. Free Palestine 🇵🇸


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jan 13 '21

Burn the Patriarchy New gym 'fit

Post image
20.4k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Aug 19 '22

Selfie Sorcery Normalize a girl breaking standards. it ain't easy, but someone's gotta do it.

Post image
8.9k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Aug 17 '22

Burn the Patriarchy I'm a trans woman, is this a terf sub or a feminist sub?

6.8k Upvotes

Edit : thanks a lot for the feedback


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Mar 22 '24

Selfie Sorcery I'M OFFICIALLY DONE TRANSITIONING. just got my new birth certificate and I am now, for all intensive purposes, legally a woman

Thumbnail
gallery
14.8k Upvotes

I'm so happy. last pic is one of the rare occasions I felt pretty without makeup cuz ik some of u wanted me to be more confident cbhdbvnc. thanks for believing in me!


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Nov 12 '23

Meme Craft Learn the alphabet with r/WitchesVsPatriarchy. Letter A is for…

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jun 28 '22

Discussion “My GF is mad at me about Roe v Wade.”

28.7k Upvotes

I’ve seen many posts from men, predictably confuddled as to why their girlfriends were angry at them “for no reason” about Roe v Wade.

Of course, these girlfriends in question were immediately labeled as “red flags” or “crazy feminists” by dudebros in the comments.

Men, your girlfriends are not angry at you because of Roe v Wade. They are most likely upset because you were unable to display empathy, and were apathetic to (or worse, in support of) her rights being stripped away. So stop reducing it to “my GF is angry at me for factors outside of my control” for pity points on the internet, and intentionally making your girlfriend the “crazy hysterical woman.”

Their anger at you is born out of your reaction to the SCOTUS ruling, not the ruling itself.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jan 15 '23

Selfie Sorcery Just a Christian homeschooled boy turned trans goth witch with her first spell!!! Trying really hard to break free from my past!

Post image
12.6k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Feb 10 '23

Meme Craft What other advice have you been told to keep yourself safe?

Post image
60.0k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Nov 30 '22

Gender Magic Getting my bits flipped today! Turning my outie into an innie! Perform dark rituals for me plz! 🥰

Post image
14.7k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Dec 31 '22

Meme Craft A reminder.

Post image
39.0k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • May 10 '24

🇵🇸 🕊️ END GENOCIDE For those out of the loop on #BlockOut2024, I made a quick summary and FAQs. (Big movement on TikTok & Twitter) ✊

Thumbnail
gallery
131 Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jul 14 '24

🇵🇸 🕊️ Modern Witches Did Witches Stop Adolf Hitler From Invading England?

0 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/G41ObAYGeCE?si=nucn6pdnxF-0MIcW

As Adolf Hitler was preparing to invade Great Britain in 1940, a coven of witches came together to cast a spell intended to keep the German ground forces at bay.

Just 6 weeks after the mysterious cone of power ritual was performed, Hitler abandoned his plans to cross the English Channel, thus changing the course of World War 2.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Dec 20 '23

Mindful Craft Standing up for closed practices

1 Upvotes

I’m so proud of myself. Today I saw a woman pick up a white sage wand, sniff it, say “that smells good” and put it in her basket. I eavesdropped and noticed she was not educated in the realm of witchcraft and metaphysicality. I have social anxiety and would never walk up to a stranger to tell them they’re wrong. However, today I chose to talk to her. I said “Did you know that’s real white sage?” We talked and i explained that white sage is not for us. It is native medicine and shan’t be used because it smells good with no further research. I ended it by saying “There are other kinds of sage that are not in closed practice. You can do whatever is right in your book, but in my book it’s a no” Ahhhhhhhh! I’m so proud of myself. I don’t know if she bought it, but i educated someone today. I stood up for others today.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Aug 26 '26

🇵🇸 🕊️ Selfie Sorcery New crystal nails

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Pretty


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Dec 29 '22

Selfie Sorcery Trans witch and gender magic go hand in hand. The left was from today, and the 2 on the right are from 2021.

Post image
21.6k Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Apr 16 '24

🇵🇸 🕊️ Decolonize Spirituality How witchy is Ayurveda?

