r/Windscribe • • Jul 27 '21

Reply from Developer Windscribe FAILED us

I have been telling people about Windscribe - how great it us at protecting our privacy and now this?

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/07/vpn-servers-seized-by-ukrainian-authorities-werent-encrypted/

9 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

39

u/nosmokingbandit Jul 27 '21

From the horse's mouth, as it were...

https://blog.windscribe.com/openvpn-security-improvements-and-changes-7b04ea49222

We have no reason to believe that the servers were compromised or that there was any unauthorized access before seizure. As we do not log VPN traffic, no customer data from those servers while in operation are at any risk.

You might want to read that whole post by Windscribe regardless. Its kind of interesting imo.

-10

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

Thanks for this.

It is just concerning that they're supposed to be experts in this field. :)

9

u/nosmokingbandit Jul 27 '21

What about this implies that they aren't?

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

well, they should be on top of all of these industry-standard security practices. I guess I was expecting too much?

4

u/Joseos_123 Jul 27 '21 edited Jul 27 '21

and of course, you the non industry standard professional is criticising others on something that is not related to the experience or skill of the employees. If there was even one man who could be “skilled enough” to stop breaches then im sure even the nsa would be interested in hiring.

edit: thanks to the fact that we are all humans and that windscribe does not have people physically present in Ukraine to oversee the physical boxes of the servers this happened. is blaming the company the problem or questioning the integrity of the Ukrainian people who did this more important

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

Frankly, not having people physically present is an excuse. When you are a security professional offering paid services to others, you should be on top of your game -- monitoring vulnerabilities that affect services that you offer and making sure that you apply fixes or remove the affected service.

Anyway, this is moot already as Windscribe already did what's needed.

And of course, you assume that people who post here are not professionals. :P

4

u/Mr_multitask2 Jul 28 '21

Dude, you pay $40/year for Windscribe.

Do you expect them to have John Rambo at each location ready to set off a thermite charge in case the server gets raided by the local authorities?

1

u/Joseos_123 Jul 28 '21 edited Jul 28 '21

considering my sarcastic tone in this thread im glad someone mentioned the word

authorities

did some stupid guy hack into or break into the vps company they were using??

NO! because windscribe was using a fucking vps

“have a person at each location” would that be possible??????? it’s literally vps providers’ private properties

authorities are able to do this because they have guns and warrants

why im treating this thread as a joke is because of your inability to use common sense to deduce the fact that the NSA FBI CIA use the same server strategy as windscribe just that its with amazon AWS.

does windscribe use aws? perhaps not. but aws is a vps provider who operate physical servers and rent them to companies.

lastly, windscribe has a valuation and asset value of less than 1million usd.

is it possible to buy/rent 480+ (as of 28/7/2021) different apartments then buy server equipment and pay bills

again, im not attacking you personally, just the fact u think that only professionals can know how things work and that people without credentials cant use logic and brain power to deduce things.

i will not be replying to any further comments unless instigated (eg. yet another personal attack on my lack of career experience)

edited for grammar

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '21

Dude, you expect them to properly configure the remote server, like the rest of their servers, and not leave it vulnerable, regardless of whether data was extracted or not. It might have been that the server was physically removed BEFORE they could fix it.

9

u/billdietrich1 Jul 27 '21

No product or service is perfect. Don't fully trust any of them. Encrypt, compartmentalize, give fake data, test, verify, use defense in depth. You can use a VPN, ISP, bank, etc without having to fully trust or fully rely upon them.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

I agree.

10

u/vmmf89 Jul 27 '21

A company is not measured by the times it falls, but by the times it rises after. They screw up big time. They are taking away the faulty protocol right now. They didn't said clearly that this had been the reason for removing the protocol, but I don't know a company who would have said it either. This is very important "Encrypted conversations like HTTPS web traffic or encrypted messaging services would not be affected" although they could see your contry of origin and traffic destination. It's bad if you connected to Ukraine servers. Apparently other locations of higher importance do have encryption. I would like to see the ones which still do not have encryption to avoid them

0

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

I am just saying that for a company that prides itself with providing secure VPN services, this one was a huge failure. Anyway, I wish that Windscribe subscribers got info about this (disclosure) before it hit the news.

17

u/o2pb Totally not a bot | CEO Jul 27 '21

You did, it was announced 3 weeks ago, on our blog, Reddit, Twitter, and inside our apps.

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

Oh, my bad. I was expecting an email. :)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

You do realize that Windscribe can be used without signing up and leaving your email address?

3

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

Yes, but paying subscribers should at least have been informed via email. :)

6

u/Axe_l Jul 27 '21

Apparently a lot of customers don’t even read the emails so they didn’t do that. Couldn’t have hurt to do it as well.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

We'd better brace ourselves for a few days of posts like these. Some other 'VPN review site' will stumble on this and regurgitate it with a new doomsday spin.

8

u/nosmokingbandit Jul 27 '21

Another review site that sells positive reviews, right?

1

u/AlwaysW0ng Jul 29 '21

No single public vpn will going to protect your privacy completely for $5-10/month.

1

u/Youarethebigbang Aug 02 '21

Soo, what price and who does?

1

u/AlwaysW0ng Aug 02 '21 edited Aug 02 '21

No one will unless you make your own vpn and able to access the server physically or able to access the server. In VPN industry, we go and trust by words from reviewers, users, and company privacy policy. VPN provider can say "We Do Not Keep And Record User Activity And Data" easy, but do they really mean it? Many were caught lying about this.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Joseos_123 Jul 27 '21

thats hacking 101

thank you because im sure you are a respected pentester/security researcher who knows that deleting logs solves all your problems 👍👍👍

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Joseos_123 Jul 27 '21

and again, deleting logs completely wipes all traces!!!!!????!?!!?? omg im shocked!! thank you mr researcher now i will have peace of mind when i pentest my friends networks!!!

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Joseos_123 Jul 27 '21

wow! your experience in hacking astounds me! im going to hack the russian military now and theyll never figure it out because of your advice!!! thank you bro, much appreciated. all those smb vulnerabilities amiright

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Joseos_123 Jul 27 '21

and you do have credentials???????

1

u/Joseos_123 Jul 27 '21

im not trying to attack you personally per se im just very bewildered by your comment i do not have credentials but im just wondering what universe i would have to be in for me to be able to delete the logs and leave no trace…

having a skill and having a career in it are two different things

0

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

[deleted]

1

u/Joseos_123 Jul 28 '21

provider

correct. but from my comment thread with him he does not know windscribe is hosted on vps(es) and assume windscribe own and operate hardware.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Joseos_123 Aug 01 '21

i agree with this point

the point i was trying to get across in this thread was that we shouldnt point fingers at someone for something unrelated

and to address the constant constant “no credentials” “not a professional” comments that for some reason means my opinion has no weight and is invalid

0

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21

[deleted]

0

u/Joseos_123 Jul 28 '21

yes!!!!!! exactly!!!! this guy is literally complaining about a hosted-for-you service

i personally host my own vpn on my own vps when im doing some slighty shadier than usual stuff. you shouldnt trust anyone but yourself, but this guy is complaining about it instead of taking action

0

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '21

[deleted]

0

u/Joseos_123 Jul 28 '21

no its just so i can run my own client thats all. besides im not doing any dark web stuff mostly torrenting and deep web stuff

0

u/Joseos_123 Jul 28 '21

i use my own vpn instead of windscribe for stability and speed