r/WindowsServer • • 7d ago

Technical Help Needed Migrate CA Server

I am planning to migrate my only ca server from current windows server 2012 r2 to windows server 2025 . Not sure what steps to preform as some template and certificates are in use . Need step by step with zero issues .

Thanks in advance

8 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

2

u/Far-Tune4183 5d ago

I know officially it's not supported but we did an in place upgrade. No problems at all.

2

u/Mediocre_Prior_1868 4d ago

From which windows server to which one ?

11

u/Zealousideal_Fly8402 7d ago

Use the official Microsoft CA Migration documentation as a starting point:

Migrate a Certification Authority in Windows Server | Microsoft Learn

7

u/UMustBeNooHere 7d ago

Was just about to post this same link. I’ve done several customer migrations this way, OP. It’s actually pretty simple.

Note: CA name is not the same as hostname. You can name the new server whatever you want, but the CA name remains the same. If you want to rename the CA, that’s possible, but then you have to reissue all certs. I’ve done both methods.

2

u/Icy-State5549 6d ago

THIS RIGHT HERE! Nothing else. If something in this process doesn't work, call mss.

4

u/Subject_Treat6956 7d ago

Well Zero issues wo t Work, Just build the new ca root / intermediate alongside, then create new Templates for the new ca one by one and Test the least critical First. 

2

u/Incrediblecodeman 7d ago

I’d be suspicious of 2025 they say it’s not recommended for domain controllers. Why not 2019? It’s def LTS

2

u/leoingle 7d ago

How tf is Windows Server of any version not recommended for domain controller??

1

u/Incrediblecodeman 7d ago

I just read Microsoft is like iffy. They would have to support it tho. Or maybe it was just a blog idk. But I never like to be on the new new ones

1

u/leoingle 7d ago

Yeah. Let others be guinea pigs to iron out the kinks in their new stuff. I’ve already been victim of that with Cisco too many times.

2

u/DutchGeek2 7d ago

Server 2019 loses extended support early 2029. Unless you want to migrate again within 2 years, better pick a more recent version.

2

u/Incrediblecodeman 7d ago

In place upgrade

1

u/Lost-Policy-2020 7d ago

CA is never on DC!

2

u/Incrediblecodeman 6d ago

Why avoid installing a CA on a DC?
Security: Compromising the server could expose both AD and certificate infrastructure.
Maintenance: CA migration and DC demotion become more complicated.
Recovery: Separating the roles simplifies backup and disaster recovery.
Privilege separation: CA administration and domain administration should be separated.

2

u/Adyshaker1885 2d ago

I did this recently from 2016 to 2025. Root was easy just followed the documentation posted above. Intermediate had a few more issues, mainly because IIS configuration wasn't documented so the CDP URLs technically didn't exist. Figured it out eventually but not before a load of VPN clients couldn't connect and I got told off by the service desk for creating a load of tickets.

1

u/Boedker1 7d ago

Oof, I have no idea but good luck bud!

-3

u/ConsistentCoat5608 7d ago

You may want to consider outsourcing this project, its a hefty one and you also will need your domain upgrade and in good health. There really is no migration for the main CA server, usually its a backup/restore to do upgrade process. The MS best practices is probably the size of a small novel and that is if everything is healthy. Dont just get advice here, bring someone in who can help and have a good backup plan.

Did this once before and had to back out a couple times before it worked.