26 Upvotes

Hello Witches! I have been learning about Ayurveda lately while living in Sri Lanka (more specifically the Ceylon branch of Ayurveda), as I made a friend who works in it. I admire her so much although she’s only 4 years into her Ayurvedic journey, but I trust her knowledge as she works/volunteers long term with a local indigenous community in the jungle here. But I should mention we’re both European. There’s something about what she does and what I’m learning with Ayurveda that definitely feels witchy. I guess I’m wondering if it counts? I don’t know if this perspective can be offensive to eastern medicine, as it seems to be widely recognised and practised here in Asia and has been for millennia. I guess it feels witchy because it’s natural, and it feels like rebellion against colonialist oppression to recognise and bow down to the wisdom and beauty of this ancient spirituality/practice. (Also furious at my travel insurance for not covering my Ayurvedic consultations because they don’t consider it “real medicine” 😡 even though it helped me more than going to the clinic… but I digress)

So what do you say? Is the practice of Ayurveda witchy or not witchy?


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Sep 04 '26

🇵🇸 🕊️ Crones Gloria Steinem wasn’t in the fight just for White women

Thumbnail
19thnews.org
0 Upvotes

r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Dec 05 '21

Burn the Patriarchy FYI: The Satanic Temple cannot help you get an abortion and it does not deserve your support

110 Upvotes

It's the time of year where we all tell each other not to donate to the Salvation Army. Which remains true, but thanks in part to any number of public records, we also want to remind you emphatically not to support The Satanic Temple either.

The Satanic Temple cannot help you get an abortion, and there is much, much worse about them when you start to look closer at their history and finances. Do not buy their membership cards or donate to them

The state of Arkansas is still trying to get to the bottom of how TST actually works as an organization, which is a product of TST elbowing its way into a suit already well in hand by the ACLU, and proceeding to draw it out so much longer than needed that one of the plaintiffs has since died. Although much remains unanswered, a number of facts about TST and about Lucien Greaves himself have emerged, thanks to his own embarrassing performance under court deposition as well as sworn testimony provided by his previous colleague, Shane Bugbee:

  • Doug Misicko/Lucien Greaves is such a fan of Mussolini that he once went to Italy to visit the fascist's birthplace

  • Greaves admits that he just dips into the general fund to pay his personal expenses, without any real structure in place for TST to formally pay him and without any kind of oversight at all. There is no board of directors or any kind of auditing process - there's just him, and he can't actually say directly that he knows how hundreds of grand are handled between a religious nonprofit and a for-profit corporation that have spent years pretending to be the same organization and calling themselves the same name

  • Back in 2011, Greaves wanted to write a sequel to Might Is Right as a foundational text for TST, the original being an intensely protofascist book that has inspired several white nationalist movements and terrorists over the last century

  • And most disturbingly, in 2013, before TST was ever anything more than a couple of racist edgelords spitballing in an email chain, the original intent was always to sell merchandise based on the idea that there were religious exemptions unique to TST members - but there was no plan to actually make sure those exemptions actually existed first. Because they didn't, and they still don't.

TST cannot and will not save abortion rights for anyone, and can't even do it for themselves. There are reasons why abortion funds and clinic workers around the country have openly denounced TST as ineffective peddlers of misinformation in the best case.

They don't deserve the donations that just disappear into a black hole to be weaponized against dissenters, they don't deserve the benefit of the doubt or to be defended by gullible rubes who call themselves progressive and rational while insisting that "at least TST is doing something" with no interest in what that "something" actually is, and they don't deserve to be treated as having some kind of unique strategy into religious freedom when it is a matter of public record that that was always just marketing propaganda for people who want to feel like at least they're smarter than evangelicals.

See also many women who have spoken out about problems among TST's leadership, although from top people this has slowed down in recent years, likely due to TST threatening people with legal action for violating Non-Disparage Agreements they forced top people to sign (and yes, continue to use):

Edit: This is non-exhaustive, but this post was long enough. Just know that when it comes to The Satanic Temple, there is always more, and it's always worse.


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Dec 17 '24

🇵🇸 🕊️ Fledgling Witch I love Jesus, but I witch a little...

57 Upvotes

I am a Christian (Episcopalian) and my faith and worship practices are important to me, as well as the community I have at my church. I am also curious about all things witchy. I love the feminine power, rituals and intention setting, as well as deep connection with nature. Just wondering if there is a place for me...are there other Christian witches out there?

TLDR: Can I be a Christian and a Witch?


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jan 09 '23

Discussion Possible unpopular opinion: female/POC superheroes

0 Upvotes

I don’t mean to say that there shouldn’t be more female superheroes or POC superheroes. Far from it. I think there should be more. But it shouldn’t be a case of “what if xyz superhero were a woman? Or black?” That’s my problem. Taking a preexisting character that was originally a white cishet man and crafting it into something more “liberal friendly”. In my own opinion, this reshaping of a character to have a different gender or race than what it was already written as poses women or POC as mere subversions of the cishet white man. There are of course exceptions to this rule such as what happened with the Black Panther series. Out of universe, the original actor tragically passed away but instead of just casting a new actor, the writers made it work in universe. Since the position of Black Panther is a title granted by the governing system already in place rather than the universe granting some local shmuck god like powers, it poses the possibility that the Black Panther can be anyone from any part of Wakanda. And since the original character had a younger sister, the writers could easily continue the story in a way that makes sense in universe and allows for more female and more POC representation. On the flip side, making Thor suddenly have tits is where I have a problem. Thor is already a character with his own arc and his own life and abilities. Suddenly making Thor a woman not only downplays the character itself but the fact that someone from a less represented community is playing the character as well. It reads the same as JK suddenly slapping “Dumbledore is gay” everywhere. It feels lazy and not well thought out and almost insulting. The remedy to this is of course writing more characters that start out as women or POC or queer or whatever and stay that way. Give them their own arcs, their own flaws, their own abilities, their own humanity. But of course Hollywood is kinda hurting for original ideas right now so read into that as you will. Please take my argument with a grain of salt. I’m a cis white bisexual woman who doesn’t like superhero movies and I’m coming at it with a very surface level interpretation. What are thoughts from people who actually enjoy this kind of media and are part of less represented groups.

EDIT: this was a post written in a fit of frustration and in turn it came out to be bigoted and small minded. Thank you to everyone for being willing to point out the problems in my opinion and being respectful about what I was trying to say

EDIT 2: so I finally got my head screwed on correctly and understood what I was trying to say with this post. Thank you for everyone who commented and called me out on my stupidity. As for the argument I was trying to make, I’m going to use a response I just typed to a comment to explain.

This was typed in a fit of frustration without thinking. I’m also a writer and I’ve had to face a lot of annoyances similar to this with my own writing. I write a lot of queer stories and people warn me that might “turn readers off” and I think my frustration stems from there not being a lot of original stories with minority representation. I think my real problem is that it feels a bit disingenuous to someone from the outside. I do consider myself a very very minor marvel fan, meaning I watched about six or seven of the movies growing up but I never read many of the comics and haven’t seen a ton of the newer things. To someone unfamiliar with the superhero trope of passing the torch and whatnot, it looks a bit like someone playing second fiddle to the “original”. Yeah there’s now a black captain America and a woman Thor but the fact is that they were played by white men first so it feels like the writers are making the minority characters coming in on the coattails of their predecessor. And maybe it’s because there’s a bias against sequels being not as good that it felt a little disingenuous to me. To dedicated fans it’s a complex universe with wonderful symbolism and carefully crafted stories but to outsiders who are only passingly familiar with the franchise, it looks like the same thing done with a group that isn’t as represented for brownie points. Perhaps I’ve been jaded by witnessing a shit ton of rainbow capitalism. It wasn’t my intention to come off as one of those whiny white supremisists that cries because the little mermaid is now black but I understand that is what happened and I will endeavor to think more carefully before I say something. Again thank you for calling me out and engaging in discussion with me


r/WitchesVsPatriarchy • • Jan 02 '26

🇵🇸 🕊️ Spells my friend’s intention burned so hot it cracked our bowl

Post image
0 Upvotes